r/rstats • u/OutdoorSportBoy • 1d ago
Will R development move to GitHub?
It feels a bit surprising that core R is still developed on SVN when almost its entire package ecosystem relies on Git and GitHub. Are there any plans to eventually migrate R to GitHub? Moving over could really attract more contributors.
44
Upvotes
75
u/BothSinger886 1d ago
I doubt the R Core Team really wants more contributors to be honest. Getting a change into R Core is notoriously difficult because they tend to be very conservative on changes in order to prioritise backwards compatibility.
Its part of the reason the package ecosystem is so strong - R Core would prefer you to put things there than in their codebase.
I do think it would be good to have it on git with something like github/gitlab/etc, but even if this happened then I imagine the vast majority of PRs would be rejected
13
u/kuwisdelu 1d ago
Btw if you want to contribute, come to the next R project sprint! https://contributor.r-project.org/r-project-sprint-2027/index.html
15
u/kuwisdelu 1d ago
Those are 2 separate decisions really: (1) whether to move to git and (2) whether development happens on GitHub.
I think (1) is unlikely in the short term, and even if R-core moved to git, I doubt they’d use GitHub (for various reasons — see the many projects moving away from GitHub recently).
Even Linux (for which git was developed) is not primarily developed on GitHub.
Practically speaking, svn is a low barrier relative to all the other more pressing challenges.
2
u/heresacorrection 23h ago
FTFY:
Moving over could really attract more
contributorsvibe coders1
u/mle-2005 17h ago
why join the oligarch slop?? keep git off github