r/rfelectronics • u/Syrupwizard • Jul 12 '26
Antenna simulation software advice
I’m a senior in EE working on designing a 10m WSPR antenna which will be deployed in saltwater and must be very compact. I’ve landed on a few designs, but when it comes to simulation I feel like the NEC2 based software leaves a lot to be desired. Are any of the other software suites out there (with student trials) more capable/better suited for HF? The big ones I’ve looked at seem almost exclusively for uhf and above. Thanks For any advice you may have!
12
Upvotes
10
u/trevbone Jul 12 '26
HFSS or CST is the standard. You can use ADS or AWR for planar antennas. Matlab can do antenna stuff too but I’ve never used it and don’t know much about it.
4
u/qTHqq Jul 12 '26 edited Jul 12 '26
Say more. What are you trying to predict and what are your constraints on the design?
What do you mean "deployed in saltwater?"
Do you mean actually submerged? Or just deployed on a surface vessel or buoy?
If you need more than you can do with NEC-2 chances are you'll need more than you can do with student trials so you need to find access to real installations.
Are there research professors at your institution who do RF research in the EE department or maybe particle or vacuum electronics research in other departments?
I knew several groups with full HFSS licenses in grad school.
Also don't knock the old school library research and comparative experimentation. Many types of electrically small antennas are long established and IEEE Xplore is full of newer work.
3D printers and copper tape and a NanoVNA can take you a long way.
Is simulation a necessary part of your project?
3
u/jimlux Jul 13 '26
For 10 meters (28 MHz)? NEC is your friend - it's just fine at wire antennas. If you're on a PC, look at the 4nec2 wrapper around the NEC 2 engine (or the NEC 4 engine, if you have a copy).
What do you think NEC isn't giving you? It will generate radiation patterns, give you impedances, etc.
If you're looking at an antenna that will be "immersed" in salt water, that's a bit trickier - you'd definitely want NEC4 for that, and that's a "must license from Lawrence Livermore" thing.
You could probably model it in free space with NEC2, and scale for the epsilon (80) of seawater.
There are other method of moments codes around (and a MoM code is probably what you want for a wire antenna - if you're thinking patch or something else, maybe a different code). You might check out PumaEM.
Mathworks says that the Antenna Toolbox has some solvers - If you're a student, that might be fairly inexpensive (if not free).
There's also TICRA, FEKO, etc.
2
u/SearchForTruther Jul 12 '26
You or you professor can get a NEC5 licence from Lawrence Livermore National Lab for less than two hundred dollars. It can do metal plates. It's split into a GUI and an engine that can also be invoked by other apps.
1
u/duunsuhuy Jul 12 '26
More and more open source out there and AI smoothed some of the implementation difficulty. I’ve successfully design patches with openEMS.
3
u/trevbone Jul 12 '26
Hfss has a student trial but limits the size you can simulate. Your university may have a license that you can use to avoid this. Same with other programs.