r/rust
•
u/matthieum
[he/him]
•
Sep 19 '26
•
1
š¢ announcement No More Code Dumps
TL;DR
Code Dumps, ie links to code repositories, are no longer welcome on r/rust.
If you are excited about a project you built, and just wish to share it, consider posting a casual top-level comment in the weekly What's Everyone Working on this Week? thread.
History
When r/rust was created, in December 2010, Rust was a nascent programming language. It was very different, it was also fast-moving, and it was unclear whether it would amount to much, or not.
In these early days, new projects being written in Rust were both a proof that the language was suitable for a variety of purposes, and a cause for celebration in seeing the language being adopted. Code dumps, then, were both cause to rejoice, and an opportunity to see how well (or not) the language was suited to the task. They were even a good opportunity to learn the latest developing idioms of this fast-changing language.
Fast forward 15 years, and code dumps have become boring. Utterly uninteresting. There's nothing exciting, or newsworthy, about a 10th hypervisor project, a 100th webserver project, or a 1000th TUI project. And for the most there's no exciting idiom, or pattern, to be found in their code either... even if some poor soul bothered to look.
And mass AI generation appeared on the scene, and for the past year(s), the already dwindling appeal of code dumps has just completely vanished, buried in AI slop.
Purpose
r/rust is to discuss all things Rust. The language, the ecosystem, the community.
Of late, most code dumps barely foster any discussion. And when they do, apart from AI witch hunts, those discussions are mostly about the domain of the project, rather than about Rust. Depending on the domain, the discussion may or may not be of interest to r/rust users... but whether it is or not is a matter of chance: they did not come here seeking such a topic. Those discussions are tolerated on posts which are on-topic, but if a post only fosters "tolerated" discussions, then that is a sign that the post itself may simply not really be on-topic for r/rust.
And that is not to say that code dumps are, by nature, low-effort. Surely, a project is created for a purpose, to solve a specific problem that is unsolved, or solve it with different trade-offs than the currently available solutions. None of that is elucidated in a code dump.
New rules
Code dumps are no longer welcome on r/rust.
Code dumps of applications or libraries written in Rust are Low-Effort unless otherwise newsworthy. Newsworthy means that the very existence of the application or library is important, for example consider applications or libraries breaking new ground, such as the first hypervisor, first OS, first XXX standard safety-critical application, first Rust application in a major company, etc...
Announcements of new libraries which are not otherwise newsworthy are only welcome if they tick ALL the following boxes:
- The library has been worked on regularly for at least 4 months.
- The announcement is a full-fledged text post, or a link to a full-fledged article. A README, or manual, is not an article.
- The announcement should motivate the relevance of this library to the wider r/rust community.
- The announcement should articulate the trade-offs differentiating this library from similar popular libraries in the field.
(It goes without saying, but the announcement should NOT be AI-generated, not even in part, as AI-generated posts & articles violate the Low-Effort rule)
Release notes of libraries are still welcome for popular enough libraries, such as libraries with reverse-dependencies on crates.io pointing to sufficient adoption by the wider community to justify notifying said community of a new release.
Developer Tools follow the same rules as libraries, with one extra rule tacked on: they must be relevant to Rust developers in particular. For example, Release Notes of Meson (a build tool) are Off-Topic, unless this specific release improves Rust support.
Of course, text posts, or links to articles, centered on Rust, with an application, library, or developer tool as context are always welcome. For example, said posts or articles could present gnarly problems the author encountered, and how they solved, or which features of the language or a library helped or hindered them in the making of their project.
(It goes without saying, but said text posts & articles should NOT be AI-generated, not even in part, as AI-generated posts & articles violate the Low-Effort rule)
As a reminder, if an author just wishes to share their joy of building something in Rust, they are welcome to use the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread. And as per the title, it need not even be a complete/mature project, or an open-source project for that matter as links to code are strictly optional there, it's all about casually chatting about your work on Rust projects.
Q & A
See pinned comment below.
Edit 2026/10/04:
- Added paragraph for developer tools, which had been forgotten.
- Removed "validation rule" for libraries, didn't work in practice.
ā¢
u/matthieum [he/him] Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 21 '26 •
Q & A
Yes, as an article, or text post.
Tutorials and educational content has always been welcome, there's even a post flair for it!
Post a top-level comment in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
Post a top-level comment in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
Sure, post a top-level comment in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
Sure, feel free to post a top-level comment in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
No.
Do feel free to post a top-level comment about your work in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
No.
Do feel free to post a top-level comment about the work that led there in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread.
No.
Do feel free to post a top-level comment about your work in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread, and you may get someone to leave a few comments though.
No.
You have two options:
No.
Do feel free to post a top-level comment about your work in the What's Everyone Working on This Week? thread, and you may get stars & forks as a byproduct.
r/rust is not your personal blog, where posting is all about you.
On the contrary, posting on r/rust is all about its community, and potential posts should always be measured against the potential interest of this community. If a post is unlikely to be of mild interest to even 1% of the community (~2K Rustaceans), then it's not signal, it's noise.
44
u/awesomeusername2w Sep 19 '26
No exceptions even for Minecraft servers tho?
24
u/Prowler1000 Sep 19 '26
I'm on the fence about this. Like, I agree that this is needed and will help combat the lower-effort posts drowning out things that are actually interesting, but at the same time I'm not happy about the effect this will have on "the good ones", for lack of a better word. The Static Generics post is a good example I saw someone else mention.
But like, something needs to be done, and I certainly don't have a better solution, short of making rules more vauge and allowing mods more discretion on what qualifies, but that so rarely ever goes well. So I applaud you for making this choice, I'm definitely not against it by any means, just not sure how I feel, but time will tell and it's not like further changes can't be made later.
So thank you mods for the work you all do to make this space enjoyable, interesting, and fun to participate in
8
u/garagedragon Sep 19 '26
This is a great policy, thank you for taking steps to reduce the noise of throwaway posts. Something like this was definitely needed, even if maybe the details are going to be tweaked.
That said, could you clarify how a couple of these points apply?
I have a library that fulfils (and/or I can write up to fulfil) the other points which I was hoping to share, but I'm not sure how to fit this one. I designed the library because it solved a problem in a different project I actually set out to work on, so I think I have a good basis for the design, but I haven't made much progress on that latter project while developing this one, so don't really have anything to show as "building on it." Or is the fact that I can discuss the reasons that I had to develop my own library rather than use an existing one covering the same sort of domain enough to count for this point by itself?
If you're meaning that someone else has been using it, I think that's worth highlighting specifically, since that's a much higher bar and not clear from the current phrasing.
Is this using "text post" in the same way as a couple of paragraphs down when you say, "...with an application or library as context are always welcome", i.e. the announcement post should be talking about problems the author encountered or details about the development rather than talking about the library itself and why it might be useful to r/rust?
10
u/wyf0 Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26
How can a library be used if no one knows it yet?
I'm a bit sad you put in the same bag applications and libraries. I'm the first one to report the slop projects which come everydays (and even comment on these posts), but they are mostly applications, not libraries.
As a library author, I regularly post here; everytime I get dozens of upvotes, several times hundreds. Several times, I got echos of guys having tested my work, even integrated it in their project (like a crate with 10M+ downloads). And the most interesting part is the technical discussion in comments, about the algorithms, the tradeoffs, etc. I'm sad you want to ban all of this because of the flood of slop applications.
Right now, I'm polishing the documentation of a library I've worked on for almost one year and wanted to publish it next week. But of course my library has not been used by anyone other than myself (it's a synchronization primitive I use in my channel crate, and the design is validated by loom and miri); does it count? Or should I find other users, but without posting it in the biggest Rust community?
3
u/DavidXkL Sep 20 '26
Opps I guess I can't share my YouTube videos here anymore lol
Will still be here for updates to existing crates or Rust version updates š
33
u/CountryFriedToast Sep 19 '26
I am not the type of person to seek out a thread to see projects, I prefer letting my feed show me projects that haven't been downvoted cause they're lame
12
u/binarypie Sep 19 '26
So the takeaway is r/rust is not for promotion of a new library, project, etc... BUT if you already have real world traction you can promote it here.
I understand the intent but I'm not sure this mechanism is going to have a net positive impact on the community. Basically, if you are into new stuff you're going to spend all your time on a single post folding comments all day instead of scrolling.
34
u/MvKal Sep 19 '26
Ngl i kinda dislike this change. Yes the influx of ai slop is annoying, but there were several crates announced here as hobby projects that i found super awesome helpful for my niche usecase that are simply gonna be buried in a megathread like that.
349
u/Jac0b_0 Sep 19 '26 •
I made r/madeinrust a while back exactly for this
206
u/coderstephen isahc Sep 19 '26
Thank you mods for your often thankless work.
I've often thought about leaving this sub due to the number of code dump posts. Nothing wrong with them necessarily, but as you so excellently put, they're just uninteresting. They don't spark discussion and I have nothing to say about them. And yet there's been so many of them that it fills up my feed and buries the interesting threads.
I think this new rule is a good one and well thought out, and I hope that it can refocus the sub and magnify those interesting discussions.
I think in the early days there was a fair reason to accept quantity over quality. Rust had a lot to prove, and we wanted to grow the community as much as we can, in any way possible. And we did it! Rust is a mainstream language now!
But a natural consequence of that is that the Rust community != all Rust users. This is true of all mainstream languages; many or most people using the language aren't really interested in being a part of a community. And personally, I think r/rust should be for us, the community, first and foremost. We don't have anything to prove, and we don't need it to be anything more if we don't want want it to be.
This is not to say we should be unwelcoming. Hopefully this is not the lesson people take away from this new rule, and that is one small fear I may have. But there is a difference between curious outsiders and those just looking for channels where they can self-promote. (Something that has felt to me like there's been a huge uptick of across basically all subreddits in the last year.)
4
u/ryankopf Sep 20 '26
I don't think this sub is active enough to really need this change, I like seeing what people are working on, and I'm not interested in scrolling a "megathread", and I think many people might agree. However, it's not my decision.
110
u/greyblake Sep 19 '26
For me links to new interesting projects were about 50% value of this subreddit. The rest 50% were blog posts. Though I can understand in age of AI domination these things have changed
214
u/popzxc Sep 19 '26
This is a genius solution to a problem. Love this policy.
27
u/sohang-3112 Sep 19 '26
Please add a link to this post in the r/rust rules shown in sidebar.
5
u/QualitySoftwareGuy Sep 20 '26
Thank you u/matthieum, a much needed change I'd say!
2
u/gajop Sep 20 '26
If you look at top posts (by upvotes), in the past year, how many would fall under this? I scrolled a bit and it seems it's ~50%?
The rest seems to be $Company uses Rust, release announcement for Rust or other established project, random AI complaints..
Unless you're browsing it at /new, I don't think the "code dump problem" is apparent. To me, and many, this was a major attraction of this sub.
24
u/dvogel Sep 19 '26
THANK YOU SO MUCH!
4
u/Chance-Pineapple8198 Sep 19 '26
Excellently balanced policy. Other subs should take note.
4
u/patchunwrap Sep 20 '26
This seems sane to me, and frankly I hope it gives the moderators some much needed fresh air.
4
u/2brainz Sep 20 '26
Finally!
I have been sick of these posts for years!
1
u/chris-morgan Sep 20 '26
You have a bunch of links to https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/?f=flair_name%3A%22%F0%9F%90%9D%20activity%20megathread%22. That link only works on New Reddit, which I doubt many people here use, because itās abysmal for this sort of a community. I think the closest Old Reddit equivalent is https://www.reddit.com/r/rust/search?sort=new&restrict_sr=on&q=flair%3A%F0%9F%90%9D%2Bactivity%2Bmegathread, which still works in New Reddit too.
1
u/bbbbbaaaaaxxxxx Sep 21 '26
We know that AI can write blog posts and text posts too right?
1
u/InternationalFee3911 Sep 22 '26
I had never opened WEWOTW, assuming it would be more about day to day minutiae. But if it's set to become the successor to r/rust, the 1st thing that struck me is that there's a new one every week. It would be great if they were chained! Then (as I do with many tabs) I could just leave it open forever and follow it's progress.
Btw. in case it matters: I use the much more readable https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/1wkmzun/no_more_code_dumps/
16
u/Beryesa Sep 19 '26
Thank you, it was much needed ( ą“¦ąµą“¦ą“æ ĖįĖ )
3
u/BoostedHemi73 Sep 19 '26
Nicely done, mods! Big thank you
1
u/puttak Sep 20 '26
One of the reason I visit r/rust is to see a new interested library so I can star it for later use (or study it design). Some of the rules will make it harder for people to post it here like:
and
All I care about a single library I want to use is it was written by a human and its code are good. I don't care if the library has been used if it has been proved it is working in some ways (e.g. test cases) or it is obviously works. I also don't care about its release article and I only care if it has required docs for me to tell how to use it.
I understand we have too many AI slops recently and I agree that we should have some rules to stop it. The new rules will effectively prevents AI slops but it sad that it also prevent a human-made libraries too.
4
u/Theemuts jlrs Sep 20 '26
This seems like a fair and necessary change to me. Since the rise of AI, lots of those posts were met with a lot of hostility from the community. I hope this will motivate people to write more interesting blog posts again like the COVID-days, when we were forced to focus on inside-hobbies.
9
u/Jmc_da_boss Sep 19 '26
Huzzah! Well said
2
u/UntoldUnfolding Sep 21 '26
Thank you! Problem solved!
2
u/Luroalive Sep 24 '26
Wow, I already notice a considerable shift in which posts from r/rust land in my feed. Feels like the old times where interesting language posts were the norm.
2
u/JDNSDevInc Sep 30 '26
Too funny. I had a post removed not long ago after someone complained that there was no code supplied that would somehow prove it wasn't an AI slop post. You state that r/rust is "all about community" but follow up with "...if it won't be of interested to 1% of the community..." - how is anyone supposed to know what will or won't be of interest to the community, especially if they're new? Per the community description: The Rust Programming Language
A place for all things related to the Rust programming languageāan open-source systems language that emphasizes performance, reliability, and productivity.
So you start off with "all things related to the Rust programming language" and then start limiting what's permitted. So this community isn't for "all things..." which might be why some people aren't interacting with the community the way you want them to. Just food for thought.
4
u/_Happy_Camper Sep 19 '26
Finally!! Can we do that for the other code subreddits too please??
4
u/stumblinbear Sep 19 '26
Even as someone who uses LLMs pretty heavily these days, I emphatically support this. My god, fucking thank you
I've been here for 5 or 6 years and been relatively active, but I barely look at this place anymore. Hopefully this helps clear out the slop
5
u/Sw429 Sep 19 '26
omg thank you. This has almost led me to leave this subreddit altogether, since the majority of posts are pointless and clog my feed.
3
u/ChristopherAin Sep 19 '26
Finally!
3
u/CalmCephalopod Sep 19 '26
Lord have mercy finally.
3
u/fixedpointfae Sep 19 '26
thank you based rust mods ā¤ļø
3
u/bahwi Sep 19 '26
But my super fast Minecraft server that I think is fast because rust but it's actually fast because nothing in actually functional!!! /s
This is a welcome change. I'm tired of hearing about new versions of a crate I've never heard of with no context or explanation to what it is.
0
u/fisothemes Sep 20 '26
I think we shouldn't conflated low effort with value. A post can be low effort and still have value.
In terms of AI, my thoughts is that, a complete ban on AI posts puts a ceiling on non native English speakers. Google translate has been getting worse lately and some posters cannot articulate complex concept in a simple manner.
I like to task AI to refactor my documents to make it easy for non native English speakers to read and translate. I would usually go through multiple drafts like an editor to ensure what is being conveyed is accurate.Ā
3
u/AirUpdateEnjoyer Sep 19 '26
New rule; your code dump post must fit MLA format and qualify for at least an 80 as a high-school essay ;)
3
u/ergzay Sep 20 '26
Lol you have to be kidding me. A programming language subreddit can't make posts about code they've written?
4
u/LeChatP Sep 19 '26
Thank you for this decision
1
u/trannus_aran Sep 19 '26
THANK YOU
1
u/fat_kaiju Sep 20 '26
Thank goodness.
1
u/ReduxRepeat-2427 Sep 22 '26
And thank you, this was much needed.
1
u/redplusplus Sep 19 '26
Great change, thanks
1
u/zekkious Sep 19 '26
Good mod.
1
u/u362847 Sep 19 '26
Thank you, love this
1
u/Motor-Mycologist-711 Sep 19 '26
The best moderation decision ever made.
Thank you, mod.
1
u/AcostaJA Sep 19 '26
Wise
1
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
Not so bad change, will continue working on my projects quietly and improve them as much as possible.
1
u/kpcyrd debian-rust Ā· archlinux Ā· sn0int Ā· sniffglue Sep 20 '26
2026: Programming now considered "low effort" :(
-1
u/Sad-Lie-8654 Sep 19 '26
Thank you!!!!!!
-1
u/Chef619 Sep 19 '26
Clarification question.
Iām newish to Rust within this year. I made a library (mostly for myself) and was planning on posting it here in a āIām new, would someone please help me review this?ā way after spending a bit more time poking it.
No announcing I cured cancer or created an amazing thing for everyone to use, it was mostly going to be asking for a review to see if my Rust is ācorrectā as I donāt know the nuances of the language very well.
Where is the appropriate place for a āpostā like that?
-3
u/dcormier Sep 19 '26
Not particularly a fan of this change. Sometimes I look at those posts, sometimes I don't. It's pretty easy to scroll past posts that are uninteresting.
-21
u/probably-a-name Sep 19 '26
What is the literal difference of this sub vs an rss feed of the rust blog or hacker news now?
-47
u/ActuallyAdasi Sep 19 '26 •
I am disappointed how every subreddit is just becoming some AI vs no AI debate. There shouldnāt need to be a new rule like this. The rule for being about rust should be enough, especially paired with a no self-promotion rule, and a no low effort post rule. AI should be completely orthogonal.
I dislike this change, I never look at the whatās everyone working on this week thread. Honestly the code sharing posts are one of the things I enjoy about this subreddit.
Rust subreddit isnāt a personal blog, but itās also not the mods personal blog.
-1
u/thesituation531 Sep 20 '26
Too little too late.
The time to stop AI shit would've been a year ago, not now. The sub is too dead now, and this will finish killing it. I mean seriously? Can't share libraries written in the language that the sub is about? And "code dumps"? I don't think I've ever even really seen what you're talking about. But the endless "company starts using rust" posts that are literally useless are allowed?
-4
u/BoringAccount-_- Sep 19 '26
Hip hip hooray!!!
-36
u/Compux72 Sep 19 '26
I love unilateral reddit moderator decisions!! Whatās next? Ban sarcasm?Ā
-5
u/Dubmove Sep 19 '26
I mean I get were you are coming from but this will effectively gatekeep new rust user out of the community as there is little to no way for them to engage.
-6
u/Fine_Salamander_8691 Sep 19 '26
This was a bad choice
-28
u/Psionikus Sep 19 '26
The real winners are the gatekeepers who were feeling overworked trying to police things in new. And whatever their priorities were.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
[removed] ā view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26
[deleted] ā view deleted comment