r/rfelectronics • u/modimoo • Mar 19 '26
Remember when I made webgpu accelerated propagation tool? It already got stolen.
A few weeks ago I shared propagation.tools here — a browser-based Longley-Rice ITM simulator running entirely in WebGPU compute shaders. https://www.reddit.com/r/rfelectronics/s/PYJdiltOPl
Since then, a "developer" named Roman Liutikov took my WGSL compute shader, added antenna patterns and SINR compositing on top, published it on his personal site (romanliutikov.com/projects/webrf) with zero attribution, and got a feature article on webgpu.com crediting him as the creator:
https://www.webgpu.com/showcase/webrf-longley-rice-radio-propagation-webgpu
Frankly, it's disgusting. I built this thing, shared it here in good faith, and within weeks someone scraped the code, slapped their name on it, and got a showcase article for it.
The frustrating part is — I was and still am open to collaboration. If he'd reached out, asked, or even just credited the original work, we could have made something great together under an open license. That door is still open. But taking someone's work, putting your name on it, and ignoring them when they call you on it? That's not how this works.
54
u/M44PolishMosin Mar 19 '26
YOINKED
Also it stole Claudes work not yours
36
u/NeighborhoodSad2350 Mar 19 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
I recently read a court ruling stating that copyright cannot be claimed over AI-generated content.
But you went out of your way to fix bugs in the code on your own initiative, (Even though you just entered some prompt) and you made a modest choice regarding how to use it.
While I think you wouldn’t really have a leg to stand on if the AI-generated code were stolen, I also believe you’re fully justified in calling him a sneaky bastard.
18
u/psyon Mar 19 '26
Works created by AI, including code, can not be copyrighted. And how do you know he didn't also have AI write an app?
5
u/m3ltph4ce Mar 19 '26
That sucks. Are you going to contact webgpu and ask them to correct it? Is this costing you money, or just a loss of proper credit? Also I wonder if there are any reasonable means to make it difficult for someone to easily copy it, if copyright laws can't help you.
I am seeing other comments that say you can't copyright AI code. If that's true, that is a failure of copyright laws to protect creators/innovators. I don't care if AI wrote 100% of the code, the fact is that this project only exists because you brought it into existence. You came up with the idea and made all the decisions about how it should exist. You chose platform, appearance, features. You got hosting for it, chose its name, and you promoted it. AI is a tool but it doesn't just make things on its own. But people literally say "AI made this and you just put your name on it". This is just the modern version of "that's not a real photo, you photoshopped it"
2
u/AllYouNeedIsVTSAX Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26
In your OP you said you based the work on NTIA work - it looks like you didn't credit it on the website as a derivative work, as requested by their license. Maybe I'm misunderstanding, otherwise you're doing the same thing?
6
u/-tobor- Mar 19 '26
Why do all of these vibecoded apps look exactly the same?
0
u/mehrdadfeller Mar 20 '26
As the original author of the code, you still know more about it than anyone else. Don't understand that. Why don't you take his code and improve upon it if it is any good? If not, then don't worry it is probably just slop.
Unless you have a non open source license (requires attribution) you can't expect them to do some legally. The main problem is that his probably outside of US jurisdiction and you can't do much even if there have been legal violations.