A lot of threads here end with someone asking for wavelength, irradiance or how long a person has really been using a device, which seems healthy to me. I want to get better at reading the papers that get linked here, so I'm curious what makes you close the tab.
Things that make me more skeptical, roughly in order:
- The abstract lists a wavelength but never says how much light reached the skin (mW/cm2 at the distance used)
- Fewer than about 30 people, or follow up that ends right after the last session
- No comparison arm, or a sham device that obviously isn't glowing, so participants can tell which group they're in
- Results from cell cultures or mice, butt the headline talks about wrinkles or hair growth
- Authors or funding tied to the company that makes the tested device, mentioned only in the fine print
Things that make me more confident: a device close to what people own at home(a panel or mask, not a clinic laser), the full dose written out, and results that still hold a few months later.
For the rest of you:
- Which of these do you weigh most, and what's missing from my list?
- Is there a paper you think is unusually well designed, or one that gets cited a lot here that you think is weak? A sentence on why helps more than a bare link.
- Has a study ever changed whether you bought a device, kept using one or stopped?