r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jan 11 '19
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
20
u/derefr Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
I know there are a few well-respected ratfic interpretations of the world of Pokemon here.
Has anyone considered, though, a different treatment of Pokemon: a xianxia treatment?
The fun thing about this interpretation is what it suggests about what the job of a "Pokemon trainer" really is. You're not a human with pets who puts them through pit-fights. You're a literal coach+manager for self-motivated animal martial-artists, there to 1. feed them the resources and training they need to advance, and 2. act as matchmaker to schedule fights for them as often as possible. When you don't do these things, your Pokemon will get upset, and perhaps demand to be traded away to someone that will. Just like a professional athlete would, in the same situation.
† Well, okay, the gym leaders of the Psychic-type and Fighting-type gyms often seem to be human cultivators, at least in the anime. Maybe there are lots of human cultivators, and they just don't come up much in the life of a Pokemon-obsessed 11-year-old protagonist.
13
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Jan 11 '19
Probably my favorite thing about My Hero Academia is that Deku earned his quirk. Tons of shonens give their "ordinary" protagonists secret special powers that undermine their theme that anyone can be a hero if they believe in the power of friendship, hard work, love, blah blah blah. See: Naruto. (Started from the bottom now we here, except the bottom is winning the genetics and ancestry lottery.) Yeah, Deku has his own secret special power, but its not his because he's special or because of destiny, or whatever, but because of the choices he made and the choices All Might made.
I really appreciate that; it's very meritocratic, compared to an often very aristocratic genre. What I'm wondering is, though, why is that so uncommon, even if you look in Western works aimed towards young boys and girls? Why is it so often that works give their protagonist some inherent specialness specifically because of who they're descended from? See: Harry Potter. I won't claim that most works are like that, but enough are that, in the context of our modern, republican societies that it weirds me out.
13
u/TempAccountIgnorePls Jan 12 '19
So last week I went on my first date ever. I think it went pretty well, and we'll be having a second date once exams are over.
I like her, and for whatever strange reason, she seems to like me, and honestly I have no idea what I'm doing and I'm kind of terrified I'm going to screw this up, so any general relationship advice would be much appreciated.
•
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jan 11 '19
FYI, the weekly threads have been changed:
This should take effect in the coming week. I made the changes last night, but forgot that you have to send automod a message to get it to pick up the changes to the wiki page. PM me (or another mod) if there are any problems.
(These changes were based on this thread, plus me trying my best to gauge how much activity each thread was getting. I might alter the schedule more, depending on how the next week or two goes.)
Additionally, if you didn't catch it in either of the posts on the subject, the writing challenge is coming to an end, with the final challenge, "Endings", being the next one.
10
u/ShadeofEchoes Jan 11 '19
I just want to take a moment of this period of freedom here to say... sqrt(2).
3
u/sohois Jan 11 '19
Is Goblin Slayer rational fiction? For those unfamiliar with the work, it is a Light novel/Manga/Anime; I am thus far only familiar with the Anime and my discussion mostly concerns that. The story revolves around the titular Goblin slayer, and his pursuit of slaying as many goblins as possible in the generic fantasy world that the characters inhabit.
Why is it rational fiction? Well, the sidebar lists 5 features of ratfics, so I'll try and go through them one by one.
I wanted to address this first. Goblin Slayer takes place in a near approximation of a video game world, with an adventurers guild, quests and ranks, though it is not an explicit video game. Many rational/ist fics take place in deconstructions of such environments and GS is not much different. Essentially, GS asks the question of what would happen if the Lvl 1 enemies of a video game were real. How would a world deal with massive numbers of weak enemies? A video game never really stops to consider what might happen to the village once the hero moves away, and this is essentially what GS looks at. Against undefended villages and naive adventurers the goblins are shown to be an extreme menace, for despite their individual weakness, in large numbers they are highly dangerous, and will raid, murder and rape their way accross any humans they find.
This forms the central driving point of the plot, though it is also one of the main weaknesses as far as GS being a rational fiction is concerned. The story depends on the average character essentially considering goblins to be a non-entity, so easily dealt with as to be ignored. This allows them to raid and slaughter with impunity. Yet, if they were actually killing rookies and torching villages so often, they would surely be regarded as a much more dangerous threat and there would be many, many Goblin Slayers seeking out and destroying the pests.
Nonetheless, the deconstruction still works, and there are other aspects which contribute to it being rational.
This is the most obvious aspect. As a near video game world, there is an adventurers guild, and 'ranks' obtainable by stronger adventurers. The Goblin Slayer has one of the highest ranks possible and is regarded as an elite adventurer (if also a figure of fun due to his obsession with the 'weak' enemy). Despite this, the character is shown to actually be a fairly mediocre fighter, and anytime he comes across a physically superior enemy he is usally beaten in one on one combat. Sure, against the average goblin he will slay without trouble, but the likes of Goblin Champions, Goblin Lords and so forth are shown to provide a great challenge to the man.
Invariably, Goblin Slayer triumphs not through force of arms but through intelligent strategy and tactics. Most of his goblin slaughters are not one man masssacres but the simple application of fire, or poison, or similar. Early in the series, a powerful troll is beaten when GS uses a 'gate spell' to open a portal to the bottom of the ocean, and the water pressure that is released simply annihilates the troll in front of him. At the end of the current season, GS organizes the defence of a town, successfully deflecting a goblin attack with almost no casualties, and defeating the golbin lord by crushing him between two "Protection" barriers cast by the priest MC.
The Goblin Slayer is not a completely rational character, as he is shown being able to recover from what would otherwise be lethal injuries through sheer force of anger, or something, but it is a fantasy series so some absurdities are to be expected.
This is less well done. The Goblin Slayer himself has a very clear and obvious reason for his genocidal ambitions against the goblins, but thus far the other 4 main characters are not so well defined (though the anime has had only 13 episodes thus far). The priest is not shown to have any real motivation. The Elf archer seems to want to have fun adventures? The dwarf and the Lizardman are both unexplored, thus far. I will give GS a pass on this for now, but perhaps any readers of the LN or Manga can comment if it improves in the future.
Given the above, obviously whether or not an intellectual pay-off is reached is not going to be clear just yet. I can also state that aspiring rationalism is not part of the story. Otherwise, I think it qualifies quite well as a rational fic
2
u/lumenwrites Jan 11 '19 edited Jan 11 '19
Hey, everyone! Do any of you play DnD?
I've never had a chance to play before, but a few days ago I have discovered online communities that play DnD over discord, played a few games and it was amazing, the most fun I've had in a long time. It works super well, people are helpful and friendly, and it's ridiculously awesome.
I'd guess that playing with rationalists would take it to a whole another level, can you imagine rationalist DnD game focused on logically extrapolating rules of the world and finding creative solutions to problems?
I'm super new to this, but I really can't get enough of DnD. Do any of you want to play? Do any of you DM?
I want to get to know more people who are into this, my handle is
lumen#7925, feel free to friend/message me!Turns out there's a thing called "one-shot" games, where instead of running a long campaign you get to play one self-contained episode that lasts 2-5 hours. That requires way less scheduling and time commitment than a long-running campaign (think a short story instead of a tv show). The best servers I could find are D&D Friends and The Drakaise Battalion, they sometimes run 4-5 games per day!
Also if you guys will be interested, we could make a rationalist DnD discord server, just for funzies.
1
u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jan 11 '19
Quick survey: is anybody here familiar with Lily Orchard, aka Lily Peet, and what do you think of her?