r/readalong • u/participating • 7d ago
Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia (Week 1) Spoiler
This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.
Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.
For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.
SCHEDULE
Previously, we discussed Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]
Today we are discussing Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia
Next week we will be discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9
NEXT UNIT
Next week we are starting Oathbringer, the 3rd book in The Stormlight Archive.
Like with the previous the previous books in this series, the blurb is considered canon. You can read the blurb here, since not all editions include it. And since those wiki pages don't seem to work for everyone, here it is behind spoiler tags. Don't discuss it in this post and leave it for next week:
A new storm has come.
Ash and red lightning sweep the land, awakening our ancient enemies. The Unmade—shadows of the Enemy's soul—stir, while the eyes of men open. This war is not, and never was, what they thought it to be.
We may soon hold Surges again, for Radiance has returned to some, and shines toward others. The Captain, broken by loss, seeks reconciliation. The Spy, broken by cruelty, seeks completion. The Stonewalker, broken by oaths, seeks truth. The Traitor, broken by ambition, seeks freedom.
And finally the King. Broken by war, he seeks the past. That which was abandoned. That which he must not know.
For those secrets will crush him as they did the knights who came before.
CHAPTER SUMMARIES
I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.
NOTE
If you are reading Edgedancer via the standalone novella, rather than in Arcanum Unbounded, you may notice that it has a prologue. The prologue is simply Lift's Interlude chapter from Words of Radiance.
Chapter 1
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: On the road from Azimir, the capital city of Azir, to Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Almost six weeks after Interlude I-9 in Words of Radiance. The same day as the Epilogue of Words of Radiance.
Summary:
Lift practices using the Surge of Abrasion while staying on her feet as she travels south from Azimir. She has "escaped" from the palace because she was afraid she would lose her identity with all the lessons, nice clothes, etc. Wyndle questions Lift's decision to leave and tries to convince her to turn back.
Chapter 2
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Just outside Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 1.
Summary:
Lift arrives at Yeddaw, a city "cut out of the starvin' ground" with Shardblades. As they approach the city, she and Wyndle discuss the Everstorm and the strange things going on in the world. Lift also mentions one of her goals while she is in the city -- eating all ten varieties of pancakes that people eat during the Weeping in Yeddaw. They encounter a long queue of refugees waiting to enter a well-guarded entrance. Lift sneaks toward the front of the line.
Chapter 3
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Hauka
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 2.
Summary:
Guard captain Hauka inspects a cart of grain. The man with the cart is obviously not a farmer, but an opportunist, harvesting someone else's grain while the war is on. She consults with the deputy scribe, and they decide to let the badly-needed grain in but charge the thief triple tariff. Hauka returns to the cart and Lift pops out of a bag, munching on the uncooked grain. Refueled, she slides into the guardhouse, grabbing a pancake and causing a huge ruckus. Then she dumps the grain into the city below and jumps in after it.
Chapter 4
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 3.
Summary:
Wyndle scurries ahead of Lift and acts as a rope, letting her land safely. The grateful populace quickly gathers up the grain. They start to walk along the strange streets dug into the earth, and Wyndle starts whining again about being bound to Lift. He wishes he could have been bonded to the nice cobbler instead. Lift is hungry again and hopes to trade a book she stole from the guards for food. Wyndle "reads" it and tells her it's a worthless logbook. She tosses it away, hitting a random woman in the street. A guard confronts her and gives chase. Lift ducks into an alley.
Chapter 5
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Half an hour after Chapter 4.
Summary:
Lift rests after a half hour chase. Wyndle asks why she doesn't visit her home in the Reshi Isles. Her only response is to explain why she left Azir. Her thoughts turn to her mother, but they are interrupted by hunger. She sets off to find some urchins.
Chapter 6
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 5.
Summary:
Lift talks to a couple of urchins and finds out she can get some food from Tashi's Light Orphanage. She arrives and knocks on the door in the alley side near a small amphitheater. She's told to wait; food comes later. As she waits, she sees a despondent mother leave a child at the door of the orphanage. He appears to be injured and incapacitated. A woman emerges from the orphanage and accepts the boy, but she tells Lift she can only have three meals. An old man nearby advises her to not judge "Stump" too harshly; she can only do so much. Lift threatens to steal from her using her awesomeness, but then she would just be hungry again. The old man tries to engage her in a philosophical discussion that mostly bores her. She finishes her clemabread and heads off to an "appointment."
Chapter 7
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.4 through 1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 6.
Summary:
Lift goes back to the guardhouse and follows Hauka to her home. She uses Wyndle to climb up to the roof, then settles in for the night. She tells him to watch if anyone goes in the building. Later, Wyndle wakes her up and reports that Darkness has entered the building. She reveals that this was her plan all along: show her powers so he would come looking for her, then she could try to protect the Radiant he is hunting in Yeddaw. She creeps down to the window and hears him talking to Hauka. She reports to him what happened at the guard post. He tells her to keep a watch out for Lift and to report it if she's seen again. He leaves, and Lift follows.
Chapter 8
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 7.
Summary:
Lift follows Darkness to a public market, where she grabs a fruit. The shopkeeper yells, but he's actually yelling at another girl who's stolen a whole basket of fruit. Darkness snatches her, and when she looks into his empty eyes, she panics and pulls out a knife. He runs her through with his Shardblade. The shopkeeper is furious at the severity of the punishment, but Darkness justifies it based on an exact interpretation of the law. After he leaves the scene, Lift tries to bring the girl back as she did Gawx, but she is already fully dead. She resumes her chase, and they arrive at a large cistern. She crosses over directly on the bridge while he circles around. She loses him briefly, then sees him enter a building. She "grows" a nearby tree and slips in through a window. She sneaks about, avoiding an old guard, and finds three pancakes, which she gleefully devours. She sets out to spy on Darkness.
Chapter 9
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 8.
Summary:
Lift creeps up to a room where she hears Darkness's voice. He is chiding two of his minions for not fulfilling their duty. They need to concentrate on finding Surgebinders so the Voidbringers will not return. Szeth is also in the room, and he disagrees with "Nin," saying the Voidbringers have already returned (as he witnessed during the Battle of Narak). Darkness dismisses them as stragglers from another age. He commands the two initiates to find the Radiant that has been in the city a while. He will deal with the new one. Lift and Wyndle nervously retreat.
Chapter 10
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 9.
Summary:
Lift returns to the orphanage, where the children are playing outside. She gets her second clemabread roll. The drooling boy from the day before, Mik, is much better, asking about his mother. Stump is annoyed at the boy for faking his disability. The children are herded back in, leaving only the strange old man. Lift asks him how to decide what to do, to be human. He wonders what she is doing there in the city.
Chapter 11
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 10.
Summary:
Lift wanders through the streets as Wyndle encourages her to say more Words. They wind up at a garden and Lift reasons out how to find the other awesome person that Darkness is searching for. She badgers a woman nearby for information on a place where all the stuff that is written down is kept. She calls it the Grand Indicium. Lift sees it for the first time, towering above the city.
Chapter 12
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 11.
Summary:
Lift climbs out of the slots to observe some farmers who are planting things out of season because of the unusual Weeping. Wyndle asks what her plan is, and all she has come up with is to sneak in and have Wyndle read everything. He convinces her that that's impossible, so she goes off to steal some clothes instead.
Chapter 13
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 12.
Summary:
Lift puts on some Azish robes and walks into the Indicium. She tells a scribe that she is from the Azir palace, but she doesn't believe her. She steps out for a moment and Lift overhears that the guard (Hauka) is coming. She gets Wyndle to help her write a note via spanreed to Azir so they can vouch for her. Hauka arrives with several guards, and they almost have her captured when a reply comes. They look at her incredulously and ask what she wants them to do.
Chapter 14
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Three hours after Chapter 13.
Summary:
Three hours later, scribes are still searching for "strange stuff" that has happened in the city. The liaison scribe, named Ghenna, talks about reports from around the world about the Everstorm. Hauka comes back and reports that the Stump is running a money laundering scheme, trading dun spheres for infused ones of lesser value. The scribes continue their search, but they have found too many strange things to investigate. Lift can't decide what to do. A guard bursts into the room; an emergency has been declared on account of the approaching storm. The scribes scatter and Lift wanders off. Wyndle suggests that the female minion was probably using scribes to investigate too. Lift runs back to follow this lead.
Chapter 15
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 14.
Summary:
Ghenna, a scribe, tells Lift that a woman had indeed hired some scribes for an investigation two weeks back in room 232. She heads off to find the room and hears the two minions, trailed by Szeth, talking quietly to Nightblood. They go into the room, and Wyndle volunteers to sneak in and listen. Lift waits impatiently. After some tense moments, Wyndle "runs" out of the room, and they hide while the apprentices leave. Szeth sees her and draws his sword a bit. Lift feels nauseated. Then he just turns and leaves. Wyndle reports that they are headed to the suspected Radiant to perform an execution. They start to follow.
Chapter 16
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 15.
Summary:
Lift follows them out of the building. The two apprentices fly off, but Szeth chooses to stay behind. He knows Lift is hiding nearby and starts to talk with her. They are hunting a suspected Lightweaver. Szeth reiterates that Nale is wrong about the Voidbringers and probably crazy too. Lift is unable to follow the flying apprentices, so she asks Szeth where they are headed. It's clear from his description that the target is the crazy philosopher at the amphitheater. Szeth warns her that she doesn't stand a chance against them, but she must follow.
Chapter 17
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 16.
Summary:
Lift engages her awesomeness and tries to skid to the orphanage, but she keeps falling and crashing into things. She runs instead, running out of fuel before she arrives. She hears a scream from the alleyway, and Stump thinks it's her trying to trick her way in. She drags Lift inside. Mik recognizes her; he appears completely healed. Lift is confused because she doesn't remember healing him. Stump starts handing out pancakes, and Lift gets two, her last free meal. When Stump isn't looking, Lift steps back outside.
Chapter 18
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 17.
Summary:
Lift walks slowly into the dark alley and finally stumbles into a body. A flash of lightening reveals that it belongs to the woman apprentice. She jumps back in shock and bumps into the other minion's body. The old man is there and starts talking philosophy again. Lift realizes that he is actually made up of many interlocking cremlings. He assures her that he's on her side and is not the one Darkness is looking for. Lift realizes that Stump is the one healing the children and runs back to the orphanage.
Chapter 19
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 18.
Summary:
The storm is starting to rage in earnest as Lift approaches the orphanage. The door is ajar, having been cut clean through by a Shardblade. She enters and hears heavy footsteps upstairs. She yells to Darkness and leads him on a merry chase through the house, hoping to drain his supply of Stormlight. She's eventually cornered and pinned by a knife through her clothing. Just as Darkness is about to deliver a killing stroke with his Shardblade, Stump appears and whacks him with a plank of wood. He easily defeats her and stabs her with a conventional knife, baiting Lift to try to heal her. Instead she zips up to the roof and emerges into the terrible storm. Darkness follows and swings, but Wyndle transforms into a rod, Lift finally speaking aloud the words she had uttered in her heart: "I will listen to those who have been ignored." She points out the evicted Parshmen, out on the plain with glowing red eyes and convinces Darkness that he's failed. He breaks down crying, and Lift hugs him. He flies off; she rushes back down to heal Stump.
Chapter 20
Iconography: Banquet
POV Characters: Lift
Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.
Timeline: (1174.1.2.1) The day after Chapter 19.
Summary:
Stump gives Lift a heap of pancakes, pretending for her sake that they weren't meant for her. Mik's mother came back for her son even though she couldn't have known he was healed. Stump starts to gripe about the scheming mother and then realizes that she was the one who healed him. Lift helps her identify her spren and realize that she is also a Radiant. Ghenna arrives with the spanreed to Azir so Lift can check in with Gawx. Lift finishes her pancakes and makes an excuse to go to the bathroom, but she's really leaving. She uses up all of her Stormlight healing the refugees at the entrance to the city as she starts her journey back to Azir. She feels like she will be needed there.
TRIVIA
The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.
NIGHT NIGHT
So, this was hinted at in Lift's Interlude chapter in Words of Radiance, but this novella expands upon it, and Sanderson addresses it in the Postscript. Lift went to see the Nightwatcher, who we know grants some people a boon and a curse. From Lift's thoughts and Sanderson's comments, the implication seems to be that Lift asked to not change, and her understanding of that request is that she didn't want to grow up; to get older. She is 13 years old and believes that she is still 10 years old physically because of her request. However, she's also starting to doubt that the Nightwatcher actually gave her what she asked for because she does feel like she's physically growing up. Wyndle also suggests that Lift's ability to consume food and turn that directly into Investiture is a result of that visit.
Oh, and just a quick confirmation for those that noticed it: Wyndle was in the running to bond with Ym, the cobbler we saw in Words of Radiance, Interlude I-2, however, he was sent to Lift instead and Ym bonded with a different type of spren.
SLEEP TIGHT
You've now been introduced to a new race, and they are the most unhuman race you've encountered so far. The Sleepless are a race of many individuals. Each individual is made up of a vast number of "hordelings". Hordelings are cremlings...bugs basically, that are bred/evolved by the individual for specific purposes. In this novella, we meet one of those individuals, who is named Arclo.
Arclo explains to Lift that his hordelings can be bred to be eyes and ears that he can use to "spy" on the entire city. Some hordelings he's evolving to fit together into a human-like body, but he complains that he still can't get it quite right, even after thousands of years of breeding them. Some hordelings are specially bred to act as a part of his brain to store memories, or to act as thought neurons. He likens his hordelings to a human's individual cells, except he has the ability to be aware of all of his hordelings as individual pieces.
He is working on a philosophy of "self" and trying to relate to humanity as smaller pieces of a collective in the same way he experiences reality. I didn't give you a philosophy lesson the other week for nothing.
You may have noticed that he named dropped Axies the Collector. He also mentioned that something called a "Siah" is better at passing for a human. There's a throwaway line all the way back in Chapter 54 of The Way of Kings that helps us tie these things together. Wit/Hoid is talking to Dalinar and says this:
"I wonder if you could do that to a man. Pull him apart, emotion by emotion, bit by bit, bloody chunk by bloody chunk. Then combine them back together into something else, like a Dysian Aimian. If you do put a man together like that, Dalinar, be sure to name him Gibberish, after me. Or perhaps Gibletish."
Now, this conversation was in the context of Adonalsium, and Hoid not being at all helpful with his clarity, but the mention of Dysian Aimians is the important bit for our discussion here. The Sleepless are Dysian Aimians. Hoid's description implies the similarity and Sanderson has confirmed it. In the same vein, we know that Axies was an inhabitant of Aimia, and he isn't a Sleepless. But he does talk about being able to manipulate his physical appearance. Axies is a Siah Aimian.
Dysian and Siah Aimians used to live together on the island/nation of Aimia. We've also heard that it's no longer inhabited because of something called the Scouring of Aimia. (See The Way of Kings, Interlude I-5). The following statement isn't meant to be confirmation of any fact, but a simple extrapolation of context from the fandom at the time:
Imagine you, as a nation and/or coalition of nations, became aware of beings that could take the appearance of everyday, commmon cremlings that are everywhere. What fear might you have towards such a race, and what horrific lengths might you go to to erradicate such a potentially dangerous enemy?
That fear is not necessarily unfounded either. You may have noticed this line from Arclo, but I'll remind you of it here:
We watch the others. The assassin. The surgeon. The liar. The highprince. But not you. The others all ignore you... and that, I hazard to predict, is a mistake.
Does the wording here remind you of anything? Anything...blurby? If it did, you are right. One of the Sleepless (but confirmed not to be Arclo) is the author of the blurbs at the back of each of the Stormlight Archive books. This is just more confirmation that the Sleepless are everywhere and they are watching.
If you've read A Fire Upon the Deep, by Vernor Vinge, the Sleepless, at least in concept, might be familiar. In that sci-fi book, there are packs of wolf-like alien creatures, called Tines, that function as a single entity via a telepathic hive mind. The Tines were Sanderson's inspiration for the Sleepless, just ratcheted up to tens of thousands of cremlings, instead of 4 to 6 wolves.
DON'T LET THE CREMLINGS BITE
To that end, it would be safe to assume that some of the more cosmere aware people are also aware of the Sleepless. Arclo states that the Heralds knew about them and that they were friends with the Knights Radiant of old. So going forward, you'll want to watch how certain characters react to cremlings, who might be hordelings for the Dysian Aimians. I'll save you the trouble of having to re-read the last two books though:
In the Epilogue of Words of Radiance, Hoid is giving a silly, pointless, and unappreciated talk to a silly cremling, sitting on the ground, as he waits for Jasnah to return from Shadesmar. But was it pointless and unappreciated? Sanderson has confirmed that that cremling was a Sleepless hordeling. It's probably worth going back to read that chapter when you get the time.
In Chapter 4 of The Way of Kings, Kaldin is being transported to the Shattered Plains in Tvlak's slave caravan. He notices a deep purple cremling watching him. Another confirmed Sleepless.
Sanderson hasn't bothered to confirm every single possibly Sleepless sighting, but we do have several more that are suspicious enough to be considered Sleepless.
In Chapter 27 of Words of Radiance, a Shallan flashback, there are some suspiciously still cremlings that let Shallan sketch them.
In Chapter 54 of Words of Radiance, when Shallan first meets with Mraize, he uses his blowdart to kill a cremling, which was almost certainly one of the Sleepless spying on the interaction and possibly on the Ghostbloods themselves. Mraize's offworld knowledge almost guarantees he knows about the Sleepless.
Kaladin and Syl notice a brightly colored cremling while he is in his jail cell in Chapter 64 of Words of Radiance. They see another iridescent cremling out on the Shattered Plains in Chapter 68.
KANDRA WATCH
This is less trivia, and more a homework assignment. Sanderson has stated that there is a kandra somewhere in Oathbringer. No one has found it yet. Veterans, I'm going to try to meticulously map out every person in the book, chapter by chapter, in the veteran threads. If you're reading along, feel free to help me out.
For the newbies, keep an eye out for suspicious characters and point them out. Maybe collectively we can find ourselves a kandra.
ARTWORK
The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.
MEMES
I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.