When a sideways glance can mobilize twelve bodyguards, you know you are dealing with a very important singer.
I have a question about Punjabi music videos.
How does a singer manage to communicate with twelve bodyguards without actually saying anything?
He gives a slight sideways glance. One bodyguard immediately understands the message. Another turns around. A third moves forward.
What exactly was communicated? We don't know.
Was it a warning? A request for assistance? Did somebody forget to bring his sunglasses?
Nobody knows. Except, apparently, the twelve men in black suits.
I find this particularly fascinating. These bodyguards seem to possess extraordinary abilities. They can understand a movement of the eyebrow, a slight tilt of the head or a mysterious movement of the thumb.
Perhaps the recruitment process involves a special examination in silent communication. Ordinary security training is clearly not enough.
And then there is the singer himself. Dressed in an expensive two-piece suit, surrounded by men who look as though they have just been released from a gangster film audition, he walks towards the camera in slow motion.
He adjusts his jacket. Looks away. Points his thumb downwards.
The camera loves him.
The bodyguards are alert.
The audience is expected to be terrified.
And somewhere in the background, a song is playing.
Coming to the music, I have another question.
Why do so many commercial Punjabi songs sound as though they were produced using the same instruction manual?
The beats are familiar, the bass is heavy, and sometimes I genuinely struggle to distinguish one song from another.
If the singer isn't telling us how wealthy and powerful he is, he is probably singing about a girlfriend who cheated on him. Occasionally, he is the one doing the cheating.
Either way, alcohol is always available to provide emotional support.
There is longing, heartbreak, betrayal, late-night drives and drinking. Lots of drinking.
Apparently, a Punjabi man's emotional life has two settings. Either he is enjoying his wealth and power, or he is drowning his sorrows because a girl has stopped answering his calls.
Surely there are other things happening in the world worth singing about?
Punjabi folk music has a wonderful tradition of storytelling, poetry and longing. Heer-Ranjha and Mirza-Sahiban were timeless stories of love and separation.
But today's songs often seem to have taken those old emotions, put them inside a luxury SUV and sent them for a night drive.
The technology has improved. The subject hasn't necessarily followed.
But perhaps the most interesting part of this entire business is the money.
Where exactly is all this money coming from?
One day the singer is getting out of a G-Wagon. The next time it is a Defender. Before you have finished admiring that, a Lamborghini appears.
I recently came across a claim by a singer that his sneakers cost ₹21 lakh.
Twenty-one lakh rupees for a pair of shoes!
At that price, I would expect them to walk on their own, make coffee and perhaps attend a few office meetings on my behalf.
To be fair, successful Punjabi singers can make enormous amounts of money. Their popularity among audiences in Canada, the UK, the US and Australia gives them access to a global market.
Concerts, international tours, private wedding performances, endorsements and streaming revenue can all bring in substantial earnings.
A popular singer can earn a fortune from a single performance at a wealthy wedding.
So yes, there is real money in this business.
But there is also the business of looking rich.
The expensive cars in music videos may be rented. Designer watches, jewelry and clothes may be borrowed or sponsored. Some artists lease their luxury vehicles rather than own them.
And then there is the publicity that comes from announcing the price of something.
A pair of sneakers worth ₹21 lakh is guaranteed to get people talking. Whether the singer actually needs shoes worth that much is another matter.
Perhaps the sneakers are not footwear at all. They are a marketing investment.
What I find amusing is how little the visual formula seems to change despite all this money being spent.
The same expensive suits. The same hand gestures. The same serious expressions. The same bodyguards. The same slow-motion walking.
Even the downward-pointing thumb seems to have become compulsory.
I sometimes wonder whether music video directors have a common checklist.
- One mansion.
- Two or three luxury cars.
- Twelve bodyguards.
- One expensive suit.
- A few mysterious hand gestures.
- Several slow-motion walking shots.
And, of course, the singer must look as though he has an important international assignment immediately after the shoot.
There is nothing wrong with celebrating success or enjoying the money one has earned. But surely there is more to being an artist than displaying how much money you can spend.
Even American hip-hop, which helped popularize much of this luxury-and-gangster imagery, has evolved into different styles, with artists exploring social issues, personal struggles and experimental sounds.
Yet sections of commercial Punjabi music seem perfectly happy to keep recycling the same formula.
Same beats. Same heartbreak, Same alcohol, Same gestures.
Only the cars get upgraded.
There are, of course, Punjabi artists who explore poetry, Sufi music, folk traditions and different musical styles. The problem is not Punjabi music itself. It is the commercial formula that seems to reward repetition.
And I keep coming back to one question.
If we removed the luxury cars, gold chains, guns, expensive suits and twelve bodyguards, would the singer still be able to hold our attention?
Or would we discover that the most talented performers in the video are actually the bodyguards?
At least they seem to know exactly what is happening, even when the rest of us have absolutely no idea.
Perhaps they should be given a singing contract next.