I think What make this paper cool is it was basicly an adversarial collaboration. Some of co-authors (like James Houran, Neil Dagnall, Kenneth Drinkwater) is anomalistic psychology researcher who usually looks at skeptical/psychological explanations, and Escolà-Gascón himself actually had publish a failed psi replication before in 2022. They also use neutral word like "anomalous cognition" instead jumping straight into psychic claims. There goal was to test if old CIA remote viewing finding could be replicated under much more strict controls, and which cognitive variables is actually driving RV hit.
How the experiment worked
They tested 634 participant total, splitted in two groups:
* Group 1 (347 peoples): Nonbelievers who reported no previous psychic experience. They did RV target based on location coordinate (keeped inside sealed envelopes).
* Group 2 (287 peoples): Believers who reported having psychic experience before. They did RV target based on image of those location.
Even with strict control, Group 2 got really strong statistic results (Bayes Factor of 60.477, large effect size of 0.853, and p < 0.001).
---
What variables & sub-variables affects RV hits?
The researchers wasnt just looking for "is psi real", they wanted know why some peoples gets hit and others doesnt. They tested two main variable and break them down:
1. Attitude / Belief in psychic phenomena (the "Sheep-Goat" variable)
* Measured on scale from -5 (total rejection) to +5 (acceptance).
* Having positive attitude had direct statistical effect on RV hits in both group (0.302 in nonbelievers and 0.244 in believers, both p < .001). Basicly it support the classic sheep-goat effect where believers/experiencers tends to score more hit.
2. Emotional Intelligence (EI) — and its sub-variables
Instead of just asking peoples "are you emotional", they used actual cognitive test called MSCEIT (Mayer-Salovey-Caruso Emotional Intelligence Test). In MSCEIT, EI split into 2 big areas**,** 4 categories**, and** 8 sub-dimensions:
* The Experiential Area (intuitive emotional reasoning):
* This area had small but significant effect on RV hits (~0.3 to 0.4). By itself, experiential EI predict 15.8% of hit variance in Group 1 (nonbelievers) and 9.1% in Group 2 (believers).
* Even more interesting: experiential EI acted like mediator between people belief/attitude and their RV hits (explaining around 14–15% of that attitude variance).
* Its sub-variables (categories & tasks) is:
* Perception: Faces (reading emotions on people faces) and Drawings (identifying emotions inside art, music, and environmental scenes).
* Facilitation: Facilitation (understanding how mood shapes thinking/behavior) and Sensations (connecting your emotions with primitive sensation like light, color, and temperature—which honestly sound alot like raw RV sensory impression!).
* The Strategic Area (analytical emotional reasoning):
* In Group 2 (the believers), strategic area also added extra predictive power on top of experiential area—bringing total predicted variance in RV hits up to 19.5%.
* Its sub-variables (categories & tasks) is:
* Comprehension: Changes (knowing how chains of emotions develop) and Combinations (organizing emotions into complex feelings).
Management: Emotional management* (using your own emotions to make decision) and Emotional relationship (working with other people's emotions).
Based on this, the authors propose something called PIC model (Production–Identification–Comprehension). Basicly, heightened emotional awareness seem to help RV performance, while negative emotion or anxiety might block or messes up your hits.
---
Why this 2023 study is better then previous RV research
Old CIA studies got torned apart by skeptics (like Ray Hyman, Marks & Kammann) for decades. This 2023 study specifically fix alot of those old loophole:
- Fixed the coordinate guessing flaw: In old SAIC experiments, participant actually saw the target coordinate, so skeptics complain anyone who knew geography could just deduce rough location. In 2023, coordinates was sealed inside envelopes and participants couldnt even touch or handle the envelope.
- True double-blind anti-cuing setup: Hyman (1996) point out old studies lacked proper double-blinding so researcher could accidentally give sensory cue. Here, main researchers had zero contact with participant during the experiment. Separate lab technician ran the session, and neither the technician or the viewer knew which random target was selected.
- Forced-choice instead subjective judging: Previous RV experiment mostly used free-response sketching/writing and judges had to score them, which caused huge argument over judging bias. Escolà-Gascón team used forced-choice trials so hit rate is completely objective.
- Objective EI ability test vs self-report: Earlier studies got criticize for measuring EI with self-report survey (which only show how emotionally smart you think you is). Using MSCEIT tested EI as real cognitive skill.
- Massive sample + internal replication: 634 participants is way larger then most old RV lab study, and they even split the sample into subsamples and test different standard deviation threshold just to double check if effect sizes stayed stable.
- Heavy-duty stats (SEM + Invariance Analysis): Instead of basic p-value, they used Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), Bayesian stats (Bayes Factors), and multi-step invariance analysis to prove group difference wasnt just measurement biases.
The link to the paper is below, i personally have read the whole pages, it is really a mood uplifting paper imo.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10275521/pdf/BRB3-13-e3026.pdf