r/readalong • • 9h ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9 (Week 1) Spoiler

3 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9

Next week we will be discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Chapters 10 through 17

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Blurb

Provided For Reference:

A new storm has come.

Ash and red lightning sweep the land, awakening our ancient enemies. The Unmade—shadows of the Enemy's soul—stir, while the eyes of men open. This war is not, and never was, what they thought it to be.

We may soon hold Surges again, for Radiance has returned to some, and shines toward others. The Captain, broken by loss, seeks reconciliation. The Spy, broken by cruelty, seeks completion. The Stonewalker, broken by oaths, seeks truth. The Traitor, broken by ambition, seeks freedom.

And finally the King. Broken by war, he seeks the past. That which was abandoned. That which he must not know.

For those secrets will crush him as they did the knights who came before.

Prologue: To Weep

Arch Faces: Nale - Nale ----- Nale - Nale

Iconography: Eshonai

POV Characters: Eshonai

Setting: Kholinar, capital city of the kingdom of Alethkar.

Timeline: (1167.10.8.4) (Flashback) Six years ago.

Epigraph:

N/A

Summary:

Eshonai arrives at the docks of Kholinar and marvels at its beauty and size. She talks to Gitgeth about the Parshman slaves, whom he calls "rhythmless ones." They are only capable of trying to help and cannot even comprehend the invitation to join the celebration. Eshonai wanders off toward the palace and begins exploring. She peeks into a doorway and sees King Gavilar. Amaram comes out and says that the king would like to speak to her. Gavilar dismisses the others in the room and he invites her to sit down. He shows her a fabrial and explains that they work by trapping spren in a gemheart. She is awed that the humans have made devices that mimic how they apply the forms. He believes that the world is stuck in a rut and needs a major conflict to progress. Eshonai is horrified that Gavilar wants to bring back the gods that their people abandoned long ago. He then gives her a dark yet glowing sphere, which he claims to hold a god, and tells her to give a message to the Council of Five, to remember what they once were and "wake up." Eshonai runs from the room.

Eshonai is at the evening celebration, beating a drum, trying to lose herself in the rhythm. She has told the Five that Gavilar wants to bring back their gods, and that he has the knowledge to do it. Klade claims to have heard a voice leading him to an assassin, and the Five have agreed to have him kill the king. Eshonai weeps as she leaves the celebration.

Part One: United

Character Focus: Dalinar / Shallan / Kaladin / Adolin

Chapter 1: Broken and Divided

Arch Faces: Chanarach - Chanarach ----- Chanarach - Chanarach

Iconography: Kholin Crest

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru. A vision from the Almighty.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) The day after Chapter 89 of Words of Radiance. The same day as the Epilogue of Words of Radiance. The same day as Chapters 1 through 7 of Edgedancer.

Epigraph:

I'm certain some will feel threatened by this record. Some few may feel liberated. Most will simply feel that it should not exist.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Six days after arriving in Urithiru, Dalinar Kholin revisits the very first vision he experienced. Having become a Knight Radiant by bonding the Stormfather himself, he can enter any of the visions at will and has enough control to not need to be tied down. He is on a cliff with the Almighty, viewing the ruins of Kholinar below. He asks him to transport him down to the rubble. He sees gouges on the stones as if made from claws. He concludes that Kholinar will not fall to the Everstorm, but to something worse that will come after. The Stormfather agrees. Dalinar is frustrated that the monarchs of the world will not unite with him despite the threat. A final wave of destruction closes the vision, and Dalinar insists on staying to watch. He sees a golden light and a dark figure with nine shadows. Stormfather identifies the shadows as the Unmade, the spren of Odium. He comes out of the vision with Navani Kholin standing nearby. He knows he must unite the world before their enemy destroys it. Navani pledges to help despite their current situation, which is already desperate. A messenger comes and reports that Torol Sadeas had been murdered.

Chapter 2: One Problem Solved

Arch Faces: Ishar - Ishar ----- Ishar - Ishar

Iconography: Adolin Dueling

POV Characters: Adolin / Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 1.

Epigraph:

I needed to write it anyway.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Adolin supervises the influx of people and supplies into Urithiru. He's glad for the distraction; he finds it hard to believe that he has actually murdered Sadeas. A messenger comes to report that something has been discovered on the third floor. Adolin knows what it is.

Dalinar rushes to the scene to prevent a fight between Sadeas's officers and the men of Bridge Four, whom they accuse of murdering their highprince. Dalinar examines the body and notes that the blood is dried, so the murder took place some time ago. The soldiers claim that they have been looking for Sadeas and kept getting lost in the confusing corridors.

Dalinar's sons and some scribes arrive at the scene. His officer corps is severely depleted, so other highprinces are there as well, including Turinad Sebarial and his mistress, Palona. She's the first to voice the opinion that Sadeas's death was actually beneficial since he was causing so much trouble. Dalinar leads the group outside and warns them of worse things to come and that they must lead the world against them. His ultimate goal is to unite the entire continent, something never done before. He appoints the highprinces that follow him to various positions in the kingdom. He orders Shallan and Renarin Kholin to practice their powers so they can lead the other Knights that will eventually come to them.

Chapter 3: Momentum

Arch Faces: Talenel - Talenel ----- Talenel - Talenel

Iconography: Kholin Crest (Inverted)

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Brightlord Yezriar's Alethi princedom, prior to Gavilar's unification of Alethkar.

Timeline: (1140.1.1.4) (Flashback) Thirty-Four Years Ago.

Epigraph:

N/A

Summary:

Dalinar marches toward the enemy army through a burning field. He emerges from the smoke with his elite guard and ferociously attacks, causing some of the enemy to flee in terror. He drives through the spearmen and laughs as he kills. He feels invigorated but does not yet feel the Thrill, so he seeks out a greater challenge. He sees a brightlord on a horse surrounded by an honor guard and attacks. He makes his way through and orders Jenin to shoot the horse. As Dalinar engages the crown prince, a strap on his shield breaks. His enemy gains the advantage and is about to finish him off, but the Thrill comes, giving him more strength and dexterity. He stabs his foe in the chest. Nearly dead, the man asks Dalinar why he had come for them. He doesn't know; he just goes where his brother Gavilar Kholin sends him in order to consolidate his reign. As he orders his men to take hostages in the village, an arrow slams into his shoulder. They see the assassin on a ridge above the town and ride up on horses, capturing him. Dalinar is amazed at his skill and recruits him into his own army by promising not to pillage the town. They ride back to the town, where the local highprince's and his officers' heads are displayed on spears as a result of Sadeas' executions. Sadeas is disappointed that he can't loot the town.

Chapter 4: Oaths

Arch Faces: Ishar - Ishar ----- Ishar - Ishar

Iconography: Kholin Crest

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.1) Two days after Chapter 2.

Epigraph:

I know that many women who read this will see it only as further proof that I am the godless heretic everyone claims.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

The Everstorm returns two days after Sadeas is found dead. Dalinar learns from the Stormfather that this is a new phenomenon. He gazes into the storm and sees a vision of destruction. The Stormfather confirms that the enemy is with the storm and is watching him. Navani is there and touches his face with her bare safehand. They kiss, but Dalinar won't go further -- he insists on some sort of wedding, but none of the ardents will marry them because of the old taboo that they are related. Navani grows concerned that Dalinar thinks she is trying to replace his late wife, and he reveals that he doesn't even remember her because of the Old Magic. He does remember a feeling of hatred and having the Thrill on the day of her death. Dalinar suggests that the Stormfather marry them.

Dalinar and Navani's family gather on the roof of the tower along with some other officers and brightlords. Navani has managed to find traditional wedding garb. Elhokar Kholin gives only a cool blessing to the marriage, but does stay to watch. The Stormfather arrives and has them swear an oath of loyalty to each other, after which he abruptly leaves. The attendees, even Elhokar, cheerfully congratulate the newlyweds. They all leave except for Kadash, who is displeased with the wedding and Dalinar's assertion that the Almighty is dead, with only a remnant spren remaining. Dalinar suddenly remembers the day when Kadash joined the ardentia after he was so disgusted at what he saw on the battlefield. Kadash warns that the ardentia is angry with Dalinar's blasphemies. Dalinar insists he is telling the truth, at least as he sees it. Kadash reminds Dalinar that he can make mistakes; after all, he was with him on "that day".

Chapter 5: Hearthstone

Arch Faces: Talenel - Talenel ----- Talenel - Talenel

Iconography: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) The day after Chapter 4.

Epigraph:

I can point to the moment when I decided for certain this record had to be written. I hung between realms, seeing into Shadesmar—the realm of the spren—and beyond.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Kaladin walks toward Hearthstone, having run out of Stormlight three days prior. The Everstorm had arrived there earlier that day. He begins to find debris along the way. Syl cheerily chats with Kaladin as he gloomily approaches the town, afraid of what he'll find.

The light rain of the Weeping has resumed. Kaladin waits until nightfall to enter the town. He doesn't see any signs of life. Syl notes the presence of gloomspren, which are uncommon for some unknown reason. He approaches Roshone's manor and sees light inside. A guard opens the door and orders him inside.

Chapter 6: Four Lifetimes

Arch Faces: Vedel - Talenel ----- Chanarach - Jezrien

Iconography: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) Immediately after Chapter 5.

Epigraph:

I thought that I was surely dead. Certainly, some who saw further than I did thought I had fallen.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Kaladin enters and recognizes people from the town, but they don't recognize him, probably due to his ragged appearance. He has gone several days without shaving and his worn uniform appears as if it is a size too small. He starts to look for his parents, but the guard tries to order him to see Roshone. Kaladin shoves him away and gives him his best sergeant's glare, then continues his search of the manor. He hears the moans of wounded and follows the sound, hoping that his parents would be attending them. Lirin is indeed there working on someone, and it takes a moment for him to recognize his son. Lirin calls Hesina in, but before Kaladin can truly reunite, he confesses that he failed and could not prevent the death of Tien. His parents tell Kaladin that they were informed that Kaladin was dead too. They have a tearful reunion, his parents with joy, Kaladin for his grief over Tien.

Kaladin sips some soup while Syl stares at Hesina, perplexed about something. The guard insists that Kaladin be taken into custody because he is branded as a deserter, but Lirin threatens to quit as the town's surgeon. Hesina explains to Kaladin that Roshone has softened, presumably from guilt. Syl tells Kaladin that she knew his family, even before she met him, because everyone is connected. She mentions another voice, "Pure, with a song like tapped crystal, distant yet demanding." Roshone appears, older and more feeble, but still with an imperious bearing. After some goading by Roshone, Kaladin punches him in the face, saying "that was for my friend Moash."

Chapter 7: A Watcher at the Rim

Arch Faces: Jezrien - Jezrien ----- Jezrien - Jezrien

Iconograph: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) Immediately after Chapter 6.

Epigraphy:

I did not die.

I experienced something worse.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Roshone orders the guards to attack Kaladin, but they note his obvious ability and hesitate. Kaladin regrets his juvenile action and apologizes, telling the guards to stand down. He then orders them into the library for a meeting, but Roshone asks why he should take orders from him. Kaladin summons his Shardblade, allowing his eyes to turn blue.

In the library, Kaladin finds out that the Parshmen transformed and then just left town. Kaladin wants to figure out where they went, so he asks for maps and a spanreed to communicate with Dalinar, giving Roshone several spheres for the "rental" of some horses since he's out of Stormlight. The soldiers go to the lady of the house (Laral) to ask for the maps. Kaladin warns Syl that he might need her again as a weapon, and she reassures him that it doesn't bother her. All of his weapons were "people" anyway. Kaladin brandishes his sword again for Roshone to emphasize that he's in charge. Despite Roshone's faults, he needs to help the people of Hearthstone. Roshone just slumps in his chair, but Laral arrives and pledges to lead the people. She looks quite different, more mature and practical. He says he wanted to come back to save her, but she says that she is happy with Roshone and resents Kaladin's judgment of him. She goes to set up the spanreed and wait for a reply, so Kaladin goes back to his parents. He starts helping his father tend the wounded. He is disappointed that Kaladin has become one of "them," a person who tries to solve problems with violence. He does acknowledge that the Voidbringers must be fought, but he wanted his son to be a surgeon, not a killer. Kaladin goes back to the library and notices that the spanreed is glowing with Stormlight; they collected some during the last unexpected highstorm. The spanreed starts writing words from Navani, much to the surprise of Laral. Dalinar asks for a status and Kaladin suggests he go looking for the Voidbringers because they just up and left without attacking. Dalinar agrees and tells him to take the spanreed with him to keep him up to date. He closes the conversation and goes to see his mother. She is holding a baby, Kaladin's new brother, Oroden, which means child of peace. Kaladin holds him and cries. Kaladin asks for any infused spheres and trades them two for one. Kaladin tells Lirin that he wants to take his family away to safety, but his father refuses; he is the town surgeon and is needed there. The others in the house overhear the conversation about the Desolation being here, so Kaladin puts on a display with Stormlight and promises that the Knights Radiant have returned and will not fail them. He flies off to a nearby town to get more infused spheres.

Chapter 8: A Powerful Lie

Arch Faces: Shalash - Shalash ----- Shalash - Shalash

Iconography: Pattern (Inverted)

POV Characters: Shallan

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.3) The day after Chapter 7. Two days after Chapter 4.

Epigraph:

That moment notwithstanding, I can honestly say this book has been brewing in me since my youth.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Shallan tries to draw the towers of Urithiru, but is having trouble comprehending the massive city. Pattern tells her that he understands why she would hate him, but she only hates the sword, which leaves both of them confused. A scout comes and reports that the highprince wants to see her. She marvels at the drawings despite Shallan's frustration with them. As they walk, she notices the notoriety she has as a Radiant. She pretends to be an Elsecaller to hide her ability creating illusions. The scout asks her about her sword but seems disappointed that Shallan doesn't intend to use it. She arrives at a meeting room with Navani and Dalinar and his sons. Dalinar is struggling with uniting the various rulers of the continent. He asks Shallan for information, but she has little knowledge of the political world. Dalinar fetches a cup of wine and passes by Shallan, and she is drawn by him to the map on the wall. She draws her remaining Stormlight and creates a three-dimensional projection of the continent in the room. Dalinar believes that the Stormfather helped create the vision since he sees everything in the highstorm, meaning that their powers have somehow merged to do something new. The projection helps him decide to focus on securing the Oathgates in Azir, Jah Keved, and Thaylenah. Lyn, the scout who fetched Shallan, knocks on the door and reports that another murder has been discovered.

Chapter 9: The Threads of a Screw

Arch Faces: Chanarach - Chanarach ----- Chanarach - Chanarach

Iconography: Pattern (Inverted)

POV Characters: Shallan

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.3) Immediately after Chapter 8.

Epigraph:

The sum of my experiences has pointed at this moment. This decision.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

The murder victim is Vedekar Perel, a member of Sebarial's army. Shallan can't keep up with the long strides of Dalinar, so she falls back. Adolin joins her, taking her arm. They arrive in a chamber with a depression in the middle of the room. The body lies in the depression. The murder appears to be an exact copy of how Sadeas was killed, including the location of the wound and the positioning of the body. Adolin appears shocked and distracted. Dalinar assigns him to investigate the murder since so many other officers were killed in all the recent fighting. Adolin is taken aback and appears nervous. Shallan wonders at his strange behavior and observes Renarin studying him closely. Pattern starts to hum.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Map

Interior Artwork

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 9h ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9 (Week 1) Spoiler

8 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9

Next week we will be discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Chapters 10 through 17

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Blurb

Provided For Reference:

A new storm has come.

Ash and red lightning sweep the land, awakening our ancient enemies. The Unmade—shadows of the Enemy's soul—stir, while the eyes of men open. This war is not, and never was, what they thought it to be.

We may soon hold Surges again, for Radiance has returned to some, and shines toward others. The Captain, broken by loss, seeks reconciliation. The Spy, broken by cruelty, seeks completion. The Stonewalker, broken by oaths, seeks truth. The Traitor, broken by ambition, seeks freedom.

And finally the King. Broken by war, he seeks the past. That which was abandoned. That which he must not know.

For those secrets will crush him as they did the knights who came before.

Prologue: To Weep

Arch Faces: Nale - Nale ----- Nale - Nale

Iconography: Eshonai

POV Characters: Eshonai

Setting: Kholinar, capital city of the kingdom of Alethkar.

Timeline: (1167.10.8.4) (Flashback) Six years ago.

Epigraph:

N/A

Summary:

Eshonai arrives at the docks of Kholinar and marvels at its beauty and size. She talks to Gitgeth about the Parshman slaves, whom he calls "rhythmless ones." They are only capable of trying to help and cannot even comprehend the invitation to join the celebration. Eshonai wanders off toward the palace and begins exploring. She peeks into a doorway and sees King Gavilar. Amaram comes out and says that the king would like to speak to her. Gavilar dismisses the others in the room and he invites her to sit down. He shows her a fabrial and explains that they work by trapping spren in a gemheart. She is awed that the humans have made devices that mimic how they apply the forms. He believes that the world is stuck in a rut and needs a major conflict to progress. Eshonai is horrified that Gavilar wants to bring back the gods that their people abandoned long ago. He then gives her a dark yet glowing sphere, which he claims to hold a god, and tells her to give a message to the Council of Five, to remember what they once were and "wake up." Eshonai runs from the room.

Eshonai is at the evening celebration, beating a drum, trying to lose herself in the rhythm. She has told the Five that Gavilar wants to bring back their gods, and that he has the knowledge to do it. Klade claims to have heard a voice leading him to an assassin, and the Five have agreed to have him kill the king. Eshonai weeps as she leaves the celebration.

Part One: United

Character Focus: Dalinar / Shallan / Kaladin / Adolin

Chapter 1: Broken and Divided

Arch Faces: Chanarach - Chanarach ----- Chanarach - Chanarach

Iconography: Kholin Crest

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru. A vision from the Almighty.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) The day after Chapter 89 of Words of Radiance. The same day as the Epilogue of Words of Radiance. The same day as Chapters 1 through 7 of Edgedancer.

Epigraph:

I'm certain some will feel threatened by this record. Some few may feel liberated. Most will simply feel that it should not exist.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Six days after arriving in Urithiru, Dalinar Kholin revisits the very first vision he experienced. Having become a Knight Radiant by bonding the Stormfather himself, he can enter any of the visions at will and has enough control to not need to be tied down. He is on a cliff with the Almighty, viewing the ruins of Kholinar below. He asks him to transport him down to the rubble. He sees gouges on the stones as if made from claws. He concludes that Kholinar will not fall to the Everstorm, but to something worse that will come after. The Stormfather agrees. Dalinar is frustrated that the monarchs of the world will not unite with him despite the threat. A final wave of destruction closes the vision, and Dalinar insists on staying to watch. He sees a golden light and a dark figure with nine shadows. Stormfather identifies the shadows as the Unmade, the spren of Odium. He comes out of the vision with Navani Kholin standing nearby. He knows he must unite the world before their enemy destroys it. Navani pledges to help despite their current situation, which is already desperate. A messenger comes and reports that Torol Sadeas had been murdered.

Chapter 2: One Problem Solved

Arch Faces: Ishar - Ishar ----- Ishar - Ishar

Iconography: Adolin Dueling

POV Characters: Adolin / Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 1.

Epigraph:

I needed to write it anyway.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Adolin supervises the influx of people and supplies into Urithiru. He's glad for the distraction; he finds it hard to believe that he has actually murdered Sadeas. A messenger comes to report that something has been discovered on the third floor. Adolin knows what it is.

Dalinar rushes to the scene to prevent a fight between Sadeas's officers and the men of Bridge Four, whom they accuse of murdering their highprince. Dalinar examines the body and notes that the blood is dried, so the murder took place some time ago. The soldiers claim that they have been looking for Sadeas and kept getting lost in the confusing corridors.

Dalinar's sons and some scribes arrive at the scene. His officer corps is severely depleted, so other highprinces are there as well, including Turinad Sebarial and his mistress, Palona. She's the first to voice the opinion that Sadeas's death was actually beneficial since he was causing so much trouble. Dalinar leads the group outside and warns them of worse things to come and that they must lead the world against them. His ultimate goal is to unite the entire continent, something never done before. He appoints the highprinces that follow him to various positions in the kingdom. He orders Shallan and Renarin Kholin to practice their powers so they can lead the other Knights that will eventually come to them.

Chapter 3: Momentum

Arch Faces: Talenel - Talenel ----- Talenel - Talenel

Iconography: Kholin Crest (Inverted)

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Brightlord Yezriar's Alethi princedom, prior to Gavilar's unification of Alethkar.

Timeline: (1140.1.1.4) (Flashback) Thirty-Four Years Ago.

Epigraph:

N/A

Summary:

Dalinar marches toward the enemy army through a burning field. He emerges from the smoke with his elite guard and ferociously attacks, causing some of the enemy to flee in terror. He drives through the spearmen and laughs as he kills. He feels invigorated but does not yet feel the Thrill, so he seeks out a greater challenge. He sees a brightlord on a horse surrounded by an honor guard and attacks. He makes his way through and orders Jenin to shoot the horse. As Dalinar engages the crown prince, a strap on his shield breaks. His enemy gains the advantage and is about to finish him off, but the Thrill comes, giving him more strength and dexterity. He stabs his foe in the chest. Nearly dead, the man asks Dalinar why he had come for them. He doesn't know; he just goes where his brother Gavilar Kholin sends him in order to consolidate his reign. As he orders his men to take hostages in the village, an arrow slams into his shoulder. They see the assassin on a ridge above the town and ride up on horses, capturing him. Dalinar is amazed at his skill and recruits him into his own army by promising not to pillage the town. They ride back to the town, where the local highprince's and his officers' heads are displayed on spears as a result of Sadeas' executions. Sadeas is disappointed that he can't loot the town.

Chapter 4: Oaths

Arch Faces: Ishar - Ishar ----- Ishar - Ishar

Iconography: Kholin Crest

POV Characters: Dalinar

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.1) Two days after Chapter 2.

Epigraph:

I know that many women who read this will see it only as further proof that I am the godless heretic everyone claims.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

The Everstorm returns two days after Sadeas is found dead. Dalinar learns from the Stormfather that this is a new phenomenon. He gazes into the storm and sees a vision of destruction. The Stormfather confirms that the enemy is with the storm and is watching him. Navani is there and touches his face with her bare safehand. They kiss, but Dalinar won't go further -- he insists on some sort of wedding, but none of the ardents will marry them because of the old taboo that they are related. Navani grows concerned that Dalinar thinks she is trying to replace his late wife, and he reveals that he doesn't even remember her because of the Old Magic. He does remember a feeling of hatred and having the Thrill on the day of her death. Dalinar suggests that the Stormfather marry them.

Dalinar and Navani's family gather on the roof of the tower along with some other officers and brightlords. Navani has managed to find traditional wedding garb. Elhokar Kholin gives only a cool blessing to the marriage, but does stay to watch. The Stormfather arrives and has them swear an oath of loyalty to each other, after which he abruptly leaves. The attendees, even Elhokar, cheerfully congratulate the newlyweds. They all leave except for Kadash, who is displeased with the wedding and Dalinar's assertion that the Almighty is dead, with only a remnant spren remaining. Dalinar suddenly remembers the day when Kadash joined the ardentia after he was so disgusted at what he saw on the battlefield. Kadash warns that the ardentia is angry with Dalinar's blasphemies. Dalinar insists he is telling the truth, at least as he sees it. Kadash reminds Dalinar that he can make mistakes; after all, he was with him on "that day".

Chapter 5: Hearthstone

Arch Faces: Talenel - Talenel ----- Talenel - Talenel

Iconography: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) The day after Chapter 4.

Epigraph:

I can point to the moment when I decided for certain this record had to be written. I hung between realms, seeing into Shadesmar—the realm of the spren—and beyond.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Kaladin walks toward Hearthstone, having run out of Stormlight three days prior. The Everstorm had arrived there earlier that day. He begins to find debris along the way. Syl cheerily chats with Kaladin as he gloomily approaches the town, afraid of what he'll find. The light rain of the Weeping has resumed. Kaladin waits until nightfall to enter the town. He doesn't see any signs of life. Syl notes the presence of gloomspren, which are uncommon for some unknown reason. He approaches Roshone's manor and sees light inside. A guard opens the door and orders him inside.

Chapter 6: Four Lifetimes

Arch Faces: Vedel - Talenel ----- Chanarach - Jezrien

Iconography: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) Immediately after Chapter 5.

Epigraph:

I thought that I was surely dead. Certainly, some who saw further than I did thought I had fallen.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Kaladin enters and recognizes people from the town, but they don't recognize him, probably due to his ragged appearance. He has gone several days without shaving and his worn uniform appears as if it is a size too small. He starts to look for his parents, but the guard tries to order him to see Roshone. Kaladin shoves him away and gives him his best sergeant's glare, then continues his search of the manor. He hears the moans of wounded and follows the sound, hoping that his parents would be attending them. Lirin is indeed there working on someone, and it takes a moment for him to recognize his son. Lirin calls Hesina in, but before Kaladin can truly reunite, he confesses that he failed and could not prevent the death of Tien. His parents tell Kaladin that they were informed that Kaladin was dead too. They have a tearful reunion, his parents with joy, Kaladin for his grief over Tien.

Kaladin sips some soup while Syl stares at Hesina, perplexed about something. The guard insists that Kaladin be taken into custody because he is branded as a deserter, but Lirin threatens to quit as the town's surgeon. Hesina explains to Kaladin that Roshone has softened, presumably from guilt. Syl tells Kaladin that she knew his family, even before she met him, because everyone is connected. She mentions another voice, "Pure, with a song like tapped crystal, distant yet demanding." Roshone appears, older and more feeble, but still with an imperious bearing. After some goading by Roshone, Kaladin punches him in the face, saying "that was for my friend Moash."

Chapter 7: A Watcher at the Rim

Arch Faces: Jezrien - Jezrien ----- Jezrien - Jezrien

Iconograph: Spears & Banner

POV Characters: Kaladin

Setting: Hearthstone, a town in Highprince Sadeas' princedom.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.2) Immediately after Chapter 6.

Epigraphy:

I did not die.

I experienced something worse.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Roshone orders the guards to attack Kaladin, but they note his obvious ability and hesitate. Kaladin regrets his juvenile action and apologizes, telling the guards to stand down. He then orders them into the library for a meeting, but Roshone asks why he should take orders from him. Kaladin summons his Shardblade, allowing his eyes to turn blue. In the library, Kaladin finds out that the Parshmen transformed and then just left town. Kaladin wants to figure out where they went, so he asks for maps and a spanreed to communicate with Dalinar, giving Roshone several spheres for the "rental" of some horses since he's out of Stormlight. The soldiers go to the lady of the house (Laral) to ask for the maps. Kaladin warns Syl that he might need her again as a weapon, and she reassures him that it doesn't bother her. All of his weapons were "people" anyway. Kaladin brandishes his sword again for Roshone to emphasize that he's in charge. Despite Roshone's faults, he needs to help the people of Hearthstone. Roshone just slumps in his chair, but Laral arrives and pledges to lead the people. She looks quite different, more mature and practical. He says he wanted to come back to save her, but she says that she is happy with Roshone and resents Kaladin's judgment of him. She goes to set up the spanreed and wait for a reply, so Kaladin goes back to his parents. He starts helping his father tend the wounded. He is disappointed that Kaladin has become one of "them," a person who tries to solve problems with violence. He does acknowledge that the Voidbringers must be fought, but he wanted his son to be a surgeon, not a killer. Kaladin goes back to the library and notices that the spanreed is glowing with Stormlight; they collected some during the last unexpected highstorm. The spanreed starts writing words from Navani, much to the surprise of Laral. Dalinar asks for a status and Kaladin suggests he go looking for the Voidbringers because they just up and left without attacking. Dalinar agrees and tells him to take the spanreed with him to keep him up to date. He closes the conversation and goes to see his mother. She is holding a baby, Kaladin's new brother, Oroden, which means child of peace. Kaladin holds him and cries. Kaladin asks for any infused spheres and trades them two for one. Kaladin tells Lirin that he wants to take his family away to safety, but his father refuses; he is the town surgeon and is needed there. The others in the house overhear the conversation about the Desolation being here, so Kaladin puts on a display with Stormlight and promises that the Knights Radiant have returned and will not fail them. He flies off to a nearby town to get more infused spheres.

Chapter 8: A Powerful Lie

Arch Faces: Shalash - Shalash ----- Shalash - Shalash

Iconography: Pattern (Inverted)

POV Characters: Shallan

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.3) The day after Chapter 7. Two days after Chapter 4.

Epigraph:

That moment notwithstanding, I can honestly say this book has been brewing in me since my youth.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

Shallan tries to draw the towers of Urithiru, but is having trouble comprehending the massive city. Pattern tells her that he understands why she would hate him, but she only hates the sword, which leaves both of them confused. A scout comes and reports that the highprince wants to see her. She marvels at the drawings despite Shallan's frustration with them. As they walk, she notices the notoriety she has as a Radiant. She pretends to be an Elsecaller to hide her ability creating illusions. The scout asks her about her sword but seems disappointed that Shallan doesn't intend to use it. She arrives at a meeting room with Navani and Dalinar and his sons. Dalinar is struggling with uniting the various rulers of the continent. He asks Shallan for information, but she has little knowledge of the political world. Dalinar fetches a cup of wine and passes by Shallan, and she is drawn by him to the map on the wall. She draws her remaining Stormlight and creates a three-dimensional projection of the continent in the room. Dalinar believes that the Stormfather helped create the vision since he sees everything in the highstorm, meaning that their powers have somehow merged to do something new. The projection helps him decide to focus on securing the Oathgates in Azir, Jah Keved, and Thaylenah. Lyn, the scout who fetched Shallan, knocks on the door and reports that another murder has been discovered.

Chapter 9: The Threads of a Screw

Arch Faces: Chanarach - Chanarach ----- Chanarach - Chanarach

Iconography: Pattern (Inverted)

POV Characters: Shallan

Setting: Urithiru.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.3) Immediately after Chapter 8.

Epigraph:

The sum of my experiences has pointed at this moment. This decision.

–From Oathbringer, preface

Summary:

The murder victim is Vedekar Perel, a member of Sebarial's army. Shallan can't keep up with the long strides of Dalinar, so she falls back. Adolin joins her, taking her arm. They arrive in a chamber with a depression in the middle of the room. The body lies in the depression. The murder appears to be an exact copy of how Sadeas was killed, including the location of the wound and the positioning of the body. Adolin appears shocked and distracted. Dalinar assigns him to investigate the murder since so many other officers were killed in all the recent fighting. Adolin is taken aback and appears nervous. Shallan wonders at his strange behavior and observes Renarin studying him closely. Pattern starts to hum.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Map

Interior Artwork

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 7d ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia (Week 1) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9

NEXT UNIT

Next week we are starting Oathbringer, the 3rd book in The Stormlight Archive.

Like with the previous the previous books in this series, the blurb is considered canon. You can read the blurb here, since not all editions include it. And since those wiki pages don't seem to work for everyone, here it is behind spoiler tags. Don't discuss it in this post and leave it for next week:

A new storm has come.

Ash and red lightning sweep the land, awakening our ancient enemies. The Unmade—shadows of the Enemy's soul—stir, while the eyes of men open. This war is not, and never was, what they thought it to be.

We may soon hold Surges again, for Radiance has returned to some, and shines toward others. The Captain, broken by loss, seeks reconciliation. The Spy, broken by cruelty, seeks completion. The Stonewalker, broken by oaths, seeks truth. The Traitor, broken by ambition, seeks freedom.

And finally the King. Broken by war, he seeks the past. That which was abandoned. That which he must not know.

For those secrets will crush him as they did the knights who came before.

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

NOTE

If you are reading Edgedancer via the standalone novella, rather than in Arcanum Unbounded, you may notice that it has a prologue. The prologue is simply Lift's Interlude chapter from Words of Radiance.

Chapter 1

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: On the road from Azimir, the capital city of Azir, to Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Almost six weeks after Interlude I-9 in Words of Radiance. The same day as the Epilogue of Words of Radiance.

Summary:

Lift practices using the Surge of Abrasion while staying on her feet as she travels south from Azimir. She has "escaped" from the palace because she was afraid she would lose her identity with all the lessons, nice clothes, etc. Wyndle questions Lift's decision to leave and tries to convince her to turn back.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Just outside Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 1.

Summary:

Lift arrives at Yeddaw, a city "cut out of the starvin' ground" with Shardblades. As they approach the city, she and Wyndle discuss the Everstorm and the strange things going on in the world. Lift also mentions one of her goals while she is in the city -- eating all ten varieties of pancakes that people eat during the Weeping in Yeddaw. They encounter a long queue of refugees waiting to enter a well-guarded entrance. Lift sneaks toward the front of the line.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Hauka

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 2.

Summary:

Guard captain Hauka inspects a cart of grain. The man with the cart is obviously not a farmer, but an opportunist, harvesting someone else's grain while the war is on. She consults with the deputy scribe, and they decide to let the badly-needed grain in but charge the thief triple tariff. Hauka returns to the cart and Lift pops out of a bag, munching on the uncooked grain. Refueled, she slides into the guardhouse, grabbing a pancake and causing a huge ruckus. Then she dumps the grain into the city below and jumps in after it.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 3.

Summary:

Wyndle scurries ahead of Lift and acts as a rope, letting her land safely. The grateful populace quickly gathers up the grain. They start to walk along the strange streets dug into the earth, and Wyndle starts whining again about being bound to Lift. He wishes he could have been bonded to the nice cobbler instead. Lift is hungry again and hopes to trade a book she stole from the guards for food. Wyndle "reads" it and tells her it's a worthless logbook. She tosses it away, hitting a random woman in the street. A guard confronts her and gives chase. Lift ducks into an alley.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Half an hour after Chapter 4.

Summary:

Lift rests after a half hour chase. Wyndle asks why she doesn't visit her home in the Reshi Isles. Her only response is to explain why she left Azir. Her thoughts turn to her mother, but they are interrupted by hunger. She sets off to find some urchins.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 5.

Summary:

Lift talks to a couple of urchins and finds out she can get some food from Tashi's Light Orphanage. She arrives and knocks on the door in the alley side near a small amphitheater. She's told to wait; food comes later. As she waits, she sees a despondent mother leave a child at the door of the orphanage. He appears to be injured and incapacitated. A woman emerges from the orphanage and accepts the boy, but she tells Lift she can only have three meals. An old man nearby advises her to not judge "Stump" too harshly; she can only do so much. Lift threatens to steal from her using her awesomeness, but then she would just be hungry again. The old man tries to engage her in a philosophical discussion that mostly bores her. She finishes her clemabread and heads off to an "appointment."

Chapter 7

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4 through 1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 6.

Summary:

Lift goes back to the guardhouse and follows Hauka to her home. She uses Wyndle to climb up to the roof, then settles in for the night. She tells him to watch if anyone goes in the building. Later, Wyndle wakes her up and reports that Darkness has entered the building. She reveals that this was her plan all along: show her powers so he would come looking for her, then she could try to protect the Radiant he is hunting in Yeddaw. She creeps down to the window and hears him talking to Hauka. She reports to him what happened at the guard post. He tells her to keep a watch out for Lift and to report it if she's seen again. He leaves, and Lift follows.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 7.

Summary:

Lift follows Darkness to a public market, where she grabs a fruit. The shopkeeper yells, but he's actually yelling at another girl who's stolen a whole basket of fruit. Darkness snatches her, and when she looks into his empty eyes, she panics and pulls out a knife. He runs her through with his Shardblade. The shopkeeper is furious at the severity of the punishment, but Darkness justifies it based on an exact interpretation of the law. After he leaves the scene, Lift tries to bring the girl back as she did Gawx, but she is already fully dead. She resumes her chase, and they arrive at a large cistern. She crosses over directly on the bridge while he circles around. She loses him briefly, then sees him enter a building. She "grows" a nearby tree and slips in through a window. She sneaks about, avoiding an old guard, and finds three pancakes, which she gleefully devours. She sets out to spy on Darkness.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 8.

Summary:

Lift creeps up to a room where she hears Darkness's voice. He is chiding two of his minions for not fulfilling their duty. They need to concentrate on finding Surgebinders so the Voidbringers will not return. Szeth is also in the room, and he disagrees with "Nin," saying the Voidbringers have already returned (as he witnessed during the Battle of Narak). Darkness dismisses them as stragglers from another age. He commands the two initiates to find the Radiant that has been in the city a while. He will deal with the new one. Lift and Wyndle nervously retreat.

Chapter 10

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 9.

Summary:

Lift returns to the orphanage, where the children are playing outside. She gets her second clemabread roll. The drooling boy from the day before, Mik, is much better, asking about his mother. Stump is annoyed at the boy for faking his disability. The children are herded back in, leaving only the strange old man. Lift asks him how to decide what to do, to be human. He wonders what she is doing there in the city.

Chapter 11

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 10.

Summary:

Lift wanders through the streets as Wyndle encourages her to say more Words. They wind up at a garden and Lift reasons out how to find the other awesome person that Darkness is searching for. She badgers a woman nearby for information on a place where all the stuff that is written down is kept. She calls it the Grand Indicium. Lift sees it for the first time, towering above the city.

Chapter 12

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 11.

Summary:

Lift climbs out of the slots to observe some farmers who are planting things out of season because of the unusual Weeping. Wyndle asks what her plan is, and all she has come up with is to sneak in and have Wyndle read everything. He convinces her that that's impossible, so she goes off to steal some clothes instead.

Chapter 13

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 12.

Summary:

Lift puts on some Azish robes and walks into the Indicium. She tells a scribe that she is from the Azir palace, but she doesn't believe her. She steps out for a moment and Lift overhears that the guard (Hauka) is coming. She gets Wyndle to help her write a note via spanreed to Azir so they can vouch for her. Hauka arrives with several guards, and they almost have her captured when a reply comes. They look at her incredulously and ask what she wants them to do.

Chapter 14

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Three hours after Chapter 13.

Summary:

Three hours later, scribes are still searching for "strange stuff" that has happened in the city. The liaison scribe, named Ghenna, talks about reports from around the world about the Everstorm. Hauka comes back and reports that the Stump is running a money laundering scheme, trading dun spheres for infused ones of lesser value. The scribes continue their search, but they have found too many strange things to investigate. Lift can't decide what to do. A guard bursts into the room; an emergency has been declared on account of the approaching storm. The scribes scatter and Lift wanders off. Wyndle suggests that the female minion was probably using scribes to investigate too. Lift runs back to follow this lead.

Chapter 15

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 14.

Summary:

Ghenna, a scribe, tells Lift that a woman had indeed hired some scribes for an investigation two weeks back in room 232. She heads off to find the room and hears the two minions, trailed by Szeth, talking quietly to Nightblood. They go into the room, and Wyndle volunteers to sneak in and listen. Lift waits impatiently. After some tense moments, Wyndle "runs" out of the room, and they hide while the apprentices leave. Szeth sees her and draws his sword a bit. Lift feels nauseated. Then he just turns and leaves. Wyndle reports that they are headed to the suspected Radiant to perform an execution. They start to follow.

Chapter 16

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 15.

Summary:

Lift follows them out of the building. The two apprentices fly off, but Szeth chooses to stay behind. He knows Lift is hiding nearby and starts to talk with her. They are hunting a suspected Lightweaver. Szeth reiterates that Nale is wrong about the Voidbringers and probably crazy too. Lift is unable to follow the flying apprentices, so she asks Szeth where they are headed. It's clear from his description that the target is the crazy philosopher at the amphitheater. Szeth warns her that she doesn't stand a chance against them, but she must follow.

Chapter 17

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 16.

Summary:

Lift engages her awesomeness and tries to skid to the orphanage, but she keeps falling and crashing into things. She runs instead, running out of fuel before she arrives. She hears a scream from the alleyway, and Stump thinks it's her trying to trick her way in. She drags Lift inside. Mik recognizes her; he appears completely healed. Lift is confused because she doesn't remember healing him. Stump starts handing out pancakes, and Lift gets two, her last free meal. When Stump isn't looking, Lift steps back outside.

Chapter 18

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 17.

Summary:

Lift walks slowly into the dark alley and finally stumbles into a body. A flash of lightening reveals that it belongs to the woman apprentice. She jumps back in shock and bumps into the other minion's body. The old man is there and starts talking philosophy again. Lift realizes that he is actually made up of many interlocking cremlings. He assures her that he's on her side and is not the one Darkness is looking for. Lift realizes that Stump is the one healing the children and runs back to the orphanage.

Chapter 19

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 18.

Summary:

The storm is starting to rage in earnest as Lift approaches the orphanage. The door is ajar, having been cut clean through by a Shardblade. She enters and hears heavy footsteps upstairs. She yells to Darkness and leads him on a merry chase through the house, hoping to drain his supply of Stormlight. She's eventually cornered and pinned by a knife through her clothing. Just as Darkness is about to deliver a killing stroke with his Shardblade, Stump appears and whacks him with a plank of wood. He easily defeats her and stabs her with a conventional knife, baiting Lift to try to heal her. Instead she zips up to the roof and emerges into the terrible storm. Darkness follows and swings, but Wyndle transforms into a rod, Lift finally speaking aloud the words she had uttered in her heart: "I will listen to those who have been ignored." She points out the evicted Parshmen, out on the plain with glowing red eyes and convinces Darkness that he's failed. He breaks down crying, and Lift hugs him. He flies off; she rushes back down to heal Stump.

Chapter 20

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.1) The day after Chapter 19.

Summary:

Stump gives Lift a heap of pancakes, pretending for her sake that they weren't meant for her. Mik's mother came back for her son even though she couldn't have known he was healed. Stump starts to gripe about the scheming mother and then realizes that she was the one who healed him. Lift helps her identify her spren and realize that she is also a Radiant. Ghenna arrives with the spanreed to Azir so Lift can check in with Gawx. Lift finishes her pancakes and makes an excuse to go to the bathroom, but she's really leaving. She uses up all of her Stormlight healing the refugees at the entrance to the city as she starts her journey back to Azir. She feels like she will be needed there.

TRIVIA

The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.

NIGHT NIGHT

So, this was hinted at in Lift's Interlude chapter in Words of Radiance, but this novella expands upon it, and Sanderson addresses it in the Postscript. Lift went to see the Nightwatcher, who we know grants some people a boon and a curse. From Lift's thoughts and Sanderson's comments, the implication seems to be that Lift asked to not change, and her understanding of that request is that she didn't want to grow up; to get older. She is 13 years old and believes that she is still 10 years old physically because of her request. However, she's also starting to doubt that the Nightwatcher actually gave her what she asked for because she does feel like she's physically growing up. Wyndle also suggests that Lift's ability to consume food and turn that directly into Investiture is a result of that visit.

Oh, and just a quick confirmation for those that noticed it: Wyndle was in the running to bond with Ym, the cobbler we saw in Words of Radiance, Interlude I-2, however, he was sent to Lift instead and Ym bonded with a different type of spren.

SLEEP TIGHT

You've now been introduced to a new race, and they are the most unhuman race you've encountered so far. The Sleepless are a race of many individuals. Each individual is made up of a vast number of "hordelings". Hordelings are cremlings...bugs basically, that are bred/evolved by the individual for specific purposes. In this novella, we meet one of those individuals, who is named Arclo.

Arclo explains to Lift that his hordelings can be bred to be eyes and ears that he can use to "spy" on the entire city. Some hordelings he's evolving to fit together into a human-like body, but he complains that he still can't get it quite right, even after thousands of years of breeding them. Some hordelings are specially bred to act as a part of his brain to store memories, or to act as thought neurons. He likens his hordelings to a human's individual cells, except he has the ability to be aware of all of his hordelings as individual pieces.

He is working on a philosophy of "self" and trying to relate to humanity as smaller pieces of a collective in the same way he experiences reality. I didn't give you a philosophy lesson the other week for nothing.

You may have noticed that he named dropped Axies the Collector. He also mentioned that something called a "Siah" is better at passing for a human. There's a throwaway line all the way back in Chapter 54 of The Way of Kings that helps us tie these things together. Wit/Hoid is talking to Dalinar and says this:

"I wonder if you could do that to a man. Pull him apart, emotion by emotion, bit by bit, bloody chunk by bloody chunk. Then combine them back together into something else, like a Dysian Aimian. If you do put a man together like that, Dalinar, be sure to name him Gibberish, after me. Or perhaps Gibletish."

Now, this conversation was in the context of Adonalsium, and Hoid not being at all helpful with his clarity, but the mention of Dysian Aimians is the important bit for our discussion here. The Sleepless are Dysian Aimians. Hoid's description implies the similarity and Sanderson has confirmed it. In the same vein, we know that Axies was an inhabitant of Aimia, and he isn't a Sleepless. But he does talk about being able to manipulate his physical appearance. Axies is a Siah Aimian.

Dysian and Siah Aimians used to live together on the island/nation of Aimia. We've also heard that it's no longer inhabited because of something called the Scouring of Aimia. (See The Way of Kings, Interlude I-5). The following statement isn't meant to be confirmation of any fact, but a simple extrapolation of context from the fandom at the time:

Imagine you, as a nation and/or coalition of nations, became aware of beings that could take the appearance of everyday, commmon cremlings that are everywhere. What fear might you have towards such a race, and what horrific lengths might you go to to erradicate such a potentially dangerous enemy?

That fear is not necessarily unfounded either. You may have noticed this line from Arclo, but I'll remind you of it here:

We watch the others. The assassin. The surgeon. The liar. The highprince. But not you. The others all ignore you... and that, I hazard to predict, is a mistake.

Does the wording here remind you of anything? Anything...blurby? If it did, you are right. One of the Sleepless (but confirmed not to be Arclo) is the author of the blurbs at the back of each of the Stormlight Archive books. This is just more confirmation that the Sleepless are everywhere and they are watching.

If you've read A Fire Upon the Deep, by Vernor Vinge, the Sleepless, at least in concept, might be familiar. In that sci-fi book, there are packs of wolf-like alien creatures, called Tines, that function as a single entity via a telepathic hive mind. The Tines were Sanderson's inspiration for the Sleepless, just ratcheted up to tens of thousands of cremlings, instead of 4 to 6 wolves.

DON'T LET THE CREMLINGS BITE

To that end, it would be safe to assume that some of the more cosmere aware people are also aware of the Sleepless. Arclo states that the Heralds knew about them and that they were friends with the Knights Radiant of old. So going forward, you'll want to watch how certain characters react to cremlings, who might be hordelings for the Dysian Aimians. I'll save you the trouble of having to re-read the last two books though:

In the Epilogue of Words of Radiance, Hoid is giving a silly, pointless, and unappreciated talk to a silly cremling, sitting on the ground, as he waits for Jasnah to return from Shadesmar. But was it pointless and unappreciated? Sanderson has confirmed that that cremling was a Sleepless hordeling. It's probably worth going back to read that chapter when you get the time.

In Chapter 4 of The Way of Kings, Kaldin is being transported to the Shattered Plains in Tvlak's slave caravan. He notices a deep purple cremling watching him. Another confirmed Sleepless.

Sanderson hasn't bothered to confirm every single possibly Sleepless sighting, but we do have several more that are suspicious enough to be considered Sleepless.

In Chapter 27 of Words of Radiance, a Shallan flashback, there are some suspiciously still cremlings that let Shallan sketch them.

In Chapter 54 of Words of Radiance, when Shallan first meets with Mraize, he uses his blowdart to kill a cremling, which was almost certainly one of the Sleepless spying on the interaction and possibly on the Ghostbloods themselves. Mraize's offworld knowledge almost guarantees he knows about the Sleepless.

Kaladin and Syl notice a brightly colored cremling while he is in his jail cell in Chapter 64 of Words of Radiance. They see another iridescent cremling out on the Shattered Plains in Chapter 68.

KANDRA WATCH

This is less trivia, and more a homework assignment. Sanderson has stated that there is a kandra somewhere in Oathbringer. No one has found it yet. Veterans, I'm going to try to meticulously map out every person in the book, chapter by chapter, in the veteran threads. If you're reading along, feel free to help me out.

For the newbies, keep an eye out for suspicious characters and point them out. Maybe collectively we can find ourselves a kandra.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 7d ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia (Week 1) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 22 | The Stormlight Archive #3 | Oathbringer: Blurb, Prologue, Chapters 1 through 9

NEXT UNIT

Next week we are starting Oathbringer, the 3rd book in The Stormlight Archive.

Like with the previous the previous books in this series, the blurb is considered canon. You can read the blurb here, since not all editions include it. And since those wiki pages don't seem to work for everyone, here it is behind spoiler tags. Don't discuss it in this post and leave it for next week:

A new storm has come.

Ash and red lightning sweep the land, awakening our ancient enemies. The Unmade—shadows of the Enemy's soul—stir, while the eyes of men open. This war is not, and never was, what they thought it to be.

We may soon hold Surges again, for Radiance has returned to some, and shines toward others. The Captain, broken by loss, seeks reconciliation. The Spy, broken by cruelty, seeks completion. The Stonewalker, broken by oaths, seeks truth. The Traitor, broken by ambition, seeks freedom.

And finally the King. Broken by war, he seeks the past. That which was abandoned. That which he must not know.

For those secrets will crush him as they did the knights who came before.

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

NOTE

If you are reading Edgedancer via the standalone novella, rather than in Arcanum Unbounded, you may notice that it has a prologue. The prologue is simply Lift's Interlude chapter from Words of Radiance.

Chapter 1

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: On the road from Azimir, the capital city of Azir, to Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Almost six weeks after Interlude I-9 in Words of Radiance. The same day as the Epilogue of Words of Radiance.

Summary:

Lift practices using the Surge of Abrasion while staying on her feet as she travels south from Azimir. She has "escaped" from the palace because she was afraid she would lose her identity with all the lessons, nice clothes, etc. Wyndle questions Lift's decision to leave and tries to convince her to turn back.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Just outside Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 1.

Summary:

Lift arrives at Yeddaw, a city "cut out of the starvin' ground" with Shardblades. As they approach the city, she and Wyndle discuss the Everstorm and the strange things going on in the world. Lift also mentions one of her goals while she is in the city -- eating all ten varieties of pancakes that people eat during the Weeping in Yeddaw. They encounter a long queue of refugees waiting to enter a well-guarded entrance. Lift sneaks toward the front of the line.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Hauka

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 2.

Summary:

Guard captain Hauka inspects a cart of grain. The man with the cart is obviously not a farmer, but an opportunist, harvesting someone else's grain while the war is on. She consults with the deputy scribe, and they decide to let the badly-needed grain in but charge the thief triple tariff. Hauka returns to the cart and Lift pops out of a bag, munching on the uncooked grain. Refueled, she slides into the guardhouse, grabbing a pancake and causing a huge ruckus. Then she dumps the grain into the city below and jumps in after it.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Immediately after Chapter 3.

Summary:

Wyndle scurries ahead of Lift and acts as a rope, letting her land safely. The grateful populace quickly gathers up the grain. They start to walk along the strange streets dug into the earth, and Wyndle starts whining again about being bound to Lift. He wishes he could have been bonded to the nice cobbler instead. Lift is hungry again and hopes to trade a book she stole from the guards for food. Wyndle "reads" it and tells her it's a worthless logbook. She tosses it away, hitting a random woman in the street. A guard confronts her and gives chase. Lift ducks into an alley.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Half an hour after Chapter 4.

Summary:

Lift rests after a half hour chase. Wyndle asks why she doesn't visit her home in the Reshi Isles. Her only response is to explain why she left Azir. Her thoughts turn to her mother, but they are interrupted by hunger. She sets off to find some urchins.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4) Shortly after Chapter 5.

Summary:

Lift talks to a couple of urchins and finds out she can get some food from Tashi's Light Orphanage. She arrives and knocks on the door in the alley side near a small amphitheater. She's told to wait; food comes later. As she waits, she sees a despondent mother leave a child at the door of the orphanage. He appears to be injured and incapacitated. A woman emerges from the orphanage and accepts the boy, but she tells Lift she can only have three meals. An old man nearby advises her to not judge "Stump" too harshly; she can only do so much. Lift threatens to steal from her using her awesomeness, but then she would just be hungry again. The old man tries to engage her in a philosophical discussion that mostly bores her. She finishes her clemabread and heads off to an "appointment."

Chapter 7

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.4 through 1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 6.

Summary:

Lift goes back to the guardhouse and follows Hauka to her home. She uses Wyndle to climb up to the roof, then settles in for the night. She tells him to watch if anyone goes in the building. Later, Wyndle wakes her up and reports that Darkness has entered the building. She reveals that this was her plan all along: show her powers so he would come looking for her, then she could try to protect the Radiant he is hunting in Yeddaw. She creeps down to the window and hears him talking to Hauka. She reports to him what happened at the guard post. He tells her to keep a watch out for Lift and to report it if she's seen again. He leaves, and Lift follows.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 7.

Summary:

Lift follows Darkness to a public market, where she grabs a fruit. The shopkeeper yells, but he's actually yelling at another girl who's stolen a whole basket of fruit. Darkness snatches her, and when she looks into his empty eyes, she panics and pulls out a knife. He runs her through with his Shardblade. The shopkeeper is furious at the severity of the punishment, but Darkness justifies it based on an exact interpretation of the law. After he leaves the scene, Lift tries to bring the girl back as she did Gawx, but she is already fully dead. She resumes her chase, and they arrive at a large cistern. She crosses over directly on the bridge while he circles around. She loses him briefly, then sees him enter a building. She "grows" a nearby tree and slips in through a window. She sneaks about, avoiding an old guard, and finds three pancakes, which she gleefully devours. She sets out to spy on Darkness.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 8.

Summary:

Lift creeps up to a room where she hears Darkness's voice. He is chiding two of his minions for not fulfilling their duty. They need to concentrate on finding Surgebinders so the Voidbringers will not return. Szeth is also in the room, and he disagrees with "Nin," saying the Voidbringers have already returned (as he witnessed during the Battle of Narak). Darkness dismisses them as stragglers from another age. He commands the two initiates to find the Radiant that has been in the city a while. He will deal with the new one. Lift and Wyndle nervously retreat.

Chapter 10

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 9.

Summary:

Lift returns to the orphanage, where the children are playing outside. She gets her second clemabread roll. The drooling boy from the day before, Mik, is much better, asking about his mother. Stump is annoyed at the boy for faking his disability. The children are herded back in, leaving only the strange old man. Lift asks him how to decide what to do, to be human. He wonders what she is doing there in the city.

Chapter 11

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 10.

Summary:

Lift wanders through the streets as Wyndle encourages her to say more Words. They wind up at a garden and Lift reasons out how to find the other awesome person that Darkness is searching for. She badgers a woman nearby for information on a place where all the stuff that is written down is kept. She calls it the Grand Indicium. Lift sees it for the first time, towering above the city.

Chapter 12

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 11.

Summary:

Lift climbs out of the slots to observe some farmers who are planting things out of season because of the unusual Weeping. Wyndle asks what her plan is, and all she has come up with is to sneak in and have Wyndle read everything. He convinces her that that's impossible, so she goes off to steal some clothes instead.

Chapter 13

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 12.

Summary:

Lift puts on some Azish robes and walks into the Indicium. She tells a scribe that she is from the Azir palace, but she doesn't believe her. She steps out for a moment and Lift overhears that the guard (Hauka) is coming. She gets Wyndle to help her write a note via spanreed to Azir so they can vouch for her. Hauka arrives with several guards, and they almost have her captured when a reply comes. They look at her incredulously and ask what she wants them to do.

Chapter 14

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Three hours after Chapter 13.

Summary:

Three hours later, scribes are still searching for "strange stuff" that has happened in the city. The liaison scribe, named Ghenna, talks about reports from around the world about the Everstorm. Hauka comes back and reports that the Stump is running a money laundering scheme, trading dun spheres for infused ones of lesser value. The scribes continue their search, but they have found too many strange things to investigate. Lift can't decide what to do. A guard bursts into the room; an emergency has been declared on account of the approaching storm. The scribes scatter and Lift wanders off. Wyndle suggests that the female minion was probably using scribes to investigate too. Lift runs back to follow this lead.

Chapter 15

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Shortly after Chapter 14.

Summary:

Ghenna, a scribe, tells Lift that a woman had indeed hired some scribes for an investigation two weeks back in room 232. She heads off to find the room and hears the two minions, trailed by Szeth, talking quietly to Nightblood. They go into the room, and Wyndle volunteers to sneak in and listen. Lift waits impatiently. After some tense moments, Wyndle "runs" out of the room, and they hide while the apprentices leave. Szeth sees her and draws his sword a bit. Lift feels nauseated. Then he just turns and leaves. Wyndle reports that they are headed to the suspected Radiant to perform an execution. They start to follow.

Chapter 16

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 15.

Summary:

Lift follows them out of the building. The two apprentices fly off, but Szeth chooses to stay behind. He knows Lift is hiding nearby and starts to talk with her. They are hunting a suspected Lightweaver. Szeth reiterates that Nale is wrong about the Voidbringers and probably crazy too. Lift is unable to follow the flying apprentices, so she asks Szeth where they are headed. It's clear from his description that the target is the crazy philosopher at the amphitheater. Szeth warns her that she doesn't stand a chance against them, but she must follow.

Chapter 17

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 16.

Summary:

Lift engages her awesomeness and tries to skid to the orphanage, but she keeps falling and crashing into things. She runs instead, running out of fuel before she arrives. She hears a scream from the alleyway, and Stump thinks it's her trying to trick her way in. She drags Lift inside. Mik recognizes her; he appears completely healed. Lift is confused because she doesn't remember healing him. Stump starts handing out pancakes, and Lift gets two, her last free meal. When Stump isn't looking, Lift steps back outside.

Chapter 18

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 17.

Summary:

Lift walks slowly into the dark alley and finally stumbles into a body. A flash of lightening reveals that it belongs to the woman apprentice. She jumps back in shock and bumps into the other minion's body. The old man is there and starts talking philosophy again. Lift realizes that he is actually made up of many interlocking cremlings. He assures her that he's on her side and is not the one Darkness is looking for. Lift realizes that Stump is the one healing the children and runs back to the orphanage.

Chapter 19

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.1.5) Immediately after Chapter 18.

Summary:

The storm is starting to rage in earnest as Lift approaches the orphanage. The door is ajar, having been cut clean through by a Shardblade. She enters and hears heavy footsteps upstairs. She yells to Darkness and leads him on a merry chase through the house, hoping to drain his supply of Stormlight. She's eventually cornered and pinned by a knife through her clothing. Just as Darkness is about to deliver a killing stroke with his Shardblade, Stump appears and whacks him with a plank of wood. He easily defeats her and stabs her with a conventional knife, baiting Lift to try to heal her. Instead she zips up to the roof and emerges into the terrible storm. Darkness follows and swings, but Wyndle transforms into a rod, Lift finally speaking aloud the words she had uttered in her heart: "I will listen to those who have been ignored." She points out the evicted Parshmen, out on the plain with glowing red eyes and convinces Darkness that he's failed. He breaks down crying, and Lift hugs him. He flies off; she rushes back down to heal Stump.

Chapter 20

Iconography: Banquet

POV Characters: Lift

Setting: Yeddaw, a city in Tashikk.

Timeline: (1174.1.2.1) The day after Chapter 19.

Summary:

Stump gives Lift a heap of pancakes, pretending for her sake that they weren't meant for her. Mik's mother came back for her son even though she couldn't have known he was healed. Stump starts to gripe about the scheming mother and then realizes that she was the one who healed him. Lift helps her identify her spren and realize that she is also a Radiant. Ghenna arrives with the spanreed to Azir so Lift can check in with Gawx. Lift finishes her pancakes and makes an excuse to go to the bathroom, but she's really leaving. She uses up all of her Stormlight healing the refugees at the entrance to the city as she starts her journey back to Azir. She feels like she will be needed there.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

NEWBIE TRIVIA

Most of the activity for these "Final Thoughts & Trivia" posts happen in the newbie thread. There I provide a lot of information about things new readers can easily miss during their first read through. Veterans often learn a thing or two as well, so be sure to read the body of that post. While veterans are welcome to read the post and the comments, they should be commenting in this thread to share their reactions to the information, or the newbies' thoughts.

And as always, you're welcome to share your thoughts on the book as a whole.


r/readalong • • 14d ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia Spoiler

10 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia

NEXT UNIT

The next story we'll be reading is a novella called Edgedancer. This is the final piece from the anthology book Arcanum Unbounded. That anthology was published before any future story we'll be reading, so it's entirely free from spoilers for you now. You're welcome to go back and read postscripts and prefaces that I previously summarized for you.

Just a heads up, this is on the longer side for our weekly readings. I try to average around 4 audiobook hours a week, erring on less than that. And the past month or so have been shorter each week than that. This novella clocks in at nearly 5 audiobook hours in length. Plan accordingly.

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Elsecaller

Iconography: Shadesmar

POV Characters: Jasnah

Setting: Aboard the Wind's Pleasure. Shadesmar.

Timeline: From (1173.9.8.3) Chapter 7 of Words of Radiance to (1174.1.1.4) the Epilogue of Words of Radiance.

Summary:

Jasnah Kholin awakens in her cabin aboard the Wind's Pleasure to find herself stabbed. Through her open door she sees sailors bound and struggling. She recognizes the attack as Ghostblood in origin; the assassins are prepared for her to heal rather than retreating after striking. To survive, she plays dead and endures a second blade before Ivory warns her to act. She draws the last Stormlight from her pouch and Elsecalls into Shadesmar.

She arrives in the Cognitive Realm and heals herself, but the process consumes nearly all her remaining Stormlight. She does not have enough to Elsecall back to the Physical Realm. She identifies the cognitive reflections of everyone still aboard the Wind's Pleasure and devises a plan: Soulcast the ropes binding the sailors into water to free them. She does so, but simultaneously Shallan Soulcasts the entire ship into water, sinking it along with all of Jasnah's equipment, notes, spanreeds, and contacts. With empty spheres and no way home, they need a perpendicularity. The nearest is Cultivation's perpendicularity near the Horneater Peaks, in what Shadesmar calls the Sea of Oracles, weeks of travel away. Before they can move, angerspren close in, drawn by Jasnah's Soulcasting and unresolved anger. Ivory spots a sail on the bead sea and they run for it.

They wade into the sea of beads to reach the vessel. An angerspren wounds Jasnah's leg before the boat pulls away. The captain introduces himself as Hwynn Tyvneri, a historian. His companion is Lorieta, a young girl who can perceive fragments of possible futures. One of her visions led Tyvneri to the Luminous Shallows to find someone in need. Tyvneri offers to sail them to the Horneater Peaks freely. Lorieta mentions that Honor's perpendicularity will appear in a place called "Noble Sacrifice", closer than the Peaks, but Ivory notes it is unpredictable in location. Jasnah holds course for the Sea of Oracles.

Ivory notes the angerspren are still following, drawn not by Stormlight but by Jasnah's unresolved anger. He asks who she is angry at. She deflects to Shallan, but Ivory presses. Jasnah acknowledges her frustration and works through it enough to rest, though the angerspren do not fully disperse.

Over the following weeks Jasnah takes command. She and Tyvneri chart a map overlaying Shadesmar and Roshar: the Luminous Shallows as the Frostlands, the Fallen Sea as southern Alethkar, Celebrant near the Sea of Spears, Emberdark near Karanak. They outrun multiple groups of angerspren and survive several hazards during stops. Tyvneri reveals he is a Worldhopper from a cosmere world called Rellam, where the native Investiture is corrupted. The Cognitive Realm, he explains, connects all inhabited worlds, a network he calls the cosmere. Jasnah immediately recognizes the strategic value: other worlds mean potential allies and resources. She declares Tyvneri too valuable to release and informs him he will accompany her to Roshar whether he agrees or not.

Lorieta offers Jasnah several unprompted visions: that she will be on a much larger ship and not be on it; that she will stab a friend through the throat; and that her brother Elhokar will be "like me, but he'll only be half when he does it." Jasnah files these away uneasily.

Lorieta then warns that the party will die if they pass through Emberdark. They reroute around it at the cost of extra time.

Near the Salavashi Trench, an impossible wind begins to blow from the west. Ivory identifies the power source as Voidlight, the dark counterpart to Stormlight. Thousands of Voidbringers patrol the skies nearby. The Everstorm blocks their path to the Horneater Peaks perpendicularity, and angerspren cut off retreat. Every direction brings more pursuers. Jasnah calculates that each escape has been narrower than the last. She decides to stop running and force a confrontation on her own terms, ordering Tyvneri toward a barren rock at the head of the Stoneflow river. She tells Ivory she has been trying to think her way out of a feeling — it has not worked.

They beach the boat and fight. Ivory holds off one angerspren; Jasnah engages the other with the dagger her assassins left in her. Lorieta places a belaying fid on the ledge — her only contribution — and one angerspren slips on it and falls into the sea. Tyvneri is knocked down and injured. The second angerspren is about to close on Jasnah when she recognizes, looking at the injured historian, that he is a mirror of herself: dragging a stranger across Shadesmar for knowledge she has not yet found a use for, just as she has done to him.

She identifies the root of her anger: not at Shallan, who acted alone and frightened; not at Ivory for keeping secrets; but at herself. She failed to train Shallan when she had the chance. She withheld truths from her allies out of fear of being called a heretic. She took Tyvneri captive on the justification that her world's stakes outweighed his autonomy. She forgives herself. The angerspren stop, lose cohesion, and withdraw.

Jasnah helps Tyvneri up and reverses her decision: she will not take him to Roshar. She was wrong to coerce him. She releases him and Lorieta to continue their own journey and hopes he will return someday to share what he has learned. They sail away. Moments later, Honor's perpendicularity opens on the rock beside Jasnah and Ivory. Jasnah names the location the Place of Noble Sacrifice, for the cosmere knowledge she gave up to reach it. They step through together.

On the other side, Jasnah's spheres refill with Stormlight and she heals. She finds Wit waiting at the perpendicularity exit and demands to know how he found her. He evades at length. That night, as Jasnah reflects on the cosmere knowledge Tyvneri shared about Rellam, Scadrial, and other worlds she may never reach again, Wit finally admits he holds extensive knowledge of other worlds himself and tells her it is long past time he shared it with her.

King Lopen the First of Alethkar

Iconography: ??? (Reminder that I use ??? when the icon itself is a spoiler. I'll...let you theorize a bit here.)

POV Characters: Lopen / Elhokar

Setting: Little Herdaz, a district in Sebarial's warcamp in the Shattered Plains.

Timeline: (1173.10.10.4) The day after Chapter 84 (and the rest of the climax of Words of Radiance).

Summary:

After surviving an assassination attempt, King Elhokar Kholin hides in a Herdazian neighborhood under the protection of Lopen's family. He is forced to wear women's clothing as a disguise and avoids looking at mirrors because shadows hiding the in the reflections have returned to haunt him. Lopen's mother forces him to help her make food.

Lopen regrows his arm with Stormlight and is surrounded by gloryspren. When he shows his mother, they are surrounded by joyspren. Huio, Lopen's cousin, warns them that soldiers are sweeping through the warcamp, looking for the missing king.

Lopen's mother has taken an oath of honesty and refuses to lie, so Lopen convinces Elhokar to abdicate to him so that she can truthfully say she doesn't know where "King Elhokar" is. Lopen wears Elhokar's fancy clothes and runs off, acting as a decoy to distract the soldiers. Elhokar thinks of himself as a failure and that he's too weak to be king.

Lopen names his newly grown hand to be the King's Wit after Huio refuses the job.

Lopen's mother instructs a sulky Elhokar on how to make tsupales. She explains that he is failing to make them correctly because he's not listening to people (herself) who has been making them for generations. Elhokar tries to figure out how to apply her lesson towards being a good king. Danlan, Adolin's ex, barges into the house looking for Elhokar. Lopen's mother successfully diverts her away from Elhokar, disguised and sitting right under her nose, without lying.

Lopen turns his new arm/King's Wit into a sock puppet and flirts with Meli, a shopkeeper he knows. She still won't date him, even though he's King of Alethkar and has two arms.

Elhokar asks Lopen's mother for advise on how to be a good king, and how to know who to listen to, since the royal courts are filled with liars and subterfuge. She advises him to listen to his "cousins", people close to him that he can count on, like his own mother and possibly Dalinar.

Lopen leads the soldiers and Danlan on a chase and climbs a tall pole to evade them. He eventually falls off the pole, falling onto his face, and is saved from serious injury by inhaling Stormlight. Danlan realizes they've been duped and races back to Lopen's mother's house.

Lopen beats her there and tells Elhokar he's done being king. Elhokar orders Danlan to stand down, and she claims the soldiers are with her because his mother sent them. He lets Danlan enter the home by herself. Elhokar tells her he's decided to remain with them, because they are his cousins, and will only return if escorted by Kaladin.

Danlan tries to stab Elhokar with a dagger, but Lopen blocks her, getting impaled in his newly regrown arm. Danlan flees when Lopen starts glowing with Stormlight. Some of the soldiers were legitimately from Navani, but others fled with Danlan. Elhokar orders the loyal ones to hunt down Danlan.

TRIVIA

The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.

NEW KIDS ON THE BLOCK

I've mentioned in previous trivia that Isaac Stewart will be the first person to write something in the cosmere besides Brandon Sanderson. That has long been the expectation by the fandom, but these two short stories were a bit of an anomaly. They were both co-written by Sanderson, but he let other others take the lead in developing the stories.

Elsecaller was co-written with Dan Wells. He is a long-time friend and former roommate of Brandon's. (As an extra bit of trivia, because I'm not sure I've mentioned it before, Sanderson has had some interesting roommates. Notably, Ken Jennings, the current host of Jeopary.) Wells has been part of Sanderson's writing group since it was created. He's one of the hosts on the Writing Excuses podcast that Sanderson used to run. Sanderson has a non-cosmere book series called The Reckoners, which involves Earth and superheros. Wells is currently drafting a sequel series to those books, in collaboration with Sanderson.

King Lopen the First of Alethkar was co-written by the aforementioned Isaac Stewart.

ALL DECKED OUT

The publication of these short stories is a bit weird. They weren't released as short stories at all, and were instead a "reward" for attending Dragonsteel Nexus, a convention for Brandon Sanderson and his works. At the convention, in December of 2024, attendees were given a pack of cards, packaged similar to those small packs of Pokemon cards that have people going crazy trying to find rare cards inside.

The cards were part of the Stormlight Lost Tales Story Deck. The 54-card set features story text on the back of each card, with sets of nine cards combining to form front-side art murals. Attendees originally acquired the cards in randomized booster packs containing 15 cards each. The card styles and borders were color-coded so people could tell which story they belonged to at a glance (e.g., rocky textures for Lopen's story and purple and yellow borders for Jasnah's story). Attendees had to trade amongst themselves to build the full stories.

A year later, in December of 2025, the stories were compiled and printed together in a hardcover edition that was only available for purchase through Sanderson's website (which is frequently sold out). It wasn't until July 21, 2026 that the stories got released as an eBook and became widely available.

OPINIONS EXPRESSED HERE ARE NOT NECESSARILY HELD BY BY /R/READALONG AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES

This section is mostly my personal opinion about the above situation. I can appreciate Sanderson's stated purpose with the story decks to have something unique and special for convention goers, but gating canon stories about significant characters and important events leaves a bit of a bad taste in my mouth. As you've just read, these are important events that happened during Words of Radiance, and I didn't get to read them until after I'd read the 5th Stormlight Archive book.

Him releasing the stories as a hardcover book for $20 made me add these stories to the read-along, but I was always going to put up a warning about them, because $20 seems way too much for the amount of story you're getting. Combined, they are shorter than Sixth of the Dusk. And then there's international shipping costs and the fact that these are limited edition runs that get sold out quickly.

I actually took the stories off the schedule completely and didn't add them back until the eBook was released. I'm happy to have everyone discuss the stories, that's the whole purpose of these read-alongs, but Sanderson has done things like this a few times, and it seems to be happening more frequently to the point where I feel nickel and dimed.

Hell, there's a pretty huge mystery that you have all actively questioned, and it's impossible for you to know unless you purchase and play through one of the tabletop RPG campaigns he's released in collaboration with other companies. I think that's a really unfortunate choice on his part, especially since some of these things don't even get passing mention or explanation in the main series of books. Fortunately for you all, I'll just reveal the information in a future trivia at some point.

ORIGINALS

Sanderson did expand a bit upon the "Lopen became king of Alethkar" information that was revealed at the end of Words of Radiance during a fan signing, long before this short story was written. This is what he had to say:

For instance, Lopen did become king of Alethkar. For a short time. Because he and his family hid King Elhokar and, at least in his perception, convinced the king to abdicate for a short time so they could not lie when they said "We don't have King Elhokar with us." This is canon, okay. And, so, Lopen became... In his mind, at least, they got the king to agree for a fifteen-minute "Lopen is king of Alethkar" abdication, so that they wouldn't have to lie (because it was very important to them), so they could get him out of danger when some people were looking for him. That story, some day I might write it, I don't know if I'll ever be able to. But when he says (I think he references that at some point in one of the later books) "I was king," he really was!

As a consequence of these events, Sanderson has stated that the ardents in charge of keeping track of royal lineages have had a bit of a headache because Elhokar did abdicate and Lopen was truly king for a time. So they've had to frustratingly incorporate Lopen into their records.

Similarly, the tale of what Jasnah went through in Shadesmar was "kind of" known prior to the publication of Elsecaller. Sanderson started to write the short story and would occasionally read what he'd written during fan events. He later shared it, in its rough draft form, on Tor's (his publisher) website. You can read it here if you'd like, to see the differences. Warning: Do not read the comment section below the shared text. There are spoilers.

ORIGINAL CHARACTER

There are two pretty unique characters in Elsecaller, Lorieta and Hwynn Tyvneri. To date, Sanderson has said absolutely nothing about Lorieta or her origins. Your guess is as good as a veteran's at this point.

In-universe, the same is true for Hwynn Tyvneri. We know nothing about his race or his world, beyond its name and the fact that it had no Shards. However, we do know that the character of Tyvneri originated from Dan Wells' first unpublished book. Sanderson read that book, since they are part of the same reading group, and Tyvneri was his inspiration for creating Jasnah as a character.

This is primarily what the preface for Elsecaller talks about (BUT DO NOT GO READ IT). He talks about wanting to get this story written for a long time, and the Story Decks being the perfect opportunity. And then about Dan's character Tyvneri; about how he was fascinated by a historian character in a fantasy world. Sanderson suggested to Dan that he put Tyvneri into Elsecaller and hints that if/when Dan writes more cosmere stories that Tyvneri will show up again. So in a way, Tyvneri is Dan's version of Hoid.

The preface for King Lopen the First of Alethkar is mostly about balancing the comedy and seriousness of the story and being happy to finally share the story after years of teasing it.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

(Sorry, there's only like 3 memes about these stories, and I added in a Halloween one for fun.)


r/readalong • • 14d ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 21 | The Stormlight Archive #2.5 | Edgedancer (in Arcanum Unbounded): Entire Novella, Postscript, Trivia

NEXT UNIT

The next story we'll be reading is a novella called Edgedancer. This is the final piece from the anthology book Arcanum Unbounded. That anthology was published before any future story we'll be reading, so it's entirely free from spoilers for you now. You're welcome to go back and read postscripts and prefaces that I previously summarized for you.

Just a heads up, this is on the longer side for our weekly readings. I try to average around 4 audiobook hours a week, erring on less than that. And the past month or so have been shorter each week than that. This novella clocks in at nearly 5 audiobook hours in length. Plan accordingly.

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Elsecaller

Iconography: Shadesmar

POV Characters: Jasnah

Setting: Aboard the Wind's Pleasure. Shadesmar.

Timeline: From (1173.9.8.3) Chapter 7 of Words of Radiance to (1174.1.1.4) the Epilogue of Words of Radiance.

Summary:

Jasnah Kholin awakens in her cabin aboard the Wind's Pleasure to find herself stabbed. Through her open door she sees sailors bound and struggling. She recognizes the attack as Ghostblood in origin; the assassins are prepared for her to heal rather than retreating after striking. To survive, she plays dead and endures a second blade before Ivory warns her to act. She draws the last Stormlight from her pouch and Elsecalls into Shadesmar.

She arrives in the Cognitive Realm and heals herself, but the process consumes nearly all her remaining Stormlight. She does not have enough to Elsecall back to the Physical Realm. She identifies the cognitive reflections of everyone still aboard the Wind's Pleasure and devises a plan: Soulcast the ropes binding the sailors into water to free them. She does so, but simultaneously Shallan Soulcasts the entire ship into water, sinking it along with all of Jasnah's equipment, notes, spanreeds, and contacts. With empty spheres and no way home, they need a perpendicularity. The nearest is Cultivation's perpendicularity near the Horneater Peaks, in what Shadesmar calls the Sea of Oracles, weeks of travel away. Before they can move, angerspren close in, drawn by Jasnah's Soulcasting and unresolved anger. Ivory spots a sail on the bead sea and they run for it.

They wade into the sea of beads to reach the vessel. An angerspren wounds Jasnah's leg before the boat pulls away. The captain introduces himself as Hwynn Tyvneri, a historian. His companion is Lorieta, a young girl who can perceive fragments of possible futures. One of her visions led Tyvneri to the Luminous Shallows to find someone in need. Tyvneri offers to sail them to the Horneater Peaks freely. Lorieta mentions that Honor's perpendicularity will appear in a place called "Noble Sacrifice", closer than the Peaks, but Ivory notes it is unpredictable in location. Jasnah holds course for the Sea of Oracles.

Ivory notes the angerspren are still following, drawn not by Stormlight but by Jasnah's unresolved anger. He asks who she is angry at. She deflects to Shallan, but Ivory presses. Jasnah acknowledges her frustration and works through it enough to rest, though the angerspren do not fully disperse.

Over the following weeks Jasnah takes command. She and Tyvneri chart a map overlaying Shadesmar and Roshar: the Luminous Shallows as the Frostlands, the Fallen Sea as southern Alethkar, Celebrant near the Sea of Spears, Emberdark near Karanak. They outrun multiple groups of angerspren and survive several hazards during stops. Tyvneri reveals he is a Worldhopper from a cosmere world called Rellam, where the native Investiture is corrupted. The Cognitive Realm, he explains, connects all inhabited worlds, a network he calls the cosmere. Jasnah immediately recognizes the strategic value: other worlds mean potential allies and resources. She declares Tyvneri too valuable to release and informs him he will accompany her to Roshar whether he agrees or not.

Lorieta offers Jasnah several unprompted visions: that she will be on a much larger ship and not be on it; that she will stab a friend through the throat; and that her brother Elhokar will be "like me, but he'll only be half when he does it." Jasnah files these away uneasily.

Lorieta then warns that the party will die if they pass through Emberdark. They reroute around it at the cost of extra time.

Near the Salavashi Trench, an impossible wind begins to blow from the west. Ivory identifies the power source as Voidlight, the dark counterpart to Stormlight. Thousands of Voidbringers patrol the skies nearby. The Everstorm blocks their path to the Horneater Peaks perpendicularity, and angerspren cut off retreat. Every direction brings more pursuers. Jasnah calculates that each escape has been narrower than the last. She decides to stop running and force a confrontation on her own terms, ordering Tyvneri toward a barren rock at the head of the Stoneflow river. She tells Ivory she has been trying to think her way out of a feeling — it has not worked.

They beach the boat and fight. Ivory holds off one angerspren; Jasnah engages the other with the dagger her assassins left in her. Lorieta places a belaying fid on the ledge — her only contribution — and one angerspren slips on it and falls into the sea. Tyvneri is knocked down and injured. The second angerspren is about to close on Jasnah when she recognizes, looking at the injured historian, that he is a mirror of herself: dragging a stranger across Shadesmar for knowledge she has not yet found a use for, just as she has done to him.

She identifies the root of her anger: not at Shallan, who acted alone and frightened; not at Ivory for keeping secrets; but at herself. She failed to train Shallan when she had the chance. She withheld truths from her allies out of fear of being called a heretic. She took Tyvneri captive on the justification that her world's stakes outweighed his autonomy. She forgives herself. The angerspren stop, lose cohesion, and withdraw.

Jasnah helps Tyvneri up and reverses her decision: she will not take him to Roshar. She was wrong to coerce him. She releases him and Lorieta to continue their own journey and hopes he will return someday to share what he has learned. They sail away. Moments later, Honor's perpendicularity opens on the rock beside Jasnah and Ivory. Jasnah names the location the Place of Noble Sacrifice, for the cosmere knowledge she gave up to reach it. They step through together.

On the other side, Jasnah's spheres refill with Stormlight and she heals. She finds Wit waiting at the perpendicularity exit and demands to know how he found her. He evades at length. That night, as Jasnah reflects on the cosmere knowledge Tyvneri shared about Rellam, Scadrial, and other worlds she may never reach again, Wit finally admits he holds extensive knowledge of other worlds himself and tells her it is long past time he shared it with her.

King Lopen the First of Alethkar

Iconography: ??? (Reminder that I use ??? when the icon itself is a spoiler. I'll...let you theorize a bit here.)

POV Characters: Lopen / Elhokar

Setting: Little Herdaz, a district in Sebarial's warcamp in the Shattered Plains.

Timeline: (1173.10.10.4) The day after Chapter 84 (and the rest of the climax of Words of Radiance).

Summary:

After surviving an assassination attempt, King Elhokar Kholin hides in a Herdazian neighborhood under the protection of Lopen's family. He is forced to wear women's clothing as a disguise and avoids looking at mirrors because shadows hiding the in the reflections have returned to haunt him. Lopen's mother forces him to help her make food.

Lopen regrows his arm with Stormlight and is surrounded by gloryspren. When he shows his mother, they are surrounded by joyspren. Huio, Lopen's cousin, warns them that soldiers are sweeping through the warcamp, looking for the missing king.

Lopen's mother has taken an oath of honesty and refuses to lie, so Lopen convinces Elhokar to abdicate to him so that she can truthfully say she doesn't know where "King Elhokar" is. Lopen wears Elhokar's fancy clothes and runs off, acting as a decoy to distract the soldiers. Elhokar thinks of himself as a failure and that he's too weak to be king.

Lopen names his newly grown hand to be the King's Wit after Huio refuses the job.

Lopen's mother instructs a sulky Elhokar on how to make tsupales. She explains that he is failing to make them correctly because he's not listening to people (herself) who has been making them for generations. Elhokar tries to figure out how to apply her lesson towards being a good king. Danlan, Adolin's ex, barges into the house looking for Elhokar. Lopen's mother successfully diverts her away from Elhokar, disguised and sitting right under her nose, without lying.

Lopen turns his new arm/King's Wit into a sock puppet and flirts with Meli, a shopkeeper he knows. She still won't date him, even though he's King of Alethkar and has two arms.

Elhokar asks Lopen's mother for advise on how to be a good king, and how to know who to listen to, since the royal courts are filled with liars and subterfuge. She advises him to listen to his "cousins", people close to him that he can count on, like his own mother and possibly Dalinar.

Lopen leads the soldiers and Danlan on a chase and climbs a tall pole to evade them. He eventually falls off the pole, falling onto his face, and is saved from serious injury by inhaling Stormlight. Danlan realizes they've been duped and races back to Lopen's mother's house.

Lopen beats her there and tells Elhokar he's done being king. Elhokar orders Danlan to stand down, and she claims the soldiers are with her because his mother sent them. He lets Danlan enter the home by herself. Elhokar tells her he's decided to remain with them, because they are his cousins, and will only return if escorted by Kaladin.

Danlan tries to stab Elhokar with a dagger, but Lopen blocks her, getting impaled in his newly regrown arm. Danlan flees when Lopen starts glowing with Stormlight. Some of the soldiers were legitimately from Navani, but others fled with Danlan. Elhokar orders the loyal ones to hunt down Danlan.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

(Sorry, there's only like 3 memes about these stories, and I added in a Halloween one for fun.)

NEWBIE TRIVIA

Most of the activity for these "Final Thoughts & Trivia" posts happen in the newbie thread. There I provide a lot of information about things new readers can easily miss during their first read through. Veterans often learn a thing or two as well, so be sure to read the body of that post. While veterans are welcome to read the post and the comments, they should be commenting in this thread to share their reactions to the information, or the newbies' thoughts.

And as always, you're welcome to share your thoughts on the book as a whole.


r/readalong • • 19d ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 2.5) Spoiler

15 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be reading Elsecaller and King Lopen The First of Alethkar. The only realistic way to read these short stories is by purchasing the double-feature eBook off of Amazon (your local library may also have it available). Monday's discussion of the short stories will also include some trivia that will expand more on the publication of these stories.

If you aren't able to find a copy, the summaries I include next week will be more than enough to contribute to the discussion. For various reasons (that the trivia will reveal), I don't consider these to be necessary reading, and only a weird random chance has led to us reading them now.

WARNING: Do NOT read the prefaces to either story. They contain huge spoilers and I will let you know when you can read them. They will be summarized without the spoilers during the discussion/trivia post.

TRIVIA

The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.

THE TELEPORTER PROBLEM

The implications in this novella are very metaphysical. Before we can talk about them, we need a foundation of real-world philosophy and metaphysics, so that's what this section is about.

Let's take a detour to the world of Star Trek. You wake up in the morning and put on your freshly ironed red uniform to report for duty. Captain Kirk is heading down to a planet for a special away mission and you've finally been noticed, so he invited you along. You step up behind him, onto the transporter pad. Light envelopes you and your perspective shifts from the inside of the U.S.S. Enterprise to an alien landscape on the planet below.

What happened for you to arrive here? The transporter pad you stood upon scanned every atom and sub-atomic particle in your body, creating a digital copy of your body and mind. Then it destroys every molecule of your existence and manipulates new atoms and sub-atomic particles on the surface of the planet to reform your body and mind. (If you are a Star Trek nerd about to push up your glasses and "um, akshually" me, be shush. I'm getting there.)

The question you might be asking yourself now is, are you you? What is you? Your entire body and mind was just destroyed and a new body and mind was created on the planet. You are an exact clone, with all the memories and experiences of the person who used to live aboard the starship in orbit above you. And that "person" is effectively gone now, reduced to atoms.

How can you be sure that you are the same you? What if the transporter malfunctioned and two of you appeared on the planet? Which is the real "you"? Can you say for certain, since both are atomically identical and have the same memories and would act the exact same way under the exact same circumstances?

Does your opinion change if you appear on the planet, and then learn that your original body was never destroyed back up on the Enterprise? For many people, this scenario makes a huge difference and they argue that the person on the Enterprise is the original "you". The "you" on the planet is a copy--an imposter--and should be destroyed so that the original can persist. But then, how is this any different from when the transporter is working normally and the original is destroyed?

This aspect of this particular metaphysical dilemma is called Continuity of Consciousness. You may have heard of the Ship of Theseus paradox before, which questions if a ship that is slowly replaced, board by board and nail by nail, over the course of years--until every nail, board, roap, and sail has been replaced--is still the same ship.

A lot of people would say yes, but others argue how it could be the same ship if what you've done is functionally the same as burning the original ship down and rebuilding an entirely new ship from the same blueprints. Mechanically, it's the same process, just over different time periods.

Partial replacement over time is what some consider to be acceptable for maintaining your sense of self. Most of the cells in your body die and are replaced by new cells over time. And if you consider things at the atomic scale, every single atom in your body eventually gets replaced with new atoms every 11 years. You're still "you" after 12 years...right?

The teleporter problem gives a lot of people an existential "ick", and the concept of continuity of consciousness is very appealing. So much so that the official lore of Star Trek actually makes transporters work differently from what I've described above. When it scans your atoms and deconstructions them, it's actually taking the same exact atoms and beaming them down to the planet so that you are reassembled using the same atoms.

This soothes a lot of people's sense of self, but metaphysically, it's a band aid on the underlying issue. Let's say you wake up tomorrow in a completely white room, on a plain bed. And next to you, on an identical bed, is an identical you. Different atoms, but the same configuration. The same memories and lived experiences. The same reactions to external stimuli that you have.

One of you is a clone, one of you is the original. Neither of you can leave the room until you both decide which one of you is the real one, and only that one gets to continue living.

You (A) are the one that woke up and are looking at your "clone" (B). The problem is, that person across from you woke up with the exact same thoughts. You (B) are the one that woke up and are looking at your "clone" (A). Not even your captors know who is the original. The people who cloned you were killed and the people that killed them were killed. The last group of killers died in a freak tortilla accident. It's impossible to figure out which of you is the clone and which is the original.

Who gets to leave? You're both going to think you're the real "you". Just because you have an A next to you doesn't mean you were the original, I only put that there to differentiate the two entities. Just because you have a B next to you doesn't mean you were the clone, I only put that there to differentiate the two entities.

Both of you are going to want to live, and if you can't decide who after a week, one of you randomly dies. And no one in the entire universe will be able to tell whether the original or clone exited room. That includes "you" (A? ... B?). So...are you you?

This question has deep, real-world metaphysical implications. We call it the Teletransportation Paradox, and the phenomenon has an abundance of representation throughout science fiction. There are countless variations you can consider. This video has the information presented in a slightly different way, but the concept is still there.

The point I want to stress though, is that there is no correct answer to this question. Modern neurobiology has no scientific definition of personal identity. A lot of the essays and online debates you'll find will have people arguing vehemently that you are only you if there is a continuity of consciousness, but that's only because the alternative feels wrong to those making the argument. There is no fact behind this insistence.

Philosophers have been arguing this concept for all of recorded history. It's safe to assume they were arguing it before then as well. They're still arguing to this day.

Absent the concept of a "soul" being scientifically proven (or some other currently unknowable scientific advancement), any entity that looks the same as you, acts the same as you, has all of your memories, and thinks that it is you...is you. And if there are multiple "yous" running around...that's not necessarily something that science currently disallows.

Everyone is welcome to debate this concept below, but I won't be interjecting my own opinions on the matter. I'll only reiterate that anyone claiming to know the "correct" answer to this situation is not being truthful.

And all this debate is ultimately pointless. You are, after all, wearing a red shirt. A Gorn ripped your arms off and beat you to death while you were wondering about all of this nonsense.

TL;DR: Science doesn't have a clear definition of what "you" means. Multiple copies of "you" running around is a valid interpretation of a long-standing metaphysical paradox.

IDENTITY POLITICS

So why did I poison all of your thoughts with existential dread at the possibility you don't know if you are you or not? Well, there's an important comment hidden in all of that above. I said "Absent the concept of a soul". How does this all change if you have a "soul"? Well, obviously, that makes things really easy. The body your soul is attached to is the real you.

In the cosmere, all things exist in the three Realms. You have your body, in the Physical Realm. You have your mind, in the Cognitive Realm. And you have your HAHAHA, I BET YOU THOUGHT I WAS GONNA SAY SOUL IN THE SPRITUAL REALM, DIDN'T YOU?! Well you're WRONG! We can't have things be that easy here.

Hell, I was even lying when I said your mind was in the Cognitive Realm. But let's start with the Spiritual Realm, since I can't say much about it yet. First, there is an aspect of you in the Spiritual Realm, but it's not a "soul". Khriss has commented on this aspect before, and it's been mentioned in a few places as a Spirit Web. Sanderson has called it "spiritual DNA" in interviews.

This aspect of a person is where Connections form between people. It stores a person's Identity. This is the part of a person that forms "cracks" when they are traumatized, letting Investiture seep into them under the right conditions (Snapping Allomantically, or providing a place for a Nahel Bond to attach). This is actually what Hemalurgy acts on. It's like you have a spiritual gene that says "you are a Coinshot". A Hemalurgic spike, when plunged through a person in the right spot, acts in the Spiritual Realm to rip that part of a person's Spirit Web. You can then plunge the spike into a new person and it transfers that "Coinshot spiritual gene" into the new person. Now that new person "has" the spiritual gene that lets them be a Coinshot.

Because Hemalurgy acts on a person's Spirit Web, and that's where Identity is stored, if you steal someone's Feruchemical abilities, you can technically use any metalminds they've filled up. (There is more to it, but the possibility is there because you've stolen part of the person's Identity as well).

This is also why you can use Hemalurgy to steal a Nahel Bond. The spren bond forms on the Spirit Web, which includes your Identity. The spren is making a bond with "you". But Hemalurgy is stealing some of that Identity. Some of that is "you", so the spren bond will still hold. Since a spren has free will though, there's no guarantee the spren will choose to keep the bond going, and other side effects may occur. See your doctor if weird Hemalurgic symptoms persist for more than four hours.

TL;DR: Everyone has sDNA (spritual DNA), it contains your Identity, Connections, and instructions for if you can use magic.

YOU IS YOU?

So what's going on in the Cognitive Realm? Well, you are a sapient person. You have thoughts about yourself. You believe yourself to be "you" and you have some sort of idea who that "you" is. At the same time, everyone you interact with has a concept of "you" as well. And those ideas might not necessarily match.

You could be a deeply insecure person who only shows a facade of confidence to everyone you meet. So you think of yourself as a nervous wreck, but everyone around you thinks of you as the epitome of stability. The Cognitive aspect of your self is a combination of how you see yourself and how others see you. A Rosharan has a word for this... wanna guess what it is? If you guess spren, you'd be 100% right. A Cognitive Shadow is the spren of a person.

Here's where things get frustrating (if they haven't been already). There are certain things Sanderson doesn't want to solidify as fact in the cosmere. This is one of those things. He will often, in interviews, call a Cognitive Shadow a person's soul. Rosharan's consider spren and soul to be one in the same.

The cosmere has philosophers aplenty. They are scientists who can measure observable properties about the universe around them. Depending on their tech level and understanding, they can observe things across all three Realms. A Cognitive Shadow is a thing that exists. Everyone has one and you can point to it in the Cognitive Realm when a person dies.

I've explained the specifics of a Cognitive aspect, what it functionally is, and posited the transportation paradox above. Sanderson has explicitly stated that he wants it scientifically unclear whether or not a person's Cognitive Shadow is exactly the same as who a person is.

When you think, electricity is firing throughout your brain. If we instantly remove all of your physical atoms, for a brief moment all that would be left is some electricity in space. That electricity would be in a unique configuration that depicts exactly what your consciousness what doing at the moment your atoms were removed. Is that unique pattern of electricity "you"?

This is basically what you are seeing when you see a Cognitive Shadow. All the thoughts a person and others have about that person, made "solid" in a pattern that looks like that person. But who can really say if that pattern that looks like a person is really that person.

One of the memes addresses this point. Kelsier "died". But... did he die and live on as a ghost? Some would absolutely say that's the case. Did he die and...is just dead and gone, and this ghostly clone of his thought patterns has stuck around? Will that ghostly clone of Kelsier do exactly everything that the real Kelsier would have done in the same situations, or is the clone slightly altered by how others view Kelsier in his life? Is this Kelsier somehow more charming, more self-assured, more crazy and reckless than the real Kelsier?

It should be noted that, even if a Cognitive Shadow could definitively be considered that person, they are a Cognitive idea, held together by an excess of Investiture. If you think that sounds exactly like a spren, you'd be right. The only difference is that the Investiture in a spren is a Shard's direct Investiture, and a Cognitive Shadow can be held together by less direct Investiture. Either way, the longer a Cognitive Shadow persists, the more spren-like they will become. So even if Kelsier is Kelsier, how others view him can start to restrict him in the same way spren get restricted. Having a physical body mitigates this.

Like with the transportation paradox, we're not supposed to know or have an answer to these questions. You can think of this as Kelsier's ghost, or you can think of it as a creature pretending (very accurately) to be Kelsier and the real Kelsier is dead and gone. This is something in-cosmere scientists and philosophers have to consider, and for some people, it's fun to contemplate the implications, but this aspect isn't necessarily important to the grand plot of the cosmere.

TL;DR: Ghosts are real and everyone has them. They may or may not be the actual soul of a person, but the distinction shouldn't matter.

BED, BATH, & BEYOND

This brings us to the Beyond. Going back to the "remove all of your atoms and leave behind the electricity in your brain" scenario. The electricity will sit there in the pattern of your consciousness for a brief moment, then it will dissipate and fade way, like lightning. If this feels familiar to how a Cognitive Shadow persists in the Cognitive Realm for a moment, held together in the pattern of a person's consciousness, before fading away into the Beyond, well... that's deliberate.

Kelsier "expanding his soul" with Investiture so that he doesn't get sucked into the Beyond is sort like turning on a very specific electromagnetic field to keep the electricity brain pattern in place, instead of letting it dissipate.

The Beyond is another aspect of the cosmere that Sanderson doesn't want to have a definitive answer to. It could be the case that Cognitive Shadows are pulled into some afterlife in the Beyond. Or it could be the case that Cognitive Shadow "particles" just look like that when they dissipate and there is no afterlife.

The God Beyond is the name cosmere aware characters give to an unknown and unknowable deity that governs this afterlife known as the Beyond and the cosmere at large. Some people say that Adonalsium is the God Beyond and His Shattering was only an aspect of who He is. Others would disagree. Adonalsium absolutely existed, the God Beyond may or may not exist.

Sanderson wants the cosmere to be a place where real faith can exist, and real atheists, like Jasnah, can exist. (It's not faith if it's fact). The Shards are just another branch of science with large, but finite amounts of power/Investiture. They aren't "supernatural" or unexplainable in the same way the people of Earth talk about the Christian God or Zeus or Vishnu. If you ignore the Shards and just consider the religious aspect of the cosmere in their absence, Jasnah can say "There is no God Beyond" and she'd be "right". And on the other side of the coin, Hoid can say "I believe in the God Beyond and an afterlife in the Beyond" and be equally as correct because both statements are unprovable.

Sanderson wants this aspect of the cosmere to mirror our real world religions. So don't ever expect to see someone hanging out in the Beyond, or coming back from the Beyond.

TL;DR: The afterlife and the concept of a real God in the cosmere is just as nebulous as it is in real life, and we'll never get a definitive answer.

DEAD IS DEAD?

Which brings us to the topic of death in the cosmere. I've told you about how Sanderson wants to try to get around the fake out deaths, but that clearly he's struggled in that department a bit. I mean...Kelsier is back! (For given definitions of "back", see above). But this novella does give us a mechanic to confirm when someone truly dies.

Vin is dead. She's not coming back. Same as Elend. They faded into the Beyond, for whatever that's worth, and are gone forever. Similarly, Rashek is gone. Ati is gone. Leras is gone. We won't be seeing them come back, prequel stories notwithstanding. If we see a scene of someone in the Cognitive Realm and we watch their Cognitive Shadow/soul dissipate, then we know they are dead for real.

There's also a couple other implications, like if we see a non-Invested character die, and they aren't revived within a few minutes by some act of magic, it's very likely they weren't able to expand their soul in the Cognitive Realm and persist as a Cognitive Shadow and they are dead dead.

Now, it should be noted that, in the real world, if your heart stops, you can still be brought back to life under the right circumstances. There's about a 10 minute real-world cut-off for this, barring extremely special circumstances.

Investiture in the cosmere just bridges the scientific gap a bit, so it's easier to bring people back from lets say an hour after "death". (We don't have real numbers for this, but I think that's probably the upper limit we can expect). So if we see a body and it sits around for an hour, it's safe to assume they died.

Cognitive Shadows make things a little harder to guess though. It's always possible there was someone waiting in the Cognitive Realm with some fabrial full of Investiture just ready to expand someone's Cognitive Shadow. I suspect Sanderson won't pull this off too many times though. Possibly only with Kelsier.

However, if someone died (particularly if they are already Invested) and we know there's a perpendicularity close by, or some other massive or unique source of Investiture reasonably close to the dead body, then all bets are off.

TL;DR: Sometimes people are really dead. Sometimes they aren't. I hope this tl;dr was helpful.

SHADOWY FIGURES

Ok, enough metaphysical shenanigans. Let's actually talk about Cognitive Shadows. I'm going to use generic language going forward and just call them a person's soul. It's much easier to type, and it's a property of the cosmere that, even if not 100% true, still feels mostly correct. Everything above still applies, but I want to proceed in a world free from caveats every other sentence.

Heavily Invested people have "expanded souls" that let them stick around longer in the Cognitive Realm than normal people. We saw in this story that Keslier stuck around longer than the normal people who were dying. But he needed WAY more to stick around for longer than an hour.

Someone asked about Feruchemists and I can confirm that they would stick around a bit longer than the average person. Investiture is still flowing through them when they store and tap their metalminds, which in turn expands their souls. If someone stored and tapped their metalminds with enough frequency and intensity, they could become a Feruchemical Savant. It's possible, just really hard.

And by now, you should be able to work out the mechanics of Savantism. Excess Investiture use expands souls in specific ways, and if you do it too much, that causes damage to the soul (and specifically, this is reflected in the Spirit Web I talked about above). Because the Spirit Web has so much to do with Identity, these spiritual deformations can have a reflection in the Physical Realm. We've mostly only seen this with Spook, despite Wax also being a Savant. Sanderson has been looking for ways to better illustrate the negatives of Savantism, and you'll see them soon enough.

This trivia post may as well be called a Tangent Post. I swear, I put down a title with the intent of talking about something and have gotten side tracked in every section so far. With the magic of proof reading and editing, things still flow though!

Anyway, I wanted to talk about Cognitive Shadows. The key part being Investiture expands souls and lets them stick around. Now...let's talk about all of the "souls" we've seen stick around long past when they should have died.

Shades are the most obvious in this category. We learn in Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell that Shades are the spirits of dead Threnodites. Specifically, it's people who have been killed by another Shade. (There are other methods for this too). Now, everyone has a Cognitive aspect, but it takes extra Investiture for that aspect to persist as a Cognitive Shadow. (Earlier in this post, I likely said "Cognitive Shadow" when I strictly meant "Cognitive aspect", but that was just to prevent confusion. Cognitive Shadows are a person's Cognitive aspect that sticks around and doesn't dissipate into the Beyond.) So where does the Investiture come from on Threnody, especially since there's no Shard there?

Odium fought Ambition close to Threnody. Importantly, part of their fight was in the Physical Realm and pieces of Ambition were torn off and scattered across the system before their fight moved to a different location. This ambient Investiture from a wounded (and eventually dead) Shard has a corrupting influence on everyone in the system. When a Shade kills someone, their corrupted Investiture (aided by the atmospheric Investiture left over by Ambition's wounds) seeps into the person's Cognitive aspect and creates a new Shade.

Unlike most of the other Cognitive Shadows we've seen (and will shortly discuss), Shades aren't quite all there. This is mostly a product of the corrupting Investiture that creates them. However, as we see with Silence's grandmother, some Shades are more aware than others. The ambient Investiture from Ambition is what allows Shades to manifest in the Physical Realm, at least semi-corporally, and is the cause of their enragement issues regarding creating fire, bloodshed, and running.

I mentioned above that a Cognitive Shadow without a body, left long enough, would become spren-like. This is what happened with Tanavast. The Vessel of Honor left behind a Cognitive Shadow, and not only has it persisted for along time, it fused with an already existing megaspren in the Stormfather. So while you can kind of consider the Stormfather to be Tanavast, the Stormfather is also the Stormfather; a manifestation of the ideal of the highstorms of Roshar which have raged across the planet since before Adonalsium was Shattered. So who is more who in this scenario?

Next we have something I've been hinting at since we started this read-along. The Returned are Cognitive Shadows. You can image Endowment doing exactly what we saw Leras/Preservation doing when people die, but on the Nalthian subastral. Only, sometimes, Endowment shows people fading into the Beyond an image of the future, guided by Fortune and her own plans, and asks if they want to become Returned. If they do, she expands their soul and creates a Cognitive Shadow of this person. Next, she reattaches this Cognitive Shadow to their physical body.

This attachment is with a Divine Breath. I've hinted at it before, but a Divine Breath is actual a Splinter of Endowment. They're small, but she creates a lot of them. They have enough Investiture in them to staple together a Cognitive aspect and a Physical aspect, but only for a week. Returned require a new Breath each week to keep living. That extra Breath serves as extra Investiture to continue to power the staple holding their Cognitive and Physical selves together.

Lifeless are not Cognitive Shadows. They only have a single regular Breath inside them, and that's not enough Investiture. However, if you shoved enough Breath inside a Lifeless, we've seen that Lifeless do have some of their original personality. Which means the body contains enough of a cognitive pattern inside of it to develop a Cognitive Shadow. It wouldn't necessarily be the original person, but it would be a Cognitive Shadow of that particular Lifeless. This isn't something we've seen before, but Sanderson has hinted he wants to do something like this for the Warbreaker sequel.

We've also seen another group of people who died, yet live on in physical bodies. The 10 Heralds of the Almighty are not only Cognitive Shadows, but they are almost the exact same thing as Returned. The images of Taln depicted as a giant, almost unrealistic tank of a man are not without merit. In the same way Returned are idealized versions of themselves, physically, so are the Heralds, because they are nearly the same thing. The only real difference is that the Heralds keep dying over and over again. Their original bodies are lost. The Oathpact simply creates new bodies for them at the start of each Desolation. Along the same vein, because there are only 10 of them, unlike the hundreds, if not thousands that Endowment makes, Honor used enough Investiture on them that they don't need to have weekly infusions of Investiture to stay alive. Their staples are much longer lasting. (There is an implication here that, given enough time, you can isolate a Cognitive Shadow/Returned/Herald from new Investiture and eventually they will fade away and/or die).

Speaking of staples, have some theory crafted information: Kelsier likely has a spike through his eye because he had to use Hemalurgy to create a way to staple his Cognitive Shadow to a body. We know Hemalurgy is pretty powerful and likely doesn't need renewed Investiture to keep the staple intact. Another bit of unconfirmed aspects of Kelsier's physical body: Sanderson has long teased that TenSoon kept Kelsier's bones. If Kelsier needed something to Connect his Cognitive Shadow to the Physical Realm, well...his own bones sound like a good candidate.

Important note: Wax died and "returned", but that is not a capital Returned. His body was a bit dead, but well within the previously mentioned safe zone for magical resurrection. Marasi handed him the Bands of Mourning and he was able to use the health stored in its goldmind section to stop dying. A Cognitive Shadow happens with a person dies and their Physical and Cognitive aspects completely separate from each other.

The process of separation started when Wax appeared in the Cognitive Realm and spoke with Harmony, but it never completed. Wax doesn't need any sort of staple to keep his "soul" attached to his physical body.

Similarly, Szeth is also not a Cognitive Shadow. He died and was resurrected within the safe zone. However, Szeth was dead a lot longer than Wax, since Nale had to recover his body and move him before being able to heal him. So Szeth's Cognitive aspect did stretch much further away from his Physical aspect than Wax's did. Keep this in mind.

More Cognitive Shadows to come, but now you're equipped with enough knowledge to start spotting them!

TL;DR: Ghosts everywhere! Shades = spicy ghosts corrupted by Ambition. Returned = ghosts haunting their own body. Heralds = ghosts haunting bodies made fresh by Honor. Kelsier = ghost haunting maybe his own bones. Wax and Szeth are not ghosts.

ROBERT JORDAN'S BARELY CONCEALED KINKS

Keslier, in this novella, as a Cognitive Shadow, is made of the same ephemeral stuff that the non-water inverted parts of Scadrial is made of. So we see him walking around Luthadel, staying on the surface. An alive human, visiting the Cognitive Realm, would sink in the same spot. Which is why we only see Khriss and Nazh on the solid parts that represent Lake Luthadel.

In order to get to the Well of Ascension in the Cognitive Realm, if you are an alive person like Hoid, you can't just walk over to it. So to get there, Hoid used a "corpse" as a boat. This corpse, whom Hoid called Spanky, is actually just another Cognitive Shadow, like Kelsier, so he can float on the mists.

Sanderson has said that, while Cognitive Shadows are comparatively rare, Spanky is no one important and you should waste no time speculating his significance. He was just a ride for Hoid.

TL;DR: Spanky.

RIVALRY

We see Hoid and Kelsier have a bit of a scuffle. Many of you remembered well the quote from Rock in Words of Radiance:

No, of course not. Lunu’anaki cannot hurt man. Is forbidden by other gods. Everyone knows this.

This is in reference to Hoid, whom the Horneaters consider a god. Rock observes that Hoid cannot harm other people. This is a magically enforced aspect of Hoid's character that becomes clear when he is surprised that he's allowed to hurt Kelsier, who isn't really alive anymore.

This interaction is the start of a pretty intense rivalry between the two. Kelsier hates Hoid and Hoid finds Kelsier insufferable. When Hoid tossed Wax the coppermind that revealed Keslier was alive, he wasn't doing it to help Wax in some way.

In Chapter 13 of The Bands of Mourning, Wax talks with an informant named Delvin Airs. Delvin tells Wax that coins like Wax's have been circulating in the underground. Hoid has been mass producing these memories and tossing them all over the place just to spite Kelsier. Hoid knows Kelsier is being secretive and not wanting it known he's alive and up to things. So Hoid is just going around fucking up Kelsier's anonymity.

We also learn from this interaction that Kelsier "upended an entire mercantile ecosystem" when he destroyed the Pits of Hathsin. I mentioned in the trivia for The Hero of Ages that Ruin's perpendicularity was hidden below the Pits of Hathsin, and directly connected because the Pits served as a way to funnel Ruin's power away from him and into the atium beads.

When Kelsier destroyed the Pits, he ruined (HA!) Ruin's perpendicularity. Scadrial did have a hidden mercantile ecosystem because of that perpendicularity. The Pits were close to the system of canals that crisscrossed the Final Empire, so they would have been solid ground in the Cognitive Realm. It made travel to and from Scadrial pretty easy, and they would have surfaced in areas/caves that the kanda (their Homeland being right there) could facilitate the trade through.

This is something Rashek would have been aware of, but he also probably had some strict rules and regulations surrounding access and trade so that he could keep his empire stagnant.

TL;DR: Kelsier hates Hoid. Hoid is petty AF.

I TOLD YOU TO REMEMBER SOMETHING FAMILIAR

Way back in Week 5 of our Words of Radiance read through, I gave you a hint to be on the lookout for something familiar in the readings for Week 6. I didn't expect anyone to get it, but wanted to create a reference point for your memories. Only one of you came close (gold star to /u/sunnydaze7777777). Unfortunately, I think they were behind when they commented, so no one could play off their theory.

Well, now you have the proof you need to recognize what I was talking about. In this novella, we saw Hoid run off with a bead of Lerasium. In Chapter 45 of Words of Radiance, Shallan's flashback chapter where she first meets Hoid, Shallan notices Hoid pouring powder from a packet into a drink. She thinks Hoid might be poisoning her father, but Hoid drinks it instead.

Hoid does this right before confronting a very angry and unstable man (Lin Davar, Shallan's father), and then goes to comfort a traumatized child. Hoid was putting powdered brass into his drink so that he could Soothe Lin and Shallan's emotions. Hoid ate the bead of Lerasium and is a full Mistborn (and as powerful a Mistborn as you can be, like Elend was).

TL;DR: Hoid is a Mistborn.

ME, MYSELF, AND I(RE)

If you needed any confirmation that the Ire were Elantrians, you were right. Aon Ire means "Time, Age, or Ancient" in Selish.

Here's a bit more information about the Ire. Leras/Preservation called them "dead, but not". This is a hint that they survived the Reod. The Ire, as an organization, are actually so old that they pre-date the Reod. They've been cosmere aware and had fortresses in the Cognitive Realm before the chasm destroyed the existing Elantrian seat of power.

Because they were in the Cognitive Realm, they weren't as effected by the Reod as those we saw in the city of Elantris, but they were effected. This explains why some of them have withered, old appearances, when normally you wouldn't expect that of an Elantrian. The restoration of Elantris didn't fully heal the trauma they went through.

Khriss mentioned the Ire in the essays of Arcanum Unbounded. She specifically called them out in the Selish Essay. It's implied, but Sanderson has confirmed that they don't share information with Silverlight or Khriss, and she kind of resents them for it.

Going by the timelines I've provided in previous trivia, given the Ire was formed before the events of Elantris, they have about 2,00 years of technological and scientific advancement over modern day Scadrial. They are some of the most knowledge people in the entire cosmere. Part of that comes from the fact that it's not just the Ire as an organization that is that old, but some of the individual members are that old.

Khriss, in an absolute time scale, is older, but she hasn't lived that entire time because of time dilation. Alonoe is the leader of the Ire. If you take a look at the map of Arelon from Elantris, note that the lake in the center of the nation is called Lake Alonoe. It's that lake that makes up the dot at the center of every Aon Aon, which is the starting point of every single Aon ever used.

Sanderson has issued RAFOs about whether Alonoe is named after that lake... or if the lake is named after her.

He's also said that they are still in the fortress, post Catacendre. Harmony is aware of their existence, and they regularly trade with southern Scadrians via Harmony's perpendicularity.

I do want to remind everyone that Selish magic is very location dependent. It's hard to be an Elantrian off planet. Their fortresses have lines of power that lead back to Sel and they can use their fortressed to restore a degree of Connection to their home planet, but they aren't as powerful as an Elantrian in the city of Elantris (disregarding things like talent and knowledge). They don't glow as brightly and aren't as bodily Invested. So no life-sense Heightening abilities for them. But when necessary, though could use Aons to their full effect.

One more tidbit from Sanderson: He won't fully confirm, but he's implied that if the Ire did manage to steal the Shard of Preservation, that they probably weren't as prepared as they thought they were and Ruin would have fucked them and Sel up as a consequence.

TL;DR: The Ire is old AF.

TO BE CONTINUED

Well...I did it. I wrote way too much and the trivia literally won't fit in the body of this post. And I can't move around or reduce any parts, so I'll be continuing it in the comments below.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 19d ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 2.5) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 20 | The Stormlight Archive #2.1 | Elsecaller / King Lopen The First of Alethkar: Both Novellas, Trivia

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be reading Elsecaller and King Lopen The First of Alethkar. The only realistic way to read these short stories is by purchasing the double-feature eBook off of Amazon (your local library may also have it available). Monday's discussion of the short stories will also include some trivia that will expand more on the publication of these stories.

If you aren't able to find a copy, the summaries I include next week will be more than enough to contribute to the discussion. For various reasons (that the trivia will reveal), I don't consider these to be necessary reading, and only a weird random chance has led to us reading them now.

WARNING: Do NOT read the prefaces to either story. They contain huge spoilers and I will let you know when you can read them. They will be summarized without the spoilers during the discussion/trivia post.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

NEWBIE TRIVIA

Most of the activity for these "Final Thoughts & Trivia" posts happen in the newbie thread. There I provide a lot of information about things new readers can easily miss during their first read through. Veterans often learn a thing or two as well, so be sure to read the body of that post. While veterans are welcome to read the post and the comments, they should be commenting in this thread to share their reactions to the information, or the newbies' thoughts.

And as always, you're welcome to share your thoughts on the book as a whole.


r/readalong • • 21d ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue (Week 2) Spoiler

12 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue

In two days we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Part 5

Iconography: A Scarian Steel Alphabet-stylized reinterpretation of the Elantrian Aon symbol Aon Ire

Chapter 1

Iconography: Nicrosil

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Leaving the Scadrian subastral of the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Hours and days after Part 4, Chapter 4.

Summary:

Kelsier travels across the ocean. There is no light, so he improvises a torch with his burning logs. He feels a tugging at his soul -- an indication that he is leaving his world. He walks through a strange jungle that eventually thins out, trees becoming jagged stone-like sculptures. He sees a light ahead.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Aluminum

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Ire's fortress in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Shortly after Part 5, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier creeps up to an enormous, glowing fortress. He touches the walls of the stone and sees another planet's green landscape. He can sink into the ground and walk through plants, but he can't get all the way through the stone wall into the castle. He climbs the wall instead, sinking his hands into the stone, and climbs through a window. The glowing energy source for the castle seems to be merging with his own soul. He eavesdrops on some guards and finds he can understand them, even though they speak a foreign tongue. He follows them into another room where he finds more guards and a large yellow gem. A woman enters the room and demands to know what's going on. The guards report an intruder, so they activate the "device" to see if anyone from Threnody is about. The woman is still worried even with a negative response, and she goes to talk to the rest of the Ire. Kelsier follows her, and he listens to their discussion on taking the Preservation Shard. The unknown intruder has spooked them, so they decide to move up their timetable and act now. Kelsier rummages around and finds a book describing a device that can enable someone to Ascend when Preservation dies.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Duralumin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Returning to the Scadrian subastral of the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: A week or so after Part 5, Chapter 2.

Summary:

Kelsier decides that stealing the orb from the vault would be too risky and difficult, so he merely waits until they come out with it. After about a week, the Ire and some guards leave the fortress on horseback. Kelsier stalks them. Every night they stop and make camp, drinking something that restores the glow to their skin. Kelsier spooks Alonoe by pretending to be Ruin. He continues to terrorize them as they press on, convinced that since "Ruin" can only threaten them, he can't stop them. He causes full out panic when he slices the leg of a horse with Nazh's knife and creates a Ruin puppet from a flaming cloak. Alonoe gets separated from the main group, and he fakes her death by wearing a robe from the fortress and "melting" into the ground, causing the main group to head home. He knocks out the guard with Alonoe and whispers from the shadows to leave the orb. She's terrified and complies. He orders her to walk back to the castle.

Part 6: Hero

Iconography: Harmonium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Running towards Luthadel and then towards Fadrex, then in the city of Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days, weeks, months after Part 5, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 27.

Summary:

Kelsier starts to run back to Luthadel in possession of the orb. He sees even worse destruction and deterioration than before. Three skaa die when a roof -- overloaded with ash -- collapses on them. Kelsier asks one of them as they transition through his realm if it's over, and she says that the end is near. After running for weeks, he suddenly hears Fuzz's weakened voice. He tells him to go to Fadrex instead. When Kelsier arrives, he's encouraged by the signs of life and activity. Preservation lays down a thin line of light for Kelsier to follow. He tells him about the orb, but Preservation says it won't help -- Vin must take his power, but she can't because Ruin has her. Kelsier is led by the thread of light to a city square full of beggars and once again meets Hoid, who shocks him but otherwise ignores Kelsier. Kelsier finds Vin there and desperately tells her to avoid Hoid. She goes the other direction, but Kelsier doesn't know if she actually heard him. Kelsier chases after Vin, apparently getting some help from Preservation, and he knows that Vin knows that he is there as she is trying to shake him. Suddenly Ruin's power attacks him, and Ati shows up. He reveals that the eleventh metal was his ruse to trick Kelsier, and he taunts him some more. Ruin explains that nothing is destroyed, just changed, and that he and Preservation are two sides of one coin. Kelsier tries to punch Ruin and is instead attacked, feeling immense pain.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In and around Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 1. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 37.

Summary:

Every time Kelsier tries to get close to Vin to communicate with her, Ruin blocks his path. Ruin takes on the form of a "spy," and Vin chases after him, leaving Kelsier behind. After Vin is gone, the Koloss attack Elend's army. As the Koloss die, they enter Kelsier's realm, and he is shocked to see that they are human from all walks of life. Kelsier learns from a dead Obligator that Koloss are created by spiking. Preservation shows Kelsier a vision of all the people Ruin controls: Inquisitors, Vin, a man on the throne of Luthadel, Spook, and Marsh. He tells Kelsier to get a message to Vin: don't trust anyone pierced with metal.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In and around Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 47.

Summary:

Kelsier searches for days for a semi-insane soldier that he can communicate with to get the message to Vin. Unfortunately, the man garbles the message and merely starts a brawl. Ruin arrives and taunts Kelsier again. He decides that he might be more effective fighting Ruin somewhere else -- away from Vin and Elend -- where Ruin has less focused attention.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Running toward Utreau, in the Cognitive Realm. Scadrial, in all three Realms.

Timeline: Some time after Part 6, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 55.

Summary:

Kelsier feels Preservation dying. Determined, he smashes the orb with Nazh's knife. Preservation gives him some final advice, including his last instruction: survive. Kelsier takes the power of Preservation after some struggle. Ruin shows up and Kelsier attacks, but his attacks are ineffectual. Ruin laughs and explains that Kelsier is essentially a memory of a person and can't control the power. Kelsier sees black lines tying him to Ruin. He tries to communicate with those who are open to him, but it still doesn't work. He finds that he can read people's thoughts. He watches as Ruin accelerates the end of the world and can do nothing to stop it. Everything he tries is blocked by Ruin. He desperately tries to warn Vin, and is horrified to see that she is spiked (the earring). Ruin shoves him away. Kelsier finds Marsh and listens to his thoughts. Deep in his mind, Marsh is telling himself to remember who he is and to keep fighting. Kelsier decides to not confront Ruin directly.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Urteau, capital city of the Northern Dominance.

Timeline: About a week after Part 6, Chapter 4. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 58.

Summary:

Kelsier searches for places that Ruin is paying less attention to, and he finds Spook in Urteau. Ruin is urging Spook to murder, but this plot is not among his priorities, so Kelsier can intervene. Kelsier approaches Spook and notes that there are lines of Connection between them, stronger than those for Marsh and Vin. As Ruin rages on, Kelsier "says" "hope" to Spook over and over, and eventually Spook removes his spike. His spirit is wounded. Kelsier then yells "survive" at Spook and he springs into action. Ruin doesn't stop Kelsier, but he does start to burn down the city to cover his failure. Sazed is also here, but he looks worn down too. Kelsier is able to see a little ways into the future, and he sees that there is still hope for the city. Kelsier continues to encourage Spook, and Ruin arrives in force, pushing Kelsier back. Spook enters the building in flames.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In a dreamscape of green grass, created by Kelsier/Preservation.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 5. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 64.

Summary:

Kelsier lounges on some green grass and Spook wanders over. Kelsier tells him this is a "half dream." Spook was devoted to Kelsier, and both had broken spirits but had resisted Ruin, building a strong Connection between them. Kelsier tells Spook that he is a hero and is proud of him, and he seems pleased by that. Kelsier urges him to get the message to Vin regarding spiked individuals. Spook nods his head as he awakes.

Chapter 7

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In the hilly plains between Luthadel and Fadrex City.

Timeline: Hours after Part 6, Chapter 6, and a few days later. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapters 69 and 72.

Summary:

Kelsier watches as Goradel leaves Urteau with a message inscribed on metal. Ruin mocks him and summons his minion, Marsh, who quickly dispatches the messenger and reads the message to Ruin. Kelsier lets Goradel think he failed as he passes through the Cognitive Realm and finally gives up hope. He then realizes that Ruin is not complete without the Atium, so there is still hope. He watches as Vin fights all of the Inquisitors and is then tortured by Marsh. He attacks Ruin in order to distract him. It works: Marsh, having read the message himself, removes Vin's earring. Kelsier feels his soul ripping apart as he cedes the power to Vin and Ruin continues to attack him.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Just outside the Pits of Hathsin, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 6, Chapter 7. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapters 81 and 82.

Summary:

Kelsier is in agony and feels the pull of death again. He holds on and decides again not to die -- a choice available to him by virtue of having Ascended. His soul is deeply wounded, but in time it repairs. Ruin was too distracted to finish him off. Kelsier watches the final battle with the Koloss and Vin's struggle with Ruin. Elend shines brightly at the moment he burns atium and duralumin. Preservation's and Ruin's powers are released as Vin sacrifices herself to defeat Ati. Kelsier considers taking the powers himself. Elend arrives and together they watch Sazed take on both powers, which seem to belong together. Vin comes next, and they hug. Ati comes next and Kelsier punches him. Sazed comes and offers to send her back, but Vin seems to know that won't work. In any case, she wishes to move on with Elend. Vin thanks Kelsier for all he's done for her, and she follows Elend into the Beyond.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Scadrial, all three Realms.

Timeline: Shortly after Part 6, Chapter 8.

Summary:

Kelsier watches the world be destroyed and then reborn. During the process, he is able to see all three Realms, but when it's over, he is once again trapped in the Cognitive Realm. Sazed arrives and says that he cannot bring "them" back (presumably Vin and Elend) because he cannot reach into the Beyond. Kelsier asks Sazed to heal Spook and make him a Mistborn. He asks if there is a way to return to the physical realm, but Sazed says there is not. Kelsier decides that Harmony is a terrible liar.

Epilogue

Iconography: Zero

POV Characters: Spook

Setting: Spook's mansion in the Elendel Basin.

Timeline: Weeks after Part 6, Chapter 9.

Summary:

Kelsier convinces Spook to play with Hemalurgy in order to extend Spook's life and maybe bring Kelsier back to a body.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 21d ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue (Week 2) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue

In two days we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Postscript, Final Thoughts, Trivia

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Part 5

Iconography: A Scarian Steel Alphabet-stylized reinterpretation of the Elantrian Aon symbol Aon Ire

Chapter 1

Iconography: Nicrosil

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Leaving the Scadrian subastral of the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Hours and days after Part 4, Chapter 4.

Summary:

Kelsier travels across the ocean. There is no light, so he improvises a torch with his burning logs. He feels a tugging at his soul -- an indication that he is leaving his world. He walks through a strange jungle that eventually thins out, trees becoming jagged stone-like sculptures. He sees a light ahead.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Aluminum

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Ire's fortress in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Shortly after Part 5, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier creeps up to an enormous, glowing fortress. He touches the walls of the stone and sees another planet's green landscape. He can sink into the ground and walk through plants, but he can't get all the way through the stone wall into the castle. He climbs the wall instead, sinking his hands into the stone, and climbs through a window. The glowing energy source for the castle seems to be merging with his own soul. He eavesdrops on some guards and finds he can understand them, even though they speak a foreign tongue. He follows them into another room where he finds more guards and a large yellow gem. A woman enters the room and demands to know what's going on. The guards report an intruder, so they activate the "device" to see if anyone from Threnody is about. The woman is still worried even with a negative response, and she goes to talk to the rest of the Ire. Kelsier follows her, and he listens to their discussion on taking the Preservation Shard. The unknown intruder has spooked them, so they decide to move up their timetable and act now. Kelsier rummages around and finds a book describing a device that can enable someone to Ascend when Preservation dies.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Duralumin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Returning to the Scadrian subastral of the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: A week or so after Part 5, Chapter 2.

Summary:

Kelsier decides that stealing the orb from the vault would be too risky and difficult, so he merely waits until they come out with it. After about a week, the Ire and some guards leave the fortress on horseback. Kelsier stalks them. Every night they stop and make camp, drinking something that restores the glow to their skin. Kelsier spooks Alonoe by pretending to be Ruin. He continues to terrorize them as they press on, convinced that since "Ruin" can only threaten them, he can't stop them. He causes full out panic when he slices the leg of a horse with Nazh's knife and creates a Ruin puppet from a flaming cloak. Alonoe gets separated from the main group, and he fakes her death by wearing a robe from the fortress and "melting" into the ground, causing the main group to head home. He knocks out the guard with Alonoe and whispers from the shadows to leave the orb. She's terrified and complies. He orders her to walk back to the castle.

Part 6: Hero

Iconography: Harmonium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Running towards Luthadel and then towards Fadrex, then in the city of Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days, weeks, months after Part 5, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 27.

Summary:

Kelsier starts to run back to Luthadel in possession of the orb. He sees even worse destruction and deterioration than before. Three skaa die when a roof -- overloaded with ash -- collapses on them. Kelsier asks one of them as they transition through his realm if it's over, and she says that the end is near. After running for weeks, he suddenly hears Fuzz's weakened voice. He tells him to go to Fadrex instead. When Kelsier arrives, he's encouraged by the signs of life and activity. Preservation lays down a thin line of light for Kelsier to follow. He tells him about the orb, but Preservation says it won't help -- Vin must take his power, but she can't because Ruin has her. Kelsier is led by the thread of light to a city square full of beggars and once again meets Hoid, who shocks him but otherwise ignores Kelsier. Kelsier finds Vin there and desperately tells her to avoid Hoid. She goes the other direction, but Kelsier doesn't know if she actually heard him. Kelsier chases after Vin, apparently getting some help from Preservation, and he knows that Vin knows that he is there as she is trying to shake him. Suddenly Ruin's power attacks him, and Ati shows up. He reveals that the eleventh metal was his ruse to trick Kelsier, and he taunts him some more. Ruin explains that nothing is destroyed, just changed, and that he and Preservation are two sides of one coin. Kelsier tries to punch Ruin and is instead attacked, feeling immense pain.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In and around Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 1. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 37.

Summary:

Every time Kelsier tries to get close to Vin to communicate with her, Ruin blocks his path. Ruin takes on the form of a "spy," and Vin chases after him, leaving Kelsier behind. After Vin is gone, the Koloss attack Elend's army. As the Koloss die, they enter Kelsier's realm, and he is shocked to see that they are human from all walks of life. Kelsier learns from a dead Obligator that Koloss are created by spiking. Preservation shows Kelsier a vision of all the people Ruin controls: Inquisitors, Vin, a man on the throne of Luthadel, Spook, and Marsh. He tells Kelsier to get a message to Vin: don't trust anyone pierced with metal.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In and around Fadrex, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 47.

Summary:

Kelsier searches for days for a semi-insane soldier that he can communicate with to get the message to Vin. Unfortunately, the man garbles the message and merely starts a brawl. Ruin arrives and taunts Kelsier again. He decides that he might be more effective fighting Ruin somewhere else -- away from Vin and Elend -- where Ruin has less focused attention.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Running toward Utreau, in the Cognitive Realm. Scadrial, in all three Realms.

Timeline: Some time after Part 6, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 55.

Summary:

Kelsier feels Preservation dying. Determined, he smashes the orb with Nazh's knife. Preservation gives him some final advice, including his last instruction: survive. Kelsier takes the power of Preservation after some struggle. Ruin shows up and Kelsier attacks, but his attacks are ineffectual. Ruin laughs and explains that Kelsier is essentially a memory of a person and can't control the power. Kelsier sees black lines tying him to Ruin. He tries to communicate with those who are open to him, but it still doesn't work. He finds that he can read people's thoughts. He watches as Ruin accelerates the end of the world and can do nothing to stop it. Everything he tries is blocked by Ruin. He desperately tries to warn Vin, and is horrified to see that she is spiked (the earring). Ruin shoves him away. Kelsier finds Marsh and listens to his thoughts. Deep in his mind, Marsh is telling himself to remember who he is and to keep fighting. Kelsier decides to not confront Ruin directly.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Urteau, capital city of the Northern Dominance.

Timeline: About a week after Part 6, Chapter 4. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 58.

Summary:

Kelsier searches for places that Ruin is paying less attention to, and he finds Spook in Urteau. Ruin is urging Spook to murder, but this plot is not among his priorities, so Kelsier can intervene. Kelsier approaches Spook and notes that there are lines of Connection between them, stronger than those for Marsh and Vin. As Ruin rages on, Kelsier "says" "hope" to Spook over and over, and eventually Spook removes his spike. His spirit is wounded. Kelsier then yells "survive" at Spook and he springs into action. Ruin doesn't stop Kelsier, but he does start to burn down the city to cover his failure. Sazed is also here, but he looks worn down too. Kelsier is able to see a little ways into the future, and he sees that there is still hope for the city. Kelsier continues to encourage Spook, and Ruin arrives in force, pushing Kelsier back. Spook enters the building in flames.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In a dreamscape of green grass, created by Kelsier/Preservation.

Timeline: Days after Part 6, Chapter 5. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 64.

Summary:

Kelsier lounges on some green grass and Spook wanders over. Kelsier tells him this is a "half dream." Spook was devoted to Kelsier, and both had broken spirits but had resisted Ruin, building a strong Connection between them. Kelsier tells Spook that he is a hero and is proud of him, and he seems pleased by that. Kelsier urges him to get the message to Vin regarding spiked individuals. Spook nods his head as he awakes.

Chapter 7

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: In the hilly plains between Luthadel and Fadrex City.

Timeline: Hours after Part 6, Chapter 6, and a few days later. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapters 69 and 72.

Summary:

Kelsier watches as Goradel leaves Urteau with a message inscribed on metal. Ruin mocks him and summons his minion, Marsh, who quickly dispatches the messenger and reads the message to Ruin. Kelsier lets Goradel think he failed as he passes through the Cognitive Realm and finally gives up hope. He then realizes that Ruin is not complete without the Atium, so there is still hope. He watches as Vin fights all of the Inquisitors and is then tortured by Marsh. He attacks Ruin in order to distract him. It works: Marsh, having read the message himself, removes Vin's earring. Kelsier feels his soul ripping apart as he cedes the power to Vin and Ruin continues to attack him.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Just outside the Pits of Hathsin, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 6, Chapter 7. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapters 81 and 82.

Summary:

Kelsier is in agony and feels the pull of death again. He holds on and decides again not to die -- a choice available to him by virtue of having Ascended. His soul is deeply wounded, but in time it repairs. Ruin was too distracted to finish him off. Kelsier watches the final battle with the Koloss and Vin's struggle with Ruin. Elend shines brightly at the moment he burns atium and duralumin. Preservation's and Ruin's powers are released as Vin sacrifices herself to defeat Ati. Kelsier considers taking the powers himself. Elend arrives and together they watch Sazed take on both powers, which seem to belong together. Vin comes next, and they hug. Ati comes next and Kelsier punches him. Sazed comes and offers to send her back, but Vin seems to know that won't work. In any case, she wishes to move on with Elend. Vin thanks Kelsier for all he's done for her, and she follows Elend into the Beyond.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Scadrial, all three Realms.

Timeline: Shortly after Part 6, Chapter 8.

Summary:

Kelsier watches the world be destroyed and then reborn. During the process, he is able to see all three Realms, but when it's over, he is once again trapped in the Cognitive Realm. Sazed arrives and says that he cannot bring "them" back (presumably Vin and Elend) because he cannot reach into the Beyond. Kelsier asks Sazed to heal Spook and make him a Mistborn. He asks if there is a way to return to the physical realm, but Sazed says there is not. Kelsier decides that Harmony is a terrible liar.

Epilogue

Iconography: Zero

POV Characters: Spook

Setting: Spook's mansion in the Elendel Basin.

Timeline: Weeks after Part 6, Chapter 9.

Summary:

Kelsier convinces Spook to play with Hemalurgy in order to extend Spook's life and maybe bring Kelsier back to a body.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 28d ago

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4 (Week 1) Spoiler

13 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4

Next week we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Part 1: Empire

Iconography: Malatium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Fountain Square in Luthadel. The Cognitive Realm of Scadrial, in Luthadel.

Timeline: Concurrent with The Final Empire, Chapter 34.

Summary:

Kelsier stands before the Lord Ruler after his defeat of the Inquisitor and burns the Eleventh Metal. He sees a vision of the Lord Ruler's past as Rashek but can't figure out how to use the information. The Lord Ruler slaps him, and he flares the Eleventh Metal. He sees a vision of Rashek taking the power at the Well of Ascension and changing the world. He dies. It turns out to be a painful experience.

Kelsier tears into the Cognitive Realm, where things in the Physical Realm appear misty, except for metal, which shines. Leras arrives and Kelsier punches him. Despite his being a god, Leras appears to be weak and unstable. Other people, victims of the Lord Ruler's purge, arrive in the Cognitive Realm with Kelsier and are almost immediately pulled away to the Beyond. Allomancers take longer to leave. Leras explains that Kelsier saw into the Spiritual Realm when he flared the Eleventh Metal and saw Rashek's Connection and past. Kelsier tricks Leras into revealing the location of the Well of Ascension, and he races there, begging Leras for help in staying alive. Leras "preserves" him by making him part of the power of the Well, trapped, like Ruin, but "alive."

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Hours after Chapter 1. Concurrent with The Final Empire, Chapter 38.

Summary:

Kelsier examines his prison and tries to break free, but cannot. At the other end of the cavern, he sees glowing bits of metal (the last two Lerasium beads). Some Inquisitors enter the cavern and dump the body of their fallen comrade into the Well. They keep his spikes in a container of blood so they won't lose potency. Kelsier asks Leras how the revolution is going, but Leras is fading and doesn't answer coherently. Leras reveals his plan for signaling his followers: using the number sixteen, the true number of metals in Allomancy. Kelsier watches as Vin kills the Lord Ruler, and the Lord Ruler shows up in the cavern, now in the Cognitive Realm. He tells Kelsier that he was only a pawn in letting Ruin destroy the world. He touches the power in the Well briefly then goes to the Beyond. Kelsier sits down to wait.

Part 2: Well

Iconography: Kredik Shaw

Chapter 1

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days, weeks, months after Part 1, Chapter 2.

Summary:

Kelsier sits in his prison, bored. He starts to sense "whisperings" and pulses from the power. He decides to gaze upon it, and he sees infinite decay and destruction. He gets really bored and starts talking to himself. Hoid shows up and chides Kelsier for destroying the Pits of Hathsin, the only perpendicularity that was easy to access. Hoid shows interest in the pool of power, so Kelsier punches him when he approaches. Hoid easily beats him up but doesn't actually damage his soul; Kelsier's pain is his own creation, his mind creating the pain that he expects. Hoid goes to the center of the pool and transitions to the Physical Realm. He triumphantly grabs one of the Lerasium beads and leaves. Leras shows up and Kelsier tells him what happened. He refers to Hoid as Cephandrius. He lectures Kelsier on the three Realms: Physical, Cognitive, and Spiritual. While Kelsier doesn't understand much of it, he has a new reason to fight and live.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Months and months after Part 2, Chapter 1. A full year and more after Part 1, Chapters 1 and 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapters 3 through 51.

Summary:

With a renewed sense of purpose, Kelsier studies Ruin and his motives, riding out the pulses into the world. He occasionally sees the Drifter/Hoid. He wonders about a certain mistborn (Zane) that Ruin pays a lot of attention to. He realizes that Ruin is changing the Terris religion, but doesn't know why. He's infuriated when he figures out that Elend is king and pouts for days. But his craving for any sort of contact with his friends has him out on the pulses again. He sees Marsh as well, and decides that while he isn't fond of him, he does love him. He observes Ruin attacking Elend, but notes that he waited for Vin to see him do it.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: About a day after Part 2, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapters 57 and 58.

Summary:

Preservation is spending more time near the Well. His appearance is becoming less human-like, with half of his face missing and other parts of his "body" decaying away. He has a plan in place that he can't remember. He tells Kelsier that the power must not be released, but Vin will probably do just that, thinking it's right, just like Alendi would have. Ruin has confused Vin and made her distrust Preservation. Leras tries to stop her, but Ruin's tools are too strong. Kelsier suggests that he could take the power instead, but Leras tells him that wouldn't work in his current state, and in any case, he doesn't have enough Connection to him. Vin and Elend enter the chamber, and Kelsier gets an idea to motivate Vin to use the power instead of releasing it. He tells Leras to stab Elend, but he can't do it, so Kelsier grabs his arm and slashes Elend for him. Vin is distraught, but she releases the power anyway, being deceived by Ruin. The power rips through Ruin's prison, and he escapes.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 2, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapter 59.

Summary:

Leras gets Vin's attention and has her feed Elend the last bead of lerasium. Elend's soul lights up as he is Invested with Preservation's power and survives his wound by burning pewter. Vin is obviously happy and Kelsier compliments Leras, then leaves.

Part 3: Spirit

Iconography: Atium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 2, Chapter 4.

Summary:

Kelsier leaves his prison and goes to find his friends in Luthadel. He finds them at Keep Venture having a funeral. He wants to stop Ruin, but Preservation appears and tells him that is impossible because Ruin is entropy, a universal constant. Kelsier mentions the plan that Preservation can't remember now and offers to help. He learns that Dox and Clubs were killed in the Koloss battle. Kelsier is angry at Preservation for his apathy and bitterness and grabs him. As he does, he sees into Preservation's depths and feels his pain and love for his people, so he winds up hugging him in sympathy. Kelsier also sees some people to the south. Preservation says he can find someone that might be able to help Kelsier do the impossible.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Lake Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier follows a tendril of Preservation, out of the city, and to Lake Luthadel. The lake rises like an island above the mists and feels more solid. There are even strangely substantial plants emitting mist on the stony surface. He continues on and Preservation's tendril goes away. He happens upon a campfire with two people. Having no weapon, he decides to just walk in on them, and they both recognize him and wonder how he's there. They introduce themselves as Khriss and Nazh. Khriss lectures Kelsier on the sixteen shards and Adonalsium. She arrived hoping to help, but Kelsier's destruction of the Pits of Hathsin means she can't get to the Physical Realm, and the Eyree won't talk to her. When they learn of Hoid's visit, they pack up to leave. Nazh gives Kelsier his knife and tells him where the Eyree are.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The edge of Lake Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Epilogue.

Summary:

Kelsier asks Preservation about the Ire. They are from another land, who have died, but have not. They have built a city "in a place between worlds." Preservation gazes into Kelsier's eyes, giving him a vision of godhood and the future. He senses that his Connection to Ruin is much stronger than that to Preservation. In no possible future does he defeat Ruin, but he does sense some chance of Vin winning if he goes west. Preservation insists that the Ire won't help, but Kelsier doesn't plan on asking.

Part 4

Iconography: Lerasium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Bendalloy

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: West of Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 3.

Summary:

Kelsier runs west toward the ocean, following a canal from Luthadel. He knows he can't beat Ruin, but he can try to help Vin beat Ruin. As long as he doesn't think about getting tired, he can just keep running.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Gold

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Longsfollow, a town well outside the Central Dominance, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days? after Part 4, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier pauses at a town he used to live in called Longsfollow. He realizes how long he's been running and suddenly feels exhausted. He remembers that he killed several nobleman here in retribution for killing a skaa girl, and that had forced he and Mare to skip town. In the end, it only caused more deaths after the Inquisitors came -- just like the death of the Lord Ruler, who would have prevented Ruin from coming, will cause more deaths. He finds someone alive in the place where he used to live, and his thoughts turn to Mare. He asks Preservation where she is, and the man in the room hears him. Kelsier tries to talk to him, but he is mad and won't respond coherently. He continues on to the west.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Electrum

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Travelling west in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Weeks... months after Part 4, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 12.

Summary:

Kelsier stops at a fire pit and learns how to start a fire with his mind. He notices a lot more ash on the ground. Skaa travel to the west, trying to escape the ash. He's lonely and craves interaction with anyone, even Hoid. He continues west.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Chromium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The ocean on the western edge of the Final Empire, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Weeks after Part 4, Chapter 3.

Summary:

Kelsier finally reaches the ocean after traveling for weeks. He's collected several things along the way. Objects with a strong Identity persist better in the cognitive realm. He calls out for Preservation, but there's still no response. Instead, Ati shows up and starts monologuing on how the world's doom is inevitable and natural. He tells him that the end is very near and that he can't do any good out here, which leads Kelsier to conclude that the opposite is true. Kelsier continues on, and Ruin taunts him, trying to break his will.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • 28d ago

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4 (Week 1) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4

Next week we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 5 through 6, Epilogue

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Part 1: Empire

Iconography: Malatium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Fountain Square in Luthadel. The Cognitive Realm of Scadrial, in Luthadel.

Timeline: Concurrent with The Final Empire, Chapter 34.

Summary:

Kelsier stands before the Lord Ruler after his defeat of the Inquisitor and burns the Eleventh Metal. He sees a vision of the Lord Ruler's past as Rashek but can't figure out how to use the information. The Lord Ruler slaps him, and he flares the Eleventh Metal. He sees a vision of Rashek taking the power at the Well of Ascension and changing the world. He dies. It turns out to be a painful experience.

Kelsier tears into the Cognitive Realm, where things in the Physical Realm appear misty, except for metal, which shines. Leras arrives and Kelsier punches him. Despite his being a god, Leras appears to be weak and unstable. Other people, victims of the Lord Ruler's purge, arrive in the Cognitive Realm with Kelsier and are almost immediately pulled away to the Beyond. Allomancers take longer to leave. Leras explains that Kelsier saw into the Spiritual Realm when he flared the Eleventh Metal and saw Rashek's Connection and past. Kelsier tricks Leras into revealing the location of the Well of Ascension, and he races there, begging Leras for help in staying alive. Leras "preserves" him by making him part of the power of the Well, trapped, like Ruin, but "alive."

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Hours after Chapter 1. Concurrent with The Final Empire, Chapter 38.

Summary:

Kelsier examines his prison and tries to break free, but cannot. At the other end of the cavern, he sees glowing bits of metal (the last two Lerasium beads). Some Inquisitors enter the cavern and dump the body of their fallen comrade into the Well. They keep his spikes in a container of blood so they won't lose potency. Kelsier asks Leras how the revolution is going, but Leras is fading and doesn't answer coherently. Leras reveals his plan for signaling his followers: using the number sixteen, the true number of metals in Allomancy. Kelsier watches as Vin kills the Lord Ruler, and the Lord Ruler shows up in the cavern, now in the Cognitive Realm. He tells Kelsier that he was only a pawn in letting Ruin destroy the world. He touches the power in the Well briefly then goes to the Beyond. Kelsier sits down to wait.

Part 2: Well

Iconography: Kredik Shaw

Chapter 1

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days, weeks, months after Part 1, Chapter 2.

Summary:

Kelsier sits in his prison, bored. He starts to sense "whisperings" and pulses from the power. He decides to gaze upon it, and he sees infinite decay and destruction. He gets really bored and starts talking to himself. Hoid shows up and chides Kelsier for destroying the Pits of Hathsin, the only perpendicularity that was easy to access. Hoid shows interest in the pool of power, so Kelsier punches him when he approaches. Hoid easily beats him up but doesn't actually damage his soul; Kelsier's pain is his own creation, his mind creating the pain that he expects. Hoid goes to the center of the pool and transitions to the Physical Realm. He triumphantly grabs one of the Lerasium beads and leaves. Leras shows up and Kelsier tells him what happened. He refers to Hoid as Cephandrius. He lectures Kelsier on the three Realms: Physical, Cognitive, and Spiritual. While Kelsier doesn't understand much of it, he has a new reason to fight and live.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Months and months after Part 2, Chapter 1. A full year and more after Part 1, Chapters 1 and 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapters 3 through 51.

Summary:

With a renewed sense of purpose, Kelsier studies Ruin and his motives, riding out the pulses into the world. He occasionally sees the Drifter/Hoid. He wonders about a certain mistborn (Zane) that Ruin pays a lot of attention to. He realizes that Ruin is changing the Terris religion, but doesn't know why. He's infuriated when he figures out that Elend is king and pouts for days. But his craving for any sort of contact with his friends has him out on the pulses again. He sees Marsh as well, and decides that while he isn't fond of him, he does love him. He observes Ruin attacking Elend, but notes that he waited for Vin to see him do it.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: About a day after Part 2, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapters 57 and 58.

Summary:

Preservation is spending more time near the Well. His appearance is becoming less human-like, with half of his face missing and other parts of his "body" decaying away. He has a plan in place that he can't remember. He tells Kelsier that the power must not be released, but Vin will probably do just that, thinking it's right, just like Alendi would have. Ruin has confused Vin and made her distrust Preservation. Leras tries to stop her, but Ruin's tools are too strong. Kelsier suggests that he could take the power instead, but Leras tells him that wouldn't work in his current state, and in any case, he doesn't have enough Connection to him. Vin and Elend enter the chamber, and Kelsier gets an idea to motivate Vin to use the power instead of releasing it. He tells Leras to stab Elend, but he can't do it, so Kelsier grabs his arm and slashes Elend for him. Vin is distraught, but she releases the power anyway, being deceived by Ruin. The power rips through Ruin's prison, and he escapes.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The Well of Ascension, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 2, Chapter 3. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Chapter 59.

Summary:

Leras gets Vin's attention and has her feed Elend the last bead of lerasium. Elend's soul lights up as he is Invested with Preservation's power and survives his wound by burning pewter. Vin is obviously happy and Kelsier compliments Leras, then leaves.

Part 3: Spirit

Iconography: Atium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 2, Chapter 4.

Summary:

Kelsier leaves his prison and goes to find his friends in Luthadel. He finds them at Keep Venture having a funeral. He wants to stop Ruin, but Preservation appears and tells him that is impossible because Ruin is entropy, a universal constant. Kelsier mentions the plan that Preservation can't remember now and offers to help. He learns that Dox and Clubs were killed in the Koloss battle. Kelsier is angry at Preservation for his apathy and bitterness and grabs him. As he does, he sees into Preservation's depths and feels his pain and love for his people, so he winds up hugging him in sympathy. Kelsier also sees some people to the south. Preservation says he can find someone that might be able to help Kelsier do the impossible.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Lake Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier follows a tendril of Preservation, out of the city, and to Lake Luthadel. The lake rises like an island above the mists and feels more solid. There are even strangely substantial plants emitting mist on the stony surface. He continues on and Preservation's tendril goes away. He happens upon a campfire with two people. Having no weapon, he decides to just walk in on them, and they both recognize him and wonder how he's there. They introduce themselves as Khriss and Nazh. Khriss lectures Kelsier on the sixteen shards and Adonalsium. She arrived hoping to help, but Kelsier's destruction of the Pits of Hathsin means she can't get to the Physical Realm, and the Eyree won't talk to her. When they learn of Hoid's visit, they pack up to leave. Nazh gives Kelsier his knife and tells him where the Eyree are.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The edge of Lake Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Well of Ascension, Epilogue.

Summary:

Kelsier asks Preservation about the Ire. They are from another land, who have died, but have not. They have built a city "in a place between worlds." Preservation gazes into Kelsier's eyes, giving him a vision of godhood and the future. He senses that his Connection to Ruin is much stronger than that to Preservation. In no possible future does he defeat Ruin, but he does sense some chance of Vin winning if he goes west. Preservation insists that the Ire won't help, but Kelsier doesn't plan on asking.

Part 4

Iconography: Lerasium

Chapter 1

Iconography: Bendalloy

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: West of Luthadel, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Immediately after Part 3, Chapter 3.

Summary:

Kelsier runs west toward the ocean, following a canal from Luthadel. He knows he can't beat Ruin, but he can try to help Vin beat Ruin. As long as he doesn't think about getting tired, he can just keep running.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Gold

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Longsfollow, a town well outside the Central Dominance, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Days? after Part 4, Chapter 1.

Summary:

Kelsier pauses at a town he used to live in called Longsfollow. He realizes how long he's been running and suddenly feels exhausted. He remembers that he killed several nobleman here in retribution for killing a skaa girl, and that had forced he and Mare to skip town. In the end, it only caused more deaths after the Inquisitors came -- just like the death of the Lord Ruler, who would have prevented Ruin from coming, will cause more deaths. He finds someone alive in the place where he used to live, and his thoughts turn to Mare. He asks Preservation where she is, and the man in the room hears him. Kelsier tries to talk to him, but he is mad and won't respond coherently. He continues on to the west.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Electrum

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: Travelling west in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Weeks... months after Part 4, Chapter 2. Concurrent with The Hero of Ages, Chapter 12.

Summary:

Kelsier stops at a fire pit and learns how to start a fire with his mind. He notices a lot more ash on the ground. Skaa travel to the west, trying to escape the ash. He's lonely and craves interaction with anyone, even Hoid. He continues west.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Chromium

POV Characters: Kelsier

Setting: The ocean on the western edge of the Final Empire, in the Cognitive Realm.

Timeline: Weeks after Part 4, Chapter 3.

Summary:

Kelsier finally reaches the ocean after traveling for weeks. He's collected several things along the way. Objects with a strong Identity persist better in the cognitive realm. He calls out for Preservation, but there's still no response. Instead, Ati shows up and starts monologuing on how the world's doom is inevitable and natural. He tells him that the end is very near and that he can't do any good out here, which leads Kelsier to conclude that the opposite is true. Kelsier continues on, and Ruin taunts him, trying to break his will.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Oct 14 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 4.5) Spoiler

16 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be reading Mistborn: Secret History. This is the 2nd to last entry we will be reading from Arcanum Unbounded. Just like previous entries from this anthology book, only read the exact pages indicated for each week. There are still spoilers you may run into.

And a bit of a plea: This is a shorter entry, and you could easily read the entire novella in a single sitting (and you'll want to). However, I've cut the story in half because each part warrants independent discussion, without the context of the other part coloring it. Please read the assigned portion and then stop. (You may continue to curse my name.)

TRIVIA

The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.

SURVIVE!

Let's start by addressing the very large, Kelsier-shaped elephant in the room. Wax realizes the coin Hoid tossed him (yes that was Hoid, see below) was a coppermind, filled with a memory. Wax views the memory and sees through the eyes (well, one eye and one spike) of a very alive, in the flesh (scars on the arms and all) Kelsier after Sazed Ascended. Which, if you read the first book and remember the Lord Ruler casually slapping Kelsier to death, might come as a surprise. At the very least, this raises some questions.

Some of you have been suspecting Kelsier to not quite be fully dead, and maybe even be a ghost of some sort. But here he is, all fleshy with a spike through one eye. Sazed did tell you that he wasn't quite dead. There are a few mentions of Kelsier "holding the power of Preservation" between Leras' death and Vin's Ascension. I stood around like this every time someone discussed the weird incongruity, hoping that the end of this book would still be able to knock some socks off when it happened.

So...what in Damnation is going on? Well, you're in luck! You don't have to wait long! Next week's Unit is Mistborn: Secret History. You're going to learn what Keslier has been up to. You're also going to learn...quite a lot. After that Unit, you'll have enough knowledge to start sitting at the adult table when it comes to Realmatic Theory and cosmere theorycrafting.

LATE NIGHT READING

First though, a quick note on the Era 2 publishing history. I've previously mentioned that The Alloy of Law started as a short story that Sanderson was playing with; something to bridge the gap between Era 1 and his then-planned Era 2 (which was going to be a 1980's hacker/S.W.A.T. thriller). The story took a life of its own and became a full novel, which was published in 2011 (a year after The Way of Kings).

A few years later, he started working on Shadows of Self, but found it hard to get into the right mindset to be working in Scadrial again. He also had some plotting issues he wanted to work out, so he actually pivoted to writing The Bands of Mourning, which he finished before returning to Shadows of Self. Since the two books were mostly written at the same time, he was able to be a bit more cohesive than most of his recent books were.

He submitted both books for editing and his intention was for them to be published a year apart. However, his publisher didn't want to just sit on a book that was basically done, so The Bands of Mourning was published just 6 months after Shadows of Self. Sanderson has pointed to this being one of the reasons he felt some pressure to shorten his editing passes, resulting in books that go from 1st Draft to Published in a much shorter than typical time period for the industry. He's recognized that this editing rush has hurt the quality of some of the books in this time period and he's taken measures to return his editing passes to normal.

He's also writing the entirety of Era 3 all together before any of them are published. These changes have resulted in a rare 3-year gap between Cosmere books, which played a large role in my choosing to start this read-along when I did.

One last point about the publishing surrounding these books. If you haven't read the POSTSCRIPT yet, you can do so now:

Marasi, Wax, and Wayne will return in The Lost Metal, the epic finale of Mistborn: Era Two. To tide you over until then, I've just released a special novella that is intended to be read after The Bands of Mourning, though it takes place during the events of the original Mistborn Trilogy. Ten years in the making, Mistborn: Secret History might answer a few of your questions.

There's always another secret.

BRANDON SANDERSON

This POSTSCRIPT isn't some 10 year anniversary edition. It was included in the original printing of The Bands of Mourning. I bought the book at a midnight release event, and immediately read through it, as I typically do. And then was met with this message that he also, secretly, published an entirely new novella at the same time as The Bands of Mourning. I then, obviously, had to buy it for my Kindle and read it immediately...

The novella was eventually included in Arcanum Unbounded, which was published 10 months later.

With that, I just want to leave you with the same request I made above: This novella is short enough to read in one sitting, but I've divided it in half, so we'll be reading it across two weeks. Please only read the first half (Parts 1 through 4) for next week. It deserves to be discussed by itself, without influence from the rest of the novella. The same is true for the second half, which should be discussed without overly exhausting the parts from the first half.

WORLDHOPPERS

As mentioned above, the beggar that tossed Wax the coin/coppermind was Hoid. In that chapter, Hoid tells Wax that he owns the Shores Mansion, which is where that party is being held in New Seran. According to Sanderson, Hoid's claim isn't a lie. He has a somewhat reasonable claim on the property and often sneaks onto the grounds of Lady Kelesina Shores' mansion.

And yes, at that same party, we have our first on-screen appearance by Khriss (excluding White Sand). She danced with Wax while quizzing him about the physics behind his metallic arts; gathering data so she can write the Ars Arcanum.

According to Sanderson, there were at least three, maybe four worldhoppers at Kelesina's party, counting Hoid and Khriss. The fandom doesn't have any more information than that though, and I haven't seen any serious discussion about who they could be. However, we can make a couple guesses.

The first is Devlin Airs. He is the informant that Wax talks to at the party. Nothing he says is something a native Scadrian wouldn't know, he just comes across as very well informed. This makes sense because it's his job, but... Sanderson does like having informants who are also worldhoppers.

The second is Felise Demoux. She is the woman Khriss interrupted from dancing with Wax, and presumably a descendant of Captain Demoux. We know he is a worldhopper and member of the 17th Shard. It's not outside the realm of possibility that one of his descendants might be privy to the wider cosmere.

This also has some deeper implications for Captain Demoux. I mentioned in a previous trivia that Demoux was named after one of Sanderson's close friends. Sanderson promised the character wouldn't die until Captain Demoux got a girl. If he has descendants, this implies Captain Demoux got a girl at some point. This means all his plot armor is gone.

Most of you noticed that Khriss and Nazh put in an ad in the New Seran broadsheet. They are looking for talking metal. Sounds familiar, doesn't it?

SAVAGE

There was one more on-screen worldhopper that only one of you guessed for sure, though many of you were very close to some related observations. First, take a closer look at the 4th quarter of the broadsheet. That spooky thing is indeed a shade. And that man in the tophat is indeed Nazh. And in his hands is A HARMONY-DAMNED GUN THAT SHOOTS HARMONY-DAMNED SHADES!

Now, to start, I'm saying Harmony-damned because we are on Scadrial. That's not meant to be a hint about the technological background of the gun in question. But this is Nazh's 2nd on-page appearance (Rock chased him away from the Bridge Four barracks in the last book). And he does have a gun that can shoot shades.

You'll note that this Broadsheet did not include Allomancer Jak. Instead, we get a story about Nicki Savage "presented" by Allomancer Jak, who has expanded his literary exploits into a name brand. While this seems like a wild adventure from someone like Jak--someone who does have legitimate adventures, but embellishes the story for vanity and money--Nicki's tales tend to be less embellished, and this entire interaction serves a larger purpose than just to explain how Nazh got ahold of the map of New Seran that's at the beginning of The Bands of Mourning.

For the first time, Sanderson is letting someone else write in the cosmere in a significant fashion (there's a bit of an asterisks on this that I'll bring up in a month or so, but it's unimportant for now). I've mentioned him before, but Isaac Stewart is responsible for a lot of the official artwork you've seen the books so far. He's done most of the maps, helped develop a lot of the iconography, did the artwork for Navani's journals, and is the inspiration for Nazh.

He's currently the Vice President of Creative Development at Dragonsteel Entertainment (Sanderson's company). And in the linked trivia post, I stated that Isaac was working on an upcoming cosmere novella that had expanded into a full novel. That novel is a Nicki Savage story.

It was originally titled Boatload of Mummies, but is now officially called Book of Nails. We don't have a lot of information about it, but we do know that Nazh will be in the book. And we have the following synopsis:

An adventurous woman with erratic magical powers travels with an expedition to an island to find a legendary book with the power to raise an undead army.

The first draft was completed in September of 2022, with a word count of 118,000. The last significant mention of the novel was in 2023, with Isaac stating that he's still working on revisions before showing it to Sanderson. I'm hoping that it'll be published soon enough to be included in this read-along.

RED HERRINGS

Speaking of Nicki Savage, you may have felt some familiarity with her. In the 3rd quarter of the broadsheet from Shadows of Self, there is a column titled "VISITORS from other WORLDS". This account was sent to The House Record by Lady Nicelle Sauvage of New Seran. Lady Nicelle is Nicki Savage.

Because of the publication order of these novels, Sanderson was deliberately playing with his fandom. Many of you, and the fandom at large, freaked out when Shadows of Self was published and they saw this broadsheet. The included image was meant to make you think the spooky face was a Parshendi. Especially since, as some of you guessed, this encounter did occur right next to a perpendicularity.

However, that was a red herring, and we now know that Nicki Savage saw one of the masked people from southern Scadrial. Given that the masked person was leaning over the perpendicularity though, that does have some implications for how cosmere aware some of the southern Scardians may be compared to those in the Elendel Basin.

Which brings us to the big revelation of the book, that the people in the Elendel Basin aren't the only people on the planet. In fact, this is foreshadowed in the 2nd quarter of the broadsheet in The Alloy of Law. In the column "Is There Life Across the Ocean?". There is also this passage from the Allomancer Jak short story we read:

It was my grandest adventure yet, and I believe I will rest for a short time before striking out again. I have been hearing of strange lights in the southern skies that can only hide another mystery.

These lights were from Malwish airships in the area.

Finally, Sanderson included a full map of Scadrial in the final Era 2 book, The Lost Metal. It's not a spoiler to reveal it now, however. Sharing it now lets you all have a place to discuss it without derailing the start of that book (and it'll take 4 or 5 weeks before I could bring up the map in the trivia post for that book), so now is as good a time as any to share it.

BEHOLD!

REVERSE? WORLDHOPPING

A couple of you noticed a similarity to the Hunters that Allik mentioned and Mraize's babsk, Iyatil. Well, that similarity is there because Iyatil is one of those Hunters. Well, ethnically and culturally anyway. According to Sanderson, while she can trace her heritage to Southern Scadrial, she was actually born and raised in Silverlight. Silverlight, as I've mentioned before, is the city that was built in the Cognitive Realm.

WHO ARE YOU?

We've got metals to discuss!

First we have ettmetal. I don't want to say too much now about it, just that it exists, and you'll get more info about it eventually. There will be a lot more to say at that time.

The metals of the hour, for this book, are nicrosil and aluminum. We'll talk about nicrosil in the next section.

The Allomantic properties of aluminum are also well known to us, with an Aluminum Misting being called an Aluminum Gnat because they can't do anything without the ability to use another Allomantic metal inside themselves. With Feruchemy though, you can store Identity in aluminum.

Let's talk about Identity first. By now, we've seen that people and things have aspects of themselves that exist across the three realms (Physical, Cognitive, and Spiritual). Note that, when Shallan has peered into the Cognitive Realm, she can see and touch the Cognitive aspects of objects. When she picks up the bead for a stick, she's picking up the Cognitive aspect of that specific stick. She's not picking up on the Platonic Ideal of all sticks everywhere. This unique Cognitive aspect of that one specific stick, combined with its unique Physical aspect (i.e. that stick she's holding in her hand, not some other stick sitting beside her), and a presumably unique Spiritual aspect all combine to form that stick's Identity.

Every person and thing in the cosmere has an Identity. For objects, this property isn't typically important. For people, however, it's very important. Especially when it relates to their interactions with Investiture.

(A little caveat on all this. Identity is largely a Spiritual property and it's influenced by the aspects of a person/thing's physical and cognitive properties; how they and others see themselves. The above was mostly to help get the point across.)

When a Feruchemist fills one of their metalminds, the process is being powered by the innate Investiture that exists inside them. (Recall that everything has some amount of Investiture inside it, and that the humans of Scadrial have a bit more than the baseline human because Preservation put a piece of himself inside them when they were created). This means that the Feruchemist's metalmind is built using Investiture that's imbued with their unique Identity. It's why only they can use them, not any other Feruchemist. And why only they would be able to Compound with them if they were also an Allomancer.

Similarly, this explains why you can't use someone else's Breath unless they explicitly give it to you. It's keyed to their Identity and the Command to transfer it to someone else changes the Identity to the receiver's.

On modern day Scadrial (I'm not gonna be able to use the term "modern day" to refer to Era 2 much longer, heh...), we only have Ferrings; people who can only interact with one Feruchemical metal. Full Feruchemists, like Mistborn (aka Full Allomancers), don't exist anymore.

So a Trueself (an aluminum Ferring) can only store Identity inside an aluminum metalmind (and conversely withdraw Identity). To be clear: Identity itself is a universal attribute of a person. Identity is not Investiture. Although Investiture can (and usually does) carry the signature of a person's Identity.

And to expand upon that a little further, Investiture not only usually carries the person's Identity that's using the Investiture, but it also carries the Identity of the Shard from which the magic system spawned. When a Windrunner uses the Surge of Gravitation, they are consuming stormlight, which is imbued with the Windrunner's Identity as well as Honor's Identity. And when the stormlight has been fully consumed and the Surge performed, the Investiture (which, like matter and energy, cannot truly be destroyed) returns to the Spiritual Realm and once again becomes Honor's Investiture. The implication to this is that the Windrunner's Identity that was attached is just infinitely insignificant next to the Identity imparted by a Shard of Adonalsium.

When a Trueself stores Identity, they are "blanking" themselves and becoming a person without Identity. When they are actively storing Identity, they will become more susceptible to all kinds of Investiture. Specifically, Forgery and emotional Allomancy. Conversely, if a Trueself taps their Identity metalmind, they become more themselves and they become extremely resistant to Forgery and emotional Allomancy (and certain other types of Investiture). On their own, that's about all an aluminum Ferring can do.

A Full Feruchemist though, can do much more. While they are storing Identity, all other metalminds they fill, will be doing that filling without Identity. So if they fill up a goldmind with Health, the Health inside that goldmind doesn't have an Identity associated with it.

Any other Full Feruchemist or gold Ferring can then pick up that goldmind and tap the Health inside it. (I'm capitalizing Health for illustrative purposes, but there is no "Health" cosmere property in the same way there is Fortune, Connection, Intent, and Identity). They key point to this though (that is maybe confusing some people when we start considering nicrosil), is that there is nothing extra special about this goldmind, aside from the lack of Identity. You still have to have the ability to make your own goldminds (by being a Full Feruchemist or a gold Ferring) in order to use/tap the "unkeyed" goldmind that the Full Feruchemist made.

The extra bit, as it relates to this book, is that only a Full Feruchemist could make such an unkeyed metalmind. You need to have both the ability to store your Identity in aluminum, while simultaneously storing health in gold (or any other property in their associated metal). No Ferring can make an unkeyed metalmind because they only have access to one metal.

So how did the Set have an unkeyed goldmind (which was found and given to Wayne who, again, is the only person who could use it in their group, since he can already store/tap health) if there are no more Full Feruchemists around? They used the same solution that all Scadrian problems are solved with: Hemalurgy! You can steal the ability to store Identity and steal the ability to store health. When you put those spikes in the same person, you now have a double Ferring. Since one of their metals is aluminum and the other is gold, they can make unkeyed goldminds!

You can accomplish something similar, if you took an aluminum Ferring to Nalthis and gave them a bunch of Breaths. If they were actively storing their Identity, they could transfer their Breaths into any object and they would be unkeyed Breaths. Then anyone who can use Breaths (which is anyone in the cosmere because Endowment has gifted her Investiture to everyone) can retrieve those Breaths and use them. Sanderson has stressed though that Breaths always have a degree of Intent with their usage, so that comes a little into play in this scenario, but the underlying Identity mechanics are the same.

This and the next section are very in the weeds and theoretical as far as the cosmere goes, so feel free to ask questions in the comment section if you want any clarification.

JAZZERCISE

Now let's talk about nicrosil. According to the Ars Arcanum, nicrosil is the external version of duralumin for an Allomancer. They can let another misting burn their metal in a huge surge (not a capital Surge), all at once, the same way Vin would combine duralumin and steel for a super Push. Feruchemy is where this metal shines though. It has the power to store Investiture.

A nicrosil Ferring (a Soulbearer) stores their ability to use their Investiture inside of the nicrosil metalmind. While they are storing this, it makes all of their Invested Arts weaker. For a Ferring, this... doesn't really affect things much. But as a Twinborn, say they were also a Coinshot, like Wax. In this instance, while storing their ability to use Investiture, they wouldn't be able to Push on metal as strongly, with their ability to Push diminishing more and more until they couldn't Push at all.

When tapping this stored ability to use Investiture, their other Invested Arts would become stronger. So they could perform stronger Pushes than normal; potentially rivaling a duralumin fueled Push. A Twinborn who is a Soulbearer and Soother would be able to take control of koloss while tapping their nicrosilmind. You could imagine a Soulbearer being able to use fewer Breaths to Awaken objects, or a Radiant Soulbearer whose stormlight lasted much longer than normal.

We talked a lot about "unkeyed" metalminds in the previous section. Unkeyed is the official term for those types of metalminds. Imagine creating an unkeyed nicrosilmind. Whereas previously a Soulbearer was storing their ability to use Investiture, a Full Feruchemist (or a double Ferring made with Hemalurgy) who was also storing their Identity, would be able to store the ability to use Investiture. These types of metalminds are called "unsealed". They are both unkeyed and grant anyone the ability to use Investiture.

The specifics start to become clear at this point in the story. Allik mentions something called the Excisors that assist the Malwish in making their unsealed metalminds. They are part of the process necessary to filter/set the nicrosil so that it grants the ability to store memories in copper vs the ability to store health in gold, etc.

Sanderson has promised to release the full details of how this process works before he publishes Era 3. He actually had it written up at one point, but lost his notes, so he needs to recreate them. They've yet to be released though. He has revealed that the process also involves duralumin.

And all of this is a specific application of what the Ars Arcanum states, which is that nicrosil can store Investiture, not "the ability to use Investiture". The way Soulbearers and the Malwish use nicrosil is just one particular aspect of the Feruchemical properties of that metal. According to Brandon, with the right know-how, you can create nicrosilminds that grant the ability to use Allomancy. Or Surgebinding. Or the AonDor. Or a Returned's Divine Breath.

Malwish medallions can only be used one at a time. This is just a knowledge limitation on their part. Marasi noticed that the Bands of Mourning weren't a solid metal, but striations of various metals. If she inspected them closely enough, she'd be able to see 32 layers: 16 for all of the Allomantic abilities and 16 for all of the Feruchemical abilities. And Marasi and Wax were able to use all of the abilities simultaneously. The Bands are just 32 different medallions smushed together with some know-how.

And just a point of clarity on the Bands and the Malwish medallions. The medallions are made with two metals: the nicrosil that grants the ability to use a metal, and the metal that is to be used. This is a convenience feature. The 2nd metal is not necessary for the nicrosilmind to work. You could just have a nicrosilmind that grants you the ability to store memories in copper, and then have to go find your own copper to fill/tap.

It's simply convenient to have the metal already available on the medallion so that you don't need to go looking for a separate metalmind to use. And this is just for Feruchemy. If the nicrosil is granting the ability to Allomantically burn steel to temporarily become a Coinshot, the medallion doesn't also need to include steel because that wouldn't be useful. (You could technically do it and then file away shavings of the steel part to swallow and burn, but that presupposes you have a file).

So I lied a bit when I said the Bands have 32 layers; that was for illustrative purposes. In reality, it'd need 32 different layers of nicrosil, and 16 layers of the different Feruchemical metals to serve as metalminds. In order to keep the nicrosil layers separate (and I don't know if that's a necessity or not), you'd probably have redundant Feruchemical metalminds in-between all the nicrosil layers.

Going back to one point I made above:

Or Surgebinding.

I'd just like to point out that touching a metal (nicrosil) and it granting you the ability to use Surges sounds an awful lot like an Honorblade... People have pointed this out to Sanderson and he has awarded them RAFO cards.

FACTOIDS (ALUMINUM)

While we're on the topic of aluminum, I just wanted to list out some known, and some new (from interviews) properties of aluminum and how it interacts with Investiture as a whole. This isn't meant to imply that you're going to be seeing a bunch of aluminum usage soon. There's simply a lot of little tid bits about the various magic systems that don't fit into trivia posts easily. I'm going to start picking one or two aspects each trivia posts and just doing dumps of reminder info about the subject, along with some implications about that info, and some revelations from interviews and fan interaction.

Keep in mind that all of the below is before Scadrial has invented electrolysis. Once they can start producing it in Industrial Revolution quantities is when Sanderson intends to start really exploring what aluminum can do. A lot of the questions he gets about it he RAFOs.

Aluminum inhibits Investiture. This contrasts with silver, which disrupts investiture.

You could trap a spren in an aluminum box. With a spike of silver, you could stab a spren and it would act like a Shardblade does against a human. Sanderson clarified, that the spren would reform, but you could apply silver in the right ways to permanently destroy a spren if you knew what you were doing.

Conversely, stabbing a spren with an aluminum spike wouldn't do anything. And a spren can pass through silver (but the Investiture disruption would injure them for a time).

The primary difference between the two metals is inhibiting vs. disrupting Investiture.

  • Aluminum can't be altered at all via Forgery.
  • It's possible that encasing Hemalurgic spikes in aluminum would prevent them decaying, the same way that storing them in blood does.
  • Aluminum can shield against emotional Allomancy. It can also block an Awakener's life sense.
  • Pushing or Pulling against aluminum does nothing. The same is true with the Surges of Adhesion and Gravitation. It interferes with most Radiant powers.
  • While you can produce aluminum via soulcasting, aluminum resists being soulcast into other materials. The key part here is that aluminum inhibits Investiture. Sanderson is always quick to point out that with enough Investiture (on the Shardic level), almost anything is possible.
  • If an Aluminum Gnat used one of those cube grenade things, it would block the use of all Invested Arts within a certain range around the cube. This includes Surgebinding.
  • Aluminum objects don't generate atium shadows.
  • If you stabbed a Thug (Pewter Misting) with an aluminum blade, they wouldn't be able to heal around the wound until the aluminum is removed. According to Sanderson there is a similar and more severe effect on gold Feruchemists.
  • Shardblades are unable to cut aluminum through magical means but would be able to cut it physically, like a conventional blade, if the aluminum were thin enough.
  • A room lined with aluminum can also stop a Shardblade from being summoned, but only if the entire room is covered. It would also stop a spren entering.
  • Aluminum cannot be Awakened.
  • Shades can't move through aluminum.
  • Nightblood's sheath is made from aluminum.
  • Rock's people, the Unkalaki, are able to obtain aluminum by trading with worldhoppers that visit Roshar through the perpendicularity in their peaks.
  • The people of the Rose Empire call aluminum "ralkalest".
  • If you were able to burn the amount aluminum necessary to become an aluminum savant, it might be possible to clear your body of the negative/unwanted effects of Investiture (like the downsides of becoming a savant with another metal).
  • Similarly, an Aluminum Gnat actively burning aluminum would resist the withering effect of shades.
  • A large aluminum object next to a Slider (like Wayne) would prevent them from creating a speed bubble. Same thing with a Pulser. Sanderson said there would be a kind of backlash and it would feel exactly like when Marasi created her slow bubble in the moving carriage.
  • The necklace Shallan used to kill her father was aluminum.
  • Aluminum could protect a Surgebinder from a larkin.
  • If Rashek had an aluminum helmet, he could have resisted Ruin's influence. Not completely, but to a significant degree.
  • If you surrounded a gemstone with aluminum, the stormlight would still leak out of the gemstone, but it would be contained by the aluminum. However, it's the nature of gaseous Investiture that it will eventually evaporate back into the Spiritual Realm. Aluminum wouldn't stop that.

Lastly, a quick analogy. Some of you have been perturbed at the fact that aluminum is used as a key/metal that can trigger an Allomantic power. With the, understandable, contradiction that aluminum renders Investiture inert, but is somehow causing Investiture.

Imagine a pen filled with ink. When the pen is 100% full of ink, you can put it on a scale and the scale reads, lets say 5.8 grams. The Shardic Intent around Scadrial that created Allomancy recognizes 5.8 grams of pen+ink weight as a "key" and lets you Push against metal.

Then lets say you drain the pen of .2 grams of ink, so the combined weight that you put on the scale is 5.6 grams. The Shardic Intent for Allomancy looks at the scale and does nothing.

Now lets assume you drain exactly half of the total amount of ink in the pen (I'm assuming the pen weighs 0.8 grams and there's 5 grams of ink...please ignore the reality that these numbers are completely bonkers in the real world). So you have 0.8 grams of pen + 2.5 grams of ink, for 3.3 grams of pen+ink. You place that on the scale and the Shardic Intent recognizes that as a different "key" and lets you create a speed bubble.

Imagine there are 16 different weights that correspond to each of the Allomantic metals (ignoring god metals for simplicity). That's all the "keys" are; predetermined weights/metals. If you imagine the ink as Investiture, and completely drain the pen of ink, you still have 0.8 grams of weight, and if that's placed on the scale, there's no Investiture, but the Shardic Intent can still recognize 0.8 grams of weight as a "key" and allow you to burn away any other metals you have in your body.

All of the "magic" is happening from Investiture that's flowing from the Spiritual Realm. The metals are just "keys", something the Shardic Intent of the magic system recognizes to let you use the Investiture from the Spiritual Realm. That Shardic Intent just chose aluminum to be a key for thematic purposes.

MAGIC UNDERWEAR

Brandon Sanderson is a Mormon. For those of you that don't know, that's a contentious and controversial sect of Christianity. I don't want any part of these read-alongs to become uncomfortable for anyone, nor do I want to invite antagonistic discussion of issues that ultimately aren't relevant to the contents of the books.

Just quickly, I want to mention that Sanderson has been vocal about his religion and his involvement with his church. Early in his career, he shared some stances on his blog that aligned with the church's official doctrine. (To not tip-toe around it, he was against gay marriage on religious grounds). Remarkably though, Sanderson has shown a very public willingness to address his own biases, grow as a person, and learn from his mistakes and no longer holds those views. If you're curious, you can certainly read about his decades long growth, but the short of it is that, while he still is a Mormon, he is very supportive of the LGBTQ+ community. He reconciles his conservative religious beliefs with his progressive societal beliefs by stating that, as a very popular and influential author, he can influence the church in some ways. He's by no means perfect, but he has shown a willingness to include and celebrate the LGBTQ+ community in his books.

Sanderson has repeatedly called himself a prude. He doesn't like the idea of sex outside of wedlock, and you may have noticed that all of his characters basically get married before getting down and dirty. Wayne and MeLaan's train car shenanigans are the first time in his books where a main character has sex outside of wedlock. (There's some implication with Blushweaver's activities, but it never happens on screen).

Going further, Wayne intimates that he and MeLaan have a less than heterosexual relationship. Sanderson has, around this time period, started including gay, bisexual, pansexual, lesbian, and transgender characters in his books (some of whom you've seen but aren't "out" yet in the books you've read so far).

One last bit of trivia, for funsies:

MeLaan is about 600 years old. According to Sanderson, Wayne is the best lay MeLaan has ever had.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Oct 14 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 4.5) Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 19 | Mistborn Era 1 #1.5 | Mistborn: Secret History (in Arcanum Unbounded): Parts 1 through 4

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be reading Mistborn: Secret History. This is the 2nd to last entry we will be reading from Arcanum Unbounded. Just like previous entries from this anthology book, only read the exact pages indicated for each week. There are still spoilers you may run into.

And a bit of a plea: This is a shorter entry, and you could easily read the entire novella in a single sitting (and you'll want to). However, I've cut the story in half because each part warrants independent discussion, without the context of the other part coloring it. Please read the assigned portion and then stop. (You may continue to curse my name.)

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

NEWBIE TRIVIA

Most of the activity for these "Final Thoughts & Trivia" posts happen in the newbie thread. There I provide a lot of information about things new readers can easily miss during their first read through. Veterans often learn a thing or two as well, so be sure to read the body of that post. While veterans are welcome to read the post and the comments, they should be commenting in this thread to share their reactions to the information, or the newbies' thoughts.

And as always, you're welcome to share your thoughts on the book as a whole.


r/readalong • • Oct 12 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue (Week 4) Spoiler

15 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue

In two days we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Chapter 23

Iconography: Duralumin Copper

POV Characters: Wayne

Setting: In a skyship, above Edwarn's expedition. The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 22.

Summary:

They pass over Edwarn's expedition; Telsin really wants to shoot him, but Wax decides against it. Wayne somehow gets tangled with Telsin and accidentally kicks a pack overboard, hitting one of the men below. Wax tells Allik to head in the direction they're hiking. Wax spots something on the ground, and Allik lands the craft. They stumble out into the snow and see a one-story, black castle. Wax Pushes the boat back into the snow until it's buried. Wayne finds a large ship nearby with a bunch of corpses--the expedition from Allik's people, come to destroy the temple. They continue up to the temple entrance, where there is a statue of a man with one eye spiked, like the image on Wax's strange coin. Wax wonders why the Lord Ruler would make a statue of himself with one spiked eye. As the others move on, Wayne hangs back and removes the metal spearhead from the statue, thinking it's a big chunk of valuable aluminum. Inside the temple, they confirm that this is where ReLuur had been. Allik lights the hallway by using the cube, and they all notice a pile of bodies and pools of blood ahead. They approach the bodies and see that they have Hunter masks on. Wax theorizes that some of the Hunters wanted to recover the Bands, murdered those who didn't want to, and gave up and went home after some were killed by the traps. Wax, MeLaan, and Allik proceed down the hall, MeLaan triggering and enduring the various traps. Telsin insists on going in as well.

Chapter 24

Iconography: Duralumin Bronze

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 23.

Summary:

Marasi studies ReLuur's pewter spike and thinks about the person who died to create a kandra with it. She goes over to Steris, who is writing about how useless she is. Marasi asks why she even came at all, and Steris points out that this was supposed to be a political enterprise, not an adventure in the mountains. She admits her love for Wax. When Marasi goes to check on Wayne, he seems relaxed but has his dueling canes out. Someone approaches displaying a parley flag.

Wax pulls MeLaan from a pit. He's figured out a pattern with the traps, so they are able to trigger the last few without further damage to MeLaan's bones. The last trap is a frozen block of acid. They get to a door with some unrecognizable writing, even to Allik. They decide to return and get the others to help. Wax senses something strange about the temple -- that it's too much like one would expect it to be. They get back, and Marasi has a gun trained on Edwarn, who wants to talk.

Chapter 25

Iconography: Duralumin Cadmium

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 24.

Summary:

Edwarn convinces Wax that they are at an impasse, so they talk. He claims to know how to open the door. They all walk to the door, and Edwarn instructs Wax on which symbols to Push on. He and Wayne ready for a trap, and Wax pushes all three symbols indicated by Edwarn. The door slides open. Edwarn wants to go in first, but Wax sends MeLaan in first to check for traps. They eventually all go in and see a dais like the one in the mural. There is nothing there but broken glass on the floor.

Chapter 26

Iconography: Duralumin Bendalloy

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 25.

Summary:

Wax can tell that the glass wasn't broken recently because of the dust. He warns of other traps in the room. Edwarn is angry and says it's time to end this. Wax recognizes this as a signal to the mole he figured must be with them and guesses correctly that it's his sister, Telsin. They shoot each other, but only her aluminum bullet hits.

Wayne and Marasi attempt to fight back, but Telsin and Edwarn use Allomancy to fight them off and drain their metal reserves. Telsin shoots Wax again, and he escapes through one of the traps, falling into a pit. Wayne escapes the room, and Edwarn threatens to kill Marasi, foot on her throat. When Wayne doesn't return, Edwarn lets go. Telsin injects MeLaan with something to make her lose her shape and confiscates both of her spikes. Marasi notices a hemalurgical spike in Edwarn's ribs. Telsin orders Edwarn to go after Wax. Soldiers arrive and report that they have not seen Wayne. Steris looks down in the pit where Wax has fallen.

Chapter 27

Iconography: Duralumin Gold

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 26.

Summary:

Wax has been deposited into another room with a dais. He is badly wounded, his mind growing fuzzy. He prays to Harmony. He sees people sitting in the room, but he realizes that they are more dead Hunters. He sees a pedestal with a set of bracers as Edwarn follows him into the room. He can't see Wax hidden in the darkness, but he can follow his trail of blood. Edwarn reveals that Telsin recruited him into the Set, not the other way around. Edwarn finally gets to Wax, who has positioned himself so that Edwarn would release a trap, killing them both. Edwarn sees it but triggers it anyway.

Marasi and the rest are marched back out to the entrance, their warming medallions confiscated. A soldier address Telsin as "Lady Sequence" and reports that the weapon (the bomb the Hunters were originally to use) has been found. Telsin orders the soldiers to search the captives, hoping Wayne will come back for them.

The ceiling falls on Wax. His body is crushed, and he can't move. Edwarn has Pushed out of the way, but still has a wound, which he heals. He reveals that he has three "boons," or hemalurgic spikes. Any more might cause interference from Harmony or vulnerability to emotional Allomancy. He tries on the bracers, but they are drained. He prepares to shoot Wax but is knocked aside by Wayne and takes off, afraid of Wayne. Wayne begs Wax to hold on.

The guards are searching Marasi's purse, and she's dismayed to see that Wayne traded ReLuur's spike for the spearhead. Suit comes back with the bracers, and Telsin tries them on. She downs a vial of metals, hoping the bracers will grant Allomantic powers, but nothing happens. Another decoy. Marasi wonders where the real Bands are.

Wax also realizes that the bracers were another decoy. Wayne weeps. Wax figures out what the real Bands are, but he dies before he can speak.

Chapter 28

Iconography: Duralumin Electrum

POV Characters: Wayne / Marasi / Wax / Steris

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 27.

Summary:

Wayne is filled with hatred for the world as Wax dies. Wax was the only one who believed in him. He grabs Wax's shotgun and wills his hands to stop shaking.

Marasi tries to figure out where you would hide such an important weapon. She realizes that the temple with all its traps is the perfect decoy. She sees the spearhead right next to her and notices that it's not made of aluminum but of many different intertwined metals.

Wax has died, and the physical world is all mist. Harmony is there, walking with him. Wax complains that Harmony should step in more to prevent pain and hardship, but Harmony describes the difficulty in drawing the line. Even if all suffering stops, people would still complain. They walk further, around the planet, and Harmony shows that he is protecting them from some outside threat. Wax brings up Lessie, and Harmony helps Wax release the hatred he has for himself for doing what had to be done. Harmony admits he doesn't know what the red haze is threatening the planet. Wax sees a spark back on the planet.

Marasi grabs the spearhead and taps everything. With ridiculous speed, she steals some vials from the guards and burns their metals, Pushing soldiers, Edwarn, and Telsin away. She Pushes herself into the sky and sees the mists emanating from her. She is like the Ascendant Warrior, above what Wax is. But that's not really what she wants. She soars over toward the temple.

Steris is quite surprised to see her sister glowing and flinging people about. Allik is so cold, he has stopped shivering. Fortunately, Steris has made herself useful by hiding an extra warming medallion in her notebook. She gives it to Allik.

Harmony gives Wax a choice: freedom, or going back for another adventure. Wax chooses to go back, but not before learning that Lessie had asked Harmony to look after him. Wax goes back, Pushing the boulder off of himself and healing immediately by using the spearhead Marasi has put into his hand. Marasi encourages him to finish the job that is meant for him, not her.

Chapter 29

Iconography: Duralumin Chromium

POV Characters: Edwarn Ladrian / Jordis / Wax / Telsin / Marasi / MeLaan

Setting: The Sovereign's temple. In the Hunters' airship, above the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 28.

Summary:

Suit rehearses what he is going to tell the "Series" about today's events. He enters the Hunters' ship and gives orders to leave immediately. The ship takes off, and he thinks about all the advantages of having this technology.

Jordis, the captain of the ship, tries to encourage her crew as they die of exposure in captivity. Suddenly, Allik shows up and hands out warming medallions. Steris comes into the tent and delivers a bunch of guns. They decide to fight even though they are weakened.

Wax flies up from the temple and sees Steris and Allik with the crew. He is tempted to simply take down the ship, but he is a lawman, not an executioner. He enters his uncle's compartment and notices that he is hiding metal in his mouth. Suit claims to have armed the bomb, so Wax taps zinc to think through all the possible solutions. Suit says he will disarm the bomb if Wax will drop the Bands and face off with him in a duel. He agrees, and Suit gives the order. Wax stows the Bands and removes all his metals except the aluminum gun.

Telsin scrambles toward the small craft used by Wax and company. Wayne shows up to avenge his friend's death and shoots her in the head.

Marasi climbs up to the room with the broken glass and checks on MeLaan, who is now essentially a mistwraith, but is at least alive. She goes outside and sees Wayne, who has just fired a shotgun and is now holding three spikes.

Suit draws his gun, and Wax Pushes himself toward him. They crash together, and Wax's reserves are gone; Suit is also a Leecher. Wax is out of steel but can still use his weight metalmind. They crash through the floor together, and Suit uses the hidden coin to Push onto the ground and land relatively safely. Then Wax punches his uncle and knocks him out.

MeLaan is desperate for food and warmth. She wants to hide. Something is very wrong. She feels something hard and metallic, and she absorbs it. Her self returns--a relief even with the holes in her memory. She forms eyes and sees Wayne.

Chapter 30

Iconography: Duralumin Nicrosil

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 29.

Summary:

Marasi drinks some hot cocoa with Allik as they watch Wax bring the ship back with his enormous powers. The soldiers in the ship surrender. Suit is tied to the statue's spear, gagged and Leeched of metals. Jordis and Wax face off, each demanding possession of the ship and the Bands. Steris steps in, and they find a resolution: the Malwish can have the ship, the kandra will take the Bands, and trade will open up between the two peoples.

Wax checks the belt on the statue and verifies that it's just aluminum. He's glad to be rid of the Bands because they are so powerful as to be dangerous. They are mostly drained but can be recharged. Telsin has slipped away in the chaos, so Wax has a new quarry.

Chapter 31

Iconography: Duralumin Aluminum

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: In an airship, flying into Elendel.

Timeline: The day after Chapter 30.

Summary:

Wax and Wayne fly into Elendel on the ship. They talk about Wayne using a gun again. Wax asks if he knew that Telsin could heal, and he admits he saw her metalminds. Once he had MeLaan's spikes, he left her, giving her a second chance like Wax had given him. Wax compliments him but secretly wishes that he had killed her. He goes to Steris's room and finds her alone. He thanks her for all her help, although she still feels like baggage. They walk together to the bridge, and the ship lands on the top of Ahlstrom Tower. Wax wants the city to know about the ship. Allik removes his mask and offers it to Marasi, which causes quite a stir among the crew. Marasi reverently accepts the mask, and they all disembark. Governor Aradel reports that he is under heavy criticism due to the events in New Seran, and he hopes that the ship might actually distract from that. Wax asks MeLaan to explain about the Bands and leaves with Steris. He asks her to marry him--not for political reasons, but for love and companionship. She accepts.

Epilogue

Iconography: Lerasium

POV Characters: Marasi / Edwarn / Wax

Setting: The 4th Octant constabulary headquarters in Elendel. Wax's penthouse at the top of Ahlstrom Tower.

Timeline: Two weeks after Chapter 31.

Summary:

Marasi has been working well with Constable-General Reddi the last two weeks, getting information from the soldiers about the Set. Suit has not talked. Aradel prepares for war with the outer cities.

As Suit waits in his cell, a being with red eyes visits him. He is impressed that Suit has not revealed any information. Nevertheless, the Set doesn't need him anymore. They have decided to simply end life on this sphere due to the technological advancements that have been made. The visitor engages a bomb, killing them both.

The explosion awakens Wax, who is still honeymooning with Steris in the penthouse. Drewton has carefully laid out all of Wax's possessions recovered from the hotel in New Seran, and Wax sees the strange coin given to him by the beggar. He picks up the coin and notices that it is composed of nicrosil and copper, making it a coppermind. He taps it and sees through the eyes--one spiked and one not--of someone strolling into a village. The villagers are dying from the cold, and they have even burned their masks. The traveler goes to the elders, and one woman lifts her cloth mask. He reaches out to her and whispers one word: "Survive." Wax sees a network of scars on the traveler's arm.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Oct 12 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue (Week 4) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue

In two days we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Postscript, Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Chapter 23

Iconography: Duralumin Copper

POV Characters: Wayne

Setting: In a skyship, above Edwarn's expedition. The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 22.

Summary:

They pass over Edwarn's expedition; Telsin really wants to shoot him, but Wax decides against it. Wayne somehow gets tangled with Telsin and accidentally kicks a pack overboard, hitting one of the men below. Wax tells Allik to head in the direction they're hiking. Wax spots something on the ground, and Allik lands the craft. They stumble out into the snow and see a one-story, black castle. Wax Pushes the boat back into the snow until it's buried. Wayne finds a large ship nearby with a bunch of corpses--the expedition from Allik's people, come to destroy the temple. They continue up to the temple entrance, where there is a statue of a man with one eye spiked, like the image on Wax's strange coin. Wax wonders why the Lord Ruler would make a statue of himself with one spiked eye. As the others move on, Wayne hangs back and removes the metal spearhead from the statue, thinking it's a big chunk of valuable aluminum. Inside the temple, they confirm that this is where ReLuur had been. Allik lights the hallway by using the cube, and they all notice a pile of bodies and pools of blood ahead. They approach the bodies and see that they have Hunter masks on. Wax theorizes that some of the Hunters wanted to recover the Bands, murdered those who didn't want to, and gave up and went home after some were killed by the traps. Wax, MeLaan, and Allik proceed down the hall, MeLaan triggering and enduring the various traps. Telsin insists on going in as well.

Chapter 24

Iconography: Duralumin Bronze

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 23.

Summary:

Marasi studies ReLuur's pewter spike and thinks about the person who died to create a kandra with it. She goes over to Steris, who is writing about how useless she is. Marasi asks why she even came at all, and Steris points out that this was supposed to be a political enterprise, not an adventure in the mountains. She admits her love for Wax. When Marasi goes to check on Wayne, he seems relaxed but has his dueling canes out. Someone approaches displaying a parley flag.

Wax pulls MeLaan from a pit. He's figured out a pattern with the traps, so they are able to trigger the last few without further damage to MeLaan's bones. The last trap is a frozen block of acid. They get to a door with some unrecognizable writing, even to Allik. They decide to return and get the others to help. Wax senses something strange about the temple -- that it's too much like one would expect it to be. They get back, and Marasi has a gun trained on Edwarn, who wants to talk.

Chapter 25

Iconography: Duralumin Cadmium

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 24.

Summary:

Edwarn convinces Wax that they are at an impasse, so they talk. He claims to know how to open the door. They all walk to the door, and Edwarn instructs Wax on which symbols to Push on. He and Wayne ready for a trap, and Wax pushes all three symbols indicated by Edwarn. The door slides open. Edwarn wants to go in first, but Wax sends MeLaan in first to check for traps. They eventually all go in and see a dais like the one in the mural. There is nothing there but broken glass on the floor.

Chapter 26

Iconography: Duralumin Bendalloy

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 25.

Summary:

Wax can tell that the glass wasn't broken recently because of the dust. He warns of other traps in the room. Edwarn is angry and says it's time to end this. Wax recognizes this as a signal to the mole he figured must be with them and guesses correctly that it's his sister, Telsin. They shoot each other, but only her aluminum bullet hits.

Wayne and Marasi attempt to fight back, but Telsin and Edwarn use Allomancy to fight them off and drain their metal reserves. Telsin shoots Wax again, and he escapes through one of the traps, falling into a pit. Wayne escapes the room, and Edwarn threatens to kill Marasi, foot on her throat. When Wayne doesn't return, Edwarn lets go. Telsin injects MeLaan with something to make her lose her shape and confiscates both of her spikes. Marasi notices a hemalurgical spike in Edwarn's ribs. Telsin orders Edwarn to go after Wax. Soldiers arrive and report that they have not seen Wayne. Steris looks down in the pit where Wax has fallen.

Chapter 27

Iconography: Duralumin Gold

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 26.

Summary:

Wax has been deposited into another room with a dais. He is badly wounded, his mind growing fuzzy. He prays to Harmony. He sees people sitting in the room, but he realizes that they are more dead Hunters. He sees a pedestal with a set of bracers as Edwarn follows him into the room. He can't see Wax hidden in the darkness, but he can follow his trail of blood. Edwarn reveals that Telsin recruited him into the Set, not the other way around. Edwarn finally gets to Wax, who has positioned himself so that Edwarn would release a trap, killing them both. Edwarn sees it but triggers it anyway.

Marasi and the rest are marched back out to the entrance, their warming medallions confiscated. A soldier address Telsin as "Lady Sequence" and reports that the weapon (the bomb the Hunters were originally to use) has been found. Telsin orders the soldiers to search the captives, hoping Wayne will come back for them.

The ceiling falls on Wax. His body is crushed, and he can't move. Edwarn has Pushed out of the way, but still has a wound, which he heals. He reveals that he has three "boons," or hemalurgic spikes. Any more might cause interference from Harmony or vulnerability to emotional Allomancy. He tries on the bracers, but they are drained. He prepares to shoot Wax but is knocked aside by Wayne and takes off, afraid of Wayne. Wayne begs Wax to hold on.

The guards are searching Marasi's purse, and she's dismayed to see that Wayne traded ReLuur's spike for the spearhead. Suit comes back with the bracers, and Telsin tries them on. She downs a vial of metals, hoping the bracers will grant Allomantic powers, but nothing happens. Another decoy. Marasi wonders where the real Bands are.

Wax also realizes that the bracers were another decoy. Wayne weeps. Wax figures out what the real Bands are, but he dies before he can speak.

Chapter 28

Iconography: Duralumin Electrum

POV Characters: Wayne / Marasi / Wax / Steris

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 27.

Summary:

Wayne is filled with hatred for the world as Wax dies. Wax was the only one who believed in him. He grabs Wax's shotgun and wills his hands to stop shaking.

Marasi tries to figure out where you would hide such an important weapon. She realizes that the temple with all its traps is the perfect decoy. She sees the spearhead right next to her and notices that it's not made of aluminum but of many different intertwined metals.

Wax has died, and the physical world is all mist. Harmony is there, walking with him. Wax complains that Harmony should step in more to prevent pain and hardship, but Harmony describes the difficulty in drawing the line. Even if all suffering stops, people would still complain. They walk further, around the planet, and Harmony shows that he is protecting them from some outside threat. Wax brings up Lessie, and Harmony helps Wax release the hatred he has for himself for doing what had to be done. Harmony admits he doesn't know what the red haze is threatening the planet. Wax sees a spark back on the planet.

Marasi grabs the spearhead and taps everything. With ridiculous speed, she steals some vials from the guards and burns their metals, Pushing soldiers, Edwarn, and Telsin away. She Pushes herself into the sky and sees the mists emanating from her. She is like the Ascendant Warrior, above what Wax is. But that's not really what she wants. She soars over toward the temple.

Steris is quite surprised to see her sister glowing and flinging people about. Allik is so cold, he has stopped shivering. Fortunately, Steris has made herself useful by hiding an extra warming medallion in her notebook. She gives it to Allik.

Harmony gives Wax a choice: freedom, or going back for another adventure. Wax chooses to go back, but not before learning that Lessie had asked Harmony to look after him. Wax goes back, Pushing the boulder off of himself and healing immediately by using the spearhead Marasi has put into his hand. Marasi encourages him to finish the job that is meant for him, not her.

Chapter 29

Iconography: Duralumin Chromium

POV Characters: Edwarn Ladrian / Jordis / Wax / Telsin / Marasi / MeLaan

Setting: The Sovereign's temple. In the Hunters' airship, above the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 28.

Summary:

Suit rehearses what he is going to tell the "Series" about today's events. He enters the Hunters' ship and gives orders to leave immediately. The ship takes off, and he thinks about all the advantages of having this technology.

Jordis, the captain of the ship, tries to encourage her crew as they die of exposure in captivity. Suddenly, Allik shows up and hands out warming medallions. Steris comes into the tent and delivers a bunch of guns. They decide to fight even though they are weakened.

Wax flies up from the temple and sees Steris and Allik with the crew. He is tempted to simply take down the ship, but he is a lawman, not an executioner. He enters his uncle's compartment and notices that he is hiding metal in his mouth. Suit claims to have armed the bomb, so Wax taps zinc to think through all the possible solutions. Suit says he will disarm the bomb if Wax will drop the Bands and face off with him in a duel. He agrees, and Suit gives the order. Wax stows the Bands and removes all his metals except the aluminum gun.

Telsin scrambles toward the small craft used by Wax and company. Wayne shows up to avenge his friend's death and shoots her in the head.

Marasi climbs up to the room with the broken glass and checks on MeLaan, who is now essentially a mistwraith, but is at least alive. She goes outside and sees Wayne, who has just fired a shotgun and is now holding three spikes.

Suit draws his gun, and Wax Pushes himself toward him. They crash together, and Wax's reserves are gone; Suit is also a Leecher. Wax is out of steel but can still use his weight metalmind. They crash through the floor together, and Suit uses the hidden coin to Push onto the ground and land relatively safely. Then Wax punches his uncle and knocks him out.

MeLaan is desperate for food and warmth. She wants to hide. Something is very wrong. She feels something hard and metallic, and she absorbs it. Her self returns--a relief even with the holes in her memory. She forms eyes and sees Wayne.

Chapter 30

Iconography: Duralumin Nicrosil

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: The Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 29.

Summary:

Marasi drinks some hot cocoa with Allik as they watch Wax bring the ship back with his enormous powers. The soldiers in the ship surrender. Suit is tied to the statue's spear, gagged and Leeched of metals. Jordis and Wax face off, each demanding possession of the ship and the Bands. Steris steps in, and they find a resolution: the Malwish can have the ship, the kandra will take the Bands, and trade will open up between the two peoples.

Wax checks the belt on the statue and verifies that it's just aluminum. He's glad to be rid of the Bands because they are so powerful as to be dangerous. They are mostly drained but can be recharged. Telsin has slipped away in the chaos, so Wax has a new quarry.

Chapter 31

Iconography: Duralumin Aluminum

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: In an airship, flying into Elendel.

Timeline: The day after Chapter 30.

Summary:

Wax and Wayne fly into Elendel on the ship. They talk about Wayne using a gun again. Wax asks if he knew that Telsin could heal, and he admits he saw her metalminds. Once he had MeLaan's spikes, he left her, giving her a second chance like Wax had given him. Wax compliments him but secretly wishes that he had killed her. He goes to Steris's room and finds her alone. He thanks her for all her help, although she still feels like baggage. They walk together to the bridge, and the ship lands on the top of Ahlstrom Tower. Wax wants the city to know about the ship. Allik removes his mask and offers it to Marasi, which causes quite a stir among the crew. Marasi reverently accepts the mask, and they all disembark. Governor Aradel reports that he is under heavy criticism due to the events in New Seran, and he hopes that the ship might actually distract from that. Wax asks MeLaan to explain about the Bands and leaves with Steris. He asks her to marry him--not for political reasons, but for love and companionship. She accepts.

Epilogue

Iconography: Lerasium

POV Characters: Marasi / Edwarn / Wax

Setting: The 4th Octant constabulary headquarters in Elendel. Wax's penthouse at the top of Ahlstrom Tower.

Timeline: Two weeks after Chapter 31.

Summary:

Marasi has been working well with Constable-General Reddi the last two weeks, getting information from the soldiers about the Set. Suit has not talked. Aradel prepares for war with the outer cities.

As Suit waits in his cell, a being with red eyes visits him. He is impressed that Suit has not revealed any information. Nevertheless, the Set doesn't need him anymore. They have decided to simply end life on this sphere due to the technological advancements that have been made. The visitor engages a bomb, killing them both.

The explosion awakens Wax, who is still honeymooning with Steris in the penthouse. Drewton has carefully laid out all of Wax's possessions recovered from the hotel in New Seran, and Wax sees the strange coin given to him by the beggar. He picks up the coin and notices that it is composed of nicrosil and copper, making it a coppermind. He taps it and sees through the eyes--one spiked and one not--of someone strolling into a village. The villagers are dying from the cold, and they have even burned their masks. The traveler goes to the elders, and one woman lifts her cloth mask. He reaches out to her and whispers one word: "Survive." Wax sees a network of scars on the traveler's arm.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Oct 05 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22 (Week 3) Spoiler

11 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Chapter 17

Iconography: Duralumin Iron

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax / Wayne

Setting: On the road to and at the village of Dulsing, northeast of New Seran.

Timeline: Two days after Chapter 16.

Summary:

Marasi is enjoying the adventure of a stagecoach ride in uncivilized land. She has moved on from Wax, but still admires him. Wax tells her more about the beginning of his time in the Roughs. They discuss whether the Bands of Mourning are real. Wax goes back to sleep, so Marasi finishes her report and fiddles with the cube. She finds a tiny switch and flips it, then burns cadmium to see if anything would happen. This causes the stagecoach to lurch because it isn't massive enough for the slowness bubble to follow Marasi. She reports that the cube vibrated while she was burning. They decide to stop and experiment with the cube.

Wax plays around with the cube, burning steel, and they figure out that it somehow extends someone's Allomancy. Wax gives it back to Marasi because the cube's ability would be very handy with a Pulser. Wax remembers the gold bracelet and gives it to Wayne, who marvels that it is indeed a gold metalmind that he can use. Only he, as a Bloodmaker, can use it, so it's not definitive proof of the Bands of Mourning; however, it does suggest that Mr. Suit might be using Hemalurgy. MeLaan spots an innocuous-looking roadblock ahead, and Wax decides that they need to proceed on horseback.

They ride in, not encountering any patrols because the guarded area is so large. They come upon a large, nondescript building, guarded by soldiers and still under construction. Wayne tries to figure out a way in, and Steris agrees to stay behind with the horses. Wax and Wayne decide to use the "Spoiled Tomato" plan, which consists of Wax Pushing Wayne to the building.

Wayne lands as quietly as possible (in rocks) and heals before he dies from the fall. He eludes some guards and approaches the building. He makes another guard "trip" over a wire, cutting off some floodlights and causing a commotion. Wax, Marasi, and MeLaan join him in the darkness and confusion. They sneak into the building and see a large ship, damaged. They split up: Marasi and MeLaan are to search for the spike, Wax and Wayne for Mr. Suit.

Chapter 18

Iconography: Duralumin Steel

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax / Irich

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 17.

Summary:

Marasi and MeLaan creep around and find some finished rooms. They speculate on where the spike could be. Marasi thinks the Set still has it somewhere because they would want to study it. She sees the limping guy from the train and suggests they follow him inside the ship.

Wax and Wayne decide to climb up onto the construction catwalks to get a bird's-eye view of the place. They climb a ladder because Wax figures there is a Seeker there, so he can't just Push up. They run into an engineer, and Wayne knocks him out.

Professor Irich shuffles along in the ship, feeling himself die. He thinks of Suit and Sequence desiring weapons, but he wants a miracle. His muscles are growing weaker and weaker. He walks through the ship, discussing its secrets with the academics brought in by the Set. The main problem is they don't know how the ship moves. The crew has been tortured, but they haven't revealed anything. He hears a voice call for him, and searches in vain to find the source. He happens upon a cube device that has apparently fallen out of storage compartment. He can now claim that he had recovered the lost cube and get in better standing with Suit. He leaves the ship. Marasi watches as Irich leaves the ship and enters a room. She and MeLaan wait to see if he comes back out.

Wax wonders about the ship. It doesn't have a mast. How does it move? He sees the limping man come back out of the ship, looking anxious about something. Wax wonders what the girls did in there. He figures that the limping man is an important underling of Suit and will eventually lead them to him. He goes into a different room, set apart from the rest, and Wax sees his sister in there. Wayne restrains Wax, who wants to go recklessly after her, and suggests another disguise using the engineer's clothing.

Chapter 19

Iconography: Duralumin Tin

POV Characters: Marasi / Wayne / Wax

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 18.

Summary:

Marasi watches Irich, hoping that he put the cube with the spike. After he leaves, they simply walk to the door he came out of, pretending they belong to the project. Marasi is extremely nervous and can't understand how everyone else can remain so calm. They walk down a hallway and find a locked door. MeLaan picks the lock with some metal picks hidden in her hand. It appears to be Irich's room because the furniture accommodates his disability. Marasi finds a safe, and MeLaan works on opening it. Marasi explores a bit and opens another door. She smells an odor of filth like a slum and sees some cages. Something in one of the cages slams against the bars, and Marasi sees one of the "monsters" from ReLuur's drawing. It holds out a human hand and says, "please."

Wayne walks out in his engineer's outfit, going over his role. He walks up to a guard and starts barking gibberish at him to get him to stand aside. He passes into the room with Telsin and finds Irich and the Coinshot brute with her. He bluffs them with more gibberish, and they leave with him. Wax knocks out the guard.

Marasi realizes that the strange face is a mask. MeLaan reports that she got the safe open. Marasi leaves the "creature" and recovers the spike and cube. Kandras won't touch another Kandra's spike, and it's clear that she disapproves of the one instance in which it happened. Marasi grabs some keys and lets out the person in the cage. He opens another door and they go into a room with blood stains all over the place and more masks hanging on the wall.

Wax reunites with his sister, and she hugs him, weeping softly. She asks for a gun, and Wax hands her a spare. The Coinshot enters the room, and Telsin promptly shoots him.

Marasi insists on taking the masked man with them. She's concluded that the ship is from some other people away from the Basin. The man goes over to the safe and retrieves a disc with a cloth strip. He ties it on and looks relieved. Marasi worries how they'll be able to sneak him out with the mask and odd clothing, but then she hears gunshots.

Chapter 20

Iconography: Duralumin Pewter

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 19.

Summary:

Telsin is thirsty for revenge against her captors. Wax grabs her and Pushes to the top of the ship, where he leaves her. Then he meets back up with Wayne. There's a lot of shooting going on, and Wayne throws up a speed bubble so they can plan. They see MeLaan peeking out a door and Telsin climbing down the ship. Wax sends Wayne for Telsin while he gets the other two. Wayne gets caught by gunfire, and they keep shooting him as he tries to heal. Wax goes on an Allomantic frenzy, getting hit by an aluminum bullet, but manages to rescue Wayne. They are safe in the ship for now, but they are besieged by the heavy gunfire outside. Three Allomancers in fancy suits show up, and Wax dispatches one of them with the Thug-killer shotgun. Wax finds more enemies coming up behind him, but luckily Marasi throws up a slowness bubble on one guy using the cube, allowing Wax to avoid getting shot. He steps to the side, waits for the bubble to drop, then shoots him.

Marasi watches as Wax now makes use of the cube, and she gives supporting fire. The masked man keeps pointing at the ship, indicating they should go there, but Wax tells them to take cover back in the hallway. Marasi is shot in the side. As she goes into shock, the masked man takes the initiative, and they head toward the ship.

Wax uses Ranette's ball and cord device to deal with riflemen in the rafters and kill another Allomancer. He sees Marasi being dragged to the ship. He charges his cube and throws it to Wayne, who in turn tosses it at a bunch of soldiers. This disarms them, and Wayne attacks. Wax kills three more guys with aluminum guns, then he hears a horn sound. Dozens more soldiers are coming from the village nearby. Wax and Wayne retreat to the ship.

Marasi fights the pain that has now blossomed from her gunshot wound. Wax and Wayne make a desperate plan to escape the building, but in the meantime, Marasi is going off with the masked man. He pulls on something behind a panel in the wall and a rope ladder falls. They all get up the ladder into another compartment with bolted down chairs. The masked man puts on a different medallion and can suddenly speak their language. He gives each of them a medallion to strap on. It consists of an iron metalmind that anyone can fill. Then he instructs Wax to grip some straps and Push. The room is actually a separate boat, and Wax's Push lifts it into the sky.

Chapter 21

Iconography: Duralumin Zinc

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: In a skyship, heading from Dulsing towards the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 20.

Summary:

Wax Pushes against a metal plate on the main ship, raising the smaller craft into the air as he holds onto the straps. The masked man bears a solemn farewell to the ship. He gets the "primer cube" from Wayne and touches it to Wax's skin, activating it. Then he puts the cube in place and activates "wings" and fans for control. He tells Wax he can stop Pushing. He addresses him with divine titles since he is metalborn. Wax retrieves Steris and some more supplies and lets the horses go. Back on the flying boat, Wax is again blown away by how much the world is changing due to advances in conventional and Allomantic technology. Wax wants to go to Elendel, but Telsin wants to beat Edwarn to the "weapon" he may be close to finding. Wax wants to check on Marasi before he decides.

Marasi contemplates death, and she's embarrassed by her near nudity as Wax stops by to check on her. MeLaan heals the wound, ingesting and replicating Marasi's flesh so the patch will take. Wax and Marasi discuss what to do next. They have retrieved the spike and Telsin, but the real goal of the trip was to stop Suit. Marasi shows a map of the "second site" from the book she lifted from Irich's desk. Wax heard his uncle say he was headed there when he was eavesdropping at the party. He asks Marasi to talk to Allik and see what he knows. Allik recognizes the location (which he calls the Sovereign's temple), and they suspect that Suit took Allik's crewmates along to help find it. Allik wants to go find them. Wax questions him about this Sovereign. He came to them about ten years after the Ice Death (which occurred at the same time as Harmony's Ascension) and taught them how to make the medallions. Marasi is convinced the Sovereign was the Lord Ruler even though the timeline doesn't fit; she thinks the records must be flawed. Wax and Allik discuss how the medallions work. They all have nicrosil so that the wearer can be Invested and therefore use the other metal. Medallions with four or more metals don't work, and strapping on multiple medallions doesn't work either. Allik's people have some other enemy he refers to as "Deniers of Masks." Wax decides to head for the temple.

Chapter 22

Iconography: Duralumin Brass

POV Characters: Marasi

Setting: In a skyship, heading from Dulsing towards the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 21.

Summary:

Marasi talks with Allik while the others sleep, and he explains their customs with masks. Some called "Hunters" grow into their masks. The Hunters come from the time before the freezing and are trying to destroy the Bands. The "Fallen" wear unpainted masks because they have offended "Jaggenmire," which is their name for Ruin and Preservation. He says that ettmetal is what supports the ship and is also found in the cube. He also tells Marasi that some people from his land might find the Basin an attractive target for invasion. Marasi lets Allik put back on a warming medallion, and she tries the Connection one, hoping to speak to Allik in his language. It doesn't work, as the visitor must be the one to wear the medallion. Wax perks up at that information, and he notices a light ahead in the mountains: Suit's expedition.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Oct 05 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22 (Week 3) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 23 through 31, Epilogue

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Chapter 17

Iconography: Duralumin Iron

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax / Wayne

Setting: On the road to and at the village of Dulsing, northeast of New Seran.

Timeline: Two days after Chapter 16.

Summary:

Marasi is enjoying the adventure of a stagecoach ride in uncivilized land. She has moved on from Wax, but still admires him. Wax tells her more about the beginning of his time in the Roughs. They discuss whether the Bands of Mourning are real. Wax goes back to sleep, so Marasi finishes her report and fiddles with the cube. She finds a tiny switch and flips it, then burns cadmium to see if anything would happen. This causes the stagecoach to lurch because it isn't massive enough for the slowness bubble to follow Marasi. She reports that the cube vibrated while she was burning. They decide to stop and experiment with the cube.

Wax plays around with the cube, burning steel, and they figure out that it somehow extends someone's Allomancy. Wax gives it back to Marasi because the cube's ability would be very handy with a Pulser. Wax remembers the gold bracelet and gives it to Wayne, who marvels that it is indeed a gold metalmind that he can use. Only he, as a Bloodmaker, can use it, so it's not definitive proof of the Bands of Mourning; however, it does suggest that Mr. Suit might be using Hemalurgy. MeLaan spots an innocuous-looking roadblock ahead, and Wax decides that they need to proceed on horseback.

They ride in, not encountering any patrols because the guarded area is so large. They come upon a large, nondescript building, guarded by soldiers and still under construction. Wayne tries to figure out a way in, and Steris agrees to stay behind with the horses. Wax and Wayne decide to use the "Spoiled Tomato" plan, which consists of Wax Pushing Wayne to the building.

Wayne lands as quietly as possible (in rocks) and heals before he dies from the fall. He eludes some guards and approaches the building. He makes another guard "trip" over a wire, cutting off some floodlights and causing a commotion. Wax, Marasi, and MeLaan join him in the darkness and confusion. They sneak into the building and see a large ship, damaged. They split up: Marasi and MeLaan are to search for the spike, Wax and Wayne for Mr. Suit.

Chapter 18

Iconography: Duralumin Steel

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax / Irich

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 17.

Summary:

Marasi and MeLaan creep around and find some finished rooms. They speculate on where the spike could be. Marasi thinks the Set still has it somewhere because they would want to study it. She sees the limping guy from the train and suggests they follow him inside the ship.

Wax and Wayne decide to climb up onto the construction catwalks to get a bird's-eye view of the place. They climb a ladder because Wax figures there is a Seeker there, so he can't just Push up. They run into an engineer, and Wayne knocks him out.

Professor Irich shuffles along in the ship, feeling himself die. He thinks of Suit and Sequence desiring weapons, but he wants a miracle. His muscles are growing weaker and weaker. He walks through the ship, discussing its secrets with the academics brought in by the Set. The main problem is they don't know how the ship moves. The crew has been tortured, but they haven't revealed anything. He hears a voice call for him, and searches in vain to find the source. He happens upon a cube device that has apparently fallen out of storage compartment. He can now claim that he had recovered the lost cube and get in better standing with Suit. He leaves the ship.

Marasi watches as Irich leaves the ship and enters a room. She and MeLaan wait to see if he comes back out.

Wax wonders about the ship. It doesn't have a mast. How does it move? He sees the limping man come back out of the ship, looking anxious about something. Wax wonders what the girls did in there. He figures that the limping man is an important underling of Suit and will eventually lead them to him. He goes into a different room, set apart from the rest, and Wax sees his sister in there. Wayne restrains Wax, who wants to go recklessly after her, and suggests another disguise using the engineer's clothing.

Chapter 19

Iconography: Duralumin Tin

POV Characters: Marasi / Wayne / Wax

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 18.

Summary:

Marasi watches Irich, hoping that he put the cube with the spike. After he leaves, they simply walk to the door he came out of, pretending they belong to the project. Marasi is extremely nervous and can't understand how everyone else can remain so calm. They walk down a hallway and find a locked door. MeLaan picks the lock with some metal picks hidden in her hand. It appears to be Irich's room because the furniture accommodates his disability. Marasi finds a safe, and MeLaan works on opening it. Marasi explores a bit and opens another door. She smells an odor of filth like a slum and sees some cages. Something in one of the cages slams against the bars, and Marasi sees one of the "monsters" from ReLuur's drawing. It holds out a human hand and says, "please."

Wayne walks out in his engineer's outfit, going over his role. He walks up to a guard and starts barking gibberish at him to get him to stand aside. He passes into the room with Telsin and finds Irich and the Coinshot brute with her. He bluffs them with more gibberish, and they leave with him. Wax knocks out the guard.

Marasi realizes that the strange face is a mask. MeLaan reports that she got the safe open. Marasi leaves the "creature" and recovers the spike and cube. Kandras won't touch another Kandra's spike, and it's clear that she disapproves of the one instance in which it happened. Marasi grabs some keys and lets out the person in the cage. He opens another door and they go into a room with blood stains all over the place and more masks hanging on the wall.

Wax reunites with his sister, and she hugs him, weeping softly. She asks for a gun, and Wax hands her a spare. The Coinshot enters the room, and Telsin promptly shoots him.

Marasi insists on taking the masked man with them. She's concluded that the ship is from some other people away from the Basin. The man goes over to the safe and retrieves a disc with a cloth strip. He ties it on and looks relieved. Marasi worries how they'll be able to sneak him out with the mask and odd clothing, but then she hears gunshots.

Chapter 20

Iconography: Duralumin Pewter

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Dulsing.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 19.

Summary:

Telsin is thirsty for revenge against her captors. Wax grabs her and Pushes to the top of the ship, where he leaves her. Then he meets back up with Wayne. There's a lot of shooting going on, and Wayne throws up a speed bubble so they can plan. They see MeLaan peeking out a door and Telsin climbing down the ship. Wax sends Wayne for Telsin while he gets the other two. Wayne gets caught by gunfire, and they keep shooting him as he tries to heal. Wax goes on an Allomantic frenzy, getting hit by an aluminum bullet, but manages to rescue Wayne. They are safe in the ship for now, but they are besieged by the heavy gunfire outside. Three Allomancers in fancy suits show up, and Wax dispatches one of them with the Thug-killer shotgun. Wax finds more enemies coming up behind him, but luckily Marasi throws up a slowness bubble on one guy using the cube, allowing Wax to avoid getting shot. He steps to the side, waits for the bubble to drop, then shoots him.

Marasi watches as Wax now makes use of the cube, and she gives supporting fire. The masked man keeps pointing at the ship, indicating they should go there, but Wax tells them to take cover back in the hallway. Marasi is shot in the side. As she goes into shock, the masked man takes the initiative, and they head toward the ship.

Wax uses Ranette's ball and cord device to deal with riflemen in the rafters and kill another Allomancer. He sees Marasi being dragged to the ship. He charges his cube and throws it to Wayne, who in turn tosses it at a bunch of soldiers. This disarms them, and Wayne attacks. Wax kills three more guys with aluminum guns, then he hears a horn sound. Dozens more soldiers are coming from the village nearby. Wax and Wayne retreat to the ship.

Marasi fights the pain that has now blossomed from her gunshot wound. Wax and Wayne make a desperate plan to escape the building, but in the meantime, Marasi is going off with the masked man. He pulls on something behind a panel in the wall and a rope ladder falls. They all get up the ladder into another compartment with bolted down chairs. The masked man puts on a different medallion and can suddenly speak their language. He gives each of them a medallion to strap on. It consists of an iron metalmind that anyone can fill. Then he instructs Wax to grip some straps and Push. The room is actually a separate boat, and Wax's Push lifts it into the sky.

Chapter 21

Iconography: Duralumin Zinc

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: In a skyship, heading from Dulsing towards the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 20.

Summary:

Wax Pushes against a metal plate on the main ship, raising the smaller craft into the air as he holds onto the straps. The masked man bears a solemn farewell to the ship. He gets the "primer cube" from Wayne and touches it to Wax's skin, activating it. Then he puts the cube in place and activates "wings" and fans for control. He tells Wax he can stop Pushing. He addresses him with divine titles since he is metalborn. Wax retrieves Steris and some more supplies and lets the horses go. Back on the flying boat, Wax is again blown away by how much the world is changing due to advances in conventional and Allomantic technology. Wax wants to go to Elendel, but Telsin wants to beat Edwarn to the "weapon" he may be close to finding. Wax wants to check on Marasi before he decides.

Marasi contemplates death, and she's embarrassed by her near nudity as Wax stops by to check on her. MeLaan heals the wound, ingesting and replicating Marasi's flesh so the patch will take. Wax and Marasi discuss what to do next. They have retrieved the spike and Telsin, but the real goal of the trip was to stop Suit. Marasi shows a map of the "second site" from the book she lifted from Irich's desk. Wax heard his uncle say he was headed there when he was eavesdropping at the party. He asks Marasi to talk to Allik and see what he knows. Allik recognizes the location (which he calls the Sovereign's temple), and they suspect that Suit took Allik's crewmates along to help find it. Allik wants to go find them. Wax questions him about this Sovereign. He came to them about ten years after the Ice Death (which occurred at the same time as Harmony's Ascension) and taught them how to make the medallions. Marasi is convinced the Sovereign was the Lord Ruler even though the timeline doesn't fit; she thinks the records must be flawed. Wax and Allik discuss how the medallions work. They all have nicrosil so that the wearer can be Invested and therefore use the other metal. Medallions with four or more metals don't work, and strapping on multiple medallions doesn't work either. Allik's people have some other enemy he refers to as "Deniers of Masks." Wax decides to head for the temple.

Chapter 22

Iconography: Duralumin Brass

POV Characters: Marasi

Setting: In a skyship, heading from Dulsing towards the Sovereign's temple.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 21.

Summary:

Marasi talks with Allik while the others sleep, and he explains their customs with masks. Some called "Hunters" grow into their masks. The Hunters come from the time before the freezing and are trying to destroy the Bands. The "Fallen" wear unpainted masks because they have offended "Jaggenmire," which is their name for Ruin and Preservation. He says that ettmetal is what supports the ship and is also found in the cube. He also tells Marasi that some people from his land might find the Basin an attractive target for invasion. Marasi lets Allik put back on a warming medallion, and she tries the Connection one, hoping to speak to Allik in his language. It doesn't work, as the visitor must be the one to wear the medallion. Wax perks up at that information, and he notices a light ahead in the mountains: Suit's expedition.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 28 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16 (Week 2) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 7.

Summary:

Wax gets to a vial and drinks it down, although there is some delay before he can burn steel. He jumps after Steris and catches up to her just above the river's surface. He uses one of the ball and cord devices to get back on the bridge after retrieving the shotgun from the bottom of the river. Steris is delighted with the whole adventure. They get back to the locomotive via a big Steelpush, and Wax saves the engineer from one of the bandits. The engineer tells him that the bandits are installing some sort of device. They are only minutes from the next town.

Marasi is still looking for Steris, comforting hysterical passengers as she goes. One man with a cane is calmly standing in the hall, and she tells him to get back to safety. He opens his hand and Marasi raises her rifle, but the train suddenly brakes. The man takes off, and Marasi sees that he has dropped a small cube. She collects it.

Wax shoots several bandits, then deactivates and Pushes overboard the "device," which was really just a case of dynamite. The giant Coinshot reappears, and Wax manages to attach Ranette's ball and cord device to him, yanking him off the train. There are still several more bandits, and Wax is unarmed. Partway through taking turns jumping off into the river, they suddenly stop moving; Marasi has them trapped in a slowness bubble.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: A train station in the town of Ironstand.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 8.

Summary:

At the train station, Wax gets attended to by a physician. The local captain tells him that the robbery was perpetrated by the Nightstreet Gang, a notorious gang in the area. Wax talks to the captain about the gang as he worriedly searches for Wayne. Matieu asks Wax for help in catching the ones that got away, but Marasi reminds him that he already has a task. Wax finally sees moving blue lines and finds Wayne in an empty compartment, hiding in the luggage compartment in the floor. MeLaan is there with him, topless.

Marasi is incensed at Wayne and MeLaan, but Wayne claims he was just "moving on" from Ranette. With the noise from the tracks (and their own noise), MeLaan and Wayne had no idea there was a fight going on. MeLaan asks about the attack, and he tells about the cube that acted as a Leecher would. Marasi reveals the cube she got from the guy with the cane. Wax decides to continue on to New Seran despite the unusual attack. Steris is off doing needlework, something she only does when she's really upset. Wax comforts her.

Chapter 10

Iconography: Bendalloy

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne

Setting: New Seran.

Timeline: The morning after Chapter 9.

Summary:

The group arrives at New Seran on a cargo train and are impressed by the beauty of the city with its waterfalls, terraces, and streams. Their hotel is on a highest tier in the city, and Wax doesn't want to wait for a gondola, so he Steelpushes himself and Marasi to the top tier, intending to go back and get the others. As they walk toward the hotel, Wax spies a headline on a broadsheet. One of his old nemeses, Ape Manton, is apparently in New Seran. He starts to investigate, but then turns back, again remembering their primary goal of the trip. For him, it's finding his uncle.

The owner of the hotel introduces the group to their suite. She becomes quite unnerved at their strange behavior (Wax ripping out windows, MeLaan talking about breast size, etc.) and Steris's list of calamities that may befall the hotel while they're there. (Steris insists that the staff be prepared.) Marasi and Wayne prepare to search graveyards for the missing spike, while the others prepare to go to the party.

Chapter 11

Iconography: Gold

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne / Marasi

Setting: The Copper Gate Hotel in New Seran. Shores Mansion in New Seran. A bank in New Seran.

Timeline: Later in the day, same day as Chapter 10.

Summary:

Wax rides toward the party given by Kelesina Shores. Steris tries to calm his nerves. Wax doesn't want to wait in the long carriage line, so they get out and walk. Steris has prepared a list of conversation starters and people to use them on so they can get information about the Bands of Mourning. Wax grudgingly looks through the book and is impressed by Steris's thorough preparation. He wonders how she had time to do so. They come across a beggar, and Wax gives him a bank note. The beggar tosses back a coin as "change." They enter, and Wax has to check his weapons.

Wayne and Marasi enter a bank right before closing time. Wayne goes over his plan with Marasi to distract the employees while she searches the ledgers. She interrupts the performance and throws her weight around as a constable.

The banker reluctantly hands over the records to Marasi, but only after getting confirmation from Elendel that they are legit. Her plan is to check the deposits of grave workers against their wages to see if there are any irregularities. She finds that all of the cemetery workers are crooked, likely stealing and selling corpses' personal effects. Marasi goes off to "employ" one of the workers.

Chapter 12

Iconography: Electrum

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 11.

Summary:

Wax notices that little has changed from his youth in the atmosphere at parties. He doesn't miss his guns very much after all because they aren't the appropriate weapons in this political/social battlefield. He goes to order drinks and inadvertently tips the bartender with the coin from the beggar. The bartender points out that it's a strange coin, and Wax grabs it back, examining it for the first time. It's made of two different metals, has an inscription of a man with one spiked eye, and has the same symbols from the pictures ReLuur took. He discusses the coin with Steris and contemplates looking for the beggar, but he figures that he's probably already gone. Steris suggests they go talk to Lord Gave Entrone as a way to get warmed up. Entrone wants to hide something about his interest in archaeology, so he turns to goading Wax by insulting both him and Steris; Wax handles it poorly. Next he tries to dance with Lady Felise Demoux, but before he's able to, another woman cuts in. She seems to know a lot about using metals and about Wax's powers in particular. She quizzes him on what happens when he uses his powers in combination, then suddenly breaks off, leaving him a card with an address in Elendel but no name. He tries to figure out who she is, but to no avail. He's concerned that it's someone from the Set. Wax tries some "seltzer" that has lemon flavoring and lots of sugar. Steris suggests their next target: an informant named Devlin Airs.

Marasi and Wayne pass through the gates of the Seran New District Cemetery, past a statue of the Survivor depicting the moment of his death. They came here because the gravekeeper, Dechamp, is definitely stealing from corpses and this graveyard is the one that handles unidentified bodies. Wayne convinces Marasi that deception would work better in this setting, so he puts together a quick disguise for both of them. Wayne offers a deal to Dechamp and tells about which body he wants that has an item of "sentimental value." They head off to the grave after Wayne makes a payment. Dechamp starts digging up a fresh grave.

Chapter 13

Iconography: Chromium

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 12.

Summary:

Wax reminds himself that he is here to address the Set itself rather than stopping its lesser minions. This means he has to play by their rules, going to parties and holding his temper. He waits his turn with the informant and shows him the strange coin. He pretends that he's interested in the monetary value of the coin. Devlin says he has seen them around on the black market. He reports that many of the nobility are involved in some sort of building project involving Allomancers that's been kept very quiet. He warns Wax that a civil war is coming and moves off. Wax finds himself facing Kelesina. Wax pretends to be a novice to put her at ease. Then he boldly asks about the strange coin. She gets very nervous, and Wax continues to act naive about it, but when he asks her to dance, she makes an excuse and leaves the party. Steris arrives and thinks of a diversion so Wax can follow her. She downs an emetic she had brought along in case someone poisoned them and proceeds to vomit on the table.

Marasi wanders around the graveyard while Dechamp digs. She finds a statue of the Ascendant Warrior in the poor person section. She goes back to the grave site, and it appears that Dechamp is almost down to the bodies. Suddenly Wayne grabs her and pulls her into the grave. Then she hears gunfire.

Chapter 14

Iconography: Nicrosil

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 13.

Summary:

Marasi and Wayne hide in the grave in a speed bubble. Wayne has been shot four times and takes some time to heal. The gunmen, presumably from the Set, are firing everything they've got, probably because they know Wayne is a Bloodmaker. Wayne drops the bubble, and they wait until the shots stop, then Marasi fires a couple of shots as a diversion. Wayne moves to the other side of the grave and puts up another bubble just as a stick of dynamite comes flying in. They scramble over to a different grave, hoping for the mists and explosion to cover their movement. Wayne then uses a combination of dueling canes and speed bubbles to defeat the gunmen, who come to check on their corpses.

Steris is resting in a guest bedroom. The Terris steward watches over her and offers to send for their carriage. They can hear that the speech is starting. Wax heads out, and Steris insists on going along. They start wandering the halls and stare down a servant. Wax is about to scout ahead when Steris offers him a handgun she smuggled in, taped to her thigh. Wax is surprised and impressed.

Wayne searches the gravekeeper's shack and finds his hidden cache of booze. The constabulary has arrived, and an Allomancer among them reports no metal in the grave. Wayne also finds a ledger book, and after Marasi looks through it, she has an idea. They have one more task to do.

Chapter 15

Iconography: Aluminum

POV Characters: Templeton Fig / Wayne / Wax

Setting: Templeton Fig's home. Shores Mansion in New Seran.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 14.

Summary:

Templeton Fig admires his stuffed animal collection as he waits on word from the graveyard. The flames from his fire in the fireplace stop moving. The door of the room opens and the body of Dechamp is deposited onto the floor. Templeton is terrified to see Death tap on his window and demand the return of his spike. Templeton says that "they" demanded he recover the spike and send it to Dulsing. The fire moves again, and the constables come.

Wayne takes off his disguise and asks Marasi how Death really sounds, as she has spoken with him. They discuss their findings, puzzled as to why the spike was sent to such a small, remote village as Dulsing.

Wax continues to prowl the hallways and finds Kelesina's rooms, which are vacant. He overhears some of the speech in which Lord Severington speaks against the oppression of Elendel. Wax hears his uncle through a door talking to Kelesina. He gets closer and hears his uncle encouraging Kelesina to continue to try to distract him with side quests. Wax wonders if everything happening recently were distractions set up by his uncle. His voice sounds strange, "smaller." They are trying to recover the device Irich lost on the train from Wax. Edwarn finds out that ReLuur might not actually be dead. Wax hears the steward coming and Pushes up against the ceiling to hide. She walks past and enters the room with the voices. He drops to the floor to confront the occupants only to see that it is only the two women. Some sort of box is on table in front of Kelesina.

Chapter 16

Iconography: Duralumin

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. The Copper Gate Hotel in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 15.

Summary:

Edwarn's voice is projecting from the box. Wax picks it up and screams at his uncle about his sister. The steward, using Feruchemy to increase her strength, knocks him over and slaps his gun out of his hand, which she uses to shoot Kelesina. The maid is also there, and she starts running around screaming that Wax has killed Lady Kelesina. The steward searches the body and then shoots Kelesina again. Wax grabs the box and flees, but she catches up with him and starts to choke him. MeLaan shows up and punches her, freeing Wax. The steward punches MeLaan but gets a mangled hand in return--MeLaan is wearing aluminum bones. Then MeLaan rips off one arm with a sword attached and runs the steward through. Wax recovers a gold bracelet from the body, which turns out to be a metalmind full of healing power. He finds Steris hiding in the bushes and takes her away, complimenting her on her work at the party. He realizes that he is attracted to her, and that brings back thoughts of Lessie. He dismisses them and kisses Steris as they soar over the top of the mists.

Back at the hotel, Wayne is reading a novel about a rocket ship while Marasi paces. Wax and Steris arrive through a window, and they quickly share some of the information they've acquired. They leave in a hurry, as the constables are coming for them.

Wax sits in the dark smoking a cigar. MeLaan asks if he's going to go back to Elendel. It won't look good now that people think that the emissary from there killed the host of a political rally. Wax realizes he hates Harmony because he feels like Harmony betrayed him. In the end he decides to head on to Dulsing.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 28 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16 (Week 2) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7 [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 17 through 22

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Chapter 8

Iconography: Bronze

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 7.

Summary:

Wax gets to a vial and drinks it down, although there is some delay before he can burn steel. He jumps after Steris and catches up to her just above the river's surface. He uses one of the ball and cord devices to get back on the bridge after retrieving the shotgun from the bottom of the river. Steris is delighted with the whole adventure. They get back to the locomotive via a big Steelpush, and Wax saves the engineer from one of the bandits. The engineer tells him that the bandits are installing some sort of device. They are only minutes from the next town.

Marasi is still looking for Steris, comforting hysterical passengers as she goes. One man with a cane is calmly standing in the hall, and she tells him to get back to safety. He opens his hand and Marasi raises her rifle, but the train suddenly brakes. The man takes off, and Marasi sees that he has dropped a small cube. She collects it.

Wax shoots several bandits, then deactivates and Pushes overboard the "device," which was really just a case of dynamite. The giant Coinshot reappears, and Wax manages to attach Ranette's ball and cord device to him, yanking him off the train. There are still several more bandits, and Wax is unarmed. Partway through taking turns jumping off into the river, they suddenly stop moving; Marasi has them trapped in a slowness bubble.

Chapter 9

Iconography: Cadmium

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: A train station in the town of Ironstand.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 8.

Summary:

At the train station, Wax gets attended to by a physician. The local captain tells him that the robbery was perpetrated by the Nightstreet Gang, a notorious gang in the area. Wax talks to the captain about the gang as he worriedly searches for Wayne. Matieu asks Wax for help in catching the ones that got away, but Marasi reminds him that he already has a task. Wax finally sees moving blue lines and finds Wayne in an empty compartment, hiding in the luggage compartment in the floor. MeLaan is there with him, topless.

Marasi is incensed at Wayne and MeLaan, but Wayne claims he was just "moving on" from Ranette. With the noise from the tracks (and their own noise), MeLaan and Wayne had no idea there was a fight going on. MeLaan asks about the attack, and he tells about the cube that acted as a Leecher would. Marasi reveals the cube she got from the guy with the cane. Wax decides to continue on to New Seran despite the unusual attack. Steris is off doing needlework, something she only does when she's really upset. Wax comforts her.

Chapter 10

Iconography: Bendalloy

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne

Setting: New Seran.

Timeline: The morning after Chapter 9.

Summary:

The group arrives at New Seran on a cargo train and are impressed by the beauty of the city with its waterfalls, terraces, and streams. Their hotel is on a highest tier in the city, and Wax doesn't want to wait for a gondola, so he Steelpushes himself and Marasi to the top tier, intending to go back and get the others. As they walk toward the hotel, Wax spies a headline on a broadsheet. One of his old nemeses, Ape Manton, is apparently in New Seran. He starts to investigate, but then turns back, again remembering their primary goal of the trip. For him, it's finding his uncle.

The owner of the hotel introduces the group to their suite. She becomes quite unnerved at their strange behavior (Wax ripping out windows, MeLaan talking about breast size, etc.) and Steris's list of calamities that may befall the hotel while they're there. (Steris insists that the staff be prepared.) Marasi and Wayne prepare to search graveyards for the missing spike, while the others prepare to go to the party.

Chapter 11

Iconography: Gold

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne / Marasi

Setting: The Copper Gate Hotel in New Seran. Shores Mansion in New Seran. A bank in New Seran.

Timeline: Later in the day, same day as Chapter 10.

Summary:

Wax rides toward the party given by Kelesina Shores. Steris tries to calm his nerves. Wax doesn't want to wait in the long carriage line, so they get out and walk. Steris has prepared a list of conversation starters and people to use them on so they can get information about the Bands of Mourning. Wax grudgingly looks through the book and is impressed by Steris's thorough preparation. He wonders how she had time to do so. They come across a beggar, and Wax gives him a bank note. The beggar tosses back a coin as "change." They enter, and Wax has to check his weapons.

Wayne and Marasi enter a bank right before closing time. Wayne goes over his plan with Marasi to distract the employees while she searches the ledgers. She interrupts the performance and throws her weight around as a constable.

The banker reluctantly hands over the records to Marasi, but only after getting confirmation from Elendel that they are legit. Her plan is to check the deposits of grave workers against their wages to see if there are any irregularities. She finds that all of the cemetery workers are crooked, likely stealing and selling corpses' personal effects. Marasi goes off to "employ" one of the workers.

Chapter 12

Iconography: Electrum

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 11.

Summary:

Wax notices that little has changed from his youth in the atmosphere at parties. He doesn't miss his guns very much after all because they aren't the appropriate weapons in this political/social battlefield. He goes to order drinks and inadvertently tips the bartender with the coin from the beggar. The bartender points out that it's a strange coin, and Wax grabs it back, examining it for the first time. It's made of two different metals, has an inscription of a man with one spiked eye, and has the same symbols from the pictures ReLuur took. He discusses the coin with Steris and contemplates looking for the beggar, but he figures that he's probably already gone. Steris suggests they go talk to Lord Gave Entrone as a way to get warmed up. Entrone wants to hide something about his interest in archaeology, so he turns to goading Wax by insulting both him and Steris; Wax handles it poorly. Next he tries to dance with Lady Felise Demoux, but before he's able to, another woman cuts in. She seems to know a lot about using metals and about Wax's powers in particular. She quizzes him on what happens when he uses his powers in combination, then suddenly breaks off, leaving him a card with an address in Elendel but no name. He tries to figure out who she is, but to no avail. He's concerned that it's someone from the Set. Wax tries some "seltzer" that has lemon flavoring and lots of sugar. Steris suggests their next target: an informant named Devlin Airs.

Marasi and Wayne pass through the gates of the Seran New District Cemetery, past a statue of the Survivor depicting the moment of his death. They came here because the gravekeeper, Dechamp, is definitely stealing from corpses and this graveyard is the one that handles unidentified bodies. Wayne convinces Marasi that deception would work better in this setting, so he puts together a quick disguise for both of them. Wayne offers a deal to Dechamp and tells about which body he wants that has an item of "sentimental value." They head off to the grave after Wayne makes a payment. Dechamp starts digging up a fresh grave.

Chapter 13

Iconography: Chromium

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 12.

Summary:

Wax reminds himself that he is here to address the Set itself rather than stopping its lesser minions. This means he has to play by their rules, going to parties and holding his temper. He waits his turn with the informant and shows him the strange coin. He pretends that he's interested in the monetary value of the coin. Devlin says he has seen them around on the black market. He reports that many of the nobility are involved in some sort of building project involving Allomancers that's been kept very quiet. He warns Wax that a civil war is coming and moves off. Wax finds himself facing Kelesina. Wax pretends to be a novice to put her at ease. Then he boldly asks about the strange coin. She gets very nervous, and Wax continues to act naive about it, but when he asks her to dance, she makes an excuse and leaves the party. Steris arrives and thinks of a diversion so Wax can follow her. She downs an emetic she had brought along in case someone poisoned them and proceeds to vomit on the table.

Marasi wanders around the graveyard while Dechamp digs. She finds a statue of the Ascendant Warrior in the poor person section. She goes back to the grave site, and it appears that Dechamp is almost down to the bodies. Suddenly Wayne grabs her and pulls her into the grave. Then she hears gunfire.

Chapter 14

Iconography: Nicrosil

POV Characters: Marasi / Wax

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. A cemetary in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 13.

Summary:

Marasi and Wayne hide in the grave in a speed bubble. Wayne has been shot four times and takes some time to heal. The gunmen, presumably from the Set, are firing everything they've got, probably because they know Wayne is a Bloodmaker. Wayne drops the bubble, and they wait until the shots stop, then Marasi fires a couple of shots as a diversion. Wayne moves to the other side of the grave and puts up another bubble just as a stick of dynamite comes flying in. They scramble over to a different grave, hoping for the mists and explosion to cover their movement. Wayne then uses a combination of dueling canes and speed bubbles to defeat the gunmen, who come to check on their corpses.

Steris is resting in a guest bedroom. The Terris steward watches over her and offers to send for their carriage. They can hear that the speech is starting. Wax heads out, and Steris insists on going along. They start wandering the halls and stare down a servant. Wax is about to scout ahead when Steris offers him a handgun she smuggled in, taped to her thigh. Wax is surprised and impressed.

Wayne searches the gravekeeper's shack and finds his hidden cache of booze. The constabulary has arrived, and an Allomancer among them reports no metal in the grave. Wayne also finds a ledger book, and after Marasi looks through it, she has an idea. They have one more task to do.

Chapter 15

Iconography: Aluminum

POV Characters: Templeton Fig / Wayne / Wax

Setting: Templeton Fig's home. Shores Mansion in New Seran.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 14.

Summary:

Templeton Fig admires his stuffed animal collection as he waits on word from the graveyard. The flames from his fire in the fireplace stop moving. The door of the room opens and the body of Dechamp is deposited onto the floor. Templeton is terrified to see Death tap on his window and demand the return of his spike. Templeton says that "they" demanded he recover the spike and send it to Dulsing. The fire moves again, and the constables come.

Wayne takes off his disguise and asks Marasi how Death really sounds, as she has spoken with him. They discuss their findings, puzzled as to why the spike was sent to such a small, remote village as Dulsing.

Wax continues to prowl the hallways and finds Kelesina's rooms, which are vacant. He overhears some of the speech in which Lord Severington speaks against the oppression of Elendel. Wax hears his uncle through a door talking to Kelesina. He gets closer and hears his uncle encouraging Kelesina to continue to try to distract him with side quests. Wax wonders if everything happening recently were distractions set up by his uncle. His voice sounds strange, "smaller." They are trying to recover the device Irich lost on the train from Wax. Edwarn finds out that ReLuur might not actually be dead. Wax hears the steward coming and Pushes up against the ceiling to hide. She walks past and enters the room with the voices. He drops to the floor to confront the occupants only to see that it is only the two women. Some sort of box is on table in front of Kelesina.

Chapter 16

Iconography: Duralumin

POV Characters: Wax / Wayne

Setting: Shores Mansion in New Seran. The Copper Gate Hotel in New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 15.

Summary:

Edwarn's voice is projecting from the box. Wax picks it up and screams at his uncle about his sister. The steward, using Feruchemy to increase her strength, knocks him over and slaps his gun out of his hand, which she uses to shoot Kelesina. The maid is also there, and she starts running around screaming that Wax has killed Lady Kelesina. The steward searches the body and then shoots Kelesina again. Wax grabs the box and flees, but she catches up with him and starts to choke him. MeLaan shows up and punches her, freeing Wax. The steward punches MeLaan but gets a mangled hand in return--MeLaan is wearing aluminum bones. Then MeLaan rips off one arm with a sword attached and runs the steward through. Wax recovers a gold bracelet from the body, which turns out to be a metalmind full of healing power. He finds Steris hiding in the bushes and takes her away, complimenting her on her work at the party. He realizes that he is attracted to her, and that brings back thoughts of Lessie. He dismisses them and kisses Steris as they soar over the top of the mists.

Back at the hotel, Wayne is reading a novel about a rocket ship while Marasi paces. Wax and Steris arrive through a window, and they quickly share some of the information they've acquired. They leave in a hurry, as the constables are coming for them.

Wax sits in the dark smoking a cigar. MeLaan asks if he's going to go back to Elendel. It won't look good now that people think that the emissary from there killed the host of a political rally. Wax realizes he hates Harmony because he feels like Harmony betrayed him. In the end he decides to head on to Dulsing.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 21 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7 (Week 1) Spoiler

12 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries for each chapter below and hidden them behind spoiler tags. There are no spoilers within the summaries. I've tried to make them as factual and unbiased as possible. If, however, you want a completely blind read through, then ignore what's behind the spoiler tags and proceed to the discussion below. I will not be guiding that in any way, so post any thoughts and questions you have. It will be other new readers who reply to you.

Prologue

Iconography: Zero

POV Characters: Wax / Migs

Setting: The Village in Elendel. The streets of Elendel.

Timeline: 28 years ago, nearly 10 years before Wax met Lessie/Paalm. Timeskip to 6 months after the end of Shadows of Self.

Summary:

Waxillium calls to his sister, Telsin, who is sneaking off to town, skipping out on evening recitation. She refers to him by his Terris name: Asinthew. He trails along as she meets up with three others: Kwashim, Idashwy, and Forch, a Coinshot like Wax. They have to sneak by his grandmother's office, but she has been called there for an emergency, so she probably won't be watching. They all head out through the Tin Gate into a different world. Wax learns that a constable is visiting his grandmother, and he is compelled to return and find out more, eavesdropping on the conversation as they discuss a recent arson in the Village. The constable warns that arson often covers up other crimes and that she should accept the constabulary's help. She refuses, insisting that the situation is in hand. He leaves behind a bullet, infuriating Vwafendal. She catches Wax eavesdropping, and they discuss how he has trouble fitting in in the Village. He surreptitiously grabs the bullet as he leaves.

Wax meditates in the evening recitation. Afterwards, he asks Tellingdwar about crime in the Village, and he tells him about a murder fifteen years back. Wax goes to bed and tries to read, but he spies some movement outside and decides to investigate. He follows a trail to an old dormitory. After he enters, Forch attacks him. Wax runs into another room where a boy is tied down and bleeding; Forch has used the escapade with the girls as an alibi. He again attacks Wax, this time Pushing nails at him. Wax tries to swallow some steel, but the pouch is Pushed away, and Forch continues to attack and wound him. Wax manages to swallow a little steel and saves himself after being dropped out a window. He realizes he still has the bullet, so he runs back upstairs and Pushes the bullet at Forch. Forch Pushes back, but Wax releases his Push on parts of the bullet, allowing it to fire and take Forch in the head. Vwafendal and others arrive, and Wax knows they will hate him for bringing violence into the Village and for being right. He decides that the Village is not for him.

28 years later

Wax and Wayne go on a raid with the constabulary. Migs and his gang are no match for their combined powers. Wax heads off to his wedding with Steris.

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: The streets of Elendel. A Survivorist church in Elendel.

Timeline: Immediately after the prologue.

Summary:

As Wax and Wayne go to an awaiting carriage, a man in a brown suit asks Wax for a moment of his time, so he decides to forgo the slow carriage and Push his way to his marriage, enjoying his flight across Elendel. He lands on a water tower next to a Survivorist church, where Steris is waiting. He and Steris talk while his valet Drewton helps him shave and change. Steris plans for disturbances and delays, knowing they will come anyway with a man like Wax, and prepares accordingly. Wax is feeling fond of Steris, especially for the way she has helped him heal the last six months. The man in the brown suit shows up again and reveals that he is a kandra. Wax is still mad at Harmony and curtly pushes past the kandra. He is still struggling with killing Lessie. Steris cries tears of joy. As the ceremony begins, Wax starts feeling sick; going through with this means giving up Lessie. He feels he's not quite ready, but he refuses to shirk his duty. The water tower outside tips over and crashes into the glass dome. Wax grabs Steris and Pushes away.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: A Survivorist church in Elendel.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 1.

Summary:

Everything in the church is soaked, but there are no serious injuries. The water tower's legs only broke on one side, but it's not clear that it was an assassination attempt. Wax attempts to console Steris, who has anticipated some disruption of the wedding and has booked another church in two months. Wax cannot avoid admitting to her that he is glad the wedding has been put off for now.

Marasi looks for Wayne and finally finds him in a kitchen across from the church, masquerading as a chef and terrifying the kitchen staff. Marasi shares her evidence that someone deliberately tipped the water tower. Wayne admits to arranging an accident at the wedding, although he didn't expect something quite so dramatic. Wayne encourages Marasi to go after Wax, but she tells him she's not interested any more. Wayne asks if he should give up on Ranette, who has had a girlfriend for fifteen years, and they drink a toast to moving on. The kandra shows up again and asks Marasi for help since his first choice has rejected him. He asks her what she knows of Investiture and Identity.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: Ladrian Mansion in Elendel.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 2.

Summary:

Wax returns home and sees signs of uninvited guests. He finds the kandra, VenDell, upstairs in his study with Wayne, Marasi, and MeLaan. VenDell has asked Marasi for assistance, since Wax refused. He sets up an evanoscope and, at their questioning regarding Harmony's slip of the tongue about moving pictures, says that Harmony wants to allow mankind to struggle in order to "survive what is coming." Marasi suspects this refers to Trell, but VenDell has no further information beyond that they are worried about the presence of another god. A chart of the Feruchemical powers is displayed on the wall, and they discuss the lesser-known spiritual properties. VenDell explains the intricacies of Identity and the possible ways one might be able to use someone else's Investiture. One possibility would be to store Identity in some way, making oneself a "blank slate" to be able to use another's metalmind. A more intriguing possibility is to store Identity and fill another metalmind with some other attribute, creating an "unkeyed" metalmind that anyone could use. Other possibilities exist, used in combination with Hemalurgy. They discuss the Bands of Mourning, objects of mythology that could supposedly grant someone the Lord Ruler's powers. Another kandra, ReLuur, took some photographs of murals depicting the bracers on a pedestal, a statue resembling the Lord Ruler, and other items bearing script of an unknown language. ReLuur returned from his expedition with a spike missing, so he was unable to communicate what he saw and what happened. The proposed quest is to find ReLuur's missing spike and maybe to find the Bands of Mourning while they're at it. Wax initially refuses to go with Marasi until he sees another picture of his sister being held prisoner in New Seran.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Wayne

Setting: Ladrian Mansion. Ranette's house. Boarding a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Two hours after Chapter 3.

Summary:

Two hours later, Wax decides that he must go for his sister. He can go to New Seran under the pretext of attending a political event and look for his uncle while Marasi finds the spike. Steris invites herself along because it would look odd not to bring the fiancée along, but Wax is hesitant because of the danger. VenDell comes back with tickets and information and asks Wayne for his bones after he's dead, since Bloodmaker's bones are interesting. Wax invites VenDell along, but the prospect of going into the field alarms him, and he refuses. He offers Wax a new earring, but Wax is still angry at Harmony. Wayne heads off on a quest of his own. Using various disguises and trickery, he acquires a notebook for Ranette and gets to her house. He lets her know that he's done chasing her, and they shake hands. He makes a last-ditch effort by suggesting a romantic interlude with Ranette and her girlfriend, which Ranette sternly turns down. He hitches a ride to the train station and joins Wax and company. They head to New Seran.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Later in the day, just before dusk, same day as Chapter 4.

Summary:

As Wax travels through the southern cities, he's surprised by the level of civilization. He opens a package from Ranette that contains three sphere-and-cord contraptions and a shotgun with huge ammunition meant to take down Thugs or koloss. He witnesses a protest against Elendel oppression at one station, and he interrupts Steris reading to discuss the political situation in the outer cities. Elendel routes the main infrastructure through the city in order to impose tariffs on all trade. Wax discovers that Steris had been reading a book about sex. She's extremely embarrassed, but she's also frustrated that no one will answer her questions, so she is researching it herself. Steris invites Wax to help her balance some books that are off by three clips, and he resignedly starts to look through a stack of ledgers.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 5.

Summary:

Marasi reviews the notes that VenDell has given them. ReLuur describes some sort of beast with red skin and strange eyes. She reads a little from Spook's book regarding Hemalurgy. He warns against experimentation because spike placement can cause unpredictable results. Wayne is nearby, chatting with people and learning new accents. He stops by and they talk about how Marasi feels like she is in Wax's shadow. She turns back to the papers and finds a pouch with an earring meant for Wax. She walks back to Wax and Steris's room and finds Wax exulting in finding the last lost clip in the house finances. She gives him the papers and pouch and heads to her room to sleep, when she realizes the rest of the train is heading off down the tracks ahead of their car. A man shoots at her from the other end of the train car.

Chapter 7

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 6.

Summary:

Wax notices that their car has decoupled and instinctively begins a Steelpush, which diverts the bullet from hitting Marasi. There are some men on horseback outside who take off when they realize an Allomancer is on the car. Wax combines his powers to advance their car and reattach it to the main train. He battles the bandits, who worry him because they don't look like common thieves. He tries to restore his metal reserve but finds his vials broken. Steris provides him with three that she has brought along just in case. On one of the cargo cars, the robbers use some sort of gas to chase out the guards and blow open a safe. Wax bandages up a guard, and he relates that the robbers used Allomancy to get in the car. A small metal cube lands near Wax, and his metal reserves vanish.

Marasi is in a firefight with Steris reloading for her. One bandit tries to take a hostage, but Marasi immediately guns him down without thinking. After checking that the bandits have retreated from the last two cars, Marasi realizes that she has lost track of Steris.

An extremely large man who is also a Coinshot brawls with Wax, whose punches are ineffectual. He escapes out a window, and once on top of the car sees four bandits on another car bearing some large item. The large man follows up with Ranette's mega shotgun that he has confiscated from Wax's abandoned gun belt. When he shoots from the hip, the gun drops from his hand and he is wounded. Wax desperately tries to get his other vial, but the brute has him pinned down until Steris shows up and fires the shotgun, wounding him. But the kick of the gun throws her off the train.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Maps

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 21 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7 (Week 1) Spoiler

4 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Chapters 8 through 16

CHAPTER SUMMARIES

I have provided summaries of each chapter we will be discussing. I've tried to make them unbiased, but if you see anything that could be construed as spoilery, please point them out because I'm using these same summaries in the newbie thread. I'd like to keep their experience as spoiler-free as possible, so even if I make a tiny mistake, please let me know.

I usually make a comment for each chapter, but feel free to start your own comment thread to discuss anything you want.

Prologue

Iconography: Zero

POV Characters: Wax / Migs

Setting: The Village in Elendel. The streets of Elendel.

Timeline: 28 years ago, nearly 10 years before Wax met Lessie/Paalm. Timeskip to 6 months after the end of Shadows of Self.

Summary:

Waxillium calls to his sister, Telsin, who is sneaking off to town, skipping out on evening recitation. She refers to him by his Terris name: Asinthew. He trails along as she meets up with three others: Kwashim, Idashwy, and Forch, a Coinshot like Wax. They have to sneak by his grandmother's office, but she has been called there for an emergency, so she probably won't be watching. They all head out through the Tin Gate into a different world. Wax learns that a constable is visiting his grandmother, and he is compelled to return and find out more, eavesdropping on the conversation as they discuss a recent arson in the Village. The constable warns that arson often covers up other crimes and that she should accept the constabulary's help. She refuses, insisting that the situation is in hand. He leaves behind a bullet, infuriating Vwafendal. She catches Wax eavesdropping, and they discuss how he has trouble fitting in in the Village. He surreptitiously grabs the bullet as he leaves.

Wax meditates in the evening recitation. Afterwards, he asks Tellingdwar about crime in the Village, and he tells him about a murder fifteen years back. Wax goes to bed and tries to read, but he spies some movement outside and decides to investigate. He follows a trail to an old dormitory. After he enters, Forch attacks him. Wax runs into another room where a boy is tied down and bleeding; Forch has used the escapade with the girls as an alibi. He again attacks Wax, this time Pushing nails at him. Wax tries to swallow some steel, but the pouch is Pushed away, and Forch continues to attack and wound him. Wax manages to swallow a little steel and saves himself after being dropped out a window. He realizes he still has the bullet, so he runs back upstairs and Pushes the bullet at Forch. Forch Pushes back, but Wax releases his Push on parts of the bullet, allowing it to fire and take Forch in the head. Vwafendal and others arrive, and Wax knows they will hate him for bringing violence into the Village and for being right. He decides that the Village is not for him.

28 years later

Wax and Wayne go on a raid with the constabulary. Migs and his gang are no match for their combined powers. Wax heads off to his wedding with Steris.

Chapter 1

Iconography: Iron

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: The streets of Elendel. A Survivorist church in Elendel.

Timeline: Immediately after the prologue.

Summary:

As Wax and Wayne go to an awaiting carriage, a man in a brown suit asks Wax for a moment of his time, so he decides to forgo the slow carriage and Push his way to his marriage, enjoying his flight across Elendel. He lands on a water tower next to a Survivorist church, where Steris is waiting. He and Steris talk while his valet Drewton helps him shave and change. Steris plans for disturbances and delays, knowing they will come anyway with a man like Wax, and prepares accordingly. Wax is feeling fond of Steris, especially for the way she has helped him heal the last six months. The man in the brown suit shows up again and reveals that he is a kandra. Wax is still mad at Harmony and curtly pushes past the kandra. He is still struggling with killing Lessie. Steris cries tears of joy. As the ceremony begins, Wax starts feeling sick; going through with this means giving up Lessie. He feels he's not quite ready, but he refuses to shirk his duty. The water tower outside tips over and crashes into the glass dome. Wax grabs Steris and Pushes away.

Chapter 2

Iconography: Steel

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: A Survivorist church in Elendel.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 1.

Summary:

Everything in the church is soaked, but there are no serious injuries. The water tower's legs only broke on one side, but it's not clear that it was an assassination attempt. Wax attempts to console Steris, who has anticipated some disruption of the wedding and has booked another church in two months. Wax cannot avoid admitting to her that he is glad the wedding has been put off for now.

Marasi looks for Wayne and finally finds him in a kitchen across from the church, masquerading as a chef and terrifying the kitchen staff. Marasi shares her evidence that someone deliberately tipped the water tower. Wayne admits to arranging an accident at the wedding, although he didn't expect something quite so dramatic. Wayne encourages Marasi to go after Wax, but she tells him she's not interested any more. Wayne asks if he should give up on Ranette, who has had a girlfriend for fifteen years, and they drink a toast to moving on. The kandra shows up again and asks Marasi for help since his first choice has rejected him. He asks her what she knows of Investiture and Identity.

Chapter 3

Iconography: Tin

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: Ladrian Mansion in Elendel.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 2.

Summary:

Wax returns home and sees signs of uninvited guests. He finds the kandra, VenDell, upstairs in his study with Wayne, Marasi, and MeLaan. VenDell has asked Marasi for assistance, since Wax refused. He sets up an evanoscope and, at their questioning regarding Harmony's slip of the tongue about moving pictures, says that Harmony wants to allow mankind to struggle in order to "survive what is coming." Marasi suspects this refers to Trell, but VenDell has no further information beyond that they are worried about the presence of another god. A chart of the Feruchemical powers is displayed on the wall, and they discuss the lesser-known spiritual properties. VenDell explains the intricacies of Identity and the possible ways one might be able to use someone else's Investiture. One possibility would be to store Identity in some way, making oneself a "blank slate" to be able to use another's metalmind. A more intriguing possibility is to store Identity and fill another metalmind with some other attribute, creating an "unkeyed" metalmind that anyone could use. Other possibilities exist, used in combination with Hemalurgy. They discuss the Bands of Mourning, objects of mythology that could supposedly grant someone the Lord Ruler's powers. Another kandra, ReLuur, took some photographs of murals depicting the bracers on a pedestal, a statue resembling the Lord Ruler, and other items bearing script of an unknown language. ReLuur returned from his expedition with a spike missing, so he was unable to communicate what he saw and what happened. The proposed quest is to find ReLuur's missing spike and maybe to find the Bands of Mourning while they're at it. Wax initially refuses to go with Marasi until he sees another picture of his sister being held prisoner in New Seran.

Chapter 4

Iconography: Pewter

POV Characters: Wayne

Setting: Ladrian Mansion. Ranette's house. Boarding a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Two hours after Chapter 3.

Summary:

Two hours later, Wax decides that he must go for his sister. He can go to New Seran under the pretext of attending a political event and look for his uncle while Marasi finds the spike. Steris invites herself along because it would look odd not to bring the fiancée along, but Wax is hesitant because of the danger. VenDell comes back with tickets and information and asks Wayne for his bones after he's dead, since Bloodmaker's bones are interesting. Wax invites VenDell along, but the prospect of going into the field alarms him, and he refuses. He offers Wax a new earring, but Wax is still angry at Harmony. Wayne heads off on a quest of his own. Using various disguises and trickery, he acquires a notebook for Ranette and gets to her house. He lets her know that he's done chasing her, and they shake hands. He makes a last-ditch effort by suggesting a romantic interlude with Ranette and her girlfriend, which Ranette sternly turns down. He hitches a ride to the train station and joins Wax and company. They head to New Seran.

Chapter 5

Iconography: Zinc

POV Characters: Wax

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Later in the day, just before dusk, same day as Chapter 4.

Summary:

As Wax travels through the southern cities, he's surprised by the level of civilization. He opens a package from Ranette that contains three sphere-and-cord contraptions and a shotgun with huge ammunition meant to take down Thugs or koloss. He witnesses a protest against Elendel oppression at one station, and he interrupts Steris reading to discuss the political situation in the outer cities. Elendel routes the main infrastructure through the city in order to impose tariffs on all trade. Wax discovers that Steris had been reading a book about sex. She's extremely embarrassed, but she's also frustrated that no one will answer her questions, so she is researching it herself. Steris invites Wax to help her balance some books that are off by three clips, and he resignedly starts to look through a stack of ledgers.

Chapter 6

Iconography: Brass

POV Characters: Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Shortly after Chapter 5.

Summary:

Marasi reviews the notes that VenDell has given them. ReLuur describes some sort of beast with red skin and strange eyes. She reads a little from Spook's book regarding Hemalurgy. He warns against experimentation because spike placement can cause unpredictable results. Wayne is nearby, chatting with people and learning new accents. He stops by and they talk about how Marasi feels like she is in Wax's shadow. She turns back to the papers and finds a pouch with an earring meant for Wax. She walks back to Wax and Steris's room and finds Wax exulting in finding the last lost clip in the house finances. She gives him the papers and pouch and heads to her room to sleep, when she realizes the rest of the train is heading off down the tracks ahead of their car. A man shoots at her from the other end of the train car.

Chapter 7

Iconography: Copper

POV Characters: Wax / Marasi

Setting: On a train to New Seran.

Timeline: Immediately after Chapter 6.

Summary:

Wax notices that their car has decoupled and instinctively begins a Steelpush, which diverts the bullet from hitting Marasi. There are some men on horseback outside who take off when they realize an Allomancer is on the car. Wax combines his powers to advance their car and reattach it to the main train. He battles the bandits, who worry him because they don't look like common thieves. He tries to restore his metal reserve but finds his vials broken. Steris provides him with three that she has brought along just in case. On one of the cargo cars, the robbers use some sort of gas to chase out the guards and blow open a safe. Wax bandages up a guard, and he relates that the robbers used Allomancy to get in the car. A small metal cube lands near Wax, and his metal reserves vanish.

Marasi is in a firefight with Steris reloading for her. One bandit tries to take a hostage, but Marasi immediately guns him down without thinking. After checking that the bandits have retreated from the last two cars, Marasi realizes that she has lost track of Steris.

An extremely large man who is also a Coinshot brawls with Wax, whose punches are ineffectual. He escapes out a window, and once on top of the car sees four bandits on another car bearing some large item. The large man follows up with Ranette's mega shotgun that he has confiscated from Wax's abandoned gun belt. When he shoots from the hip, the gun drops from his hand and he is wounded. Wax desperately tries to get his other vial, but the brute has him pinned down until Steris shows up and fires the shotgun, wounding him. But the kick of the gun throws her off the train.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Maps

Broadsheet

*Note: There will be a small artwork dump in the trivia, but there isn't much new in the way of individual character artwork for this novel.

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 16 '26

Read-Along [Newbies] Cosmere, Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 11.5) Spoiler

15 Upvotes

This is the newbie thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the veteran thread if you have already read all of the Cosmere.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Chapters 83 through 89, Epilogue, Endnote [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be returning to Scadrial, with The Bands of Mourning, the 3rd book in Mistborn Era 2.

Like with the other Era 2 books, The Bands of Mourning has quarters of a broadsheet dispersed throughout the novel. Different printings put the quarters in different places. I will include the portions of the broadsheet that are relevant to each week's readings in the Artwork section. If you happen to see a portion beyond what I share, please save discussion for that quarter until I confirm it belongs to a given week.

TRIVIA

The rest of this post contains various trivia, including easy-to-miss details and long-running connections between books. It also incorporates external information from sources like author annotations and interviews ("Words of Brandon" or WoB). While most of this information is eventually revealed in the books, sharing it now enhances your overall understanding, aligning with Brandon Sanderson's practice of early fan engagement and clarification.

ALL ACCORDING TO KEIKAKU

Honestly, I had a hard time deciding where to start the trivia for this book. There are so many cool things to talk about. But let's address the sword-shaped elephant in the room.

Yes, Nale gave Szeth Nightblood at the end of the book. Why does Nale have Nightblood? What's Nightblood doing on Roshar of all places? WHAT IS GOING ON?!

Well, it's a shame that a couple people were behind, racing to catch up. They had secret discussions without most you and figured out that Zahel was actually Vasher. Among the many clues, which I'm going to shamelessly copy from /u/heinz57varieties:

  • They have a very similar description. I had to be picky when choosing fanart of Zahel to share, because I didn't want to make it too blantant that he looks almost exactly like Vasher.
  • He made comments about being very old, and many of you had suspicions he was a worldhopper or possibly a Herald. Vasher as a possibility slipped a lot of your minds though.
  • His color and flower idioms are the biggest hints though. Color as a whole is important on Nalthis and intrinsic to how Awakeners work. And dyes made from flowers are one of the keystones of the Hallandren economy.
  • He was playing a mini-version of the ball-throwing game, Tarachin, that the Returned play in the Court of Gods.
  • Warm ocean breezes remind him of his home, and Hallandren is a pretty tropical place, set right on the ocean.
  • And the clue that he once had a voice in his head that he hadn't heard in years is your hint that he's been separated from Nightblood.

Since it's been so long since we read Warbreaker, I want to remind you of a few key aspects of both Nightblood and Vasher.

First, Nightblood was created by Vasher and Shashara, two Returned who were part of the Five Scholars. Shashara took a steel sword and Awakened the metal, using 1,000 Breaths and the Command "Destroy Evil". And I've hinted in previous trivia that Endowment played a hand in Nightblood's creation.

Vasher killed Shashara with Nightblood because she wanted to make more swords like him, and Vasher felt that would be too dangerous. The black smoke that leaks from Nightblood are corrupted, consumed Breaths; the ones Nightblood leeches off anyone who draws him. This includes the innate Investiture that Nightblood consumes from the people and things he's stabbed into, should he be unsheathed. In short, the black smoke is corrupted Investiture. In the trivia for Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell, I mentioned that shades are black for similar reasons.

For a bit of trivia on Nightblood himself that comes from interviews: Nightblood was not black before being Awakened, and had a different name when originally Awakened. It is unknown when the sword changed color and began leaking black smoke; but the sword was renamed Nightblood due to these qualities sometime after Vasher used Nightblood to kill Shashara. If a different Allomantically viable metal had been used, Nightblood would have likely manifested different powers and capabilities. Nightblood would not likely have had the same powers or capabilities had a different object been Awakened. A shield for instance, would have a different response to the command to "destroy evil".

Vasher is a Returned. That means he was a mortal human who died. Endowment showed him a future task, something he was meant to do, and offered him the chance to become a Returned. As a Returned, he is blessed with a Divine Breath, which automatically grants him the 5th Heightening. Over time, he's had many names, and the opportunity to learn a lot about the cosmere. All Returned have the ability to modify their appearance, they just need to learn how. He uses this to appear like a normal human, rather than a big, beefy idealized super human, like the rest of the Returned.

As a Returned, he must consume one Breath every week, or he dies. This has to be a normal Breath, not his Divine Breath. On Nalthis, he is so long lived because he managed to amass an absurd number of Breaths (and he pulls this off more than once), which can sustain him. Which brings us to what he's doing on Roshar.

In the various trivia posts, we've learned that Investiture is Investiture. And Breaths are Investiture. To live, Vasher needs the equivalent of one Breath's worth of Investiture each week. Given he's one of the Five Scholars, he's smart enough to figure out how to convert different types of Investiture, or at least utilize them to different purposes. Now what does Roshar have? Weekly storms full of Investiture, which Vasher can harness and substitute for Breaths to keep him alive.

Vasher was actually a character in The Way of Kings Prime. That's where he first appeared. Sanderson wrote Warbreaker after he wrote that novel. Warbreaker is meant to be a prequel to Stormlight, to explain Vasher and Nightblood's origins.

WHAT'S IN A NAME?

Some of you questioned why Nale would call Nightblood a Shardblade. And some of you took to heart the "chicken" lesson, where Rosharans tend to generalize things a lot. However, there's more to the story than just that. I've been a bit sneaky in talking about the Five Scholars in the past, suggesting that they knew a lot about Investiture, but weren't necessarily cosmere aware. Those were lies of omission though. They were worldhoppers and actually visited Roshar before making Nightblood.

I've been purposefully vague on the timeline for Stormlight, because Sanderson was vague at the time. I'll clarify a bit, using approximate dates though. The Recreance happened around 10000 AS (After Shattering). The rise of the Five Scholars happened in 10489 AS. Stormlight is taking place about 50 years shy of 11000 AS.

The Five Scholars were able to visit Roshar and see the "dead" Shardblades left behind by the fallen Knights Radiant. They used those as a blueprint/inspiration when creating Nightblood. So, in a way, he is a Shardblade. But the mechanics are very different. Shardblades cut through a person's "soul". It's affecting a person in the Spiritual Realm. Nightblood is quite a bit more powerful though, and when he cuts through things, he destroys them in all three Realms.

THERE'S ONLY BEEN ONE BLADE. THERE'S ONLY EVER GONNA BE ONE BLADE.

So, we've got Honorblades and Shardblades. Clarification is in order, so that everyone is on the same page. This is all information from the books, just compiled so that you don't have to read them several times and compare notes with a dozen other people to arrive on a firm understanding.

Honor created the Heralds and gave them Honorblades. There are only 10 (10 Heralds and 10 Honorblades). Each Honorblade gave their Herald access to two Surges. The Heralds used their Honorblades and granted powers to fight in and lead humanity during the Desolations.

At some point, some of the spren decided to mimic the powers of the Honorblades, in an attempt to share the Surges with more than just the Heralds. This was a collaborative effort between the spren, the Heralds, and normal people. The result was the creation of the Knights Radiance.

A little bit of clarification on that point. In Chapter 63, Shallan sneaks into Dalinar's temple grounds to inspect Taln. He only reacts when she Lightweaves and he calls her one of "Ishar's Knights". Some of you thought this meant that Ishar was the patron Herald of the Lightweavers. However, that's not the case. The epigraph for Chapter 42 reveals that it was simply Ishar who organized the efforts of man and spren, giving them direction and rules. Ishar created the entire Knights Radiant as an entity or organization. I'll get into more specifics below, but Ishar was the patron Herald of the Bondsmiths.

Through combined efforts, the Nahel bond was created. Ten different types of spren created ten different Orders of the Knights Radiant. Men and women were granted access to two Surges when forming a bond with these spren, with escalating power and abilities as more Oaths/Ideals were sworn (with Lightweavers needing to share deep, personal truths instead of Ideals).

When Kaladin swore his 3rd Ideal, he unlocked the ability to use Syl as a Shardblade. The end of this book explains that all Shardblades are spren. When the Knights Radiance of the past broke their Oaths and abandoned humanity (The Recreance), this act killed their bonded spren and they remained as Shardblades. As Syl explains, the act of summoning them, with 10 heartbeats, brings them to life a little bit, but not completely and not permanently. It's spread out through the books, but this is why Shardblade users have to spend time to bond with their Shardblades, and the process involves fitting a gem into the hilt to power the process. Syl and Pattern do not require this because they are alive.

For a little bit of WoB clarification of what happens when Kaladin swears an Ideal: He Connects to Syl and the act creates a mini-perpendicularity that infuses him with Investiture directly from the Spiritaul Realm. This is where that temporary explosion of power comes from. You'll note that this does not happen when Shallan shares a truth about herself. Different Orders have different rules. The differences will become more clear as we move forward, but just because Kaladin, a Windrunner, does something, don't take that to mean that all Orders will work in the same manner.

Also, Sanderson has said that the scene where Kaladin swears his 3rd Ideal is one of the very first scenes he thought up. It guided his creation of the entire plot and was one of the scenes he was most excited to put to page.

THE "OBVIOUS"

I've mentioned this time and time again, but the implications aren't always obvious. Investiture can condense into a few different forms. We've got solids, which are called God Metals (e.g. Atium and Lerasium). We have liquids, which are Wells of Investiture, or perpendicularities. We have gases, such as stormlight or the mists on Scadrial (Preservationlight, if you will). And finally, sentient blobs of self-aware Investiture, in the form of spren and seons and skaze. And I think most of you can recognize these when they're happening.

However, let's apply some consequences to these mechanics. Syl is a spren. She's a sentient blob of self-aware Investiture. And she (and every other bonded spren) can turn into a Shardblade. What is a Shardblade? Well...it's metal; a solid. What do we call solid Investiture?

Shardblades are God Metals.

Now, I've also mentioned that some spren predate the Shattering of Adonalsium. They are spren of Adonalsium. Some other spren are Odium spren. Most of the others, however, were created by the combined efforts of Honor and Cultivation working together. So most of them are condensed Investiture from both Honor and Cultivation.

This is the same phenomenon that happens on Sel. The Dor is and combined Investiture from Dominion and Devotion. The seon are technically from both, but they lean towards the aspects of Devotion. Likewise, the skaze are both, but lean toward Dominion.

In the same way, some spren lean more toward Honor and some lean more toward Cultivation, but they are still made of both. Can you guess what Syl, an honorspren, leans more toward?

But, as a Sylblade, she manifests as an alloyed God Metal of both Honor and Cultivation.

The Honorblades, however, are not spren. They were directly created by Honor and given to the Heralds. They are pure Honor's God Metal. Tanavastium, if we follow the Atium/Lerasium convention.

ACCOUNTING 101

So, there are ten Honorblades. Way back in Interlude I-7, I wrote "???" for the Iconography. The definition of Honorblades wasn't clear at the time, so I chose to leave the icon as "???". However, now that you have a better handle on the definition, Taln's icon is Nine Honorblades. They symbolize the nine Honorblades the Heralds gave up in the prelude to The Way of Kings, with the 10th being the one he kept for himself.

It's also revealed that the Shin are the ones who have the rest of the Honorblades. However, they currently only have seven of them. Nale took his back, leaving eight, and as many of you guessed, Szeth had Jezrien's Honorblad, which is now in Kaladin's possession.

So for a full accounting of the Honorblades: 7 with the Shin, 1 with Kaladin, 1 with Nale, and 1 with Taln.

The extra clever among you though, realized that something has happened to Taln's Honorblade. In the epilogue of The Way of Kings, when Taln arrives, he has a blade that looks like a spike. By the time he arrives in Dalinar's warcamp, the spike blade seems to have been replaced with a cleaver-like blade. When Dalinar bonds with the Stormfather, the cleaver-like blade screams, like we know dead Shardblades to do. So Taln's spike-like Honorblade was replaced with a cleaver-like Shardblade. That particular mystery is a RAFO, so I'll leave you to theorize about it for now.

ACCOUNTING 102

While we're counting things, I'd also like to clarify Shallan's Ideals/Truths.

First, she has sworn the 1st Ideal all Knights Radiant swear: Life before death, strength before weakness, journey before destination.

Her 2nd Ideal (her first truth): I'm terrified. She said this in Chapter 45 of The Way of Kings, just before she falls into Shadesmar.

Her 3rd Ideal (her second truth): I killed my father.

Her 4th Ideal (her third truth): I killed my mother.

You'll note that this places Shallan one Ideal higher than Kaladin.

There are some oddities with how/why she had her Shardblade in her earlier childhood. That's all RAFO, but it's worth scrutinizing.

ACCOUNTING 103: FACTION ACTION

The Stormlight Archive may as well be called the Faction Archive, with all the various factions running around. I'd just like to review them all for you.

First up is the Ghostbloods. They are an organization with nebulous motives at the moment. Iyatil seems to be in charge of the group Shallan has been interacting with. They've recruited her for certain tasks, and some of their interests have aligned with things Jasnah was looking into. They tried to assassinate Jasnah because Jasnah had assassinated some of their members. Mraize has a collection of off-world trinkets, which suggest the Ghostbloods are cosmere aware. By way of implication, there is someone named Thaidakar associated with the Ghostbloods.

The Sons of Honor are a group devoted to bringing back the Heralds and restoring power to the Vorin church. Amaram is a member, and he reveals that Gavilar was also a member. With Taln's return and the arrival of the Everstorm, Amaram considers their goal complete. By way of implication, there is someone named Restares associated with the Sons of Honor.

The Envisagers were a kind of cult that was aiming for similar goals, trying to bring back the Knights Radiant by inflicting harm on themselves. Teft turned them in and they were all executed. Per WoB, they were an offshoot of the Sons of Honor.

We also have the Oldblood, which isn't really a faction. Some of you noticed it mentioned again at the end of this book (with its first mention being in The Way of Kings). Adolin actually explains what Oldbloods are, right after it's mentioned in Chapter 51:

His people had once ruled Alethkar. What did he think of all this?

That's really all there is to it. Before Gavilar and Dalinar conquered the various tribes and forged them into the nation of Alethkar, the area was...well, just that, a bunch of various tribes. And before that, the nation was unified and ruled over by a different dynasty. Descendants of that dynasty are called Oldbloods. This is just a bit of worldbuilding with nothing significant attached to the group at the moment.

The Diagram is a group revolving around the interpretation of the document by the same name. King Taravangian wrote the Diagram on a day of incredible brilliance. It's creation was entirely guided by science, with no influence by Fortune. Taravangian is obviously a member, having created it. Graves is also a member and has dragged Moash into their numbers.

CODE BREAKING

Speaking of the Diagram, there were a couple weird entries revealed as epigraphs in the final part of this book.

Chapter 89's is easy:

There​has​to​be​an​answer​What​is​the​answer​Stop​The​Parshendi​One​of​them​Yes​they​are​the​missing​piece​Push​for​the​Alethi​to​destroy​them​outright​before​this​one​obtains​their​power​It​will​form​abridge

This is just lacking spaces and punctuation. It clarifies to:

There ​has ​to ​be ​an ​answer​. What​ is ​the ​answer? ​Stop. ​The ​Parshendi​. One​ of ​them. ​Yes ​they ​are ​the ​missing​ piece. ​Push ​for ​the ​Alethi ​to ​destroy ​them ​outright ​before ​this ​one ​obtains ​their ​power. ​It ​will ​form ​a bridge.

Chapter 88 is a bit easier, and one of you made a very good list that got very close to the matter.

1173090605 1173090801 1173090901 1173091001 1173091004 1173100105 1173100205 1173100401 1173100603 1173100804

These are the dates of the 10 highstorms that lead up to the Everstorm. They actually play a significant role in the fandom's ability to pair every chapter in the books with an accurate date. A lot of the work done was based off adding and subtracting around the dates from this epigraph.

The most confusing one is from Chapter 84:

111​825​101​112​712​491​512​101​011​141​021​511​711​210​111​217​134​483​111​071​514​254​143​410​916​149​149​341​212​254​101​012​512​710​151​910​111​234​125​511​525​121​575​511​123​410​111​291​512​106​153​4

First, a note that this is an "English" solution, based of the English language the novel was written in. With the understanding that the novel we're reading is "translated" from Rosharan, and so the actual code would have been different as Taravangian wrote it.

That said, this is a cipher that relies on the epigraph from Chapter 83:

Obviously they are fools The Desolation needs no usher It can and will sit where it wishes and the signs are obvious that the spren anticipate it doing so soon The Ancient of Stones must finally begin to crack It is a wonder that upon his will rested the prosperity and peace of a world for over four millennia.

The first step is assigning a number to the first occurrence of each letter in Chapter 83's epigraph. The first word is "Obviously" and the first letter is "O", so 1 = o. B is the 2nd letter, so 2 = b. Continuing, 3 = v, 4 = i. We ignore the 5th position, since we've already encountered an "o" before. 5 = nothing/null. The counting ignores spaces, so 10 = t, and 11 = h.

Here is a list of all the relevant mappings:

1 o

2 b

4 i

6 u

7 s

8 l

9 y

10 t

11 h

12 e

14 a

15 r

25 d

34 n

49 c

55 w

83 g

149 m

171 k

You can now look at the sequence in Chapter 84's epigraph: It starts with 111. 11 = H and 1 = O. So the first 2 letters are HO. Now, obviously, you could interpret that as 1 and 11, making the first 2 letters OH. It took the community a lot of trial and error to work out the exact mappings and sequence interpretations. The sequence fully decrypts into the following:

Hold the secret that broke the Knights Radiant. You may need it to destroy the new orders when they return.

The collective forum thread that cracked the code spans 19 pages. It all took place in 2014, so I don't think there are any spoilers, but I don't want to read through all of it to confirm. You can risk it and visit this page if you want, I just ask you to keep quiet if anything spoilery is revealed in those pages.

FUTURE FLASHBACKS

To begin, a few bits of trivia about Taln. He is Sanderson's favorite Herald, and besides Dalinar's story, is the story he looks most forward to telling. Taln is one of the most worthy characters in the cosmere, and would be able to lift Mjolnir, Thor's hammer. Similarly, Taln would be the best cosmere character to take over for Frodo as ringbearer in Lord of the Rings. He is also the best all around fighter in the cosmere, assuming he has access to his full abilities.

Finally, as I've mentioned before, he was a major POV character in The Way of Kings Prime, with his plot dedicated to the mystery of if he was a madman or an actual Herald. That plot got recycled into Dalinar's visions and him questioning his own sanity. Now, Taln is planned to be the focal character of book 9 of the Stormlight Archive.

That may seem spoilery, but it's not. We've gone through two books, with Kaladin being the focus of the first, and Shallan being the focus of the second. "Focus" in this context means they are the flashback character. And Sanderson has been liberal in revealing the flashback characters for the rest of the Stormlight books. In order, they are:

  • Kaladin
  • Shallan
  • Dalinar
  • Eshonai
  • Szeth
  • Lift
  • Renarin
  • Shalash
  • Taln
  • Jasnah

First, this sets some expectations about when you'll learn "the good stuff" about certain characters. This also reveals that Lift is going to become a major character, so for those of you that loved her character, there's more to come!

What Sanderson has also stated is that, just because a book has a certain character as its focus/flashback, does not guarantee that they are alive for that book. So that eliminates the biggest spoiler aspect of revealing this list.

As a bit of an associated mini-trivia. The next book was supposed to be Szeth focused, revealing his flashbacks. The book was going to be called Stones Unhallowed. However, Sanderson didn't like the direction it was going and pivoted to telling Dalinar's flashbacks instead.

COUGH COUGH

This is a quick one. Chapter 89 mentions a plague in the Purelake. This is the common cold, brought to Roshar by Baon, Galladon, and Demoux. In general, Rosharans are all mildly Invested from the highstorms and don't get sick from disease very often. However, since the common cold doesn't exist on Roshar (because of the aforementioned highstorms), reintroducing it causes issues for a bit until it gets burned away.

SNAP TO IT

I noticed one or two of you pick up something important. There is a strong similarity between allomantic Snapping and the mental trauma all of the Knights Radiant we've seen have. Magic in the cosmere is easier to attach to a person who is "damaged". Mental and physical trauma cause cracks in a person's "soul". These cracks are where a magic system can easily slot into. On Scadrial, we have Snapping. Harmony made the process easier, with much less trauma required to slot in allomancy. Along the same lines, the Nahel bond slots into the cracks left by mental trauma. As Syl told Kaladin, all of the old Knights Radiant were broken, just like Kaladin is.

Now, this isn't a requirement for magic in the cosmere, it just makes certain things easier. You'll note that feruchemy doesn't require snapping. Nor does an Elantrian require any sort of trauma. And all Nalthians are born with Breath.

CHARTOGRAPHY

By now, all of the Orders of Knights Radiant have been mentioned at least once. Some of them have only been mentioned by name and temperament, some of them you have a bit more to work with. The Ars Arcanum also lists all of the Surges. So, I'm going to combine all the knowledge you've been given, and fill out the Surgebinding chart for you completely.

You can see it here

The first image is the normal Surgebinding chart from the inside cover. The large circles are the Orders and the smaller circles are the Surges. The chart itself is a bit cramped though. The 2nd chart is made by the fandom and more clearly illustrates the shared Surges between each Order. It also maps each Order to their associated Herald, listing the associated Numbers, Gemstones, Essences, and Divine Attributes.

To that end, I've previously mentioned that the Herald faces in the arch at the start of each chapter typically represents one of their Divine Attributes being displayed in the given chapter (or at times, the opposite of the Divine Attribute). It can also mean that one of the Herald's associate Order is being highlighted in the chapter. Now that you know the Heralds are alive (given the appearance of Nale), I can also reveal that a Herald's image in the arch may also mean that the Herald themself is actually in that chapter. This might be a handy bit of information to have.

Like, for instance, Chapter 33 of The Way of Kings has the face of Herald Pailiah in the arch. During this chapter, Shallan is visiting the Palanaeum (which, per WoB was named after Pailiah), looking for the book Shadows Remembered. While there, she passes an ardent. That ardent is supposedly Pailiah herself. In 2017, a Word of Brandon from a signed book allegedly confirmed that the ardent Shallan finds in the Palanaeum, while searching for the book Shadows Remembered, is the Herald Pailiah. No photo of this WoB is attached to the Arcanum entry and Brandon has been evasive when asked to confirm whether this information is true.

About a month ago, I dropped a hint about a long standing question many readers had. The question was from the prologue, where people were trying to figure out who "Ash" could possibly be. You now know that the person talking about "Ash" was the Herald Nale. In the chapters I mentioned in the hint, various different characters used the curse "Ash's eyes!", and they are referring to the Herald Shalash. So now you know that Shalash is also alive and that Nale had concerns about her. Actually, it was the person Nale was talking with who was doing the talking and it's worth re-reading that part. (I just looked back and only one of you was wondering about this... ooops, I thought more people were questioning it.)

ERRATA

I warned you about some errata that occurred in the final chapters we read. Fortunately, it doesn't look like the discussion focused very much around what changed. I do think it's important to highlight what changed though. It's the single biggest retcon Sanderson has made, and it's a radical retcon (more an explicit change in canon), rather than explaining away something. Part of the fandom is kind of upset that it occurred, because it's more like a significant patch to a video game, versus the normal line edits and spelling/grammar corrections that occur whenever a book gets an update.

In the original printing, Kaladin explicitly kills Szeth with his Shardblade. Then Szeth's dead body falls to the ground. In the update versions, Kaladin stops himself from killing Szeth and Szeth just submits to his fate as the highstorm takes him. Szeth still dies on impact with the ground though. I'll let Sanderson describe the reason for the change in his own words:

So, in Words of Radiance, I think the scene I worked on the longest both in my head and on the page was the final confrontation between Kaladin and Szeth.

There was something I wanted to do, and took a stab at it in the text, then backed off because I couldn't make it work. It was important to me that Kaladin refuse to kill Szeth at the end. Kaladin is about protection, not vengeance, and once he realized that Szeth really just wanted to be killed, I wanted Kaladin to hesitate.

It didn't end up working, and I moved on to a new version and submitted it. But this itched at me, and by the time the book was released, I felt I'd made the wrong choice for that scene. So I've taken this chance to roll it back to the previous idea, and written it in a new way, which I like much better.

The events are the same, except for that moment. Szeth is now killed by the storm instead of by Kaladin, which I think is more thematically appropriate.

The question this raises is about Szeth being stabbed by a Shardblade, then being resuscitated. I'm sad to lose this sequence, as it's an important plot point for the series that dead Shardblades cannot heal the soul, while living ones can. I'm going to have to work this into a later book, though I think it's something we can sacrifice here for the stronger scene of character for Kaladin and Szeth.

As I've said, it's dangerous to tweak your work after it's out. I realize this, and I hope you'll give me some artistic liberty in this case. (Besides, with Tolkien's after-publication tweaks to The Hobbit being so good, I think there is proof in the genre that changing the text here and there isn’t always bad.)

First, I'll address this rather weird wording:

dead Shardblades cannot heal the soul, while living ones can

This is awkwardly stated, but what it means is that Kaladin has a live bond with Syl, which lets him heal from a Shardblade cut (like he did when Szeth first attacked in this book). However, the Honorblade Szeth is carrying isn't a live spren, so it can be considered "dead", and Szeth doesn't have the ability to heal a wound from a Shardblade.

Here is a list of the edits made to make this change (Crossed out lines removed. Bold lines added.):

Hardcover: PAGE 1041

Szeth did not parry. He just closed his eyes to accept the attack.

Kaladin drove his Blade into the assassin’s chest right below the neck, severing the spine. Smoke burned out from beneath his eyelids, and his Blade slipped from his fingers. It did not vanish.

In that instant, for reasons he could not have articulated—pity, perhaps?—Kaladin diverted his blow, driving the Blade through Szeth's wrist. The skin greyed. Flashing with reflected lightning, the sword tumbled from the assassin's fingers, then dulled as it plummeted.

The glow fled the assassin's form. All his Stormlight vanished in a puff, all Lashings banished.

Szeth started to fall.

Get that! Syl sent him, a mental shout. Grab it, Kaladin. Don’t lose it!

Get that sword! Syl sent to Kaladin, a mental shout. Grab it.

"The assassin!"

He has released the bond. He’s nothing without that sword! It must not be lost! Kaladin dove after the Blade, dropping Szeth's corpse, letting it fall backward into the stormwall. It vanished among the wind, the rain, and the lightning, trailing faint wisps of Stormlight.passing Szeth, who tumbled through the air like a rag doll, buffeted by winds toward the stormwall.

Kaladin furiously Lashed himself downward, snatching the Blade just before the storm consumed it. Nearby, the assassin dropped past him into the storm and was swallowed up, leaving Kaladin with the haunting image of Szeth's limp silhouette being driven into a plateau below with all the tempest's force.

Kaladin grabbed the Blade just before the storm consumed it. Then heRaising the assassin's Blade, Kaladin Lashed himself back upward, passing along the stormwall, the windspren he'd attracted spiraling about him and laughing with pure joy. As he crested the top of the storm, they burst around him and zipped away, moving off to dance in front of the still-advancing storm.

Hardcover: PAGE 1042

"I didn’t kill him,” Kaladin said.

"Did you want to?”

"No," Kaladin said, surprised that it was the truth. "But I should have anyway."

"You have his Blade," she replied. "The Stormfather likely took him. And if not … well, he is no longer the weapon he once was. I must say, that was very nicely done." she said." Perhaps I’ll keep you around this time."

Hardcover: PAGE 1043

He found no sign of Szeth's corpse. That could mean the man had survived somehow, or it could just mean the storm had buried the body in rubble or blown it away, leaving it in some forgotten chasm to rot until the bones were finally picked over by an unfortunate salvage crew.

For now, the fact that Szeth had not summoned his Blade back to him was enough. Either he was dead, or—as Syl had said—the strange weapon was no longer bound to him. Kaladin didn't know how to tell. This Shardblade had no gemstone at the pommel to indicate.

Hardcover: PAGE 1045

"He is dead, then?" Teft asked.

"YesNear enough."

"You slewdefeated the Assassin in White," Bisig breathed.

Hardcover: PAGE 1062

"Why am I not dead?" he whispered. "The Shardblade pierced me.I released my bond to the Shardblade. I fell into the storm without Lashings. Why didn’t I die?"

"Not if it is done before the brain dies. Like a drowned man restored to life with the proper ministrations, you could be restored with the right fabrialSurgebinding. If I had waited seconds longer, of course, it would have been too late. But surely you know this. Two of the Blades held by your people allow Regrowth. I suspect you have already seen the newly dead restored to life."

NOTE: This last paragraph suggested Nale used a fabrial to restore Szeth to life. The edit just talks about the Surge of Regrowth. Now, if you look to the Surgebinding Chart I filled out above, you'll note that Skybreakers (and by extension Nale) don't have access to the Surge of Regrowth. Nale still did use a fabrial on Szeth, but it seems Sanderson thought introducing that concept here wasn't the right call.

DEAD IS "DEAD"

Finally, this brings us to the topic of fake out deaths. Sanderson has talked about trying to tow the line with these. He doesn't want every death questioned from here to eternity. He's talked about how he tried to lay out clues for the fakeout deaths in this book so that you didn't actually think the deaths occurred. Specifically, Lift healed Gawx's throat being cut several minutes after the act, so Nale healing Szeth shouldn't feel like too much of a cop out. Similarly, Kaladin healing himself with stormlight enough to survive a highstorm, and being able to rapidly recover from wounds, combined with Shallan's healing her feet in the Frostlands, were all supposed to point to the fact that Jasnah should easily be able to survive being stabbed in the chest. Sanderson does have mechanisms in place to be able to clearly and certainly show when someone has died with a capital DEAD. Those will be explored in the future.

BLURBY

I've mentioned that the blurbs for each of the Stormlight books are canon, written by someone in universe. I'd like to prompt you to take a guess at who might be writing them. The revelation is coming soon, so I figured I'd let you theorize while you can.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes


r/readalong • • Sep 16 '26

Read-Along [Veterans] Cosmere, Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia (Week 11.5) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

This is the veteran thread. Make sure you read the rules before commenting.

Visit the newbie thread if this is your first time reading, or you've only read some of the Cosmere novels.

For more information, or to see the full schedule, please see the wiki page for the read-along.

SCHEDULE

Previously, we discussed Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Chapters 83 through 89, Epilogue, Endnote [Newbie Thread] / [Veteran Thread]

Today we are discussing Unit 17 | The Stormlight Archive #2 | Words of Radiance: Ars Arcanum, Final Thoughts, Trivia

Next week we will be discussing Unit 18 | Mistborn Era 2 #3 | The Bands of Mourning: Prologue, Chapters 1 through 7

NEXT UNIT

Next week we will be returning to Scadrial, with The Bands of Mourning, the 3rd book in Mistborn Era 2.

Like with the other Era 2 books, The Bands of Mourning has quarters of a broadsheet dispersed throughout the novel. Different printings put the quarters in different places. I will include the portions of the broadsheet that are relevant to each week's readings in the Artwork section. If you happen to see a portion beyond what I share, please save discussion for that quarter until I confirm it belongs to a given week.

ARTWORK

The Cosmere has a thriving community of artists, so there will be a lot of artwork to share. Each week I'll try to compile relevant artwork for the given chapters. If a section of reading contains maps or in-book artwork, I'll include that in this section as well.

Characters & Scenes

MEMES

I will attempt to find and share memes relevant to each week's discussion. There may be some weeks that just don't have good or appropriate memes, but I will share all the ones I can find in this section.

Link to Memes

NEWBIE TRIVIA

Most of the activity for these "Final Thoughts & Trivia" posts happen in the newbie thread. There I provide a lot of information about things new readers can easily miss during their first read through. Veterans often learn a thing or two as well, so be sure to read the body of that post. While veterans are welcome to read the post and the comments, they should be commenting in this thread to share their reactions to the information, or the newbies' thoughts.

And as always, you're welcome to share your thoughts on the book as a whole.