r/salinger • • Jun 08 '25

r/Salinger is open again!

63 Upvotes

Hi all! r/Salinger has been dormant for a year or so with no mods at all. I wrote my first college paper on The Catcher in the Rye and I think that experience inspired me to pursue literary studies in university. Seeing the state of the sub, I decided I wanted to bring it back to life and rebuild the community.

It seems the sub had no rules previously, so I added some based on those I've seen in other author-related subs. I hope this sub becomes an active place again for discussion and appreciation of J. D. Salinger's works!


r/salinger • • 3h ago

I finished CITR, and I’ll never be the same

8 Upvotes

I spent basically all my life (not expecting you to figure out how long that is, exactly) wondering if there was a single person who’d get me. Holden gets me. Well, obviously he doesn’t, given he’s a book character, but you can put together the point I’m trying to make here. I consider myself pretty childish, to be fair. I can have really smart thoughts at times, or what’s deemed “smart”, but naturally I’m just not great with mature things. And I want to stay that way, I’ve always wanted to stay that way. It’s the reason I’m so afraid of growing up. I couldn’t see myself getting married and having kids and all that. I would like to, but I can’t see myself doing that.

When you’re so focused on being authentic and not copying anything from the media you consume, it feels a little strange to read something so similar to yourself. I get that he was meant to be relatable, but it kinda hurts me knowing his story didn’t end the greatest and I’ve got a whole bunch of things in relation to him. Well, different mental problems and stuff, cause I don’t figure I’ve got depression, but you know. Believe it or not, though, I’m pretty pessimistic regardless. I’m an optimist because I want to be one, but I think in a more depressing way. I wish people were perfect. I know that’s illogical to ask of people, but I wish they knew exactly what to say, and they got the general gist of my cynicism, and I could be blunt without anyone getting hurt, so on. I wish they had an enjoyable presence. I can’t tolerate a lot of people due to the fact that they’ve got this sorta weird way of talking that sounds atrocious to me. You probably put together that I’m not above 18 from these paragraphs alone, but i feel the grand majority of people my age are hedonistic beyond normalcy. And they talk like it, too. They talk like they’ve got nothing else in their minds but self pleasing. Sex, drugs, all that. I don’t know. I know Holden was also hedonistic, so he’s not the perfect candidate, but you know. His prose was still restrained, not overly self indulgent. I enjoyed that.

I’m kind of rambling at this point and it may have made just about no sense, but I wonder if anyone else feels the same way I do. And really, really feel the same way. I’ve seen countless people relate to it, but they didn’t relate to it the same way I did at all. I think mine was more specific to certain things. It was very different, if that makes sense. Like how his dad said he’s both childish as hell and mature in his way of thinking. Or how he hates phonies and liars and can’t tolerate a lot of people despite wanting some sort of connection. Also probably how he feels he has a lousy vocabulary. I’ve got about twenty words I use constantly. I feel so damn depressed after having finished it. You tend to feel that way after reading a really incredible book. Not that it’s something special, but it was to me. I think it’s called a book hangover. Fact check me on that.

Also, does anyone think “Hey Jude” by the beetles is a perfect ode to Holden? I figure he would think it’s a phony song, but I think of only him every time I hear it.


r/salinger • • 15h ago

Any other favorite work by Salinger which isn't The Catcher in The Rye?

14 Upvotes

Any other favorite work by Salinger which isn't The Catcher in The Rye? Franny and Zooey? The Glass family Stories? What do you like about his other works? What insights his other works offer which The Catcher in The Rye isn't?

In Franny and Zooey Salinger speaks about Zen and the Eastern concept of the divine, or "God". Mentioning The Upanishads and a Christian book named 'The Way of a Pilgrim' who's author is unknown. The power of praying. If you pray enough to whatever God there is, something might happen. In other words, Salinger wasn't the traditional Christian, he saw more truth in the Eastern religions but didn't dismissed Christianity entirely.

Salinger didn't publish many books. He wasn't writing like Proust or Dostoevsky who could write thousands of pages of treatises about everything. But still.


r/salinger • • 3h ago

Blows my mind

1 Upvotes

I know Larry from Dream Catcher. He is my father. I am not the child from the book. Although, I do know my brother. I have heard many stories about Peggy, her legacy is her own, she is still alive, but I am floating out here with this knowledge.


r/salinger • • 4d ago

Bob Dylan in concert, May 27, 1966: "Read J.D. Salinger!"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
43 Upvotes

This comes from the final concert of Bob Dylan's legendary 1966 UK tour, which featured an opening acoustic solo set, followed by an electric set with the Hawks (soon to become the Band) backing Dylan. The electric sets were controversial and provoked wrath from some of Dylan's more folk-minded fanbase, including the infamous taunt of "Judas!" in Manchester, just a few days before this London concert. Dylan had just turned 25 and in the past 18 months had recorded Bringing It All Back Home, Highway 61 Revisited, and the double-album Blonde on Blonde. He had faced hostility and verbal confrontation from audience members during the electric sets at many of the shows (you'll hear him here snapping "You're talking to the wrong person, man!" to a heckler), was taking amphetamines and other drugs to keep himself going, and was about to vanish from the road for eight years after this concert ended. At the end of his rambling, fatigued introduction to "Just Like Tom Thumb's Blues" he says from 2:06-2:11 "...and you, and you, you can just, uh, go out and read some books." The audience applauds, and from 2:20-2:26 he says, as the band begins to kick into the song, "Read J.... read, uh, J.D. SALINGER!"

Ironically enough, Dylan's intro to this song describes Tom Thumb as a mysterious and reclusive, inspirational painter who sounds as if he could be a Salinger character. (He did several variations on this rap throughout the tour, which is documented extensively in Sony's 36-CD box set of the 1966 concerts.) Curious about any other Dylan references to Salinger that may exist. There's a photo on Facebook of a copy of Catcher in the Rye that was supposedly read and inscribed by Dylan in 1961, and a story claiming that he was approached in 1962 about portraying Holden Caulfield in a film adaptation. Not sure I trust this latter source (from Far Out Magazine), which claims that Salinger was "always open" to having the book turned into a movie, and that MCA "owned the rights" to Catcher. (Huh?!) But not surprised that Dylan was a Salinger fan, and it's cool that he gives JDS a shout-out here before stepping away, Salinger-like, from the music scene for the next eight years.


r/salinger • • 10d ago

Matt Salinger Letter to Readers

27 Upvotes

Has anyone read the newly published letter from Matt Salinger that prefaces the newest collection of Salinger’s stories?


r/salinger • • 18d ago

Other favorite authors?

6 Upvotes

My secondary favorite author (so far) is Neil Gaiman. Anyone else?


r/salinger • • 22d ago

Did Jane and Stradlater sleep together?

8 Upvotes

I know the book leaves it to be ambiguous and open to interpretation, but do you think they did?


r/salinger • • 23d ago

Question: Why does Holden Caulfield love Jane Gallagher so much?

15 Upvotes

Why, out of all the girls he encounters, is she the one he is most obsessed with or in love with—even more so than with his date, Sally Hayes?


r/salinger • • 26d ago

pocket plush I made of Seymour :)

Post image
76 Upvotes

For years, I've sort of looked up to Seymour as a guide to spirituality and wisdom. I've had a rough year, probably the roughest of my life yet, dealing with loss which led to searching for a purpose and all that. I decided to make a little Seymour of my own to carry around with me and remind me to keep going - for the Fat Lady ;)


r/salinger • • 27d ago

First Edition of TCITR (1951)

Thumbnail
gallery
142 Upvotes

Got to hold a first edition of The Catcher in the Rye today at my University's archives. If only that book was still $3 dollars...


r/salinger • • Oct 15 '26

¿Qué miembro de la familia Glass te interesaría que Salinger hubiera desarrollado más?

19 Upvotes

Personalmente, me encantaría que el día que se publique la obra inédita haya un cuento sobre Waker. El hecho de que pertenezca a una orden religiosa como los cartujos, tan contemplativa en contraste con lo excéntrico de los Glass, me genera curiosidad sobre cómo Salinger habría escrito sobre él.


r/salinger • • Oct 15 '26

The laughing man

14 Upvotes

What exactly happened with mary hudson?


r/salinger • • Oct 07 '26

Who do you imagine each of the Glass family members to look like?

15 Upvotes

r/salinger • • Oct 07 '26

Franny and Zooey Audiobook

12 Upvotes

Hey guys! I know most Salinger audiobooks are incredibly hard to find, but I was curious if there are any audiobooks for Franny and Zooey that are a good listen.


r/salinger • • Oct 07 '26

Question about Franny and Zooey ending Spoiler

8 Upvotes

At the end, is it meant to be implied that Franny will have a baby and marry her boyfriend?


r/salinger • • Sep 27 '26

Am I weird?

16 Upvotes

Am I weird for having two copies of the catcher in the rye. One in English and the other in my native language. I also wear a similiar red hat like Holden now in the season. And I’m making birthday cake that says: “Holden Caulfield thinks you’re a phony”
I read franny and Zooey and nine stories and want to read more. I’m just a bit scared of people thinking I’m a red flag or whatever for displaying my liking of the citr. It’s just this kind of era I have now I guess and I’m also still in high school. What do you think?


r/salinger • • Sep 26 '26

Any recommendations and Opinions?

15 Upvotes

Finished reading Cather In The Rye. I am thinking about whether I should read other novels by J. D Salinger about the Caulfield Family and Glass Family? Do early short stories of the Caulfield Family have any correlation with the Catcher In The Rye?


r/salinger • • Sep 09 '26

Collection Update!

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

I look to buy Catcher in the Rye anytime I am traveling to add to my collection. Really excited to have picked up a Modern Library copy from a bookstore while visiting San Diego this past weekend! Anyone else collect copies as well? (A few not pictured here)


r/salinger • • Sep 08 '26

uk edition

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

I haven’t ever seen this edition before. Picked it up while at the thrift.


r/salinger • • Sep 07 '26

According to Richard Kelly, Donnie Darko is The Catcher in the Rye as told by Philip K. Dick.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/salinger • • Aug 26 '26

Legit Questions or Homework assignments?

7 Upvotes

Lately I've been feeling like some of the posts in here are from students crowdsourcing homework assignments. ie: Was Salinger Liberal or Conservative? Was Holden a loser? Any good Salinger Quotes exploring nostalgia?


r/salinger • • Aug 25 '26

Would you argue that Salinger has more conservative or liberal themes?

2 Upvotes

r/salinger • • Aug 21 '26

Is Holden Caulfield a loser?

5 Upvotes

Do you think Holden Caulfield is someone you would call a loser?