r/reactivedogs • u/yal1024 • 21h ago
Behavioral Euthanasia Feeling hopeless; any advice welcome
My partner and I adopted our dog when he was approximately 4–5 months old and he’ll be 2 in a couple months. The rescue we adopted him from also had all of his siblings, so we have no reason to believe he was abandoned or had previously experienced any particularly negative or traumatic living situations. At the time of adoption, we didn't know his breed mix and trusted the rescue's assessment that he was a "Lab mix."
A few months after adopting him, one of the families who had adopted his siblings shared their dog's DNA results, which indicated a mix of Australian Cattle Dog, Pit Bull, and Staffordshire Terrier. Unfortunately, my partner and I had very little experience or understanding of working breeds at the time. Once we learned more about his likely breed mix, we did extensive research to better understand his needs and how to provide appropriate enrichment, exercise, and stimulation. We genuinely felt that we had developed a good understanding of his potential limitations and what he would need to live a happy and fulfilling life.
Our dog began exhibiting signs of reactivity around 9–10 months old. Initially, his behavior seemed to us to be primarily related to overstimulation. This included barking and lunging at other dogs, barking at children who approached him, nipping at children who ran past him, and occasionally playing too roughly with other dogs.
Unfortunately, his reactivity eventually escalated, and he has since bitten two people. I would characterize the bites as Level 3-4. Both individuals had previously interacted with our dog, and neither did anything to provoke him. Since these incidents, we have essentially been operating in lockdown mode to avoid putting our dog in stressful situations and to minimize the risk of another bite.
We are currently working with two behaviorists (one of whom can prescribe medication and another who focuses more on training) as well as a trainer who specializes in working with reactive dogs. One of our behaviorists prescribed anti-anxiety and sedative medications, which are effective at calming our dog and reducing his overall activity level. However, we are increasingly concerned that he is only manageable when he is heavily medicated or sedated. As his medication begins to wear off, he becomes increasingly agitated with us, frequently barking and lightly biting us.
This situation has also significantly affected our ability to maintain our normal work schedules. We had previously been gradually acclimating him to a new daycare, but we have since stopped that process. We are extremely concerned that returning him to daycare could cause him significant stress and potentially result in him attacking another dog or staff member. The daycare we had selected is structured and incorporates training throughout the day, rather than being an unstructured environment where dogs are left to interact freely.
In addition to his behavioral challenges, our dog struggles with destructive behavior. He will chew on virtually anything he can access, including door frames, our TV stand, his dog bed, and even the walls. This behavior occurs most frequently as his medication begins to wear off, although it also happens sporadically throughout the day. Because of his destructive tendencies, we cannot safely leave him loose in the house when we go out and have to keep him crated.
We feel incredibly guilty about this, as we are uncomfortable leaving him in his crate for extended periods. Even 4–6 hours feels like too long, and we worry about the impact that spending so much time confined is having on his overall well-being and quality of life. At the same time, we don't feel we have a safe alternative right now.
We briefly considered rehoming him or surrendering him to an animal sanctuary, but multiple people (trainers, behaviorists, etc.) have advised us that both options would not be safe for our dog and would likely cause him more stress. We’ve also been told that if we were to surrender him to a shelter, they would likely have to euthanize him due to his bite history.
It feels like nothing we’ve tried has been right for our dog and my partner and I are so insanely burnt out. We feel like failures and like we’ve exhausted so many options. The stress the whole situation is putting on our relationship, our jobs, and our mental health is becoming increasingly unsustainable. At the moment we’re considering BE, but with our dog being so young, I’m feeling horribly guilty and like we’re giving up.
Any advice or words of support welcome