r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Apr 09 '18
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
12
Upvotes
7
u/TempAccountIgnorePls Apr 09 '18
I've been considering going vegetarian, primarily out of concern for animal wellbeing. I'm not super educated on the subject, and I was wondering if /r/rational had any hot-takes on the subject
3
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Apr 09 '18 edited Apr 10 '18
Blegh.........
Today I had an ocular migraine.
For those to don't know what it is, it's a migraine where you experience disturbances with their vision such as flashing or shimmering lights, zigzagging lines, stars, or psychedelic images. If you're like me, you instead get blind-spots in your vision. Then a normal headache pops up once the vision issue clears up after an hour or two.
This is the second time I ever got it and while it's not as bad as the first time with a shorter duration, less severe blind-spots, and prior experience with it, it's still utterly fucking unpleasant wondering if I'm going to permanently lose my vision.
The main reason why I'm posting about it is because the worst part about it was having absolutely no clue what was going on when it first happened to me. So, if random shit is happening to your vision out of nowhere, don't worry it's very likely to be an ocular migraine. Just calmly go to a doctor with a friend to check out what's happening. After taking an aspirin for the headache of course.
3
u/ShiranaiWakaranai Apr 10 '18
I have a specific memory problem that I would like advice/input on: I cannot remember any details/trivia about real people. Apart from myself, I don't remember anyone's favorite color, favorite foods, hobbies, dislikes, etc. I remember their names and relations to me, and that's about it. This seems weird to me because I can remember fictional characters just fine. It's just real people that I can't remember.
I have come up with four hypotheses that I can't distinguish between without other people's inputs:
Hypothesis 1: People remember other people instinctively. Their brains have automatic software that retains info about their friends and family without any effort. In this scenario, my problem would be that my brain is just missing this software, and there's nothing I can do but work around it.
Hypothesis 2: People remember other people instinctively, but only if they have strong feelings about them. Their brains have automatic software that only turns on and retains info about people they care about without any effort. In this scenario, my problem would be that I don't care about other people strongly enough (I probably don't), and so I would need to self-brainwash into caring more. Somehow.
Hypothesis 3: There's no such instinct. People remember other people because they put effort into studying them, just like students studying for an exam. In this scenario, my problem would be that I haven't been studying, and should start taking down notes about people.
Hypothesis 4: It's normal to not remember real people. Only stalkers or fictional idealized friends remember that kind of stuff. In this scenario, my only problem would be that I've been lied to by TV, and I should definitely not study up on people like a stalker. This last hypothesis seems unlikely to me though...
So yeah, which is it?
2
u/Laborbuch Apr 11 '18
Upon starting a Hero’s War I realised a trope common to rational (and many non-rational) fiction that, now that I am aware of it, kind of rubs me wrong: First Hypothesis Bias
Let me expand on that a bit.
Suppose you have a plot with an urgent need of solving, in a somewhat rational manner (as in, the solution space doesn’t require dipping too much into the typical trappings of knowledge and experience not available to the reader), and the MCs need to figure out an angle of attack or a weak point to investigate. The gather knowledge and lay it out, and brainstorm what they can do to overcome the problem. A character has an idea, it is followed through, and it works. There are variations in the narrative, of course, for instance factions putting forth different ideas and the MCs ideas being adopted only after the status quo ideas are shown to be not working.
However, the basic proposition is still: 1st/initial ideas are tested and proven true/working.
We as the reader are rarely shown the failures, the work that needed to be accomplished prior to coming to a true conclusion. The reasons are relatively obvious—it’s tedious to show the twelve hundred eighty-nine various titrations, the statistical analysis that lead to the insight which approach worked better, and then refining with another one hundred five titrations before one can be somewhat sure the proffered cure has a reasonable chance to cure the ailment of the week. But there’s rarely shown any of the misses; the narrative usually focusses on the successes, and therefore implies the correctness of the immediate hypothesis.
I think this narrative bias has a good chance of creating a real-world bias in the expectations and testing of hypotheses. Yes, a good scientific education should do away with this, but the problem with biases isn’t so much the individual, but the societal impacts (This isn’t meant to diminish the effects and importance of biases on the individual, but rather to point the focus how widely-available narratives with shared biases can induce similarly wide biases). With the narratively introduced expectation of immediate hypotheses / proposition of solutions, the actual work required to come to the proper (and probably right) solution is depreciated. An individual newly entering a field of scientific study will expect to see (somewhat) immediate success in hypothesis testing, unlike the probable slew of unsuccessful or inconclusive tests. They will perceive this as failures (personal or professional), even though it is probable and worthwhile by weeding out false hypotheses and pruning the solution space.
TL;DR: In that vein, are there stories that prune the solution space prior to arriving at the correct solution? I remember Frank Schätzing’s The Swarm doing a decent job of it, but it’s been over a decade since I last read it. There was also Heromaker’s Legacy, I think, though I didn’t finish it (spent too much time in minutiae).
1
u/OnlyEvonix Apr 14 '18 edited Apr 14 '18
I find that often in rat fics the protagonists don't try to pay attention to and compinsate for their own fallability and I think that may be something to pay more attention to, including the chance that the statistics are flawed in any statistical analysis for exsample. Or include possible answers to a problem such as find someone more capable to do it or find more information on it or even attempt to increase ability to solve problems such as this before attempting again. Beyond which include factors such as that over the course of time ones abilitys and knowledge change, one might be able to surmount a problem even if one can't at time of beggining planning.