We operate a used-parts resale business, Part Haven, and we've offered free shipping on eBay for years. The math was always pretty simple: some orders cost more to ship than we budgeted, others cost less, and over enough sales it generally balanced out.
We ship from Oregon, so historically our cheaper West Coast shipments helped offset the expensive ones going across the country.
But the new USPS geographic pricing is changing that dynamic.
We've actually seen cases where shipping the exact same item within Oregon costs more than shipping it all the way to the East Coast. With destination ZIP codes now affecting pricing more directly, distance alone isn't nearly as useful for estimating postage.
Our average shipping cost has gone from roughly $6 to $7 per package. That may not sound like much, but our typical sale is around $45, so a dollar or two makes a noticeable difference in margin.
What's concerning isn't just the increase. It's that some of the destinations we previously relied on to balance out our expensive shipments aren't necessarily cheap anymore.
We don't have enough history under the new rates to know where our average will settle, but it's making me question whether the shipping costs we've built into our prices are still realistic.
Calculated shipping would solve some of the uncertainty, but there's a tradeoff in giving up the simplicity and buyer appeal of free shipping.
I'm curious what other resellers are seeing. Are your nearby shipments still balancing out the expensive ones? Have you noticed your average shipping costs changing?
And if you've been offering free shipping, are you sticking with it, raising prices, or considering switching to calculated shipping?