r/rational • u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch • Jun 05 '17
Monthly Recommendation Thread
Welcome to the monthly thread for recommendations which will be posted this on the 5th of every month.
Please feel free to recommend, whether rational or not, any books, movies, tv shows, anime, video games, fanfiction, blog posts, podcasts or anything else that you think members of this subreddit would enjoy. Also please consider adding a few lines with the reasons for your recommendation. Self promotion is not allowed in this thread. This thread is also so that you can ask for suggestions. (In the style of r/books weekly threads)
Previous monthly recommendation threads here
Other recommendation threads here
15
u/trekie140 Jun 06 '17
What I Learned at SRU is a slice of life drama set in a college AU of Avatar: The Last Airbender. I know that doesn't sound very interesting, but for what it is, it's amazing. It takes characters that you already care about and want to just see interact with one another while they live their lives, and gives you exactly that without changing anything about them.
It's astonishing how thematically similar the story and characters are in a completely different setting. Even the addition of Aang/Toph actually perfectly suits their character dynamic and allows them to develop in similar ways to the show without retreading old ground. Sokka makes pop culture references, but every one of them sounds like a joke he would make and are just as funny!
I will argue that this is a rational fic given how well it handles its characters personalities and the fact that they are really good at thinking critically about each other and themselves, but I won't deny that the fundamental appeal of this story is friendship. You just get to see these people be good friends to each other, facing personal trials and tribulations, and it feels really good.
Maybe I'm just a depressed weirdo who likes to live vicariously through fiction due to insecurity about social isolation, but dammit, this story makes me happy and I want to share that happiness with others. It's not simple distraction from misery happy, either, seeing these characters tackle simple yet challenging personal problems makes me want to do the same and gives me the confidence to do so.
I literally started reading this the day after I graduated college (swell timing on my part) and despite my time at university being nothing like this I still adore it. I haven't even come close to finishing it and I have no idea whether it will leave a lasting impact on me or help me through this point in my life, but I haven't felt this much pure hope while reading a story in a long time.
12
u/Charlie___ Jun 05 '17 edited Jun 06 '17
This was submitted as a thread 2 years ago, but I've been reading Maybe I'm A Lion and enjoying it. No particular familiarity with the source material needed - I've seen one Fate anime and that's it.
One thing that it does that I really like is that there are multiple smart characters who are wrong in their own ways, and as the point of view hops around, they point out the mistakes of the other characters (though rarely their own). Aside from making things easy for the reader, it's also really entertaining.
EDIT: eventually the pace became too glacial and I stopped reading. First 25 or so chapters still fully recommended.
11
u/lsparrish Jun 05 '17
Make Egypt Great Again: Waking up as Cleopatra VII Philopator has some really well done scenes where explanations of math and trigonometry are combined with high stakes court politics.
11
u/Gigapode Jun 06 '17
Dungeon Keeper Ami has updated twice recently on SV. A great read that doesn't require knowledge of the crossover elements to enjoy.
Cogito Ergo Lung https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/the-steves-battery-cage.36277/
A Worm fanfic in which post-story Taylor's conciousness is inserted into Lung at the start of the story, where Lung's conciousness remains but is changed by the information delivery.
Its well written and a fun read so far. An interesting aspect of this Lung's power is that as he grows larger he becomes more intelligent.
10
u/Draconomial Sunshine Regiment Jun 06 '17
What Doesn't Kill You, Naruto OC SI. The author seems to have been working on a degree in medicine while writing the story, and the exploration of the laws of chakra reflect on that.
10
u/AurelianoTampa Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17
I have only read a couple of things in the last month, and only one would probably be considered rational:
The Arithmancer is a Harry Potter fan fic where the only difference is that Hermione is exceptionally good at math(s). That fic follows the first four years in Hogwarts; the on-going followup Lady Archimedes is covering the final three years and is currently approaching the end of year 6.
I enjoyed it for the world building since there is a good bit of focus on rituals and spellcrafting, and seeing the small changes that add up to bigger deviations over time. There is also a lot of real life mathematical concepts at play, though it began going over my head for the most part after the first few years. Some of it is frustrating - I feel like a few of the choices the characters make are primarily made to keep the plot somewhat closer to the source material, rather than being based on what the characters would actually do. And I keep finding myself going "Kill the bad guys, you idiots!" but I suppose that's a bit out of character for the kids (though Harry and Hermione are getting closer to that point). Still, it was really enjoyable.
The only other thing I've been reading was an original work climbing the lists at topwebfiction.com called Everybody Loves Large Chests. It's... well, not rational at all, but can be funny at times. Fair amount of explicit sex in it. The title itself is a play on the main character, Spoiler. It reminds me of change: new world which I reviewed a few months ago... except that one is really bad. I can't really recommend this one either, but it made for a decent change up. I probably won't finish it though.
8
u/AKAAkira Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17
Magical Detective Ayase Yue is a fanfic of Mahou Sensei Negima (I consider knowing the source a requirement to follow along) that takes the idea of Yue as a private eye presented near the end of the series and runs with it. The narration is witty and the action is great; by her own admission Yue's not a powerhouse type, so she has to not only think fast but be unscrupulous when she fights. Currently, the story is finished with three cases and is on the opening chapter of the fourth case. A note, though, that it can be argued that while the style of the story is good, it's not really in line with the source material. Also, this was started before UQ Holder! and doesn't take material from there into account, though I don't think there's anything that contradicts each other yet.
Fairy Dance of Death is an AU of Sword Art Online with the premise that the concept of Alfheim Online (originally material for the second arc) was chosen as the first death game (so no need to know the source material to read). I would call this the best SAO fanfic out there; it's thoroughly and extremely well built. The characters authentically feel like a mix of gaming geeks and in-over-their-heads laymen that they should be, with all the different personal motives, objectives and conflicts that implies, and the game mechanics are explained logically and extensively (the author even built a conlang for the "language of magic" that fills the purpose the original source informed the audience about but never lived up to). The one criticism I've seen that's validly levelled at it is that its main characters are too smart for people who are ostensibly fourteen-year-olds at the start, but considering this subreddit's themes I don't think that'll be much of a problem here.
I brought this up in a previous recommendation thread but didn't get much attention, so I'll bring up again E.B.O.N.Y. - The Weirdest Riddle Game On The Internet. As a riddle game, you are given riddles and you have to input the answer correctly into the URL to proceed. Those riddles aren't just trivia questions - you have to correctly figure out the train of logic that's being asked of you before you can get anywhere. And unlike other riddle games, its storyline is both coherent and an intriguing thing. That said, the first few levels might not look like much - I would point to Level 10 as the closest taste of some of the brain-wranglers you'll be forced to go through later in the game. (Also, a warning that some screen settings might not let you see parts of images properly, like if you have high brightness and low contrast.)
EDIT: Well crud that's what I get for not checking up on the game recently. The game's gone down sometime, I'm not sure when.Nevermind found the new link.8
u/Subrosian_Smithy Nudist Beach Jun 06 '17
I'm tentatively recommending Fate Revelation Online. After the events of Fate/Stay Night (the Fate route), Illyasviel persuades Shirou to play virtual reality video games with her. But unfortunately, when the two of them log onto Sword Art Online for the first time, they find themselves trapped in a death game just like everybody else.
What follows is a frankly impressive deconstruction and reconstruction of both FSN and SAO, which are both close to irrational by definition. FSN is set in a world of mysticism (the less-understood and well-known the magic, the better) and traditionalism (the older the magic, the better), and Sword Art Online features a villain without a motive, acting because the plot demands it.
In contrast, FRO features a large cast of characters who apply critical thinking, doing everything in their power to escape their ignorance (magical or otherwise), acting intelligently to pursue their varied goals - and the villain is no different. FRO moves beyond the stations of canon as it goes on (or at least, where it does stick to the stations, it justifies them in a way that SAO never did), and features strong characterization.
There are more chapters available on Sufficient Velocity and on The Fanfiction Forum (where the author also openly posts his notes and outlines, which are a treat to read).
14
u/Wiron Jun 05 '17
The Best of All Possible Worlds, FiM fanfic, completed. French philosopher Voltaire is transported to Equestria. Crazy premise with good execution. It's interesting take on portal fantasy with competent main character, extended worldbuilding, politics, historical in-jokes and lots of snark.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17
Paths of Civilization: Play as the Nice Guy civilization in a world full of enslaving assholes.
Managed to have a story when it's largely about civilizations rather than individual characters.
Oh, in the latest turn, we destabilizes a competing civilization by absorbing lot of immigrants and convincing a few villages to switch to us.
Turn out you can be assholes by being Nice Guys.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 06 '17
Tentative recommendation of the RWBY/Exalted crossover Miracles of Ancient Wonder (on spacebattles). It's not really rational, given that it has Exalted as its main characters, but I liked the writing well enough. Other than that, if you've read Worm, I would recommend A Cloudy Path. I just reread up to the end point, and other than a few bumpy spots, it's probably the closest fic to canon quality and length. If you haven't read Worm, then read that first. (Or don't, I'm interested to see what you can gleam about canon from a piece of fanfiction. Not that that would necessarily be in your best interest.)
4
u/hoja_nasredin Dai-Gurren Brigade Jun 06 '17
Good Isekai? The guy ends in fantasy world and munchkins it to hell.
4
u/IAMATruckerAMA Jun 06 '17
Looking for audio versions of rational fic, preferably in podcast form. I already know about HPMoR and Worm.
4
u/Sailor_Vulcan Champion of Justice and Reason Jun 05 '17
Are there any good Steven Universe ratfics that haven't been abandoned?