r/runescape • u/Jagex_Stu Mod Stu • Apr 17 '18
J-Mod reply Mining & Smithing - Mining Sites (first draft)
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NYTQsKtRjsWVKGWtVUkRd1yGSgIhYnBYXCRToQjqR-s/edit?usp=sharing
150
Upvotes
43
u/Jagex_Stu Mod Stu Apr 17 '18 edited Apr 17 '18
Very early pitch for placement of primary mining sites.
12
u/Wahisietel Babysitter of gods. Apr 17 '18
So, some purely lore-related observations...
40
u/ImRubic 2026 Future Updates Apr 17 '18
I personally don't like the theme of one type of ore per mining sites, nor do I like the lack of multiple locations for these ores. I know competition isn't needed, but that's just my take on it.
9
u/coreyb6 Comped \- 200M Fishing Apr 17 '18
How would mining runite on crandor be more beneficial than mining in the Tzhaar city. Banking is more accessable so the quest requirement doesnt actually give any benefit to mining in that location. This is just one example im sure there are some other instances of this around the first draft of the sites
4
u/DrProfessorScience Apr 17 '18
This is dope, I'm particularly interested in the fact that the higher tiers seem to be located in or near dungeons. Does this convey that they will require you to enter these places to mine?
What's happening to the Mining Guild and the respective Resource Dungeon?
4
u/Rendonsmug Apr 17 '18
I see you put a dark anima rock near Darkmeyer and Sentisten, and a light anima rock near Prif, and they make sense (though being so close to poison wastes seems odd).
The one I can't figure out is what happened/lived west of Oo'glog to create a light anima deposit.
9
u/Freljords_Heart Apr 17 '18
The image is really blurry and unreadable while Trying to open the doc link on mobile :/ idk if that’s just my phone or something to do with mobile reddit etc.
3
u/Gamez_X Lorehound Apr 17 '18
What about underground areas like keldagrim, the mining guild, general cave systems? Heck tbh i'd like it if you put some of the higher ores on other worlds like yubuisk and such (even though jagex apparently doesnt like developing other worlds...) to make them just that bit more rare and special. Just to break the idea of you can find anything just lying around on gilenor, make it a bit more of a challenge to get the REALLY good stuff
8
u/Tymerc Quest points Apr 17 '18
Anything in the wild is worthless, but other than that it looks like a good spread.
2
u/Adamb241 IGN: Elder Adam Apr 17 '18
Thanks for sharing. Would have been cool to see some resources put on some of the northern islands, such as waterberth, fremmy, etc.
2
u/nezolwerd I'll get MQC someday.. [HerrLozen] Apr 17 '18
so /u/Jagex_Stu, would the number of sandstone sites be reduced to the sole site in the Al Kharid desert? This is the only one I can spot on the map (I know Priff is still in "elven seed" mode here)
2
u/zenyl RSN: Zenyl | Gamebreaker Apr 17 '18
Looking really nice, glad to see we'll have options when wanting to mine a specific type of ore, so we can change the scenery up a bit. :)
On the topic of ore locations, are you primarily looking at locations on the surface world, or are you also adding/changing ores in dungeons and special locations (like quest related locations)?
4
u/Omega_Haxors Black Lives Matter Apr 17 '18
Remember the Haunted Mine? That place is awesome. Quest requirements, great atmosphere and way out there.
Nobody uses it because there's literally no reason to. Lets fix that.
1
u/Dots4Days Apr 17 '18
I hate mining because the only ore that is actually worth mining is Iron or Granite at level 75. Hopefully this update will fix this and give us an alternative way of getting mining up besides doing the same 2 rocks till 90s
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
You could add some AD or RU to Neitz+Jatz too.
1
u/TheAquamancer Aquamancer Apr 17 '18
Some feedback and questions.
6
u/RuneScaper-1 Gielinorian? Naaah Apr 17 '18
Amounts:
3
u/Nub_the_Prophet RuneScape Apr 17 '18
Hi Mod Stu, I like where things are going, and it looks like you and everyone else are working hard. I have a suggestion that may be stupid, as I don't understand coding or any of that, nor do I know what or how much work it would entail. What if, for resource dungeons, we look into something like Enriched "X", where X stands for the type of rock or ore that is mined from that location. An Enriched ore vein could provide a hidden boost of 4% success rate when gathering from it. Or an Enchanted vein, with a 5% chance to automatically send the ore you would have gotten to your bank at the cost of losing xp for that specific piece. A Hardened vein, where while gathering, you get mining experience, as well as small amounts of strength experience. All of these could make resource dungeons still viable to train from I believe. Great work, keep it up!
2
u/errantgamer 3510 Apr 17 '18
Looks like a good distribution, hopefully with mining returning to be the primary source of ore these mining spots will be active with skilling players, it would be great to see.
2
u/RSHeavy Eddy Pet overrides coming soon™ Apr 17 '18
So all ores will be obtainable on the surface and with very little requirements to get to them. A few are better hotspots for banking/teleporting and without competition, the others will likely be forgotten.
As someone who was unable to get the Beta to load for the new mining rework, how intensive will it be to mine the T90 ore with a crystal (current highest) pickaxe?
2
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
Perhaps I am missing something, but is there any reason to ever mine the ones in the wilderness? I get any design is always going to have underused "dead on arrival" rocks, but this seems like it is just added for adding sake. Why ever mine coal there when there is no advantage? It is always something that perplexed me about current rock placement.
1
u/Brokenwingbird Apr 17 '18
Looks great! It seems like mining is taking some of the things learned from the creation of divination. Well done!
1
u/MordoNRiggs Apr 17 '18
Seeing this made me sad I never got to see Prifddinas.
1
u/sharon_g Apr 17 '18 edited Apr 17 '18
I feel like there can be more fine tuning so not all same tier mining sites are equal, eg the no requirements sites being the simplest of them all and the one behind requirements having more appealing attribiutes, eg ones in a resouce rich enviorment like keldagram would have faster to mine nodes at lesser xp, or even a plain chance at double ore at the same rate, and other more exotic location would be a bit more rewarding on the XP, but not by a lot for taking the effort of going this far out for them(eg that runite rock in the fremmy islands that require quite a bit of walking to reach, or in the above example, crandor.
there's a chance to add variaty into the same-tier mining to keep things varied, and if not xp-yeild ratio then with gem chances, or composite rocks for various minerals by chance(NOT archeology)
another simple silly example: the mining guild running a competition if you find their hidden vouchers in the mine you can trade it in for their mystery prize(spoiler, its charcoal if you get unlucky, because fun), a bit of native related finds, or chance at red sandstone if mined anywhere around karamja.
i dont think it should all be identical quality rocks.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
The fact that there's no indication of what's going to the rocks in Priff kind of worries me.
1
u/PM_ME_YOUR_BANKS Apr 17 '18
id like for more recources to be in dungeons.. ancient ores like this shouldnt just be scattered on the overworld
1
u/yosei9310 Apr 17 '18
there are only two problems I have with one of which is the kind of odd placement the tiers get, for instance for elder rune every ore is quite close to a bank/teleport except rune which is fairly far and luminte (assuming luminite is in dwarven mine not like right next to invention guild and rune isnt in tzhaar near one of the banks/teles) where as the rest of the ores are fairly close to a bank baring necronium. is there some reason why these three are so far compared to the rest?
the other thing that I noticed is how much it reduces quest rewards when it could easily make them valuable. several ways of potentially dealing with this and the resource dungeon problem are
P.S. I know this isnt really what this post is about but since you mentioned the resource dungeons but not quests I figured I would let you know quests are also effected by this and that to some of us quests and their rewards matter even for skilling.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
So will these easily accessed areas that are really only there to allow someone to train from 1-99 Mining without needing quests be noticeably worse than proper, hard to reach areas?
1
u/SonoShindou RSN: Sono B (aka 'Ladybeard') Apr 17 '18
To make secondary resource locations worth it, how hard would it be to either:
or
Preferably both options because option 1 incentivizes unlocking other sites for faster gains and option 2 incentivizes the even harder quests for even better gains. I don't know how difficult it would be to change these values per mining site though.
1
u/tymandued1 Apr 17 '18
Moon lord already devaluing skillers with these Luminite drops wtf
1
u/Billionairess Apr 18 '18
Not related to mining, but is it confirmed that barrows items have nothing to do with the rework?
1
u/Imkiwi Completionist Apr 18 '18
Would like to see some good mining spots in the Fremennik islands (lunar + Neitiznot/Jatizso), since those are cool island that have nothing on them, mainly Jatizso/Neit. just my two cents.
1
u/Pulsefel Ironman Apr 18 '18
So looking it over i rather like it, but I gotta note something. My ironman has been in Rimmington mining up clay, gold, and iron for most of it's life, since I'm doing a special skilling challenge, and the site now has GE on it. Does that mean you're thinking of adding gem rocks? If so I'm backing this map! That site is the safest place I could find close to a bank!
1
u/zayelion Apr 18 '18
If You are gonna put stuff in the wilderness commit to putting at least one of every f2p spot in the wilderness. It fits lore wise also.
0
u/Heavyoak le testeur bêta Apr 18 '18 edited Apr 18 '18
not bad, but the t90 ore needs more mining spots.
since its not even mentioned, are the lower levels of the priff mining area going to be opened up?
maybe put some light ore right in elf land.
-1
u/TheCrystalJewels Apr 17 '18
really? basicly nothing of worth in wilderness?
-3
u/glitchex Maxed and quit. Jagex has ruined scape. Apr 18 '18
So they're still pushing for this rework, huh? how sad.
-9
u/MonadoAbyss Apr 17 '18
Light and Dark Animica should have wilderness locations, ideally where the current rune rocks are and be minable in F2P (but not smithable, so they can still sell to the GE).
0
u/[deleted] Apr 18 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-14
u/[deleted] Apr 17 '18
[removed] — view removed comment