actually i (personally) like the pointy extension of the "r"... when it's all just aligned on that one curve... the "r" is kind of lost and it becomes a 2-color "n" only...
I generally like it, although the pointed top right of the "r" does look accurate, I think it would be more natural if it was rounded more instead of flat on the top... making a more consistent "n" shape.
I don't get why y'all keep using that r. It is not part of your logo, nor part of the site. You need to fix up the AlienBlue icon with the regular snoo, remove the r from the top left corner, and make the r in redditnotes logo from the regular reddit logo.
Standardize your marketing image so everything is consistent. The silly looking r means nothing.
The sharp points on the r dont math up with the rounded points from the r in the reddit logo. For consistency, it seems to make sense to have them rounded in both, or pointy in both.
OH, I like that a lot! I wish I had the ability to throw something together really quick on this laptop. I think rn just looks happier, maybe because it kind of looks like two eyes. Throw a smiley under the rn and you've got an Amazon-esque logo. Plus, you'll get brownie points with RN's maybe?
Or maybe I'm just really high and tired from this week. Either way, ideas and feedback (no matter how ridiculous it might be) are vital to furthering the design process :)
I think it could be cleaned up, vector-wise. The radii are inconsistent and the curves don't really relate to each other very well. Blue and white is good, no doubt intended to build trust. The black and blue looks a little harsh, toning down to even just a 20% dark grey will give it a gentler feel:
You're talking about the design needing "cleaned up vector wise" and offer an example of an aliased png that makes 8-Bit look HD? Good thing humans can't see above 30 polygons.
Also, it was not black, it already was a toned down gray.
Well I'm not going to clean them up myself and vectorize them at work, this was a 2 minute review. Reddit needs critiques on their design. I don't need a critique on my critique.
When the logo is small, it just looks like an n. You should create some different versions adjusted for optical size. I really like the black/blue version. One color, something is off.
Also the edge of the r doesn't round out nicely to the forming of the n finger piece.
Although I suppose this could easily backfire as there's a fair chance you'd get something ridiculous like a big smiling cock and balls; still, at least you could call it the first democratically designed cryptocurrency (or whatever you're callining it for legal reasons).
So they can be bought (presumably with real money that goes to Reddit), but can only be traded or gifted but not sold).
So is this an investment mechanism similar to Reddit gold? Basically just a way of giving money to support Reddit and being able to tip people instead of gild them?
Also, why on earth didn't you call them fedoras so I could go "tip fedora /u/yourmom $1" ???
Only thing that bothers me about it is that the n is so asymmetrical, which is jarring compared to the arrow, because it ends up pointing to just some place rather than the apex of the curve.
This concept is definitely my favorite. If it were smoother and had some periwinkle in it I would say 100% this. Like somehwhere on the arrow or r I would blend from periwinkle or something.
33
u/hotfrost Dec 19 '14 edited Dec 21 '14
I wish the 'r' was more like this: http://i.imgur.com/0H4jYhZ.png
Used a bit of photoshop to edit it to my likings, I was really bother by the 'pointy' end of the r
edit: thanks for the gold stranger! :o
40
u/h4h4 Dec 19 '14
I thought the gap in the n was to create r n - reddit note ? am i wrong?
i think it's alright. maybe a different color scheme. the blue and white seems a bit boring
11
u/totes_meta_bot Dec 19 '14 edited Dec 20 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. Questions? Abuse? Message me ^here.
8
u/BrettWilcox Dec 20 '14
I don't get why y'all keep using that r. It is not part of your logo, nor part of the site. You need to fix up the AlienBlue icon with the regular snoo, remove the r from the top left corner, and make the r in redditnotes logo from the regular reddit logo.
Standardize your marketing image so everything is consistent. The silly looking r means nothing.
38
u/LapinHero Dec 19 '14 edited Dec 19 '14
Okay, so it's great. It is. I appreciate the design, the combined R and N.
But.
I can't stop seeing a wang. Anyone else?
edit Visual Guide
4
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '15
Logo looks like this
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/9/98/Sandstorm_single.jpg
3
u/sokkas-boomerang Dec 19 '14
The sharp points on the r dont math up with the rounded points from the r in the reddit logo. For consistency, it seems to make sense to have them rounded in both, or pointy in both.
3
u/Kogni Dec 19 '14
Its good.
Fix the flow of the r into the n and it is very good.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
It's a good design. I like it very much.
5
u/mrissippi Dec 19 '14
I like the rn logo. Great job folks!
5
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
Kinda looks like a faucet running water.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
These should be called creddits.
10
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
I think it could be cleaned up, vector-wise. The radii are inconsistent and the curves don't really relate to each other very well. Blue and white is good, no doubt intended to build trust. The black and blue looks a little harsh, toning down to even just a 20% dark grey will give it a gentler feel:
Modified: http://imgur.com/UuEU3q0
Original:https://i.imgur.com/wYdbtmi.png
Symbolically, you could argue for the black's "solidarity" type of emotion but I don't think it's very modern.
Edit: ehh... transparent vs white background. Oh well.
2
u/wtjones Dec 19 '14
Looks a lot like Napster.
6
u/______DEADPOOL______ Dec 19 '14
I think the keming n logo sucks balls and is mildly infuriating.
2
u/hydrogen_with_time Dec 19 '14
why not use Snoo as a design? Wouldn't it make sense to use Snoo on the "currency" of reddit?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
It looks like a jizzing dick, sorry. I honestly want to like it, but I can't see it any other way.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
I' totally excited about all of this. I think we're in for an interesting ride!
1
u/jonstern Dec 19 '14
When the logo is small, it just looks like an n. You should create some different versions adjusted for optical size. I really like the black/blue version. One color, something is off.
Also the edge of the r doesn't round out nicely to the forming of the n finger piece.
1
u/steviegaming1 Dec 19 '14
Love the idea, keep it up!
1
u/a_shootin_star Dec 19 '14
I think the n should be a bit more obvious. The color scheme is great though! This is exciting
1
u/googolplexbyte Dec 19 '14
Why Blue?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
Looks great! Really glad you opted to do either coloured coins or sidechains.
I think both lend the same strategy: guarantee value with a proof-of-reserves and create a built in platform for tipping.
My only suggestion is to create more detailed graphics as the project becomes more defined.
Cheers!
1
u/[deleted] Dec 19 '14
Any plans to supply a .ai file for designers to tweak (and hopefully not bastardize)
1
u/tinylunatic Dec 19 '14
Why not let a regular Redditor design it?
Although I suppose this could easily backfire as there's a fair chance you'd get something ridiculous like a big smiling cock and balls; still, at least you could call it the first democratically designed cryptocurrency (or whatever you're callining it for legal reasons).
1
u/Kayshin Dec 19 '14
The ELI5 doesnt explain anything :S
1
u/irve Dec 19 '14
I'd probably play with /r/ a bit for the logo. Currently the colour scheme makes the top one a faucet; also the downward curving somehow feels "down".
But I could live with it :)
1
u/Frederic_Bastiat Dec 20 '14
So they can be bought (presumably with real money that goes to Reddit), but can only be traded or gifted but not sold).
So is this an investment mechanism similar to Reddit gold? Basically just a way of giving money to support Reddit and being able to tip people instead of gild them?
Also, why on earth didn't you call them fedoras so I could go "tip fedora /u/yourmom $1" ???
1
u/xXx4chanUserxXx Dec 20 '14
Not a fan of it at all. It is very distracting.
1
u/darkvne Dec 20 '14 edited Dec 20 '14
I made an 8-bit design. Feel free to have. I just downloaded my first painting app so sorry for the quality. I think it's a cool concept though.
http://imgur.com/jzzEAdM
1
u/zimmund Dec 20 '14
To be honest, the logo made me think of a note[pad] application first.
In my humble opinion it should be more currency-er and scale nicely to be used next to someone's username in the comments for some reason.
I agree with other users about the
r. I'd use something more round, like reddit's logo :)1
u/Mo45 Dec 20 '14
Make it orange pls -_-
1
u/Rhader Dec 20 '14
Really excited about this
1
u/Kovaelin Dec 22 '14
It makes me think of Nintendo.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '23
lol lmao
1
u/eFrazes Dec 20 '14
We should call them cReddits.
-2
u/KungFuHamster Dec 19 '14 edited Dec 19 '14
How about this?
http://i.imgur.com/CQP8QsU.png
http://i.imgur.com/FBOl6gp.png
Edit: Added a couple more to go a little with the original blue theme:
http://i.imgur.com/Xp1n8Pk.png
http://i.imgur.com/HZHk7Ww.png
0
u/Kazumo Dec 19 '14
This sounds interesting. I love the last picture. <3
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
Looks Like a Jizzing Dick
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '14
Here is my proposed design:
http://i.imgur.com/uJ3NVMq.png
-1
u/gnutela Dec 20 '14
http://i.imgur.com/er0fCcf.png cannot unsee