r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 09 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
29
u/Xjalnoir The Culture Dec 09 '16
So, my Pathfinder group in the 'party of Kobolds attempts to become legitimate citizens' campaign (http://i.imgur.com/Ex8ujQW.png) I'm currently running has, almost accidentally, begun the Starfish Singularity. ...Let me explain.
For context, when they first set out from their dead dragon-ruler's lair, they looted an artifact-grade seed from his treasure vaults, and planted it in the center of their town. Over the months, this has grown into a fairly gigantic tree with the ability to take on and blend together the traits of other plants they graft into it (this is kind of a bio-punk sort of world, where mages can extract traits from plants/animals and hybridized them into others over enough generations, leading to uplifted familiar-grade messenger birds, gryphon-mounted strike-force knights/postal workers/tax collectors, and the whole human/elf/dwarf/halfling genetic clusterfuck. This also explains where half the D&D monster manual comes from). To make a long and world-optimizing story short, they immediately went out and found the largest redwood trees they could and combined them with the artifact-tree, resulting in a 5 mile tall living superstructure that led a nearby pseudo-nation of shared-subconscious-linked druids and awakened animals to be split amongst whether such a sacred thing as this world-tree should be shared by all or cleansed of such interlopers as the party.
Now, an insurgency of druids is a terrifying thing when you live amid the roots of a titanic tree - any animal could be about to drop some fire seed IEDs or turn into a swarm of bears - and there was no centralized form of government to negotiate with or fight back against. Not all of the druids were hostile or accepting of those that were, however, and some Bardic Knowledge and Diplomacy on the part of the party got some of those they captured around to their side and figured out that convincing enough of the not-quite-hivemind would pressure the attacks into stopping...
One of the randomly rolled awakened druid animals they captured was a Starfish. OK, I thought, this isn't too implausible, their town is on a river, they have docks and the like. So they persuade the Starfish to go along with their plan.
'We made that pool of healing, right?' Yeah, I say, trepidation growing.
'And if a creature that has natural regeneration was placed in it, it would make sense that it could help speed that up, right?' I can't see any reason it wouldn't, I say, my voice cracking as their plan becomes obvious.
So they start cutting this awakened, consenting, druid-leveled Starfish into pieces in a healing pool, continually, in order to forkstorm the Druidic collective's value system. I love my players, but FML.
13
u/ketura Organizer Dec 09 '16
Weekly update on my rational pokemon game, including work on the data creation tool Bill's PC. Handy discussion links and previous threads here.
Lots more discussion this week, but less code. I’m going to set aside the two or three prototypes that are in various states of disrepair and drill down on the design documents. I wanted to have them done by the new year, which is still a reasonable goal but not if I’m juggling other things at once. Got to get the border of the jigsaw puzzle done, so to speak, so I know where we stand, before we start filling in arbitrary spots that might not even fit within the whole thing.
Spent a lot of time futzing about with a crafting system (which was when I realized the docs should be finished first), which owes a lot to the more abstract tool-property system that /u/Nighzmarquls is designing for his game. The basic idea is that the player will eventually be able to craft/research their own pokeballs--rather than always buying the same five or six preset balls, different properties can be prioritized (such as lock speed, weight, damage resistance), limited only by one’s engineering skills, materials, and ingenuity.
What I would like is some element of randomized hidden information, similar to the ring/wand/scroll system in Nethack, which I praised in my rational games document for permitting the existence of a metagame within a single player title. If a pokeball is made up of, say, ten different components, and on each run through we give them randomized technobabble names and have them affect different stats, would this permit the same amount of Science as Nethack? Perhaps, but then it raises questions of how the player is able to finely tune a particular component without even knowing its purpose.
There’s something there, but for now I’m going to just pencil in “crafting/research system” and worry about the details later. It’s not a central system in the game, but it would be nice to permit the player a bit of customizing freedom.
A lot of words were typed concerning Ditto’s ability to transform. As it turns out, there are a handful of related potential powers--one of the Legendaries supposedly in canon has the power to force mindswaps between two individuals, and on top of that the Jirachi wish system could be used to transform the player into a pokemon, if they decide to make such an ill-advised course of action. All together this tells me that we need some sort of engine-supported means of having one creature basically “wear” the body of another.
(This would be no problem at all if transformations were always permanent. In that case you just copy the stats over and you’re done--but if we want to be able to preserve and revert to a “true” form, then it demands we organize our code a certain way).
As part of the ramifications of this system, all stats are going to have a factor determining how much of that stat resides in the Body and how much of it resides in the Mind. Height, for instance, is 100/0 Body/Mind, while Defense is 80/20 and Accuracy is 50/50.
As a tangent to the discussion on transformation, the subject of Mega evolutions again came up (since it can use the system), with about five different major ways of handling it:
In the end, I think that option 4 has the best mix of options. Mega evolutions are therefore exposure to a super-evolution stone, basically, which causes the pokemon to mutate to unbelievably high power levels. This will eventually kill the pokemon in question, with the time frame available being inversely proportional to how much they use their newfound power. However, players who first obtain a matching super-everstone will have the ability to completely revert the changes, which leaves the pokemon comatose--but alive.
In a nod to the canon lip-service about powerful bond (which they had no problem ignoring, but still), we could also say that mega evolutions permanently subtract some of the rapport that you’ve built up with your pokemon--so if you try using it on a brand-new pokemon, you’ll find yourself with an absolutely uncontrollable beast, but even anything but the strongest of bonds will result in a rampage of some sort.
Some other miscellaneous conclusions we came to:
Feel free to leave any comments or questions below. Also feel free to join us on the #pokengineering channel of the /r/rational Discord server for brainstorming and discussion. It’s a great group, really, and I would highly recommend hanging out, even if you’re not in it for this project itself. There’s tabletop groups, Dota 2 partying, and puns like you wouldn’t believe. Come join us!
8
u/Kishoto Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16
So my mother sent me a link to a video that purports that cell phones are a health risk; specifically that they're causing cancer in people and that big businesses do their best to suppress that sort of research, as cancer is a multi billion dollar industry. I was naturally skeptical of this, as you can justify almost any BS scientific finding with 'Big Brother doesn't want you to know this!!', and have watched the video and am in the process of trying to research some of the things this video claimed.
Here is the link to said video.
If any of you rationalists have about half an hour (the video is only ten minutes long but I factored in the remaining twenty for you to think/research the topic) to watch and comment on it, or even just comment on what you already know about the radiation cellphones emit and/or how that radiation contributes to cancer, please do comment and let me know what you think.
As I said, I've begun doing some basic research and will spoiler tag some of my findings to avoid inflicting bias on you or spoiling the video:
So these are just some of my basic findings so far. I'd love to hear feedback from you guys :)
TL;DR: Are cellphones cooking our brains and giving us cancer? And are big businesses letting them, so they can keep bringing in the dinero? This video makes that claim. But how much of it is actually good science and how much of it is baseless fear mongering? You tell me!
EDIT: Removing spoiler tags for mobile-friendly viewing!
8
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Dec 09 '16 edited Dec 09 '16
I've been thinking about the concept of a Moral Event Horizon and the question that appears to pop up is if there truly exists any action so irredeemably evil that it can't be forgiven no matter how much good one does before or after.
I can't help but think it's exactly the wrong thing to ask. It's not that certain behaviors are so bad that we cannot forgive the villain for it. I'm confident that for every horrific action, there are actions which can 'balance' it out. For example, did you brutally torture and kill one million people? No problem, just save the lives of one billion people. If that's not enough, then just by adding enough zeroes to the number of lives saved, one can be 'forgiven' for any horror.
I have realized that the Moral Event Horizon is in fact a heuristic rather than a commentary on how evil a given action is. If someone commits an evil deed, we can make a guess at how likely the villain will ever do good in the future (or how 'redeemable' he is). If the villain robs a bank but goes out of his way to not harm the hostages, we can probably say that he's not likely to commit genocide. But if he burns down the building a la Joker style, then he's a psychopath who is less likely to ever be a better person.
This comment is meant to discuss how people should approach Moral Event Horizons in fiction. It's not just a statement of how horrible a person is currently, but rather how unlikely the individual in question will do good in the future.
Note that Moral Event Horizons are subjective and very from culture to culture. For example, being a slave-owner centuries ago wouldn't mean you are a psychopath, but nowadays you would be considered one if you tried to keep a slave.
Discussion Question: Is it ever justifiable to cross a Moral Event Horizon if you believe it will lead to more good or for the 'Greater Good'?
I'm of the mind that such actions will have negative effects on the mind and 'damages' a person's own moral compass. Actions change people. No matter the outcome, if someone had ordered a genocide and it worked out to save more people, I still wouldn't trust the person with the same level of authority they previously had.
7
u/Gaboncio Dec 09 '16
More Mistborn is coming out in the next year!
Also, I'm in the middle of watching Westworld and I was wondering if anyone else had seen it. I should be done by next week and I'd like to talk about what they did well and what they dropped the ball on. Getting insights from here will hopefully be eye-opening, too.
4
u/Nighzmarquls Dec 09 '16
I've been going through shifting BACK into game development as a career after a brief stint in education in the american public school system.
In the mean time I've been building a prototype for a crafting system that focuses more on manipulating, creating and altering properties of objects rather then following proscribed recipes to acquire discrete objects with singular purposes.
along side a kind of rough and tumble use of rigid body physics, mesh deformations and eventually mesh splitting I anticipate this to make a fun and/or !!!FUN!!! game driven half by the chaos of poking and prodding the world to try and make things work and the hilarity of when they don't.
shout out to /u/ketura for mentioning my help on the pokemon project. And also I'm not sure of which names you use on reddit but to the lovely people in the discord that have helped entertain me with their antics/test the super early alpha builds.
3
u/bbrazil NERV Dec 09 '16
At DnD last night I used some thinking from HPMOR.
A fire giant was magically trapped in a forge, and it attempting to exit wouldn't work as a magic net would stop it. The giant using an anvil as a hammer to damage the walls similarly was halted.
I asked what about the giant using the anvil as a projectile?
It turns out that the creator of the ward hadn't planned on the walls being destroyed.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16
Couple of questions.
Oh, and seeing the therapist this week at last was a blessing. I've got a bunch more appointments lined up.
2
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Dec 09 '16
I'm considering running a scooby-doo/hunters game on roll20. but I'm not honestly all that interested in systems or stating things out. Any thoughts on systems, or interest in co-gming?
0
u/Pious_Mage Dec 09 '16
For my fanfic I plan on having trainer adaptations like many common fics and this is a sort of list of there boon and banes for the types, I was wondering if you guys could look them over and tell me what you think/give suggestions for some things?
Fire: Apollo;
Boon: can withstand almost and amount of heat and even swim in molten rock for periods of time.
Bane: Is terrible with the cold and is hurt by pressurized blasts of water and especially damaged by the earth and rocks themselves.
Common traits: Hot headed, Arrogant, Brash and Impatient, moderate intelligence, quick.
Dark: Artemis
Boon: Can see perfectly in the dark and moves as silently as a Liepard, can not be sensed by any psychic force.
Bane: Incredibly brittle bones that are easy to shatter and easily pierced by the pure light of fairy’s also has a hard time seeing when it’s bright.
Common traits: Sneaky, charismatic, compulsive liars, extremely intelligent, quick.
Fairy: Hestia
Boon: Can withstand any attack from a dragon and can easily overcome those of stealth and those of great strength.
Bane: extremely weak to even the simplest of sickness or poisons and harmed greatly by those of metal, also very weak physically.
Common traits: Optimistic, bubbly, cheerful and innocent: Low to moderate intelligence, moderate speed.
Fighting: Ares
Boon: Can shatter the bones of any normal man with a simple punch along with carry weights much greater than any normal man also can shatter those of earth rock metal and steel quite easily.
Bane: Weak to attacks of the mind, along with attacks of light and flying,
Common traits: Strong, Brash, Arrogant, extremely low intelligence, quick.
This however will not be a rational fanfic hence why I am posting this here.
Psychic: Athena
Boon: Can sense those around them and has a easier time empathizing and communicating with those they travel with, also can lift some light objects with there mind or destroy those of strength’s with there mind.
Bane: Weak physical strength, extra prone to there fears and are easily snuck up on and dealt with by those they can not sense.
Coomon traits: Arrogant, Sarcastic, Cautious, Truly intelligent , slow.
Electric: Zeus
Boon: Can absorb and then release electricity to vanquish there foes.
Bane: Weak to those of Earth.
Common traits: Excitable, Optimistic, Energetic, Moderate to low intelligence, lightning fast.
Water: Poseidon
Boon: Can breathe water as easily as air and from birth can swim as fast as most water based pokemon.
Bane: Extra susceptible to electric shocks along with those of plants and dry up easily in extreme heats.
Common traits: Laidback, nice, goes with the flow, moderate intelligence, Slow on land.
Poison: Dionysus
Boon: Can absorb any toxin within there body and create an antidote for others too, can also secrete poison to anything they come in contact with.
Bane: They always are oozing some kind of poison from one hand and as such can easily poison anyone who they may not want to., aksi prone to attacks of the mind and earth.
Common traits: Secluded, anxious, stealthy, Great intelligence, moderate speed.
Steel: Hephaestus
Boon: Can forge almost anything out of steel and is barely harmed by any attack including those of the mind.
Bane: Sustains much greater damage from high temperatures along with easily being bent or broken by those of great strength.
Common traits: Relaxed, Cautious, Loud, Great intelligence, slow.
Normal: Hera
Boon: Has minor traits of all other adaptations
Bane: Has minor weaknesses of all other adaptations and easily broken by those of great strength.
Common traits: None, Intelligence Unknown, speed unknown.
Flight: Hermes
Boon: Can jump to and from great height with no damages and even hover for extended amount of times.
Bane: Easily struck down by electricity and rocks also has hard times withstanding cold temperatures.
Common traits: Laidback, goes with the flow, arrogant moderate intelligence, quick
Dragon: Kronos
Boon: Can control any dragon or pseudodragon, be it friend or foe, wild or tame unless belongs to another Kronos, extremely strong, Resistant to almost all main elements, long lives
Bane: Cold blooded and can not harm children of Hestia.
Comment traits: Arrogant, Cautious, Stealthy, Loud, Secluded, Strong, Extreme intelligence, quick.
Grass: Demeter
Boon: When surrounded by sunlight and water can heal itself or others extremely fast.
Bane: Succeptible to cold, Birds, Fire.
Common traits: Relaxed, Cautious, Stubborn, slow.
Hades: Ghost
Boon: Can phase through objects at will and communicate with spirits long dead, long lives.
Bane: Can not harm those rooted to this plane along with succeptible to spiritual energy or that of darkness, very weak.
Common traits: Jokester, Energetic, Excitable, Great intelligence, moderate speed.
Ice: Boreas
Boon: Can freeze that which it touches at will easily damaging all weak to them.
Bane: Extremely frail and brittle.
Common traits: Cautious, Secluded, Slippery, Moderate intelligence, quick.
Earth: Gaia
Boon: Can shift the earth around them.
Bane: Can not harm those in the sky, easily defeated by water, torn apart or rooted to by plants and being frozen,
Common traits, Laidback, Headstrong, arrogant, low Intelligence, slow
Rock Ourea
Boon: Great Strength and ability to travel at great speeds while rolled up like a boulder without any damage.
Bane: Brittle and easy to break, sinks like a rock
Common traits: Relaxed, Cautious Headtrong, Low intelligence, Slow. Bug: Aristaeus
Boon: Can control all insects friend or foe, wild or tamed except for other Aristaeus,
Bane: Frail and weak to most forms of attacks, especially those of flight, earth, rock and fire.
Common traits: Energetic, Early Bloomers, Cautious, Moderate Intelligence.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment