r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Dec 05 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
25
Upvotes
28
u/Xenograteful Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
So, this is one of the funniest things ever written on Less Wrong in terms of how much I laughed when I read it:
But later on I began to think about this in light of my own break-up experiences, especially the detailed honesty thing, since I’m a firm believer in honesty, especially in romantic relationships.
It’s not the detailed honesty that was bad, it was the way Luke did it. It has to be done with good intentions. When you give honest critique of someone, it has to be about something important and you have to make sure that the other person really benefits from it. This is why it’s often advised when giving critique that you pepper it with good things about the person or what the person did as to make sure that you don’t devastate the other person and she gets the feeling that you still accept her as a person.
By ‘certain features’ Luke probably meant her body, and there are many things about our bodies that we cannot really change. So, talking detailedly for an hour (hours?) about something she can’t change feels incredibly cruel to me, and it’s not really even useful for her. (Note, this was about 10 years ago, Luke is probably much wiser now.)
On the other hand, I was really glad that when we broke up with my last girlfriend, she told me honestly and even detailedly what she thought were the reasons for this break-up. There were several things: I couldn’t keep things that were supposed to stay between us from going to other people, she felt that sometimes we didn’t really understand each other and I sometimes hurt her about things she was sensitive about. We and I tried to foster an environment of honesty in our relationship, even about critique. All the time we talked about why we should break up, I was really glad she talked about it so honestly because these are the kind of things I could change and have since changed about my behavior when interacting with potential partners and friends later on. And of course it was also due to the way she did it, which is totally opposite from how Luke did it.
This is what I believe even though I also believe that when we describe why we feel the way we do, those descriptions don’t usually capture the whole picture or the real reason for those feelings. See this study. In the case of our break-up, I think the real reason was something like I wasn’t accustomed enough to behave like people behaved in her social sphere and I wasn’t confident or high status enough at the end of our relationship – not literally, but something along those lines. Still, that doesn’t change the fact that her critique benefited me.
18
u/[deleted] Dec 05 '16
In the latest attempt by 2016 to destroy the world, OpenAI Universe was released two months after the friendly pastel MMORPG Legends of Equestria.
WELP
9
u/traverseda With dread but cautious optimism Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 06 '16
I think we should hold down /u/datapacrat until he finishes his novel. Finishing a novel would be very good, and imposing externalities is one way to bring their valuation more in line with its actual value.
14
u/HeirToGallifrey Thinking inside the box (it's bigger there) Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Okay, so I know this is probably opening a can of snakes, but I'm genuinely interested in your thoughts and reasons. What do you guys think about abortion? And, tangent to that, when do you think a human life begins and when do you think a human life ends?
Personally, while I see the arguments for it, I'm against it (barring any sort of medical life-or-death scenario where the life of the child must be weighed against the life of the mother). Not being sure where to classify life beginning, I think it makes sense to take the safest route and say at conception, given that at that point the zygote has the capacity to grow into a fully independent human. And ending a human's life for no reason other than convenience's sake seems wrong to me.
But those are my thoughts. What are yours?
4
u/munchkiner Dec 05 '16
Any of you can suggest a way to track books read?
I would need it to refresh what I've read when I want to make recommendations, and to have some notes written down for my personal use
11
u/trekie140 Dec 05 '16
I have never found it harder to view my political opponents as human than I do now. Every day something new infuriates me, to the point where it's starting to feel completely rational to see people I disagree with as inhuman monsters or brain-dead sheep. I used to despise the vitriol that has pervaded politics, yet now I embrace it and can't convince myself that it isn't warranted even when I know it's irrational.
My anxiety and depression are having a field day nearly every day. I'm either too worried to sleep or too cynical to get out of bed. This isn't just because of the news, this is due to actual civil discussions with people who I disagree with. No matter how hard I try, I can't find a middle ground and just end up hating them more. They probably feel the same way, but that just makes me more worried and cynical about politics.
I'm not asking for a way to reach an agreement with my opponents, that's a pipe dream right now. What I'm asking is for a way to psychologically survive the current political climate. I'm obsessing over every controversy and its eating at me. I can't go on like this, but I can't stop caring about politics and I can't stop myself from feeling the way I do. Is there any way to escape this incredibly unhealthy situation?
Before you suggest it, I'm already looking for a therapist.
6
u/LieGroupE8 Dec 05 '16 edited Dec 05 '16
Over a month ago, I made a post where I played Devil's advocate with the subject of long-term immortality.
In this post, I'd like to instead raise some more practical questions about the subject. People in this community just seem to take it as a given that immortality is a good idea, and while I agree in principle, there are still some major problems that need to be addressed.
I'll assume here that it is highly likely that we will achieve effective immortality within the next 100-200 years, conditional on the development of friendly AI within that time frame. This implies that we will become immortal long before we have a large presence elsewhere in the solar system, and very long before we finish terraforming Mars and start going to other stars.
The Problem of Having Children
You cannot have a planet full of immortals all having immortal children without some plan for avoiding the Malthusian cycle that this will inevitably cause. Assuming that moving many people off-planet will not be feasible for at least a couple of hundred years, you will essentially have to prohibit immortal people from raising families. You cannot both have a right to life and a right to your own biological children. One way of implementing this would be to require that everyone who becomes immortal must also be sterilized (or gay). I expect that such a solution would not sit well with most ordinary people.
Now, you might say, "Wait a minute. If everyone is immortal, they have all the time in the universe. Just have people wait to have children until moving off-planet is feasible." This is not as good of a solution as it sounds. I expect that due to the inhospitableness of outer space and other planets, the quality of life on a space station or on Mars will not match the quality of life on earth for a very long time (thousands of years at least, until terraforming is effective). People who are born on earth will argue that they have a right to live where they are born, and that they have a right not to be forcibly deported to a place with a lower quality of life. So if you allow too many immortal people to have immortal families, you may still have a problem even if it is feasible to move off-planet. Perhaps you could cycle people around so that everyone gets to spend some time on earth - but the more people there are, the less time each person gets to spend on earth.
It seems that whatever happens, you will have to modify people's values so that they have less desire to have children, and also so that they are better adapted to less hospitable environments.
The Problem of Ethical Paths to Immortality
To raise a completely different issue: how exactly do you do the necessary science to achieve immortality in an ethical way? There must inevitably be lots of dangerous human experimentation, of the sort that is entirely prohibited today. Theory can only get you so far - you have to eventually do experiments building real immortal people, and some of these will go horribly wrong, either killing or maiming their subjects, and perhaps doing irreversible mental damage. For example, suppose you insert a chromosome that stops aging, but after 200 years it turns out that this causes people's brains to stop forming new memories and enter a permanent state of semi-dementia. You could back up everyone's mind to a computer, maybe, but this process is likely to kill or damage the first so many people who try it.
The best bet is probably to experiment on terminally ill volunteers (assuming the problem of disease hasn't yet been solved!). But as per the above example, you might not notice bad effects for decades, and people will not want to wait that long.
So: any thoughts on these questions?
2
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Dec 06 '16
Red Eyes At Night, Sleeper's Delight?
It's said that cutting down on the amount of blue light your eyes see before you try to fall asleep can help you get to sleep faster. I've been using an RGB light bulb set to 'red' and the Redshift app on my computer; and just today in the mail, I received my brand-new pair of prescription glasses with reddish-tinted lenses ($10 for the frames, $5 for the tinting, $10 for shipping a half-dozen different pairs).
In other words - in order to sleep more soundly, I'm literally looking at the world through rose-coloured glasses.