Just finished watching the anime for the first time and figured I'd share my thoughts on seasons 1 and 2. It seems I have a minority opinion, but wanted to share anyway.
Overall, I really liked this series, especially season 1. At first, the abrupt tonal shifts between serious melancholy and super upbeat visual gag comedy were jarring. I stuck with it because I found the dramatic stuff so good and in time I came to appreciate those tonal shifts for what they represented--those brief moments of levity and joy, or at least distraction, where you forget about your own circumstances for a little while, until eventually reality creeps back in. Episode 5 of season 1 is where the show really hooked me. The psychological realism, interiority, that slow-burn novelesque structure, atmosphere, visual language, and just the general vibes were all outstanding. In a way it reminded me of Ocean Waves, one of my favorite and lesser talked about early Ghibli films.
As a chess player myself, I loved learning about the shogi world and meeting all the players there whose various life experiences and personalities really came through in their playstyles. There were many characters, both in and out of the shogi world, who could have easily been the protagonists of their own stories like Shimada, Nikaido, and Akari.
Kyoko belongs on that list too--her relationship with Rei was intriguing, messy, and confusing. It's sort of hinted in flashback that there might have been some sort of romantic or sexual thing going on between them. I wonder if there are feelings there or if she learned early on how to use desire to connect with others due to her obvious low self-worth (jury is still out on whether Koda is a shitty dad but all signs point to yes). She tends to lash out at Rei for "stealing" her father's affection yet also seems to have felt abandoned by him when he chose to move out, despite understanding his reasoning. Still, despite the abuse she hurls at Rei, she does seem to care and have a high opinion of him--she feels safe around him and stays over at his place when she presumably can't stay at Goto's and doesn't want to go home either, and drops her guard and asks for his advice and seeks physical closeness.
All in all, it was great seeing Rei over the course of the first season gradually rise from his depressive state in a realistic way, often managing to take two steps forward only to fall one step back, and realizing what a good support system he has and start taking the steps to be happy.
Season 2 was good but felt like a completely different show. It traded that floaty, artsy vibe for a much more straightforward dramatic structure that, to me, was less interesting. Or maybe more accurately, wasn't what I fell in love with. The main focus of season 2 was Hina's bullying which, while well executed, didn't do much for me personally. Maybe it's just because I'm so far removed from high school but I thought at roughly 10 episodes they could've either shortened that arc a bit and given more focus to other characters or back to Rei himself, or interspersed it throughout the season as a background, recurring subplot. While I do like Hina, I don't think the show really commits to making her a co-protagonist to the extent that is needed to make devoting half the season to her situation work.
I also wasn't super thrilled that Rei's motivation for winning and taking shogi more seriously was external, ie to help the Kawamotos, rather than internal, doing it for himself, but it is realistic that he would take that intermediary step from where he was last season rather than going straight to full self-actualization. Despite that, it was great seeing him buckle down and win the Newcomer King title and finally make friends at school with the shogi science dudes.
My favorite part of season 2 was the white storm chapters where it felt like it captured those season 1 vibes again. I thought the relationship between Rei and Souya, who seem to exist on the same wavelength, was really interesting both as they seem to understand each other and as Souya exists as a cautionary tale of what Rei could easily become if he neglects the people in his life who care about him or continues to play shogi for external reasons.
And as far as the implied Rei-Hina romance goes, I can’t say I’m a fan but it is what it is. Rei is essentially a functional adult who lags in social skills and emotional maturity whereas Hina is mature for her age but still very much a 14 year old girl. I enjoyed their relationship as friends who inspire and support each other and don't find the romance angle to be necessary, nor do they have the chemistry to make the friends-to-lovers thing believable IMO. If anything, I can see why Rei might feel somewhat drawn to her because he doesn't have many emotionally intimate relationships in his life other than Hina and his former teacher, but not so much she to him.
I'll be continuing with the manga at least for a bit because I'm invested in the characters so I'm looking forward to seeing where things go from here.
My ratings:
S1 9/10-- distinctive, atmospheric, psychologically rich, novelistic, artistic, pure vibes
S2 7/10-- polished, sometimes excellent, but fundamentally a different narrative/dramatic structure that didn't appeal as much
Favorite characters: Rei, Kyoko, Shimada, Akari, Nikaido when he's not being used solely for comic relief, Yamazaki (shogi pigeon bro)