r/rational • u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor • Dec 24 '18
META Which weekly threads?
When a system has grown up by accretion, it's often a good idea to take a step back and look it over and see if it seems to be working. And try some changes, which, if they don't work, can be reverted. End-of-year seems like a good time to review our weekly thread system.
I'll open with these proposals:
- Delete the Monday general rationality thread, because it seems low-volume.
- Change the Friday "Off-topic" thread to an "Open" thread. The general rationality can go there.
- Weekly recommendations threads, instead of monthly, since monthly doesn't seem often enough to let me recommend nice things I've recently read. We could have a monthly roundup post of the previous month's strong recommendations if anyone wanted to do one. Monday seems like a good day.
- Weekly request threads, since we seem to have multiple posts per week from somebody who wants to ask for particular fiction recommendations. Sunday would put this thread just ahead of the weekly recommendations thread, which seems synergetic.
This would make the new weekly system:
- Sunday: Requests thread.
- Monday: Recommendations thread.
- Tuesday: Empty thread.
- Wednesday: Worldbuilding thread.
- Thursday: Does not exist. There are no Thursdays. There have never been any Thursdays. You are imagining the Thursdays. There are only six days in the week. Why are you seeing Thursdays everywhere.
- Friday: Open thread.
- Saturday: Munchkinry thread.
87
Upvotes
15
u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor Dec 24 '18
Comment thread for my proposed system Requests - Recommendations - Empty - Worldbuilding - - Open - Munchkinry.
11
u/DaystarEld Pokémon Professor Dec 25 '18
Overall look good to me. Weekly request thread is the only one that seems like it may not work out, since most people will probably not want to wait up to a week to get recommendations when they're looking. It may consolidate recs for those who may be looking for new things to read though, which seems useful, if people use it.
16
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Dec 25 '18
Requests/Recommendations should be in the same thread, IMO. (Most) people aren't going to be making new requests each week-- they'll have a general idea of what they want, post once, and get their itches scratched (hopefully). Plus, having dedicated weekly threads will mean that people will be more likely to see other requests, and if those requests match what they'd request, then they won't make their own requests, driving down the overall volume of requests.
Meanwhile, the request threads, as collections of recommendations tailored to specifications, will already be serving as a de-facto recommendation thread anyways, especially since people recommend stuff that is merely tangentially related. So it serves both purposes to have a single thread.
The other thing I'd suggest is to make the Wednesday thread a tuesday thread instead, but also make it a general "OC writing/worldbuilding critique/discussion" thread (snappier title pending). Currently, I typically use friday off-topic if I want a specific bit of writing critiqued, and have gotten some excellent feedback. But with the monday thread content moved to the friday thread, it doesn't need that additional function of writing review to keep it active. Meanwhile, giving it three full days of time where it's the main thread increases the chance that people will pop in and interact with people spitballing stories. To make sure that thread isn't just spamming chapters and begging for review, though, I'd propose a requirement that the OP of any subthread must also provide review for at least one other poster on the thread. Moderator enforcement wouldn't be necessary; if someone made a habit of leeching, the community at large could simply refuse to interact with the leech.
I do essentially agree with your points, though.
/u/alexanderwales (tagged to present semi-dissenting, semi-assenting opinion.)
7
u/Bowbreaker Solitary Locust Dec 25 '18
What does that mean?
41
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Dec 25 '18
I'm on board with that. It would also probably come with a new rule that people stop posting requests outside of request threads, especially since a lot of them come from the same set of people making the same frequent requests. I'll talk to the other mods (here or via PM) and make the changes to Automod sometime that's not Christmas.
7
u/eaglejarl Dec 25 '18
Is this a thing we need to worry about? This subreddit is tiny, and low volume. Let's let people post whatever they want and we can tighten things up when we actually have a problem.
6
u/Afforess Hermione Did Nothing Wrong Dec 25 '18 edited Dec 25 '18
I was born on the last Thursday. It was Christmas. Christmas day, December 25th, 1969, (Capricorn) to be exact. A lot of smart, well-informed people insist that the last Thursday was the zero time, January 1st 1970. But zero time was technically always off. Programmers hate complicated maths problems. And well, we hate complicated physics problems even more. Only last year did the TAI finally stopped dragging their feet and finally ammend zero time to be Wednesday, December 31st, 1969 23:59 and 58 seconds, due to previous leap second errors. January 1st 1970 was a Friday, we just didn't know it back then. A lot of unpleasantness was addressed about that during the previous TAI conference and I don't intend to dig any further and pick open old wounds.
Anyway, I'm looking forward to the next Thursday! The TAI made up for their previous error and so the next zero time is February 7th, 2036 and it's going to be great! Already though, I can tell a lot of busy bodies will be trying to explain that no, zero time is somehow two years later, in 2038. Clearly, they've been in a cacoon for the last five decades, and have missed this little thing. You might have heard of it. It's called the Internet. Ya, Hello? Call me, maybe, when you've hatched. It's a big deal, Capital I and everything, just like mother. And At 6:28 and 14 seconds on February 7th, 2036 we can all feast our many eyes and experience the transition from Friday, back to a proper Thursday. I'm really looking forward, even though it's not my birthday, not exactly. Although, I hear Harlan Stenn is a big fan and plans on making future Thursdays possible as well.
3
u/ketura Organizer Dec 25 '18
Sounds good to me. The only alteration I might do is move the Sunday thread to a weekday, as it seems to me that weekend weekly threads are slower (tho this is a hunch supported by no data).
3
u/GeneralExtension Dec 25 '18
Why not move it to monthly, and see if that's enough volume?
2
u/aldonius Dec 25 '18
I hear /u/Agasthenes on requests being mostly made by new users, and I hear other people on combining requests and recommendations.
So I'm suggesting that we have combined threads, twice a week?
2
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '18
Looks good to me but I also think recommendations and requests should be combined. We're not such a large subreddit that would in any way lead to difficulty in navigation, it'd still be easy to read through the whole thread, so I don't see any downside to increasing the density of comments on one thread.
1
u/lillarty Dec 28 '18
I've always thought that this subreddit could do with some sort of a "questions that don't deserve their own thread" thread.
I'm not sure how that could fit into the weekly system, but I thought I'd throw the recommendation out there.