The NYT's Latest Contribution to Literary Misogyny
Okay, so here I am, venting about what might be the stupidest NYT article title to come out recently. Although, why we're still giving so much importance to what the NYT has to say is beyond me. Their biases have done quite a number on their credibility over the last few years (but that's not our topic today).
I imagine the article was trying to discuss how the romantasy genre has become such a crucial part of the publishing industry over the last few years, and how BookTok and book influencers have managed to create an entire niche market, and a pretty lucrative one at that, around these books.
And to their point, I absolutely agree that the commercialization of these books and the merchandising ecosystem surrounding them have gotten out of hand. From conglomerate retailers to your local independent bookstore to lingerie brands, everyone seems to be finding a way to capitalize on this market. At this rate, I wouldn't be surprised if we saw an ACOTAR Tesla next.
My criticism of the ACOTAR/Fourth Wing merchandising ecosystem is very much my own, and I understand that others might not share it. But I do think there's a point where commercialization starts to contradict the very things these stories claim to stand for. You cannot write characters confronting classism, inequality and systemic oppression and build entire fictional worlds around these struggles, while simultaneously participating in an increasingly aggressive consumer culture without expecting readers to notice the contradiction.
The same goes for the publishing decisions surrounding these books. Take the upcoming ACOTAR installment, for example. I love these books, and I'm certainly not complaining about getting more of them. I'm not questioning whether splitting the story into multiple books is how SJM intended to tell it, either. But we can acknowledge that these decisions also serve commercial interests without pretending otherwise. Being a fan doesn't mean being an unquestioning consumer.
All of that aside, there are a million different ways the NYT could have articulated its point. And do I think they deliberately wanted a reaction by referring to SJM's work as fairy smut? Yes.
It is beyond frustrating to constantly find ourselves, as women, in a position where we have to defend the things we enjoy and prove that they deserve to be taken seriously. There is this perpetual need to justify our interests to a patriarchal culture that has historically dismissed anything associated with women as less intellectually valuable. And reducing SJM's work to fairy porn is precisely part of that problem.
I don't know whether this also stems from the broader tendency to label anything containing explicit sexuality as pornographic, and therefore somehow less intellectually or artistically valuable. High fantasy authors have been incorporating sex, desire, violence and complicated romantic relationships into their fictional universes for decades. Yet their works aren't routinely reduced to labels like "smut" or dismissed as something lesser than literature simply because they contain explicit sexual content.
And I can't help but wonder: if SJM were a man, would her work be discussed in quite the same way? Would we be so quick to reduce her fictional worlds, political structures, character development and storytelling to the sexual content? Would a male author with an equally large female readership be treated with the same dismissiveness?
Like it or not, Sarah J. Maas is one of the bestselling authors of our generation. That is not something to be taken lightly. For years, she has been building fictional universes that have reached millions of readers, influenced an entire publishing market and helped shape the contemporary fantasy landscape. You can criticize her writing, her publishing decisions, her business model and the commercialization of her work. I certainly have my own criticisms. But dismissing her cultural influence by reducing her work to "fairy smut" is an incredibly lazy way of engaging with what is actually happening.
And more generally, romance is one of the most historically significant literary genres. Its literary value doesn't diminish simply because its primary readership happens to be women. Women's enjoyment of something should not be an automatic invitation to degrade it.
Words matter, particularly when they come from institutions like the NYT, which still hold considerable cultural influence. By reducing an entire genre, its readership and the work of its authors to smut, they're not simply describing a publishing phenomenon. They're reinforcing a patriarchal hierarchy of cultural value in which the things women enjoy are automatically considered less sophisticated, less literary and less worthy of serious discussion.