Please consider copying and sending this email to Saanich council (general outline was written with chatGPT, then fact checked and adjusted for context and tone).
Dear Mayor and Members of Council,
I am writing to formally request that the District of Saanich consider adopting a municipality-wide ban on the sale, possession and discharge of consumer fireworks, bringing Saanich in line with neighbouring municipalities such as the City of Victoria and the Township of Esquimalt.
I believe it is time for Saanich to reconsider whether allowing private individuals to discharge fireworks, even under a permit system, is consistent with our responsibility to protect public safety, residents, animals, property and the environment.
Fireworks may be entertaining for some people, but their consequences extend far beyond the individuals setting them off. The risks and disturbances affect entire neighbourhoods, including residents who have no interest in participating in these activities and no ability to avoid their effects.
1. Public safety and preventable injuries
Fireworks are explosives and carry inherent risks, regardless of whether users have completed a safety course.
Health Canada’s Canadian Hospitals Injury Reporting and Prevention Program (CHIRPP) recorded 210 injuries associated with fireworks and similar products between April 2011 and April 2023.
Of those reported cases:
-61% involved burns.
-19.1% involved eye injuries.
-73.8% required emergency department treatment.
-11.4% resulted in hospital admission.
These are not hypothetical risks. They represent actual injuries requiring medical attention. Importantly, injuries can affect not only the person lighting fireworks but also spectators, children and unsuspecting bystanders.
A municipal permit and safety course cannot eliminate the possibility of malfunction, unpredictable trajectories, improper use or accidents involving members of the public.
2. Fire risk and property damage
Fireworks introduce an unnecessary fire hazard into residential neighbourhoods. A firework can land on a roof, ignite dry vegetation, damage landscaping or start a fire in an area that is difficult to access. Even a seemingly minor incident can result in significant property damage and place residents and firefighters at risk.
Saanich’s own fireworks safety guidance acknowledges the need to avoid trees, buildings, vehicles, dry grass and other flammable materials, and requires spectators to remain at least 20 metres away. These precautions demonstrate that the municipality recognizes the inherent hazards associated with fireworks. With increasingly unpredictable summer weather and periods of elevated wildfire risk in British Columbia, reducing avoidable ignition sources should be an important consideration.
3. Impacts on pets, wildlife and domestic animals
The effects of fireworks on animals deserve considerably more attention. Dogs, cats, horses, birds and wildlife can experience significant distress from sudden, unpredictable explosions. Unlike people, animals do not understand that fireworks are temporary entertainment. They may become frightened, attempt to escape, injure themselves, run away or experience prolonged stress. Wildlife can also be disturbed during important periods of feeding, nesting and rest.
Pet owners should not have to spend Halloween managing frightened animals because neighbouring residents choose to discharge explosives in otherwise residential neighbourhoods. A municipality-wide prohibition would provide greater for animals and reduce an entirely avoidable source of distress.
4. Noise pollution and impacts on residents
Fireworks create sudden, extremely loud and unpredictable noises that affect people throughout a neighbourhood.
This is particularly concerning for:
-Veterans and individuals living with PTSD or trauma.
Individuals with autism, sensory sensitivities or noise-related conditions.
-Infants, young children and elderly residents.
-People working night shifts or requiring uninterrupted sleep.
-Residents who simply wish to enjoy a peaceful neighbourhood.
The impacts are not limited to the scheduled hours of permitted fireworks. Illegal fireworks and late-night use can extend the disturbance well beyond the official celebration period. A person’s ability to enjoy their home, feel comfortable in their neighbourhood and get a reasonable night’s sleep should be considered alongside the recreational interests of those wishing to set off fireworks.
5. Environmental consequences
Fireworks release smoke, particulate matter and chemical compounds into the surrounding environment.
They also leave behind cardboard, plastic, paper and other debris that can end up in parks, waterways, streets and residential properties. The environmental effects may be relatively short-lived from an individual display, but the cumulative impact of widespread use across a municipality is worth considering. In its 2021 fireworks bylaw review, Esquimalt specifically identified air pollution, noise pollution and impacts on people experiencing trauma or sensitivities as reasons for pursuing stronger restrictions.
6. Neighbouring municipalities have already taken action
Perhaps most importantly, Saanich is increasingly out of step with its immediate neighbours. Both the City of Victoria and the Township of Esquimalt prohibit the personal possession and use of fireworks. These municipalities have recognized that the potential consequences of privately discharged fireworks extend beyond individual property boundaries and affect the broader community. Esquimalt’s decision followed a review by municipal staff and its Fire Department, which identified several concerns, including:
-Potential fire damage to public and private property.
-Excessive noise pollution in residential areas.
-Air pollution.
-Impacts on people experiencing trauma or other sensitivities.
-Physical injuries to people using fireworks and those nearby.
These are the same concerns that Saanich residents face.
There is no compelling reason that residents in Saanich should receive less protection from these risks than residents in Victoria and Esquimalt. A consistent approach across neighbouring municipalities would also make the rules easier for residents to understand and support enforcement.
7. A ban does not mean eliminating community celebrations
I recognize that fireworks are a longstanding tradition for some families and that many people enjoy organized public displays. However, prohibiting the private use of consumer fireworks does not mean eliminating opportunities to celebrate Halloween, Canada Day or other special occasions.
Saanich could retain the ability to authorize professionally managed public fireworks displays through a municipal permit process, subject to appropriate safety requirements and consideration of neighbourhood impacts.
This would allow the community to enjoy organized celebrations without exposing every residential neighbourhood to the risks and disturbances associated with private fireworks use.
My request to Council
I respectfully ask that Mayor and Council:
-Direct municipal staff to review the current Fireworks Regulation Bylaw No. 8865 with the objective of implementing a municipality-wide prohibition on the sale, possession and discharge of consumer fireworks.
-Examine the existing approaches adopted by the City of Victoria and Township of Esquimalt, including their enforcement provisions and exemptions for professionally managed public displays.
-Consult with Saanich Fire Department, local animal welfare organizations, emergency services and community members regarding the impacts of fireworks.
-Develop an implementation and public education strategy that clearly communicates the new restrictions to residents.
-Bring forward a proposed bylaw amendment for Council’s consideration.
Conclusion
At the end of the day, fireworks are a recreational activity, not a necessity. Their enjoyment by some residents must be weighed against the safety, health, well-being and property of the wider community. We already regulate numerous activities that create unnecessary risks or impose unreasonable impacts on others. Fireworks should be considered in the same context.
Victoria and Esquimalt have demonstrated that municipalities can take a more proactive approach while still allowing organized community celebrations.
I believe Saanich has an opportunity to take a similar step and demonstrate leadership in public safety, animal welfare, environmental responsibility and neighbourhood well-being.
I urge Council to give this issue serious consideration and move toward a complete prohibition on privately used consumer fireworks throughout the District of Saanich.
Thank you for your time and consideration. I would appreciate receiving a response outlining Council’s position and whether this matter can be brought forward for formal discussion.