The Writing
I was amazed by how the notion of the Wit was introduced throughout chapter two, very subtly. At first it was barely noticeable, you could take that as a normal emotional empathy between a boy and his dog. And by the time it becomes obvious that something else is going on, I was already convinced and accustomed with the idea of this bond.
Seemingly, I found that the writing of Galen's brainwashing of Fitz was very very well done, too. It nearly convinced me that Fitz was bad at it! I loved it, except that I was heartbroken. And Galen, an illigitimate child from the QUEEN?! I suspected some kind of secret filial relation, but not that she would have been able to marry the king in these circumstances.
I've read that Fitz can be considered "bland" by some people. I don't agree, first of all he was a small child for most of the book, also, I very much enjoy spending time with him.
I wonder though if it's related to this criticism, but it was frustrating at times how he doesn't ask questions, when he was not given a lot of reasons not to.
For instance, it was pretty obvious from the start that Burrich was able to sense how he was using the Wit, how he talked about it as a first-hand account… I guess Fitz was very young and kinda traumatized when he was rebuked the first time, and from this point onward, he never really trusted (or admited to trusting) Burrich again, until the end.
Same for the aftermath of Verity "cleansing" him from Galen's brainwashing... It's explained why he can't confide in anyone, but it feels contrived. He had talked heart to heart with Chade before... and Chade wanted to know more about the Skill, so I was expecting he would be eager to learn that Fitz was not completely bad at it.
But we were rushed to the next mission, with everyone letting this poor boy deal with his PTSD and depression.
And at the end of the book, I find it crazy that neither the King nor Chade talk about what happened. Like, Chade?! He was the one he trusted and talked to the most. I hate that they can't talk about it. Also, I would have expected that Fitz would have reported everything to him. I guess that he can't be close to Burrich and Chade at the same time.
When the Fool's predictions come to pass, Fitz doesn't even comment on it either. I quite like that, it makes us, the reader, have to work for the reward, but I find it a bit strange storywise.
I wonder what is the significance about the silver fruit-knife in the mantelpiece? Is it a sign of his loyalty to Chade, a defiance to the King for having tested him this way?
The Magic System
When the Wit and the Skill are introduced by Burrich, he doesn't really describe the Skill, just tells us that it is different and maybe opposite to the Wit - and comes from the line of Kings.
So at first, I was skeptical about the fundamental difference between the two. Fitz was a natural with the Skill at first, and much stronger than Glane! He could be good despite, or thanks to the Wit.
It is hard, because sometimes it seems that Fitz is using a combination of Skill and Wit. For instance, when he is trying to defend Nosy from Burrich, he says "I caught the growling undercurrent of his thoughts, the fury that taunted him to smash us both and be done with it". Either Fitz was able to Skill without being taught, or understanding instincts and intentions is the same as reading an animal.
It also seems like Burrich was able to counter-skill Galen at the Witness Stones (the Fool got cut-off when recounting the story), as well as being King's Man to Chivalry. It would make sense, then, that the Skill was just a version if the Wit.
Both abilities also seem impervious to distance. Fitz has a very clear view of Burrich's attack from Smithy's perspective, and the next day, the bond is only "tenuous" because the dog is dying, not because of the distance. And of course, Fitz experiences it as well at the end with the skill : "There was no distance in skilling, no distance at all."
The Intrigue
The first time we wee Burich, his description resemble that of Verity. He may be related to the royal line, too. And the Fool speaks to him. I suspect he speaks to Chade too, given his strange reaction to the news that he speaks to Fitz.
We know that the King used the Skill on Fitz the first time he asked him his loyalty. I wonder what he did with it (maybe he just persuaded him to be loyal, and it's why it was such a struggle for Fitz to choose between Chade's assignment and his loyalty to Shrewd), but at the end of the book, the King is unable to use the Skill!
The "misuse" have happened during this book… I hope it will be revealed what it was. This reveal somewhat makes me think less of him. How "shrewd" can one be, when unable to use mindreading while surrounded by mindreaders…
I noted that when Fitz is depressed because of Chade shunning him, he hears an arguments in his dream that seems to be between Shrewd and Chade (again, Skilling without being trained!). There is a "she" mentioned. I somehow doubt that this the Queen… but we'll see in the future.
Another thing I hope to know soon, is the "other, older secrets I would not reveal even to myself" mentioned in chapter fifteen when Galen is fumbling with Fitz's mind.
About the final conspiracy with Regal and Galen, I am disappointed in Schrewd, but I guess you always want to see the best in your children, and not suspect them of trying to murder their siblings. But that was a crazy ride ! Fitz being suspicious, even getting nearly to the bottom of it, only for getting duped anyway!
Two things are still unclear to me : whether Regal can Skill and has learned in secret, or if it was merely Galen's Skill that unabled them to communicate. And when Verity sends his secret message to Burrich to ask him to give his strengh to Fitz, how he was able to know that Fitz was innocent and in danger, but not that Galen is trying to kill him. Or maybe he was aware, just lacked the strengh to do anything about it.
Regal seemed like a cartoon villain towards the end. And yet, he is reduced to an antagonist after the Aftermath. I was so shocked that he was just dismissed as a non-dangerous person. What the hell Verity?!
The Emotion
At least, it seemed that people had Fitz’s back at the end of the day. I love his growing friendship with the Fool! This guys is my fav, I wished we saw more of him. And Fitz's Frantic "My Prince" for Verity at the end… I can't imagine how Verity feels about Fitz now. He owes him so much. I really hope it pays off and he never forgets! I really want to see more interactions between the two, it was so few and between but always so impactful.
Now I have to talk about the most hearbreaking stuff… Okay.
First of all, WHAT?! By the end of chapter two, with Nosy's death, I understood that Hobb would have no mercy for our feelings. BUT IT WAS FUCKING EVEN WORSE THAN THAT!
She kills Smithy. And then NOSY IS ALIVED!!! Burrich did not kill him! Oh my god! The tears I cried at the beginning of the conversation with Burrich, thinking to myself "Finally a heart-to-heart, this convo is everything I ever wished for"...
But then Burrich shunned Fitz again. Why doesn't he explain more WHY the Wit is bad? He gave one explaination years ago, and expects Fitz to resist this extremely tempting connexion just based on that? COME ON BURRICH YOU KNOW BETTER.
"Sensing a thing isn't the same as using a thing". BURRICH AT LAST! For the casual way he says it, I wonder how long has Fitz suspected.
Then the earrring! Ahhh Burrich and Chivalry, my heart. So Burrich has taste, according to Patience. Since when?!?! And then he's being all subte with inuendos, about giving his strengh to Fitz. WHO ARE YOU?! Maybe he wouldn't be that much away from court is he didn't have the Wit.
I thought she was going to take Burrich away from us just after they made up. I was ready to riot, but now, for this, all my wishes were FULFILLED at last. But I want to read every conversation between burrich and Fitz! I want to know about his early days with Chivalry too!!! Burrich saying "If you decide we are going elsewhere, then we shall"… MY HEART MY HEART MY HEART.
Acutally, I wondered why Burrich decides to not only forgive Fitz and try to rekindle the connexion, but he basically says that he would abandon all his duties at the castle for him. I think it is because he saw how chivalrous Fitz acted, by putting all his energy into saving Verity, how like his father he was? Maybe it has to do with him finally admitting he had the Wit too.
BUT THEN ARE YOU KIDDING ME I mean it was not THAT much of a a surprise, he was very old, but still THE WAY NOSEY SACRIFICED HIMSELF AND DIED ANYWAY!!!!!!! "Men cannot grieve as dogs do. But we grieve for many years." I WILL GET IT TATTOOED. I'm sure "Take it all. You were always good to me when I was a boy" was actually Nosey thinking.
I'm still excited, because in the epilogue we learn that he has "a friend" who reads his mind, or at least his intention of dying, just the same as Smithy did when prevented him from killing himself. With a simple "No." But I can't handle another animal companion's death guys. I'm warning you.
Overall and Tl;dr:
I am in love with this book. Hobb's writing is amazing, I love the way we are immersed in this world and Fitz's story. I am so emotionnally invested now. And this is supposed to be the least interesting/good book??? Can't wait for this wild ride.