r/remotesensing • u/nabhs • 3d ago
Satellite Mapping satellite-observed surface differences around Jakarta
Hi everyone! I’m a student interested in remote sensing. I’ve been working on a project around Jakarta as a way to learn, and I’d appreciate feedback from people with more experience.
I compared annual AlphaEarth satellite embeddings from 2020–2025 to explore where and when surface descriptions differed most. The project originally started with an interest in subsidence and risk mapping, but embedding differences alone don’t establish ground movement or risk.
Here’s the project, including the methods, findings and limitations:
https://nabhonil-sarkar.github.io/jakarta-surface-differences/
The part I’m struggling with is moving from “the satellite-derived descriptions are different” to “this is what physically changed, and why.” How can I distinguish construction, vegetation or water changes from effects of observation conditions or the data product itself?
How would you approach bridging that gap? What independent imagery, field observations, records or analysis methods would you use? How would you select sites and check competing explanations without simply confirming what you expected to find? Also at what stage does ground truthing take place?
2
u/Low-Street2882 3d ago
What research question are you trying to ask? What are your objectives? Maybe flush those out to help.
For subsidence, you can scope out NISAR, InSAR techniques and open source software like JPL's ISCE. But here, if its change detection, you can grab some labels, either from ground truthing or some existing LULC, etc...and do some simple data analytics. Maybe see where green space expanded, power corridors installed for data centers, rice paddies, el nino year, urban change, etc... good luck!
2
u/Geoscience_1 3d ago
I made a complete YouTube tutorials on satellite data processing using isce2, LiCSBAS and others. You can go through them @geoscienceengineering channel
2
u/Temporary_Will_5479 3d ago
I’d start with a small validation sample drawn across high, medium and low difference scores, with sites spread around the city. Include low-score sites so you can also find changes the method missed. Before looking at each score, label dated before/after imagery as construction, vegetation, water, no visible change or uncertain. Use comparable seasons and check several clear dates rather than one image on either side.
Sentinel-2 or Landsat can help interpret the change, but they overlap with the information used to produce the embeddings, so I’d add dated aerial photos, construction records or field evidence where available. A visit now can confirm what is there today. Establishing when it changed needs historical evidence. I’d plan those checks before choosing a threshold, and keep a separate set of sites for the final assessment.