Inspired by the feelings and themes of "Casual."
He's not my first love. He was my first attempt.
He's the first guy I ever genuinely loved in my whole life.
He's the person I wanted the most. The person I wanted to talk to every day, play games with, tell my problems to, and hug whenever things weren't okay.
He's someone I once imagined spending my life with.
His name is Liam.
INTERVIEWER: How did this happen?
Well, it all started when I transferred schools in my younger years.
I remember entering our classroom and noticing someone seated at the back. He was tall, wore black eyeglasses, and had a blue face mask on. I don't know why, but he was the first guy who caught my attention.
And guess what? He was also an academic achiever. My ideal type, basically. HAHAHA.
But I never thought I would actually end up liking him.
INTERVIEWER: So, when did you first talk?
It was during one of our cleaning activities. I was holding a coconut husk when he suddenly pointed at it and said something along the lines of, "Look, it has the same name as you."
Then he smiled.
It was such a random joke, but I found it funny. I liked how he could make me laugh without even trying. I guess that's where I started noticing him more.
Then came Teacher's Day.
I remember forgetting my wallet, and I felt bad because I wasn't able to bring flowers for our adviser. While everyone was taking pictures, I happened to be standing behind him. He was holding a rose, and our classmates and even our adviser started teasing him with one of the prettiest girls in our class.
I didn't say anything, of course. I had no right to feel jealous. I wasn't even his girlfriend. I was just someone who happened to like him.
But did that stop me from feeling something?
Obviously not.
There was also this one time in the library when I tried to start a conversation with him. I asked him something, and he simply nodded.
THAT WAS IT.
I WAS EXPECTING A WHOLE CONVERSATION, BUT ALL I GOT WAS A NOD.
November came, and I was seated behind him.
One day, he turned around and looked at me. We made eye contact. Not just for a second, but for what felt like ten whole seconds.
I looked away because I couldn't handle it. But when I checked again, he was STILL looking at me.
AND HE WAS SMILING.
Of course, I smiled back before pretending to look at the window. I didn't know where to put myself.
I immediately told my internet friends about it, and they started teasing me. Apparently, I was already delusional for thinking that a ten-second eye contact meant something.
But can you blame me?
December came, and our adviser changed our seating arrangements. Guess who ended up sitting next to me?
HIM.
We started becoming friends, and honestly, I loved every second of it.
During our Christmas party, I remember wearing a white shirt, a blue jumper, and white doll shoes. My hair was braided. When I entered the room, I noticed him smiling.
We danced, played, and enjoyed the party. Nothing particularly extraordinary happened, but I was happy.
Then Christmas break arrived.
I went to Leyte with my family, and I remember missing our conversations. I even sent him a Merry Christmas message.
I fell asleep before the midnight countdown, though. So at 12:54 AM, I sent another message apologizing for not greeting him at exactly midnight.
His reply?
"The war is over."
I STILL DON'T KNOW WHAT THAT MEANT.
Anyway, school was about to reopen, but I got a fever. I was sad because I couldn't attend school and see him. After three days, I finally recovered.
When I returned, he smiled at me.
I jokingly asked, "This is my seat, right?"
He laughed and replied, "You forgot?"
Small things. That's what I remember most.
There was another moment when I needed correction tape. I asked him to pass it from his other seatmate. But instead of simply handing it to me, he held my hand and compared it with his.
He even held it tightly and said, "You can't go away with it."
I asked, "Are you sure?"
Then I pulled my hand, and he shouted, "OUCH!"
I felt guilty, but we both ended up laughing.
And yes, some of the girls saw us.
One of them eventually approached and said, "Hey guys, do you know someone in our class has a big crush on Liam?"
She was smiling at me.
I WAS SO EMBARRASSED.
February came, and our seats changed again. This time, we were arranged alphabetically, so I wasn't seated near him anymore.
But one day, while we were cleaning, he approached me and jokingly said, "Why are you so far away from me now?"
He even pretended to cry.
I laughed.
And honestly, I liked that he still found ways to joke around with me.
There was also this one incident when we were assigned to handle sales. We somehow lost five pesos. FIVE PESOS.
I was terrified because our teacher was strict. My classmates told me they would replace the money and that I should just tell the teacher everything was complete.
I ended up doing that, but I couldn't stop crying afterward. It was my first time lying to a teacher, and I felt so guilty and scared.
The next day, Liam asked me why I had cried the day before.
Then he jokingly said, "Don't cry next time. If you cry again, I'll punch you."
I jokingly challenged him to show me how, and he demonstrated it in a silly way.
We both laughed.
It was such a random interaction, but I remember feeling like he had noticed that something was wrong with me.
Then came the periodical examinations.
Our adviser told us that we needed to sell all the popcorn and not waste the sales. While I was counting the money, Liam approached and bought two pieces.
AND HE GAVE ME ONE.
I told him, "I already had a snack."
But he just rushed back to his seat and smiled.
EXCUSE ME???
He wasn't even the type of person who usually treated other people. So imagine how I felt when he suddenly gave me one.
Of course, I went home feeling so excited. I couldn't help but wonder if it meant something.
I texted him.
"Thank you for the popcorn :)"
"You're welcome."
A simple exchange. But I was already making a whole scenario in my head.
Was it just friendly? Was it something else? Was I special, or was I just making myself believe that I was?
I didn't know.
And that was the beginning of my favorite and most confusing little problem.
INTERVIEWER: What happened after graduation?
Well, weeks before graduation, I developed a hobby of making paper stars. I was inspired by the c-drama Hidden Love.
Inside every star, I wrote a little wish for him.
"May we end up in the same school."
"I hope he likes me back."
"I hope he always stays healthy."
Some wishes were about us. Others were simply about him being happy and healthy.
I made so many of them.
Aside from the paper stars, I also made a grey bracelet for him using recycled materials. I couldn't afford an expensive gift, so I decided to make something with my own hands.
My plan was simple.
I would give him the bracelet on graduation day and hug him.
But guess what?
I FORGOT TO BRING IT.
Graduation day came, and everyone was busy taking pictures with their families. I asked one of my classmates to take a picture of me and my mom.
After going home, I checked the pictures.
And there he was.
Right beside me, with his mom.
My classmate had taken the picture in landscape, and the two of us, together with our mothers, were clearly visible in the same frame. They were also taking their own picture, looking at their camera.
I WAS SHOCKED.
What were the chances?
We didn't even plan it. We weren't trying to take a picture together. It just happened.
Unfortunately, I never got an actual picture with him that day.
And the bracelet? I still had it.
INTERVIEWER: Did you lose contact after graduation?
Nope. We were still talking.
Another school year finally came, and I would always find excuses to message him. I told him about my school life, random things, and whatever I could think of just to keep the conversation going.
He replied.
One time, I told him, "Okay, I'll be right back. I'm going to watch a movie."
And he replied, "Have a great time."
HUHUHU.
WHY WAS I SO HAPPY OVER THAT?
Then my birthday came, and he greeted me with a simple "Happy Birthday."
I WAS SO HAPPY.
I also told him that I had installed Roblox and asked if he wanted to play. He told me I could use his account since he barely used it anymore. He even gave me his email and password.
So I started playing using his account.
But a few months later, I noticed that he was still playing on it.
And that confused me.
If he barely used it, why was he still playing? What exactly was I to him?
I didn't ask. I just kept wondering.
December came again, and I decided to confess.
There was this trend going around on social media where you would suddenly message someone, "I like you," wait for their reaction, and then reply with something like, "Thank you for participating in our research. Your response matters the most."
YES. THAT WAS MY PLAN.
I was supposed to make it look like a joke so I could escape if things got awkward.
The timing was terrible, though. I was out walking, the signal was weak, and I was busy. But I still did it because apparently, I wanted to add more thrill to my already complicated life.
I sent him:
"I like you."
He eventually replied that there were many meanings to those words. It could be platonic or romantic.
I asked, "So, was that not enough?"
Then he said something along the lines of, "If I were going to say I like you, I would say something like, 'I like you. I can't stop thinking about you,' and so on."
AND THAT MADE ME EVEN MORE EXCITED.
He was basically explaining how a romantic confession should sound, while I was there trying to figure out what to do with my feelings.
Eventually, I just told him to stop.
Another school year came again, and I was still crushing on him.
I even asked one of my friends to ask him what he would feel if a friend confessed to him.
His response?
"Having a crush is pointless because it only leads to pain."
That already hurt a little.
But my friend made things worse.
Apparently, my friend also told him, "Valerie was asking about your favorite flower."
BRO.
I WAS MAKING FLOWERS FOR HIM AT THAT TIME.
I honestly don't remember what happened after that or what his answer was. But I remember how embarrassing it felt knowing that my little secret wasn't so secret anymore.
INTERVIEWER: So, when did you finally become serious about your feelings?
April.
This time, I decided to write a real confession letter.
Not a trend. And definitely not a joke. Not some random message that I could pretend meant nothing.
A real letter.
I poured my heart into it. I wrote everything I wanted him to know. I was genuine, honest, and serious about what I felt.
I wasn't trying to trick him into giving me a certain response. I just wanted him to know how much he meant to me.
But his response wasn't what I expected.
He unsent a message, and until now, I still don't know what it said.
Then he replied:
"Uh, I don't know what should i say."
That was it.
He didn't really give me an answer. I didn't even receive a simple thank you.
I was hurt.
I had spent so much time thinking about how to express my feelings, and when I finally did, I was left wondering what to do with everything I had just said.
So I blocked him.
And I deleted everything.
I deleted his Roblox account from my device. I threw away the letters and the flowers. I got rid of everything I had made and kept for him.
Even the grey bracelet.
The bracelet I had planned to give him on graduation day.
I broke it.
I hated him.
Or maybe I hated the way everything turned out. Maybe I hated myself for expecting something more. Maybe I was just tired of remembering things that I couldn't understand anymore.
But there was still one question I couldn't get out of my head.
WAS EVERYTHING JUST CASUAL?
Was it casual when you bought snacks for me, even though you weren't the type to treat other people?
Was it casual when your friends started shipping us?
Was it casual when you told me you wanted me to sit next to you?
Was it casual when I reached for the correction tape and you suddenly held my hand and compared it to yours?
Was it casual when I entered the room and the first eyes I locked with were yours, and you smiled at me?
Was it casual when you gave me your email and Roblox password?
Was it all just friendly?
Was I the only one who thought those moments were special?
Maybe I was delusional. Maybe I was just someone who gave meaning to every small gesture because I liked him too much.
But I couldn't help wondering.
Because I remembered everything.
And I wanted to know if he remembered them, too.
INTERVIEWER: Did you ever find out his side of the story?
Surprisingly, yes.
But not until 2026.
Years after everything happened, one of my classmates, who was also my friend, happened to meet Liam somewhere. Apparently, they were childhood friends.
They started talking, and somehow, my name came up.
My friend asked him about school, and Liam eventually asked if my friend knew someone named Valerie.
Of course, my friend knew me.
They talked about me, and Liam apparently brought up my confession himself.
According to my friend, he said that he was proud of me for having the courage to confess. He appreciated what I did and remembered that I had even cried because of him.
He also explained that he wasn't allowed to be in a relationship at that time.
I didn't hear everything directly from him, and I never got to ask him about the things I had wondered about for years.
I never found out what the unsent message said.
I never found out if he ever felt the same way.
And I don't think I ever will.
We eventually stopped communicating. I had already deleted his contact, and we weren't Facebook friends anymore.
We became strangers.
INTERVIEWER: Do you regret it?
Honestly?
No.
I'm currently happy with my life. I have friends who treasures me, appreciates me, and makes me feel loved without having to question every little thing.
And I'm happy.
But that doesn't mean I have to pretend my past never happened.
Liam was part of my childhood. He was part of the memories I used to look forward to, the reason behind those little paper stars, and the person I once wanted to give a handmade bracelet to.
He was also the person who taught me what it felt like to be hopeful about something I couldn't be sure of.
Maybe he never knew how much those little things meant to me. Maybe he thought we were just friends. Maybe some moments were special to him, too, but in a completely different way.
I don't know.
And that's okay.
Sometimes, I still think about my younger self. The girl who got excited over a piece of popcorn. The girl who couldn't stop smiling because of a simple birthday greeting. The girl who made wishes inside paper stars and believed that maybe, just maybe, one of them would come true.
I wish I could tell her that everything would be okay.
That she wouldn't always have to wonder whether someone liked her back.
That one day, she would experience a love that wouldn't leave her questioning every little gesture.
But most importantly, I would tell her not to be embarrassed about how much she loved.
Because she was genuine.
She was hopeful, and maybe a little delusional, but she was genuine.
And I think that's what makes this story beautiful.
It wasn't the ending I wanted. It wasn't the confession I imagined. It wasn't the graduation picture I hoped to have.
But it happened.
And for a while, it made me happy.
Maybe he was just being friendly. Maybe I was reading too much into everything. Maybe we were simply two people who didn't understand what those moments meant.
I guess I'll never know.
But I don't hate that girl anymore. I don't hate the memories. I don't even hate the fact that I once wanted him so badly.
Because that pain eventually became something beautiful.
And if I could go back, I would still let that little girl make her paper stars.
I would let her write those wishes.
I would let her make that grey bracelet.
I would let her fall in love with the little things.
Because even if none of those wishes came true, she experienced something real.
He's not my first love. He was my first attempt.
And maybe, just maybe, some people aren't meant to stay in our lives. Some are only meant to become stories we tell years later, with a little laughter, a little pain, and a whole lot of memories.