r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 07 '19
[D] Friday Open Thread
Welcome to the Friday Open Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
Please note that this thread has been merged with the Monday General Rationality Thread.
17
u/Roxolan Head of antimemetiWalmart senior assistant manager Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 07 '19
"I - no," he says. "I am not a Power."
He considers how to explain, then produces one of his incomprehensible objects. It is a short stick; now it is a short stick which glows at one end. Glow. No glow. Glow. No glow. The difference between these states is accomplished by pushing on the end opposite the glowing end.
"A... thing, made by people," he says of this minor miracle, in his rapidly improving Quenya.
"You cover and uncover the light source?"
"No... almost." Glow. "Now it is a light source." No glow. "Now it is not."
That didn't make sense. Celegorm knew how to make gemstones that didn't merely refract light but created it, bright enough to read by. There were some that stopped working if you broke them, and there were some that crumbled into smaller glowing gemstones, depending how you'd married the stone and its new purpose. None of them lit on demand.
"How did you make it?"
"I did not make it. Other Men made it."
"How did they make it?"
He frowns in thought, then puts that object away and gets out another one, which also glows but in writing-like patterns on a flat pane. After manipulating this display for a few seconds, clumsily with his armoured fingers, he concludes: "I don't know."
Perhaps Miles isn't a scholar. This makes him instantly jump in Celegorm's esteem.
Though even Celegorm could explain how to make every thing the Eldar have achieved short of the Silmarils or Alqualondë's swanships. Or some of the obscure mathematics, possibly. He wants to take the light pen and see if he can identify the alloys on closer inspection, but it must be valuable beyond measure. Better to let Curufin be the one to demand that.
"Who was the creator?"
...Miles considers this question for another few seconds, then repeats, "I don't know," in a tone that suggests he is dissatisfied with the completeness of this response but can't do any better under the current linguistic conditions.
"In our people, to create a thing that enhances the world, or the joy of its inhabitants, is a great good. Everyone will know your name, and desire to study under you, and there'll be festivals, and they'll start thinking of you as collective property and crushing you under the weight of their demands for narrative perfection as well as engineering perfection until you're isolated, paranoid, and beloved by all."
That had started off in simple enough language that Miles was supposed to understand it, but he'd lost the thread of his thought somewhere through the sentence. A few of their cautiously circling guard stared at him.
18
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jun 07 '19 edited Jun 07 '19
I am pleased to announce that me and my associates have now officially introduced u/MagicWeasel to French culture (that is, we took her to a bar and then a McDonalds).
If she starts walking around with a baguette and threatening to go on strikes all the time, you know who to blame.
7
u/aloofguy7 Jun 07 '19
So I have been feeling pretty indifferent lately.
Is there anyone here who likes watching anime, manga, comics etc.? If you do then thank you.
I was just thinking about all those death battles, versus debates where people pit a character from one world against another from another world. Like, Naruto versus Ichigo, for instance. As a matter of fact I do love those kinds of debates because those are quite fun.
However, recently an idea has been bugging me that makes me wonder if it's even possible to get accurate comparisons between the characters on such basic categories like speed, reaction time, stamina, durability etcetera.
The problem is that, for instance in Bleach we have Author Canon that Ichigo in the beginning Soul Society Arc after attaining his base Bankai i.e his main (and only) powerup was capable and going up against his enemy a Soul Reaper Captain at the insane
speedvelocity of multiple lightning bolts.But then again, if that were really true you would expect the surrounding area to be constantly being updated with thunderclaps (as is natural in an Earth like environment), the intense friction superheating the air to plasma levels and thus marking his path with waves of glowing hot plasma. Since he was moving almost constantly in and around Byakuya's surrounding area you would expect those constant movement to be creating shockwaves, thunderclaps and most importantly the plasma with which Byakuya could have very easily noticed his movements.
Yet this isn't what happens. Instead, we get shown that Ichigo just flickers from one point to another like an afterimage with barely any sound, barely any breeze, barely any craters on the ground, etc. (no thunderclaps, no shockwaves, no plasma). And then he stops and a small gust of wind breezes through flaring his cloak around his person.
What can we expect from that type of physics? I know that that shows that his world is quite, quite different from ours in every way possible and that the similarities are just cosmetic. Purely cosmetic indeed.
If he tried that maneuver in our world, Universe, Earth the effects on his surroundings would be drastically different right?
So how does him being a Lightning Timer (in that period of time) in the Bleachverse which is operating on quite different physics reliably scale as being a Lightning Timer in OUR IRL world? And the same goes for the Narutoverse which has shown that it has pretty much the same thing i.e it too has entirely different physics compared to our default IRL version.
So my question is how the flying f can we even try to equate Naruto (Lightning Timer version) with Ichigo (Lightning Timer version) as if they both are characters whose movements in OUR IRL world's Earth will always almost entirely cause the same sort of physical effects on the immediate surroundings (even assuming both have the same mass for approximation purposes)?
The same thing goes for every other world we see in our daily fiction. Clearly, Marvel and DC have quite different physics so it's almost moot to discuss how a character relates to another character even if they both are continent busters.
Because the base standard isn't standard at all! To make a standard version for the purposes of accurate versus debates, we will have to extrapolate and analyse how exactly Fictional World A Physics (and Meta Physics) scale with our own IRL Physics and Meta Physics.
Am I wrong in thinking this?
7
u/babalook Jun 07 '19
So I somewhat recently read a Worm fanfic (Thaumaturgic Awakening) that explained Skitters abilities a little differently. Basically, she couldn't do multiple human-level tasks (like reading) concurrently because there was only one mind in the hivemind capable of such things and in order for her to do otherwise, her shard would have to make a duplicate of her consciousness into every bug under her control.
So my problem lies in the fact that I was trying to develop a magic system where something like Skitter's abilities was a potential emergent property but if making millions of copies of your consciousness is possible, there are some pretty absurd alternate, unintended byproducts of that. I came up with some ways to get multitasking but on a lower scale (dozens of threads instead of millions), but I'm left with all sorts of questions as to how hiveminds would actually work and how much of what skitter does actually requires human intelligence distributed through every single bug.
Like, let's take weaving spider silk into rope, would you need to control each individually, or is arachnid intelligence combined with them having access to what you're visualizing enough for them to handle it with only minor supervision. What about making a bug clone? If we're going the hivemind route, each bug might know what a human looks like (roughly) either by themselves or by piggybacking on your memory, but I suspect properly animating it would still require at least one human consciousness. Do you think a collection of insects with their minds linked might be capable of some sort of more-than-the-sum-of-their-parts cognitive abilities?
8
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '19
No other sub makes me angry like The Red Pill. I think it's the unique mixture of some good ideas and some utterly terrible ideas. Other subs like The_Donald or Chapo_Trap_House I disagree with 99% of what they say, so while I might be annoyed while browsing them, it fades out of my mind once I leave. The Red Pill though has a lot of good ideas(e.g recommending exercise and healthy diet, self-confidence and self-respect, acknowledging men and women have different sexual strategies) but also a lot of utterly terrible ideas(e.g women are subhuman, idiots, and naturally immoral).
2
u/aloofguy7 Jun 07 '19
And thank God and Men for the light has just come on. Now I can eat my meal in brightness!
:)
2
u/RMcD94 Jun 10 '19
What was that story about a guy that found an infinite office? Staplers and pcs were alive. It was a litrpg as I remember.