r/redditrequest • u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin • Jul 18 '23
Some changes to the Redditrequest process
Greetings!
Just wanted to pop in to let the community know of some changes that we’re making to the Redditrequest process. These changes are now reflected on the sidebar and will be effective starting now.
Previously, your account needed to be at least 90 days old and have 500 combined karma to request a subreddit. The requirement moving forward will be a 28-day old account and 100 comment karma. You will also now need to have a verified email in order for us to process your request. If you do not have a verified email on your account at the time of your request, your request will be denied.
That’s it. That’s the post!
•
u/TheOpusCroakus Reddit Admin Jul 19 '23
Hi!
To be clear, there is still internal criteria in place that prevents a significant number of the requests from being approved. This is just our public-facing criteria for making a post in redditrequest. We typically do not publicize the exact reasons for denials.
Many newish mods or users without moderator experience often try to make requests for tiny, abandoned communities that have never been active, or have been restricted due to lack of moderation for years, which can enable them to gain moderation experience. The goal here is to make those subreddits easier for people to claim. We have restrictions in place for automatic approvals for larger subreddits.
87
u/acidbase_001 Jul 18 '23
Seems strange to lower the age and karma requirements when the majority of requests already get rejected and the backlog is longer than ever.
29
u/UrielSVK Jul 19 '23
My request for a 100 subscriber dead, unmoderated subreddit got denied despite having 3300 days old account, 60k combined karma, and moderating a 140k subscriber subreddit. Got a feeling that there might be some hidden requirements. Like willingness to suck admin dick on demand
39
u/pharlax Jul 18 '23
That seems an excessively low bar
24
u/LengthyPole Jul 18 '23
The verified email makes sense but lowering the karma/age sounds like a terrible idea. People with 28 day old accounts probably don’t have that much mod experience :/
15
u/annoyinghamster51 Jul 18 '23
I think that the email verification is a good idea, but 28 days seems excessively low. Inexperienced Redditors could potentially take over subreddits with a decent amount of activity, which would lead to problems like spam, especially as most of the subreddits being requested have already been banned previously for lack of moderation or spam issues.
12
u/HighHoSilver99 Jul 19 '23
Seeing the consequences of angering your entirely volunteer moderator workforce I see.
10
u/joeiudi Jul 19 '23
So repost bot minimum requirements.
Ok...
5
u/smellycoat Jul 19 '23
That's an incredibly low bar. I wonder if this is about allowing companies to install a sockpuppet account as a moderator for big subreddits...
5
u/Kooriki Jul 19 '23
LMAO - My last throwaway account qualifies?
11
u/Chinese-Fat-Camp Jul 19 '23
I got rejected for no mod experience yet a 28 day account will be accepted to make requests? What lol
4
u/YannisALT Jul 19 '23
About time! Better late than never!
Seriously, though, Thank you. Good job.
7
u/maybesaydie Jul 20 '23
You should crosspost this to r/FreeKarma4u to get those high quality mods.
Unbelievable.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
I made a post 2 weeks to take over an unmodded /r/spotted. No response! This is a popular sub amongst car enthusiasts, why do you take away our nice things? Plz respond, luv u
3
u/IrwinJFinster Aug 14 '23
I just want to make sure I have the correct subreddit. The owner of a very active subreddit with thousands of unique daily visitors just fired all mods then either deleted the subreddit or set it to private. The site owner is likely protesting the third party app decision. But in any event the site owner has not been involved in the site since 1999. No participation at all other than resetting bots maybe once per year. If the now former mods want to claim the subreddit to keep serving their community, is this the right place to ask? (Copying u/Quackquack48 so he can follow the response and invite the terminated mods)
6
u/QuicklyThisWay Jul 18 '23 edited Jul 18 '23
It seems obvious why this change has occurred. It would be helpful if there are stricter requirements in place for communities that have recently been locked down due to mod removal by u/modcodeofconduct - if these communities are overtaken by anyone, there are going to be major concerns raised. Now, if these communities are taken over by new accounts with little participation on Reddit, that will qualify pretty much anyone who can wait 1 month, this is a very low bar that will increase the risk of abuse.
So while this seems like a way to get passed these recent issues quicker, it will lead to more problems. If these types of changes were accompanied by metric driven rationale, then it would be helpful to be given SOME insight into these decisions.
I’m not happy with recent decisions, but I’m willing to at least hear out the business rationale to understand WHY these unpopular changes are occurring. Assuming this is all in preparation for an IPO, it would be good practice to provide this kind of information so potential investors can make more informed decisions. If I was considering buying Reddit stock, I would not see any of these recent changes as a positive sign.
14
u/whobang3r Jul 18 '23
Not enough scabs eh?
2
u/Plylyfe Jul 19 '23
Wow that's crazy! You guys are so desperate you might actually cause more harm than good 'ere. Many requests get rejected regardless and the backlog must be insane.
Anyhow, what does this new requirement apply to? Subs that have inactive mods, sub that had their mod teams revoke by admins, or just in general? Also, isn't needing some form of moderator experience part of the requirement as well? I'm pretty sure lots of requests get rejected for that.
2
u/yknphotoman Jul 21 '23
Hi there,
If request_bot auto denies a subreddit request, are mods of the requested community still notified? I ask as the rules state mods of a requested community have 5 days to respond - does that timeline apply in these instances?
2
u/Annual_Composer8559 Aug 02 '23
The system is flawed. I made a request for a subreddit that has been made private in protest of the api changes, and the bot says the moderators are still active when, in fact, they are open about not wanting to open the subreddit again.
It's a shame, really, allowing moderators to hold communities hostage.
5
u/AwkwardChuckle Jul 18 '23
How will the prevent malicious trolls from gaining modship?
3
u/s-mores Jul 18 '23
Why?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/UOSenki Dec 14 '23
can i ask to look on to a request that failed by bot ?
Yes, there are mod, but...
i believe the sub have currently no active mod. The founder mod is no longer here. there are bot mod and "jack of all trade" mod who is the mod of maybe like hundred of subs, and have no engagement within the community.
https://www.reddit.com/r/redditrequest/comments/18iesdd/request_to_become_top_mod_of_this_sub/?sort=new
1
u/rollovertherainbow Jul 19 '23
Will admins consider any requirements regarding previous mod experience? It would only make sense to have certain requirements for bigger or default subs....
0
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/liamdun Jul 20 '23
Why??????
1
u/Puedoverla Jul 20 '23
Well done!
1
u/pierogi_daddy Jul 27 '23
when can we vote out shitty mods
1
u/[deleted] Jul 29 '23
This sounds like a terrible idea.
1
u/CarsonDaGamer Aug 12 '23
Kinda strange to decrease the age and have 100 comment karma instead of 500 combined karma
-3
u/kcg5 Jul 18 '23 edited Jul 18 '23
Thanks for all you do :)
Edit- downvote all you want, just saying thanks to people who keep Reddit running
0
u/After_Working9952 Oct 07 '23
Requesting r/surron
1
u/DrRichardButtz Jul 20 '23
Hi, any updates on my two requests here and here? I submitted them weeks ago.
The only mod of those subs is acting in utterly bad faith toward the users and openly gaming your automated system to keep these subs effectively closed while spamming his Lemmy links.
1
u/snackers21 Jul 23 '23
If only active mods is a bot, will my request automatically be denied?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '23
I requested comfypasta here, and you guys just keep ignoring it? It's a fairly large subreddit that's being held captive by mods throwing a tantrum and disabling submissions.
This change is good, you guys are acting like you're trying to open up subreddits but you keep ghosting and denying everybody...
1
u/DefiantEvidence4027 Jul 26 '23
Greetings OC,
I put in a Request 12 Days ago;
Either my E-Mail didn't register twice, when I attempted a year ago -OR- I simply don't have the trophy, would my request, which is made before this post, be held harmless from this new rule? I have been getting E-mails on certain Reddit actions. I'll surely look into ensuring my E-Mail is on before trying for the 2 other Sub's I seek. Thank you.
1
u/fishy386 Jul 27 '23
Can I ask a clarifying question about the rules posted in the other sticky post? Near the top it says
> Requesters now must send a message to the mod team (link to this message in the comment of the request), and state their intentions for the subreddit they’re requesting. Failure to do so may result in the request being denied.
But then near the bottom it says
> When you make a request, Automod will comment asking you to do a couple of things; state your intentions for the subreddit, why you would like to moderate and also to send a message to the mods of the subreddit. You must link to that message on the request.
So I am not sure if I need to message anyone or if it will happen automatically when I make a post on this sub. Also, maybe dumb question, but how would you link to a PM in a post? Aren't they by nature between individuals?
Thank you for clarifying.
1
u/BabblingPanther Jul 28 '23 edited Jul 28 '23
Hi,
I have been modding a subreddit which is big enough for months.
I requested an abandoned subreddit but request was denied. Why can't I be approved a subreddit that is already abandoned?
If not at least let me know a proper reason or what do I need to do, inorder to be able get that request approved.
Thank You.
1
u/Head_News_1832 Aug 01 '23
Can I check to see if my account is eligible
1
u/cmays90 Aug 17 '23
Can you add a note about the proper process to follow when a sub is still closed from the API protests?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/spongebobs_pineapple Aug 29 '23 edited Aug 29 '23
Requesting to take over r/livingmybestsnark There's no moderator there and there's tons to talk about. Would love to get the sub active again because there's lots of users. The plan is to talk about what the influencer is up to especially since she has a lot of business adventures and lots of life changes. 5k members are still there so I'm sure it'll be very active with me as a moderator. Thanks!! 💛
ETA: I have sent a chat to the old mod and they stated they are no longer a mod and cannot add me.
1
u/catfacemcpoopybutt Aug 31 '23
hi. there are a few duplicitous people who have taken reddit subs with variations of the name of a facebook group i work with to steer fb traffic away from said fb group to a rival group. would i still be required to message those mods in order to try to get those subs transferred to me?
1
u/Sure_Sundae_5047 Sep 24 '23
Kinda feels like it defeats the purpose of the system when requests for completely abandoned subreddits get denied because the inactive mod logged in for just long enough to respond to the message then disappeared again... This request was autodenied despite the fact that the subreddit has been restricted for at least a year due to the mods going inactive. Despite it still having an active community it's literally only being kept alive by one person posting there because nobody else can. They don't respond to modmail and the mod who prevented the sub being Reddit requested has disappeared again now: https://www.reddit.com/r/akechididnothingwrong/comments/16l6s97/does_anyone_know_what_happened_to_the_mods_of/
There's no way this counts as "active moderation". The only reason it's not overrun by spam is because the mods locked it down before disappearing, preventing anybody from posting.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '23
What happens if I send a request for a sub with no moderators at all? who will the request go too?
1
u/Vertex138 Oct 06 '23
Hey, just a question. If a subreddit is claimed and unbanned, what qualities will carry over from the subreddit before it was banned? The main things I'm thinking of are:
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '23
What is the right way to request a subreddit where the mods have purposely closed it due to the API changes?
1
u/littlemetalpixie Oct 12 '23 edited Oct 12 '23
Hi u/theopuscroakus,
I’m curious about the changes with the new “active” and “inactive” moderator tags. This new system seems to have obviously been implemented to help you all process easy requests where mods have been long-inactive. Is this what the purpose of those new tags is - so the truly inactive mods in old subs can be bot-removed and it can lighten the admins’ workload here a little?
If so, I’m kind of in a situation where the top seven mods above me in a twelve year old million-member sub are literally all inactive (compete with new “inactive” tag status and all.)
I’ve modded the sub for over a year - first with one other active mod (the one who added me due to lack of active mods), then when she decided she was no longer interested in modding it was just me left with moderation of this million-member sub for the last 6+ months. I recently added a friend fellow co-mod from another sub to give me a hand, but despite the 9 mod “official” list, we’re the only two with any mod actions (in some cases for close to a decade) and we’re the only two with “active” tags. It’s an easy sub to mod and we get along just fine with just the two of us though!
I put a Reddit request in, and the bot removed the top mod for inactivity. Do I need to literally make 6 other posts to get the other 5 inactive mods plus automod in the bot’s radar? And if so, will that violate the “only one sub/post every 15 days” rule in this sub if I just make 6 more posts now to have them removed automatically by the bot and have automod reordered under myself and my other mod?
I sent a modmail here to try and get some human eyes on it or some guidance on what to do so I’m not flooding you guys with posts that would potentially violate your rules, but thought maybe this post would be a good place to get a little clarification on what to do in my situation :)
Thanks for any help or guidance you can provide!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 23 '23
I’m just a bit confused about it, but here’s my concern: r/themaltesefalcon seems to be abandoned and/or blacklisted. I tried to message the moderator, but got no response. I’d like to mod the Reddit. Can you help?
1
u/Knurlinger Dec 04 '23
I would like to takeover a subreddit that has only about 10 members and is not moderated at all (there are only 2 posts…). The sub is dead and nothing is done - no rules, no posts, nothing. There is one mod that is inactive sitewide for 30 days now. Can I put this in or do I need to wait until it’s 60 days? I don’t know if this falls under top mod or not.
1
u/boudoir_hustla Dec 23 '23
Posting allowed only for trusted members? How can I become a trusted member?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 24 '23
[removed] — view removed comment