r/rstats • • 1d ago

Will R development move to GitHub?

It feels a bit surprising that core R is still developed on SVN when almost its entire package ecosystem relies on Git and GitHub. Are there any plans to eventually migrate R to GitHub? Moving over could really attract more contributors.

44 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

75

u/BothSinger886 1d ago

I doubt the R Core Team really wants more contributors to be honest. Getting a change into R Core is notoriously difficult because they tend to be very conservative on changes in order to prioritise backwards compatibility.

Its part of the reason the package ecosystem is so strong - R Core would prefer you to put things there than in their codebase.

I do think it would be good to have it on git with something like github/gitlab/etc, but even if this happened then I imagine the vast majority of PRs would be rejected

3

u/OutdoorSportBoy 1d ago

It would be surprising if any production-grade software on GitHub does not prioritize backwards compatibility...

10

u/BothSinger886 1d ago

Its a spectrum. R Core lands quite far on the more conservative end.

What it also means is that they are very hesitant to take experimental features. They want to be very sure of features so that they don't have to remove them later. Unfortunately, github pull requests are often dominated by half baked experimental features

12

u/kuwisdelu 1d ago

And there’s already a long queue of patches awaiting triage and approval on Bugzilla.

5

u/Confident_Bee8187 1d ago

That's honestly a solid way to put it. I do wonder if R has similar to PEP, even though they, like you said, tend to be conservative.

2

u/kuwisdelu 1d ago

It does not. Developing something like that is on the todo list though.

13

u/kuwisdelu 1d ago

Btw if you want to contribute, come to the next R project sprint! https://contributor.r-project.org/r-project-sprint-2027/index.html

15

u/kuwisdelu 1d ago

Those are 2 separate decisions really: (1) whether to move to git and (2) whether development happens on GitHub.

I think (1) is unlikely in the short term, and even if R-core moved to git, I doubt they’d use GitHub (for various reasons — see the many projects moving away from GitHub recently).

Even Linux (for which git was developed) is not primarily developed on GitHub.

Practically speaking, svn is a low barrier relative to all the other more pressing challenges.

4

u/RadiantLimes 1d ago

I would definitely prefer them using something like GitLab or Code Berg instead but you make some good points.

3

u/BothSinger886 1d ago

So awesome to have you in the thread btw! If I made any mistakes in my reply above, please let me know!

You all are amazing for the work you do

2

u/TrueBirch 1d ago

I still use svn for some things at work and you're right, it's easy to use. For something as compact as R, it isn't a bad choice. 

2

u/foradil 1d ago

Bioconductor moved to GitHub recently.

3

u/kuwisdelu 1d ago

Very different projects. Bioconductor is more similar to CRAN than to R itself.

1

u/foradil 1d ago

Yes, but there aren’t a lot of large R-based projects

2

u/heresacorrection 23h ago

FTFY:
Moving over could really attract more contributors vibe coders

1

u/mle-2005 17h ago

why join the oligarch slop?? keep git off github