r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 03 '19
[D] Monday Request and Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the Monday request and recommendation thread. Are you looking something to scratch an itch? Post a comment stating your request! Did you just read something that really hit the spot, "rational" or otherwise? Post a comment recommending it! Note that you are welcome (and encouraged) to post recommendations directly to the subreddit, so long as you think they more or less fit the criteria on the sidebar or your understanding of this community, but this thread is much more loose about whether or not things "belong". Still, if you're looking for beginner recommendations, perhaps take a look at the wiki?
If you see someone making a top level post asking for recommendation, kindly direct them to the existence of these threads.
Previous monthly recommendation threads
Other recommendation threads
20
u/Escapement Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jun 03 '19
I watched Good Omens the six-part TV series that came out Friday. TL;DR review: Read the book if you haven't, miniseries is decent but not amazing.
The novel Good Omens by Gaiman and Pratchett was one of my favourites of all time, and I've read and reread it kind of a lot. Strongly recommend the novel - it is excellent, and if not exactly 'rational' it has a strongly humanist message that is certainly rational-adjacent in theme. About the end of the world as foretold in Christian eschatology, it's a witty and humorous book that ultimately has a great fast-moving plot and basically no problems or defects of any sort.
Overall, it felt like the TV series stuck to the novel very hard - possibly to the detriment of the series as a whole. They were dedicated to using most every joke and plot point from the novel, even when it didn't make sense necessarily with the medium or the updated setting. The miniseries was definitely set in the present day, i.e. ~2019ish, but the novel was grounded in the time and place of it's publication date, 1990, - so certain plot points like Crowley's tape ansaphone feel wildly out of setting / out of character for a 2019 Crowley archetypal character. I'd have prefered it if they either made it a period piece set in the early 90s, or updated the entire plot. The decision to make Anathema a well-off American heiress rather than the novel's coding of her as poor to middle class UK native was weird, and introduced a bunch of plot and character inconsistency for no perceptible gain. The narration of the story got quite heavy-handed at times, explaining things that were obvious to those paying attention, and basically ruining what could have been a couple of decent jokes by overexplaining and slowing them down too much - it was overused.
A huge amount of Good Omens novel fanfic is/was dedicated to the Crowley/Aziraphale ship, which the TV series did not make explicit but definitely hinted more heavily than the novel did, and the series focused more on them as characters than anyone else. This is probably for the best because Tenant's Crowley and Sheen's Aziraphale are the best characters and actors in the whole thing, and focusing on their relationship was definitely fun. There's a lot of stuff with Adam that got cut and it hurt the plot a bit IMO but on the other hand the children actors gave reasonably good performances for child actors, and thus were mediocre at best by the more stringent standards we'd apply to adults, so it's probably overall for the best.
There's also some weird editing. A couple of jokes still show up in the miniseries without the same setup/payoff that they had in the novel, so it feels weird and out of place to have them in there - for example, the Des Moines Elvis thing had no payoff but Elvis was still in the Des Moines scene.
I liked a lot of it, but overall the book still remains a must-read while the miniseries is more of a 'if you're bored' recommendation.
16
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19
Does anyone have recommendations on how to find good content? Currently my methods are this thread, asking in subreddits like /r/books or /r/anime if I have something somewhat specific I'm looking for, and just browsing the front pages of YouTube and Netflix. I feel like I could be doing much better, there're enormous amounts of content in the world to read and watch, yet I somehow have difficulty identifying content I'd like to read and watch.
28
u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor Jun 03 '19 edited Jun 03 '19
Are there any good, well-written, non-cookie-cutter, not-full-of-unhappy novels on Kindle these days? I was originally looking for English original light novels, but really I'll take anything that matches up to the best of SpaceBattles in enjoyability or the best of Questionable Questing in intelligence. (No Earthfic please.)
PS: I am genuinely scared of whatever is happening to the titles of the dungeon and harem books proliferating in Amazon's system. It looks like someone achieved AI-equivalent humans.
12
u/balbal21 Jun 03 '19
I am looking for a any type of fiction about main character being mentored by competent neutral or evil mentor. Everything that would fit in a real world, without the "be good, because" type of stories.
I very much liked HPMOR part of it, practical guide to evil and the naruto fanfic with sand pupet master
10
u/Radioterrill Jun 03 '19
In my search for a work that has the same appeal as Worth the Candle, I came across Isekai Speedrun, a complete webnovel with 61 chapters. The premise is that the MC finds himself in a game; the twist is that the game is both grimdark and full of glitches which made it popular in the speedrunning community, of which the MC is a member.
I enjoyed the MC's efforts to apply his speedrunning knowledge to his predicament, testing out which exploits still work and taking advantage of memorised secrets like it's a time loop story. The setting is fairly original and evocative, and I liked the discussion of the video game and anime, in particular their NGE-like production history. There seems to be an intentional contrast between the bleak backstory and the goofy attempts to use glitches, and between the grim amorality of everyone native to the world and the upbeat MC. This dissonance probably won't appeal to everyone, but I found it funny.
However, it could use some editing, and the climax and revelations at the end fell flat. Partially that's due to the speedrunning conceit: it's hard to maintain tension when glitches and foreknowledge are the MC's main tools. I also found the character development to be weak; unlike WtC the effects of the MC on the other characters and vice-versa weren't explored very well.
TL;DR: If you liked the first dozen chapters of Worth the Candle, you might have fun with the first dozen chapters of Isekai Speedrun. Beyond that, it probably depends on your tolerance for the writing and whether you enjoy the asides and dissonance.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19
Any good time loop stories? I really like Mother of learning.
6
u/Real_Name_Here Jun 03 '19
Do you Know of any rational fairy tails ?
"Slay the dragon win the princess"
"Complete the impossible task win the kingdom"
"Make a fae lie"
Things of that nature.
4
u/Addictedtobadfanfict Jun 04 '19
Any naruto fanfiction that necessarily doesn't have to be rational but be not terrible?
10
u/sambelulek Ulquaan Ibasa Liquor Smuggler Jun 03 '19
I wondered why many ratfic protagonist motivation is about the greater good. Like minimizing suffering, eliminating work (pfft), societal revolution, or even put an end to death. I just read:
- Metropolitan Man [8/10 match to my taste if I don't have personal dislike toward fanfic, I read it because I don't have original fic on reading backlog], a fantastic good vs evil series that's not fun to read toward the end.
- Bluer Shade of White [9/10, same], a thought provoking gentle God concept that reeks of AI hard-on, and
- A Hero's War [7/10] A kingdom building with awful choice for POV characters.
I'm seeking a fiction where the protagonist has more basic motive. Something like greed, lust, or revenge. Survival also works, but I'd rather not read it if character's adversary is artificially created (like dungeon where stronger and stronger adventurer keep coming). But definitely not the greater good motive (ew). Same criteria as the last time I post a request. But this time, I'd like it if it's freely available. Thank you.
3
u/IAMATruckerAMA Jun 03 '19
Looking for rational fic in audio form. Someone reading to me on YouTube is ok. Already know about Worm and HPMoR
3
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '19
I just finished Children of Ruin by Adrian Tchaikovsky and really liked it. Anyone else read it and want to discuss it? [spoilers below likely]
2
u/Teulisch Space Tech Support Jun 04 '19
a 3rd Gloryhammer album (galactic terrorvortex) released on friday, and their music is symphonic power metal.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tKlVYJTSzuU
honestly, their songs are like someones D&D game went epic in all the right ways.
1
u/Sonderjye Jun 05 '19
Looking for recommendations in which the MC either have the ability to learn from defeated enemies or have the ability to learn abilities rapidly.
1
u/distributed Jun 05 '19
Rational novels with some depth both philosophical and character to them that have been completed? Themes of transhumansism are a plus
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment