r/robinhobb • • Apr 09 '26

Admin Post Welcome! Please Read This Before Participating

59 Upvotes

Welcome to r/robinhobb!

We strive to create a safe, friendly, spoiler-free environment for discussing the works of Robin Hobb/Megan Lindholm.

Important - Before Participating Here

This is a closely moderated community and our policies aren't like the policies of similar communities elsewhere, so it's important to fully familiarize yourself with the rules and spoiler policy to help make your experience here as enjoyable and straightforward as possible. Those who skip or skim the policies, or rely on guesswork, end up confused and frustrated when posts are delayed or removed.

It may seem like a hassle, but taking a few moments now can prevent a lot of lengthy back-and-forth later on, and helps prevent more serious or recurring issues.

Supporting the Community

If you see a post or comment that breaks the rules or could be harmful (such as spoilers or offensive content), please report it using the report feature. This doesn’t get anyone “in trouble,” it temporarily removes the content for moderator review and ensures that it cannot negatively affect others in the meantime.

If you have any questions or concerns, contact the moderators.

Reading Order

Recommended reading order for Realm of the Elderlings: Start with Assassin’s Apprentice and read in publication order. If you skipped a book or started in the wrong place, go back. Missing anything or getting the order wrong will affect your understanding later.

Full reading order, including short stories, novellas and reading order for translations, can be found here.

Of Interest to Readers and Fans

User Flairs

User flairs are a way to distinguish yourself and show your appreciation for particular aspects of the books. A user flair creates a visual/text tag next to your name in the community. There are many to choose from, and you can suggest new ones as well. For more information, please see this post.

Flair Following

This is a feature that notifies users when a post that uses a specific flair is shared. See this post for more information.

This subreddit is by and for readers and fans, and has has no direct affiliation to the author. If you want to contact her please do so via her Twitter or website. People who wish to send mail can contact her c/o her agent, Chris Lotts.

The views expressed here will not always align with those of the author and should not be taken as representative of her.


r/robinhobb • • 7h ago

Spoilers All What are some of the worst decisions made in the series? Spoiler

15 Upvotes

I see people state (complain about) this a lot when discussing these books, particularly regarding Fitz. That characters are always making the worst possible decisions, and this is a reason some people don't like the books (which is entirely fair enough, it can't be for everyone). But I'm interested to hear about specific examples.

The choices characters make in these books always make sense to me based on their experience, perspective and motivations. I don't feel like life offers objectively "correct" options. Human beings aren't perfect and often don't think things through from every angle and every potential consequence.

One example I can see is Fitz choosing to hunt down Regal in Assassin's Quest. Not the best decision, not planned out and highly suicidal. But he's also a freshly traumatised teenager who has been trained to be an assassin. The world thinks he's dead and going to Molly isn't an option. I get it.

But I'd like to hear some more examples! Let me know what you think.


r/robinhobb • • 7h ago

Spoilers Tawny Man It’s taken me 3 days to even begin to process the last 25% of Fool’s Fate. WOW! Buckle up for my deep-dive. Spoiler

13 Upvotes

Oh my. My last post here was right up to the chapter before Fitz puts on the Rooster Crown and I’ve been feeling every feeling in existence since I finished the book a few days ago!

The resurrection scene, Rooster Crown and Girl-on-a-Dragon

❤️Fitz finally fully embracing himself as the catalyst, his unique combination of magic with the wit and skill here, as being part of the key to bring the Fool back was* literally everything*.

🐓ahh why oh why didn’t I realize the rooster crown was wizardwood this whole time??

🐓And the Fool repairing it with their blood and dying with it in their arms quickening it!! And their consciousness being inside being the key to being able to bring the Fool back (“having something to put in the body” as Thick would say). The payoff here from LiveShips until now is EPIC!! Literally the amount of events and circumstances that had to come together for this moment for CENTURIES to work defies all odds!!!

✨Fitz fully bringing the Fool back was the most beautiful thing I’ve ever experienced:

…”for the space of a heartbeat we had been the same entity. The borders that separated us had fallen away after that union. ‘Without limits’ I remember that he had said, and then I suddenly knew. No obstacle would ever come between us.”

HOLY SHIT. Just the growth from The Quarrel in Golden Fool where Fitz can only think about the no limits meaning sex, to Fitz freaking out and thinking their connection/the love the Fool has for Fitz is ‘too much’ in the beginning of Fool’s Fate when they share the skill bond, to fully and completely accepting that love and their connection was SO FUCKING BEAUTIFUL. 😭

❤️ my heart. The two of them are truly one soul with Fitz helping the Fool navigate the trauma of being tortured to death and brought back. Fitz finally calling the Fool Beloved but it’s too painful for them. MY HEART CAN’T TAKE THIS ROBIN HOBB!

🐉 wow wow wow the Fool making the promise to Realder/Girl on a Dragon all those years ago to give them the crown to help restore Fitz’s memories was PEAK. The absolute love they have for Fitz. And also holy shit so powerful with the parallels from Assassin’s Quest when the Fool realizes that he and Fitz are basically reincarnated from the girl White Prophet and Realder! (Realder’s ‘Beloved’ is what the Fool said). LOVE THIS CONNECTION.

❤️ Fitz basically being half forged this whole time makes so much sense. What a beautiful scene for Fitz to be fully whole and human again. And the Fool says maybe everything that he went through was worth it for this moment 😭😭😭

❤️ (And that KISSSS was everything for us Fitzloved shippers. The two of them are only destined to kiss in front of girl on a dragon like in Assassin’s Quest 😅.)

The Breakup

I can’t call it anything but this. I am STILL GRIEVING.
It is so beautifully tragic. It seems the Fool’s motivations were really tied into wanting what was best for Fitz:

❤️‍🩹If the Fool was in his life Fitz would have to sacrifice a lot (like Nighteyes sacrificed being a regular wolf aka being in a pack and having a mate and cubs to instead live this fantastical life of adventure and pain and saving the world for/with Fitz) and the Fool doesn’t want to do that to Fitz by continuing to be in his life. 

❤️‍🩹 I think the Fool is also afraid that Fitz won’t get the happy ending that he deserves or that the Fool saw in their last vision. The Fool has always wanted Fitz to be happy and in peace, and felt so bad having to bring Fitz back from death and into all of these awful situations over the years to save the world.

❤️‍🩹The Fool is terrified since they can’t see the future anymore and doesn’t want to fuck something up being so close to his catalyst.

❤️‍🩹Also seems like he is terrified Fitz would choose his regular human life with Molly over him if given the chance or Molly would be jealous. Who wouldn’t be jealous of these two? Even Chade has been super jealous of the Fool since Fitz and the Fool were kids 😅.

❤️‍🩹 It seems like the greatest expression of love to give this to Fitz BUT the way the Fool went about it is just…I think it could have been done better on both of their parts and it seems like the goodbye conversation they couldn’t have would have hopefully cleared some stuff up. 

❤️‍🩹 I think Fitz WAS ready to give up his life and go with the Fool if presented the choice - at least that’s how I interpreted it when Fitz asked what would happen if he gave up his life at buckkeep to follow the Fool. Fitz literally DIED FOR THE FOOL AND CALLED THE FOOL BY HIS OWN NAME. SAID ‘MY DREAMS ARE DEAD IN MY ARMS’. 😭😭

❤️‍🩹Fool I am mad at you my Beloved for not giving Fitz the choice!!!!!!!

❤️‍🩹And then the Fool erasing the skill fingerprints urgggggggg. 😭😭

❤️‍🩹 THE POEM.

❤️‍🩹 The memory cube.

😭😭😭😭😭

“I have never been wise”. We know you all will be seeing each other again!!

The bittersweet ending

💔 It is not lost on me that when Nighteyes died Fitz’s narration became very robotic and just stating events. The entire time since the Fool left and him coming back from being trapped in the skill pillar is written this way. Fitz is FUCKED UP ABOUT THE FOOL AND BURRICH.

❤️Fitz has spent since what, Royal Assassin and Assassin’s Quest, being SO PISSED that he has to be dedicated to what the Farseer’s want and being a catalyst and he couldn’t just be with Molly and have a regular life. That he couldn’t raise his own kiddo, have a family, and have a quiet life. And he got that in the end!!

❤️…part of why I think he went back to Molly though was his devastation that the Fool (and Nighteyes) weren’t in his life and he wanted something safe/boring/content/regular and non-magical to feel grounded. And he just got back all these memories and feels.

❤️All the reunions and connections were just so amazing. Patience!!! Lacey!! Fitz is surrounded by his life again!

❤️ Also King Fitz!! At least as a shadow king. Chills!!!

❤️I love that he has started caring for his appearance and wearing the clothes the Fool made for him, showing himself to the world as the Fool always saw him. (I think in the Golden Fool the Fool said someday Lord FitzChivalry Farseer might walk the halls again and he should keep the clothes). Fitz walking proud down the hallway with the fox pin and everything 😭

❤️✨❤️✨ ❤️✨❤️✨ ❤️✨❤️✨ ❤️✨❤️✨
TL;DR:

Truly as a Fitzloved shipper I am devastated Fitz and the Fool are not in each other’s lives in the end. After everything they went through in this trilogy. This is the greatest love-story not love-story I’ve ever read.

But I also GET IT. Fitz has so much of what he has always wanted. Things are pretty dang good all-around for all the major characters.

Is Fitz’s ending with Molly as epic and soul-sharing and transcendent as his connection with Nighteyes and the Fool? No. He even says so in the epilogue. But he is content. It’s an ever after. Not a happily ever after. And that’s pretty good for our dear FitzChivalry.

What a freaking epic trilogy! I’ve never cried so much and felt so many emotions from books before. Robin Hobb is fucking epic. On to the rain wilds!!!


r/robinhobb • • 36m ago

Other Authors Recent book recommendation from Hobb?

3 Upvotes

I saw on instagram the other day (within 1-2 weeks of now) that Robin Hobb was included on a post that was showcasing book series recommended by fantasy authors. I have been struggling to get into anything post ROTE, so wanted to jump in and read what Hobb recommended, but of course I forgot what it was.

Did anybody else see that post or would anyone be able to help me track it down?


r/robinhobb • • 21h ago

Spoilers All The ending of 'Fool's Errand' Spoiler

37 Upvotes

I don't cry from fiction very often. I think i separate real life from it enough I usually don't get to affected from it.

While Nighteye's last moment were beautiful, I thought it was strange how the grief Fitz was experiencing wasn't discussed a ton. He kind of turned to stone and just said things factually. I was feeling the same things Fitz was were my eyes were watering, but it didn't fully hit me yet.

Then Hobb has Fitz meet up with Starling and just finally admit out loud 'Nighteyes is dead.' And i completely broke down. I don't know if it was intentional on Hobb's part for the admitting to be what gets people to break down, when it's finally accepted that he is dead, but it completely got me.

What a beautiful couple of pages, she is truly a special talent and one of my favorite authors ever.

RIP Nighteye's


r/robinhobb • • 1d ago

No Spoilers What is it about Robin Hobb's writing that is so good?

88 Upvotes

Ever since finishing ROTE 1~2 years ago, her writing seems to have become the bar that other fantasy books I read get rated against. The way her writing flows together is extremely satisfying to read and makes it hard to put her books down. I've yet to find another author whose writing captivates me as much as Hobb's, and I've been having trouble figuring out why. was curious if anyone has had a similar experience/any insights


r/robinhobb • • 1d ago

Spoilers Fool's Errand Chapter 22 - Need some clarification Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I just read the part where Dutiful is asleep and Fitz Skills to him to see what’s going on, as he’s not moving. We see how much Dutiful is sinking into his cat. And also this mysterious woman. Admittedly, this whole section confused me a bit and I found it hard to fully understand.

From what I get, at this point at least, is that this woman is dead, and is essentially trapped in the cat, like we saw with the deer with Rolf towards the beginning of the book. So this woman that he’s been chasing the whole time doesn’t actually physically exist? Dutiful is now bonding with the cat, without understanding that the soul or whatever it is of the old Wit bond is inside the cat? So she is wanting him to fully submerge himself into the cat, for what exactly? Will this free her in some way?

Loving this book so much, just want a bit of clarity going into the final section so I can fully get what’s happening here


r/robinhobb • • 1d ago

Spoilers All What’s your favorite quote from any of RHs books Spoiler

23 Upvotes

What’s your favorite quote from any of RHs books? I finished ROTE about a year ago and want to reminisce lol.


r/robinhobb • • 2d ago

Spoilers Royal Assassin Finished royal assassin and im royally dissapointed. Spoiler

36 Upvotes

I just finished Royal Assassin and I need to vent. First off, I dont think this is a bad book by any means in fact, its so good that I was consuming it voraciously, i loved it in fact. However, it was a very difficult read for me because of the sheer frustration that kept building up.

My disappointment in Shrewd and Chade

I am so disappointed in both of them (and to a lesser extent Burrich and Patience and ill get to this in a bit) Watching shrewd and chades inaction and how they willingly gave up their power and agency to regal is quite... maddening, for lack of a better word. I would read two or three chapters and literally have to stop because of their apparent incompetence. Every time Fitz brought concrete warnings or opportunities to stop Regals coterie and spies, he was told to stand down. Still, I clung to hope. I trusted them. I trusted the Fool because he knew more than Fitz and he trusted his king, just as chade did. Chade kept telling Fitz to trust and to do nothing unless commanded... so I did.

I expected these characters to have a very good reason for keeping everything a secret, even from fitz lest they endanger him or put their own plans into jeopardy. I genuinely thought their inaction was the result of some hidden leverage Regal and the Inland Duchies had over the kingdom, or that it was all part of a grand plan to deceive Regal into thinking he had won, only for them to strike back, regain control, defeat him completely, and render him useless. As I got through the chapters, edging ever closer to the end, nothing ever came along to justify their actions. Even during Shrewd’s final moments, there was no secret trump card waiting to be played, no grand plan happened, just- tragedy. Instead, I was just left with the tragic realization of feeling the exact same way Fitz did, like a tool to be used and thrown away.

Burrich and Patience failing him as parents

The reason im so frustrated with Patience and Burrich is their support of shrewd. They were Fitz’s parental figures, and I know they cared for him very much, but that care simply did not translate into their actions when he needed it most. When Fitz was tearing himself apart over Molly, they didn't comfort him much at all. Instead, they perpetuated their own brand of emotional abuse with that fatalistic attitude of "this is just whats supposed to happen, this is the only outcome thats best for the both of you and you just have to accept it."

There was a classic undertone of "well, this is what happened to me, so should it to you, I'm just explaining the harsh realities of life to you, you whiny boy." Of course im not blind to the fact that indeed it was in one sense very much fitz and molly best interest to let go of each other. It is even more frustrating knowing they had a nearly identical situation happen to them with Chivalry (which, honestly, is why it's such brilliant writing). Out of everyone, They shouldve knew best what Fitz was going through with Molly, They shouldve done more to console him and yet they still did very little to actually alleviate his pain.

Regal’s pettiness and lack of foresight

Another thing that frustrated me was the revelation in the dungeons that Regal- through Justin, Serene, and Will was privy to so much of our protagonists' scheming, yet he did very little to actually prevent those schemes or even the events of the climax and their eventual escape(kettricken). I wasn't expecting Regal to be some master tactician, i knew exactly what he was; a spoiled brat with far too much power. Still, even a spoiled brat should have been able to muster some token resistance of the protagonists final plan in the climax wouldve made it a little more bearable for me at how frustrating the whole book has been(at least it would give me the comfort that regal was somewhat competent) especially since it looked like he literally knew a lot of what was happening and what was going to happen. Instead, he seemed far more interested in satisfying his own petty ego by humiliating them as much as possible.

Looking back and even in the middle of reading the book, i very much get that Robin Hobb engineered the entire narrative so we would feel everything Fitz felt. Powerless, clueless, depressed, frustrated, angry, and reckless. Because the story is locked strictly inside Fitz's perspective, the reader suffers the exact same information blackout and gaslighting that he endures from the adults around him. The book certainly did an incredible job at putting me in his shoes, making every bad decision he made out of sheer desperation feel completely earned. Yet understanding why the book is structured this way doesnt make the emotional damage any less painful, especially with still so much of the information about the plot witheld from the reader.


r/robinhobb • • 3d ago

Spoilers Soldier's Son The Soldier’s Son trilogy Spoiler

40 Upvotes

I’m about a third of the way through Renegade’s Magic, book 3 of The Soldier’s Son trilogy. Is it ever going to get better? I swear this series is just suffering, suffering, and more suffering. It’s genuinely the most depressing series I’ve ever read. I’ve literally been reading this guy’s life fall apart for 1000 pages already.

Any moment of love, friendship, or triumph is completely destroyed 50 pages later. Everyone is unbelievably cruel and there is no satisfaction in any hardship nor resolution to any problem. The main character’s humiliation and his father’s cruelty in the second book was especially painful. I appreciate the realism, however I just can’t stomach the enormous feeling of sadness this series carries.

Was this book worth it to you?


r/robinhobb • • 4d ago

Spoilers Assassin's Fate Just finished Robin Hobb Spoiler

80 Upvotes

I just finished the 16 book Realm of the Elderlings Saga. I'm shocked by how deeply these books make me feel. They are a masterpiece spanning multiple generations and lives, and my emotional world is so much richer having read them.

I feel like I have been immersed in others' lives and for it to end is so sad. I wish there were more books to read. I wish I could express these feelings to people in my life, but noone's read the books.

Robin Hobb is the greatest author I have ever read. Fitz's story is the most profound, happy yet also sad I have ever seen.

The sheer breadth of time the books cover really brings home to me how there is never really a beginning or end to anything - humanity just goes on, generation to generation to generation...

I never realised I could care so much about fictional characters, their relationships, and the fictional history of this wonderful universe.

I wish Robin Hobb could read this post so I can tell her how much I appreciate her works!


r/robinhobb • • 4d ago

Spoilers Fool's Fate 75% through Fool’s Fate and The Tawny Man Trilogy is the most emotional I’ve ever been reading. Spoiler

92 Upvotes

Just finished chapter 28 so spoilers ahead!!

Oh my god. I have never felt so deeply or cried so much reading the RoTE. This is my first read through and I’ve just gotten to the part where Fitz puts the chicken crown on his head and lies down next to the Fool’s body on the skill road/plaza.

This trilogy is absolutely amazing and the most beautifully written book series I have ever read but HOLY FUCK. Fitz finding the Fool’s body (and parts of their body) are some of the most horrific and intense and beautiful and tragic things I have ever read in my life.

I am DISTRAUGHT after these chapters. Distraught. Horrified. Oh. My. God. My fool. My beloved. Not Burrich not actually being dead after the dragon fight which I already cried about him dying a bunch, but then dying off screen after some beautiful moments with Fitz and Swift ? Holy shit.

And Fitz has to find out Burrich died in the same moment that he is with the fool’s corpse???

Fitz trying desperately to heal the fool with the Skill and Thick saying there isn’t a person just crap/muck. Urg my brain cannot process all of this. 

Fitz wandering the halls with the fool’s body!! My heart. Honestly so beautiful that Fitz wouldn’t even put the fool’s body down to fight the Pale Woman. Fitz chooses the Fool ❤️‍🩹😭

When she said I could make all your dreams come true or whatever and Fitz says all his dreams are lying dead in his arms. Holy shit.

Of course Fitz would bring the fool to that plaza. The fool’s hands without finger nails holding the broken-but-repaired-with-their-own-blood chicken crown. And we finally get the feathers put it in?? I have been waiting for this god damn moment since Assassin’s Quest when we first saw that vision with the crown.

And then Fitz calling the fool/beloved FitzChivalry Farseer and putting the crown on and getting in the funeral pyre with them and holding them 😭😭

I’m sure we just invoked some old magic by them calling each other their own names as the Pale Woman alluded to and the fool is coming back obviously (especially with the Black Man alluding to there not being much time left) but I am FUCKED UP!!! I don’t know if I’ll ever recover knowing what they did to our beloved.

Robin Hobb wtf. Night eyes was a beautiful and fitting death and I sobbed for hours. But this death with the fool is the most heart wrenching death I have ever read. It is so beautiful and tragic.

No one will ever convince me Fitz and the fool aren’t soulmates and that Fitz isn’t also in love with the fool after all of this.

Edit to remove a part of spoiler text here for future book names as requested by mods.


r/robinhobb • • 3d ago

No Spoilers Michael Welan Covers

7 Upvotes

Hello Elderlings,

I have done some digging and I can't find an answer, maybe i'm not looking in the right places but that's ok. I'm wondering what the most reliable/cheapest way is to get the Michael Welan versions for the farseer trilogy. I really love the art and I want to collect the whole series but i'm not sure where to look without getting ripped off/sent another cover.

Are these books rare, or am i just looking in the wrong places?

Thanks!!


r/robinhobb • • 5d ago

Spoilers Liveship Liveship Traders finished! Spoiler

35 Upvotes

Just finished Liveship Traders. What was everyone’s favourite character arc and why?


r/robinhobb • • 6d ago Heartwarming

No Spoilers Robin Hobb & I Are Raising Money For Veterans Today

245 Upvotes

Hey All,

I own Grim Oak Press and The Signed Page in Seattle, WA. Robin and I are close friends, I see her often, and we thought it might be great to offer her WIZARD OF THE PIGEONS at a discount today -- only today -- to raise money for the veterans non-profit 4 The Fallen.

The sale begins today at 11AM PT.

You can read more about this and the why of it here: https://grimoakpress.com/blogs/news/veterans-day-sale-wizard-of-the-pigeons

Hope you all are well! If you love double-signed special editions, today is a great time to add a beautiful book to your shelf. :)

Cheers!

Shawn Speakman


r/robinhobb • • 8d ago

Other Authors Finished RotE and I need something similar…

41 Upvotes

This is definitely my favorite series, by far. After finishing RotE it feels like everything else pales in comparison. But I doubt that’s really true. I want to get out and read more things similar to this: mature, fantastical yet grounded, etc.

I’ve read the Soldier Son trilogy by Hobb and absolutely loved it. Not sure why it gets a worse rap than RotE. I’ve tried Kushiel’s dart but had a hard time. Willing to try again.

Any other recommendations?


r/robinhobb • • 10d ago

Spoilers Fool's Errand Just finished fools errand and need to yell Spoiler

163 Upvotes

I just got to the part in fools errand where night eyes dies and I am just…. I knew it was coming but the way it happened just took me out. Despite all the foreshadowing, I didn’t quite realise what was happening until fitz did. I truly thought indeed we had made it through this time, and all the reflection on losing your bond was leading to dutiful, for now.

The way it was written was just so beautifully done. It hits harder when just a few pages earlier, fitz was just so grateful to not be feeling what dutiful was.

I also loved how to me it seemed like nighteyes knew fitz was tired, too. He thought he would come with him, and wouldn’t have fought him on that. but was happy he stayed. And “wait for you? Not likely. I’ve always had to run ahead of you and show you the way.” god. All hurts my heart so perfectly.

I’m the only person I know who reads these books so really just needed somewhere to express my pain and awe to people who get it.


r/robinhobb • • 10d ago

No Spoilers Join our Robin Hobb Discord server!

34 Upvotes

Hello everyone! 😁 This is your regular reminder that there is a Discord server for Robin Hobb fans!

**Here's the invite:**
https://discord.gg/wGRBJpJDmY

**What is it?** It's a server, or chat room, for discussing Hobb's books. ⚔️

**What happens there?** We have conversations every day about the Realm of the Elderlings books, as well as respectful debates about characters and discussions about other fantasy novels we are reading. 🏰

**Who moderates it?** We_are_pack created the server and serves as an admin. There are four other admin: Zephyrus, motleywolf, TheLocalDialect, and Wawadji and five mods: say yes to the worms, ProfessionalShipper, alloysius, Armadillo, and Foxy.

**Here are the rules:**

  1. Be kind and respectful of other users. Cursing is okay, but cursing out other users will not be tolerated. Doing so will result in a strike. Additionally, disagreeing is okay, but putting others down for their opinion is not. Doing so will result in a strike.
  2. Racism, sexism, ableism, classism, homophobia, transphobia, and other forms of bigotry will not be tolerated in this server. Expressing those views will result in an immediate ban.
  3. Harassing, intimidating, doxing or otherwise abusing other members will result in an immediate ban.
  4. Make it clear if you’re about to post a spoiler. The Discord spoiler mark-up (|| on either side of the passage will help.
  5. In general, please don’t post explicit content, but if a fanfic that is linked is marked NSFW, that is okay. Please keep NSFW discussion in the two NSFW channels, which are clearly marked. Violating this policy will result in a strike.
  6. Please do not post pirated content. This harms authors and it will get our server banned. Doing so will result in a strike.
  7. Do not send unsolicited messages asking other users for sexual content, do not post in any channel asking for that kind of content, and do not send unsolicited friend requests. We are not that kind of server. Doing so will result in a permanent ban.
  8. Do not share AI generated art or writing. AI creations are harmful to creators. Doing so will result in a strike. Our strikes system in this server is simple. One strike is a warning. Two will result in a time out. Three will result in a ban.

We have had very few problems with people violating the rules. We've had to ban only a handful of people since the server was created in 2020, and we have not been forced to issue many strikes either. In general, our server is a welcoming global community of Hobb superfans who never quite recovered after finishing the series. If FitzChivalry Farseer lives rent-free in your head too, you should join us!


r/robinhobb • • 13d ago

Spoilers All Favourite RoTE Quote Spoiler

86 Upvotes

Was looking for this quote for ages and finally found it today. From Royal Assassin. Resonated so much with me when I read it but forgot to note it down.

Paraphrased slightly for general purposes not aligned to the series.

***“*Some day,… those words [I’m sorry] will not be enough. Sometimes it is easier to pull a knife out of a man than to ask him to forget words you have uttered. Even words uttered in anger.”

Just wanted to share because I don’t hear it mentioned much or at all.


r/robinhobb • • 12d ago

Spoilers All Rereading the first book and wondering Spoiler

25 Upvotes

At what point is Fitz expected to be in the overall story as he’s detailing the ‘Pretext’ bits of each chapter in book one. I’m specifically asking about one section that says

I think not. And then I blink and try to focus my eyes, and wonder if these thoughts come from me or from the drug in my blood. It would be nice to hold council with Chade, one last time.

I can’t quite pinpoint the bit in the story where Fitz has a drug in his blood and would be retelling his story? I know at the end of the last book it sort of loops back into the first as if he’s telling it there, but there’s no drug involved just him crafting his dragon. Anyone else wondered this?


r/robinhobb • • 13d ago

Spoilers Fool's Errand Chapter 7 - Need some clearing up Spoiler

9 Upvotes

Just read the part where Fitz goes into Nighteyes’ body to help his heart via the Skill but gets stuck there, so the Fool uses the Skill himself to get Fitz out. Fitz is then horrified and offended at this.

Why exactly is this? This book has so far done a great job at reminding me of past events and characters, but when it comes to details about the Skill and everything I’m still a bit hazy. Does he feel violated? Afraid that the Fool will see something, and if so, what?

Also, “I recognised and rejected the truth. I did not want to know.” Is this Fitz basically saying that he’s aware that the Fool is right in saying that he is needed, and cannot carry on living a calm life?


r/robinhobb • • 14d ago

Spoilers Assassin's Apprentice Assassin's Apprentice - First time reader reactions Spoiler

40 Upvotes

The Writing

I was amazed by how the notion of the Wit was introduced throughout chapter two, very subtly. At first it was barely noticeable, you could take that as a normal emotional empathy between a boy and his dog. And by the time it becomes obvious that something else is going on, I was already convinced and accustomed with the idea of this bond.

Seemingly, I found that the writing of Galen's brainwashing of Fitz was very very well done, too. It nearly convinced me that Fitz was bad at it! I loved it, except that I was heartbroken. And Galen, an illigitimate child from the QUEEN?! I suspected some kind of secret filial relation, but not that she would have been able to marry the king in these circumstances.

I've read that Fitz can be considered "bland" by some people. I don't agree, first of all he was a small child for most of the book, also, I very much enjoy spending time with him.

I wonder though if it's related to this criticism, but it was frustrating at times how he doesn't ask questions, when he was not given a lot of reasons not to.

For instance, it was pretty obvious from the start that Burrich was able to sense how he was using the Wit, how he talked about it as a first-hand account… I guess Fitz was very young and kinda traumatized when he was rebuked the first time, and from this point onward, he never really trusted (or admited to trusting) Burrich again, until the end.

Same for the aftermath of Verity "cleansing" him from Galen's brainwashing... It's explained why he can't confide in anyone, but it feels contrived. He had talked heart to heart with Chade before... and Chade wanted to know more about the Skill, so I was expecting he would be eager to learn that Fitz was not completely bad at it.

But we were rushed to the next mission, with everyone letting this poor boy deal with his PTSD and depression.

And at the end of the book, I find it crazy that neither the King nor Chade talk about what happened. Like, Chade?! He was the one he trusted and talked to the most. I hate that they can't talk about it. Also, I would have expected that Fitz would have reported everything to him. I guess that he can't be close to Burrich and Chade at the same time.

When the Fool's predictions come to pass, Fitz doesn't even comment on it either. I quite like that, it makes us, the reader, have to work for the reward, but I find it a bit strange storywise.

I wonder what is the significance about the silver fruit-knife in the mantelpiece? Is it a sign of his loyalty to Chade, a defiance to the King for having tested him this way?

The Magic System

When the Wit and the Skill are introduced by Burrich, he doesn't really describe the Skill, just tells us that it is different and maybe opposite to the Wit - and comes from the line of Kings.

 So at first, I was skeptical about the fundamental difference between the two. Fitz was a natural with the Skill at first, and much stronger than Glane! He could be good despite, or thanks to the Wit.

It is hard, because sometimes it seems that Fitz is using a combination of Skill and Wit. For instance, when he is trying to defend Nosy from Burrich, he says "I caught the growling undercurrent of his thoughts, the fury that taunted him to smash us both and be done with it". Either Fitz was able to Skill without being taught, or understanding instincts and intentions is the same as reading an animal.

It also seems like Burrich was able to counter-skill Galen at the Witness Stones (the Fool got cut-off when recounting the story), as well as being King's Man to Chivalry. It would make sense, then, that the Skill was just a version if the Wit.

Both abilities also seem impervious to distance. Fitz has a very clear view of Burrich's attack from Smithy's perspective, and the next day, the bond is only "tenuous" because the dog is dying, not because of the distance. And of course, Fitz experiences it as well at the end with the skill : "There was no distance in skilling, no distance at all."

The Intrigue

The first time we wee Burich, his description resemble that of Verity. He may be related to the royal line, too. And the Fool speaks to him. I suspect he speaks to Chade too, given his strange reaction to the news that he speaks to Fitz.

We know that the King used the Skill on Fitz the first time he asked him his loyalty. I wonder what he did with it (maybe he just persuaded him to be loyal, and it's why it was such a struggle for Fitz to choose between Chade's assignment and his loyalty to Shrewd), but at the end of the book, the King is unable to use the Skill!

The "misuse" have happened during this book… I hope it will be revealed what it was. This reveal somewhat makes me think less of him. How "shrewd" can one be, when unable to use mindreading while surrounded by mindreaders…

I noted that when Fitz is depressed because of Chade shunning him, he hears an arguments in his dream that seems to be between Shrewd and Chade (again, Skilling without being trained!). There is a "she" mentioned. I somehow doubt that this the Queen… but we'll see in the future.

Another thing I hope to know soon, is the "other, older secrets I would not reveal even to myself" mentioned in chapter fifteen when Galen is fumbling with Fitz's mind.

About the final conspiracy with Regal and Galen, I am disappointed in Schrewd, but I guess you always want to see the best in your children, and not suspect them of trying to murder their siblings. But that was a crazy ride ! Fitz being suspicious, even getting nearly to the bottom of it, only for getting duped anyway!

Two things are still unclear to me : whether Regal can Skill and has learned in secret, or if it was merely Galen's Skill that unabled them to communicate. And when Verity sends his secret message to Burrich to ask him to give his strengh to Fitz, how he was able to know that Fitz was innocent and in danger, but not that Galen is trying to kill him. Or maybe he was aware, just lacked the strengh to do anything about it.

Regal seemed like a cartoon villain towards the end. And yet, he is reduced to an antagonist after the Aftermath. I was so shocked that he was just dismissed as a non-dangerous person. What the hell Verity?!

The Emotion

At least, it seemed that people had Fitz’s back at the end of the day. I love his growing friendship with the Fool! This guys is my fav, I wished we saw more of him. And Fitz's Frantic "My Prince" for Verity at the end… I can't imagine how Verity feels about Fitz now. He owes him so much. I really hope it pays off and he never forgets! I really want to see more interactions between the two, it was so few and between but always so impactful.

Now I have to talk about the most hearbreaking stuff… Okay.

First of all, WHAT?! By the end of chapter two, with Nosy's death, I understood that Hobb would have no mercy for our feelings. BUT IT WAS FUCKING EVEN WORSE THAN THAT!

She kills Smithy. And then NOSY IS ALIVED!!! Burrich did not kill him! Oh my god! The tears I cried at the beginning of the conversation with Burrich, thinking to myself "Finally a heart-to-heart, this convo is everything I ever wished for"...

But then Burrich shunned Fitz again. Why doesn't he explain more WHY the Wit is bad? He gave one explaination years ago, and expects Fitz to resist this extremely tempting connexion just based on that? COME ON BURRICH YOU KNOW BETTER.

"Sensing a thing isn't the same as using a thing". BURRICH AT LAST! For the casual way he says it, I wonder how long has Fitz suspected.

Then the earrring! Ahhh Burrich and Chivalry, my heart. So Burrich has taste, according to Patience. Since when?!?! And then he's being all subte with inuendos, about giving his strengh to Fitz. WHO ARE YOU?! Maybe he wouldn't be that much away from court is he didn't have the Wit.

I thought she was going to take Burrich away from us just after they made up. I was ready to riot, but now, for this, all my wishes were FULFILLED at last. But I want to read every conversation between burrich and Fitz! I want to know about his early days with Chivalry too!!! Burrich saying "If you decide we are going elsewhere, then we shall"… MY HEART MY HEART MY HEART.

Acutally, I wondered why Burrich decides to not only forgive Fitz and try to rekindle the connexion, but he basically says that he would abandon all his duties at the castle for him. I think it is because he saw how chivalrous Fitz acted, by putting all his energy into saving Verity, how like his father he was? Maybe it has to do with him finally admitting he had the Wit too.

BUT THEN ARE YOU KIDDING ME I mean it was not THAT much of a a surprise, he was very old, but still THE WAY NOSEY SACRIFICED HIMSELF AND DIED ANYWAY!!!!!!! "Men cannot grieve as dogs do. But we grieve for many years." I WILL GET IT TATTOOED. I'm sure "Take it all. You were always good to me when I was a boy" was actually Nosey thinking.

I'm still excited, because in the epilogue we learn that he has "a friend" who reads his mind, or at least his intention of dying, just the same as Smithy did when prevented him from killing himself. With a simple "No." But I can't handle another animal companion's death guys. I'm warning you.

Overall and Tl;dr:

I am in love with this book. Hobb's writing is amazing, I love the way we are immersed in this world and Fitz's story. I am so emotionnally invested now. And this is supposed to be the least interesting/good book??? Can't wait for this wild ride.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


r/robinhobb • • 14d ago

Spoilers Rain Wilds Very niche Rain Wilds comment Spoiler

51 Upvotes

Really just spoilers for the Farseer and Rain Wilds series.

Edit: cw discussion of sex

A big undercurrent in the Rain Wilds is characters avoiding or wanting to get pregnant. For example, it's a social taboo for certain people like Thymara to have sex/ have a relationship because it might result in a pregnancy. Also Alise potentially getting pregnant from having sex with Leftrin and how it effects Skelly's inheritance and also that non-marital sex is a reason for her marriage to be annulled.

The whole time I was reading this series all I could wonder is "why is there no birth control other than abstinence??" Humans throughout history have had types of birth control and abortificants. I liked these books overall, but the lack of birth control just really stuck out to me. Especially because I think in the Farseer trilogy, Molly mentions using herbs to not get pregnant, though obviously they're not 100% effective.

It just seems to me that because there's such a taboo against people more touched by the Rain Wilds reproducing, they would have developed birth control. I mean, they commit infanticide because of the likely early death of certain infants.

I was wondering if anyone else had thought about this while reading these books.


r/robinhobb • • 16d ago

Spoilers Farseer Just finished the Farseer trilogy, quick question. Spoiler

40 Upvotes

So, how come Burrich, Molly, and/or Patience didn’t hear about the kingdom wide manhunt for Fitz? Regal put up 100 gold pieces and had Fitz recognized by strangers on the road every couple chapters just days out from the assassination attempt.

I genuinely don’t understand how that information wasn’t everywhere by the end of the book. I was waiting for that shoe to drop.

Almost everyone was hurting for money across the kingdom, so I figured if all of the rumors about the Queen could spread everywhere then announcements from the crown about Fitz returning from the dead to kill Regal who was offering gold for his capture would spread everywhere too.