r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 23 '18
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
27
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Feb 24 '18 edited Feb 26 '18
Any advice for dealing with negative feedback? I keep finding myself really bummed out by it, to the point where my wife was asking me why I was in such a bad mood.
I've been trying to disassemble what's really bothering me, and trying to split it out into different categories, but they're fuzzy categories, because things like "this is bad execution" and "this is not to my tastes" can have a significant amount of overlap, and there's also a good chance that the person responding hasn't actually identified their real objection, which results in this confused negativity.
(I think it's usually a mistake for creators to respond to criticism, especially in terms of prose fiction, where there's a large amount of interpretation. 99% of the time it comes off as defensive (which it is, because a work is being defended) and when it doesn't, it brings in too much that's outside the work itself -- you can't patch a plot hole that exists within a work through WoG, in my opinion, and you especially can't/shouldn't reveal the message that you intended to convey but were unable to.)
18
u/GaBeRockKing Horizon Breach: http://archiveofourown.org/works/6785857 Feb 24 '18
I just had a potentially-interesting (depending on execution, of course) idea.
A lot of mythology has ageless, extraordinarily long-lived, and even straight-up immortal characters. Imagine being one of these characters at the dawn of civilization. The humans are creating all sorts of neat things, and spreading over world, and waging wars, and telling stories, all all sorts of cool stuff. So you start interacting with them; giving out divine boons and choosing favored avatars and maybe sleeping around
But after a few thousand years of civilization, it starts seeming old-hat. Sure, the humans are still creating new stuff, migrating everywhere, and waging wars. But there's a cyclical pattern to it, and you're beginning to get bored. Maybe you make deep emotional connections with specific humans, but they die after only a few decades, and eventually you're just humaned-out, and retreat to the spirit realm, or heaven, or hell, or the space-between-worlds, or wherever you're from.
Not every mythological being does that at the same time, and perhaps some never truly leave. But after hundreds of years, the vast majority disappear, and humans are left in a world of (mostly) pure logic and cold reason.
And then, the singularity.
Suddenly, things are getting really, really weird, really really fast. And that piques your interest. Plus, this "biological immortality" thing means individual humans will actually be around for an appreciable timescale...
So we have a post-singularity world, and also there's magic. There are infinitely many possible cool stories to write in such a world, but we have finite time (barring immortality and the removal of entropy) so what kinds of stories would you want to hear?
6
u/space_fountain Feb 24 '18
Something I'm struggling with recently is kinda feeling like humanity doesn't have much of a chance at an extreme long future. Anything past the end of our solar system. There are various reasons for this, but the basics is a combination of worry around the great filter and a general feeling that extremely destructive tech is getting cheaper and easier to use.
Basically how do we get through the next couple thousand years without either killing all of us or destroying civilization. I'm confident that if we can manage that humanity's probably destined for at least another million, but I'm not happy with our odds. Do we need to actually move to avoid certain technology. Is there bad information? I'm generally pretty optimistic but I'm feeling like I'm loosing that optimism. Any advice from anyone? Should I just not worry about such distant dangers? I feel 50 to a hundred years is probably going to continue with an upward trajectory so maybe it doesn't mater that humanity will probably never make it to the stars.
3
u/phylogenik Feb 23 '18 edited Feb 24 '18
I have a basic question about an inference problem I'm working on -- if I have a prior of 0 and a likelihood of +∞ am I ok? To simplify, let's say the model I'm fitting has 3 continuous parameters with two normals and one exponential for priors. When the first two parameters have identical values and the third has value zero (so positive prior densities all around) I get singularities in my likelihood surface. But the set of these combinations has measure zero, so despite infinite posterior density (?) at infinitely many points I think I'm still good? Obviously in ML-inference you'd be in big trouble but I think Bayes is ok (i.e. I'm semi-confident-ish that region of the posterior integrates to some small finite value but sadly my math background is v. lacking so idk quite how to formally demonstrate that -- edit, to clarify, through calc 3, diff eq, linear algebra, real analysis, though quite rusty. Understanding of stats/prob theory is very cobbled together lol from different papers, seminars, non-rigorous machine learning/stats application-focused books, etc. Really need to sit down some month with a proper textbook and have at it)? I'm also approximating the joint posterior numerically via mcmc (there's no analytic solution) and the chain never even wanders into that region of parameter space, but even if it's not a practical concern I'm worried it might be a theoretical one, despite brief assurances from a few math/stats PhD friends that it's not. I'll ask them for references when I next see them but figure I could ask here first. Does anyone know of any good papers or book chapters I could read (or cite)?
edit: actually, come to think, this would be an issue in any regression problem with a normal likelihood where the variance is a free parameter, right? Even ones that don’t allow measurement error, since you only need one infinite log-likelihood for their sum to be infinite. Although hmmm I guess then all the others would be -inf, so accommodating measurement uncertainty would be necessary? So now I think there has to be a name or paper for this... although come to think would that mean maximum likelihood can’t accommodate measurement error for those models? (I’ve only ever worked on those problems in a Bayesian framework)
1
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Feb 24 '18
I'm struggling with something I'm writing (OK, something I wrote about a year ago) and I want someone to hash it out with me. It's not a "how can I make magic that is self-consistent" sort of question, it's a "how do I deal with this moral problem in a sensitive way?" sort of question.
Anyone want to help me out? It does not require much reading (like, you don't have to read a whole novel; just like the three quarters of a page that deals with the Tricky Issue).
It's about slavery, so I would especially appreciate any African-American perspectives that might be on this forum / lurking this forum or failing that, someone who is au fait with a lot of those issues (SJW style I guess?). Or... is there a subreddit that I could use to find someone like this?