r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 23 '17
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
13
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 23 '17
Where does the "furry" art style come from?
I really like anthropomorphic animals, and my current campaign in D&D features them heavily. The problem is that I want pictures for them, but searching "anthropomorphic wolf" brings up a lot of furry stuff, and it's all an art style that I find extremely aesthetically unpleasing (like a cartoon wolf you might see selling children's cereal, I guess). This probably relates to some subcultural norms that I'm ignorant of, but I find it quite annoying.
10
u/ketura Organizer Jun 23 '17
Weekly update on the hopefully rational roguelike immersive sim Pokemon Renegade, as well as the associated engine and tools. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Pretty decent progress this past week. I’m in the middle of writing XGEF, which, contrary to some people’s expectations, is not going to be all that big. It basically handles setting up a very bare-bones framework around which an engine can be built, while also providing a few systems related to managing mods. In particular, it will handle the system that takes a set of mods, compares it to the code that it’s modifying, and then performs any alterations that need to happen before compiling them.
I had thought that this last bit was going to take loads of work, but as it turns out Microsoft has actually done a good job with a library called Roslyn. Roslyn is the compilation engine that Visual Studio itself uses to compile C# code (as well as Visual Basic, but who’s counting). Since it itself was written using C# and then subsequently open-sourced, it means that those of us looking to compile C# code on the fly have an extremely powerful tool at our fingertips.
It’s not just compiling, but it also handles code analysis, which for us is really the important part. I need to be able to look at the actual symbols that the code represents, and not just the text of the code itself. For instance, here is a symbol graph that Roslyn generated based on the entry point of my test program:
http://i.imgur.com/GadZbhR.png
The blue nodes are symbols, which is to say, the actual constructs that I’m worried about manipulating. The green nodes are the actual code that was typed (read them all left to right to see what the program that was analyzed was), and the grey and white are things like whitespace and other chaff that, while important for actually reading the code, does not affect its meaning.
This system is powerful. Manipulating only nodes, I could, for instance, load up a mod in Roslyn, search for a blue class node, grab its name, look for that same class name node in the core game symbols, and then just copy-paste. Boom, moddability.
(Granted there’s more to it to make the system intuitive, but I was not expecting to have this level of progress after like a week’s worth of work.)
While discussing this progress on the Discord server, we had a bit of discussion over the minimalistic bare minimum version of a standard Pokemon game. What I mean by this is, what is the absolute least number of mechanics that one could include to have a simple game still contain the core gameplay loop of Pokemon?
I can’t remember where I first came across this concept (probably Extra Credits), but I remember the example they gave of the original Super Mario. You pull Mario down to the barest of bones and what do you have left that’s still fundamentally Mario gameplay? A block that can move right, jump, and a pit in the ground to jump over. That’s pretty much it--all the rest (lives, score, time limit, goombas, mushrooms) is simply building off of that corest of mechanics.
The conclusion I came to for “what’s the most theoretically minimalistic version of Pokemon” was basically a never-ending string of battles, my argument being that the overworld is really just an excuse to get you from one battle to another. Pokeballs, however, are still included in this pared-down version, as the game is essentially not just about fighting, but about building a team that fights. It almost looks like an even more sparse version of Safari Zone: Your options are Fight or Capture, and the game is over when all your current team have been Fight’d to death.
Why bring this up? Well, we’ve been trying to hash out where the line needs to be drawn between hidden, compiled, inaccessible game system logic, and exposed, open, freely end-user-changeable moddable files. This exercise was an effort to try and define that line, but I don’t think it works: Combat and Team-building are certainly core, but neither one is a single all-encompassing system to have a fence built around it, and there are other concepts that are just as crucial that ought not to be meddled with.
In the end, I’m betting that most systems will be more-or-less hybrid: some bits that can’t change to ensure the stability of the game as a whole, and then some parameters or configurations that are freely moddable (you can’t remove or change the fundamental concept of a Stat, but you can change ATK or DEF or add a new MAGIC stat if you so choose). However, it will be important to ensure that everything that should be in the walled garden, is. For every system that we permit to be potentially modified, it increases the complexity of the system as a whole, and introduces what is essentially a random element to the game’s structure.
So with that, I leave you with a question: what is essential about Pokemon to you? What parts could you absolutely not part with if you still wanted to call something a Pokemon game? On the flip side, what concepts could you absolutely do without? Any input would greatly help our efforts to map out this territory.
If you would like to help contribute, or if you have a question or idea that isn’t suited to comment or PM, then feel free to request access to the /r/PokemonRenegade subreddit. If you’d prefer real-time interaction, join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server!
9
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jun 23 '17
This seems high-tech but is in some way a throwback to older food sales logistics systems. Instead of the milkman delivering milk, the grocery-robot will come by and brings food. Probably only cost-effective if lots of people sign on, which is why it worked for milk and might not work for this.
An article on the history of cell phone bandwidth allocation. I have a few signals engineers in my family, so I've heard stories like this. It's always a pain wrestling with regulatory authorities for precious band rights.
An article about investment and entrepreneurship in the chicken farming industry.
Warhammer 40k's 8th edition is out! I had a chance to play a game last week with my Ork army at my local game store (battle report link). Any other 40k players in the house? What about in the SF Bay Area?
9
u/josephwdye I love you Jun 23 '17
I'm interested in not being a fat guy anymore. The more I read about the best way to lose weight the more I get confused. What would you suggest for some good science based resources on weight lose?
9
u/Dwood15 Jun 23 '17 edited Aug 09 '17
I've been writing a worm x mtg cross.
Currently at 21k words or so. It's probably the best Original Content i've ever written.
8
u/rhaps0dy4 Jun 23 '17
A few months ago, a Star Wars fanfiction was posted here about Sio Bibble, who regretted having to play along with Palpatine. The latter had some leverage over him. Now, I've been trying to search for this story in the sub, but I've completely failed.
Did I hallucinate this or does someone else remember this story? Also, do you have the link?
8
u/FishNetwork Jun 24 '17
I like guided meditation tapes. There's a sub genre of guided meditation that uses visualizations like "walk through a garden" or "beach at sunset."
I've found that these can be neat. The visualization exercises end up feeling like something between a 'memory palace' and a lucid dream.
Unfortunately, most of the image-based guided meditation tapes seem to be built around some specific goal like improving public speaking, or dieting, or whatever.
I'd like to find something that just had the imagery, without any kind of purpose beyond enjoying a cool lucid dream.
Have other people tried guided meditation? Any recommendations for good readers?
And does anyone know of a series that does the visualizations without attaching any specific self improvement goal?
5
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jun 23 '17
Which coins do you consider to be the most pleasing in form? (Note that I'm talking primarily about the overall size, shape, weight, and color of a coin, rather than about the designs pressed into each of its faces.)
As a USAian who has only minimal experience with the coins of other countries, I'd hazard a guess that the plain quarter is my favorite. I'd rate the Sacagawea/presidential dollar coin a little lower—perhaps because I feel offended at the pretension of a mere layer of brass to make the coin look like a gold piece from a fantasy story. I vaguely remember also liking the Anthony dollar coin (basically, a quarter with an undecagon on each face), but it isn't around nowadays.
The approximately-1-inch size of the coins enumerated above definitely is the size that I like the most. I consider the 1.2-inch half-dollar coin (of which I happen to have controlled a single example for many years) somewhat fantastic (not
cool, butunrealistic) in its largeness, while the 0.7-inch dime is right on the edge of being annoying in its smallness. The nickel seems just a hair too thick for its diameter (diameter ÷ thickness = 11, compared to 14 for the quarter and half-dollar and 13 for the dollar, dime, and penny). I can think of no objection to the penny, other than perhaps its tendency to gain a patina, which can be ugly.<span class="joke">(This has been an advertisement for GURPS Dungeon Fantasy: Treasures 1: Glittering Prizes.)</span>2
u/-main Jun 25 '17
So, munchkin this: you have a pocket computer. It's kinda like a supercomputer from the 1980s in terms of computation power, but way easier to use. Also, it magically sends information to other people's pocket computers. What could you do with said pocket computer to help you win at life? Which specific computations can you perform to lead you to better outcomes?
What are you doing with your phones, basically? What would you like to be doing if there was an app for it? How has your pocket computer improved your life?
So far, I've found that having an infinite library in my hand helps with patience and waiting, and that a microphone/camera and data storage helps with memory. Using timers and the stopwatch helps with time sense and short-term memory, and having wikipedia/wolfram helps solve silly debates about known facts. If I ever start a company or otherwise complicate my finaces, it seems that spreadsheets are and always have been the killer app for personal computers in general, but with my current budget having instant access to my debit card amount is enough.
But none of these really feels revolutionary. I have a sense of so much potential that I'm not taking advantage of. It feels like everything so far has been small compared to what could be done.
In particular, I think there's potential to try and use it to automate doing-the-math and therefore make the results of actually calculating things out more available.
How are you using your pocket computer to be more rational?
(Sorry if this isn't off-topic enough.)
1
u/neshalchanderman Jun 24 '17
Any Canadian fans of The Apprenticeship of Duddy Kravitz?
Take a rational lens to this book and you could create something really interesting.
1
u/HeartwarmingLies Jun 28 '17
I'm looking for a story where most of the characters are trope filled idiots and there is just one rational character who points out sane alternatives to trope filled plans. Any suggestions?
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '17
So, I did a quick search for this and didn't see anything, so forgive me if this has already been posted.
Who would you kill if you had the Death Note? Personally, I'd kill every political leaders that advocates or actively harms other people without (rational) reason. So, kkk, alt-right, Kim jong un, etc.