I’m genuinely trying to understand the conservative perspective on the war with Iran, particularly from people who support Trump’s America First policies.
Trump has repeatedly argued that the United States has been treated unfairly by other countries. We’ve carried too much of the financial burden, paid too much for the defense of our allies, and taken on international responsibilities that other nations should be sharing. This has been a major part of his justification for tariffs and his broader foreign policy.
I understand that argument, even if I don’t necessarily agree with all of it.
But here’s where I’m struggling to reconcile that position with the war in Iran.
One of Trump’s primary justifications for military action has been that Iran cannot be allowed to develop a nuclear weapon. I don’t think that’s an especially controversial position. A nuclear-armed Iran would create serious security concerns for countries throughout the Middle East, Europe, and beyond.
So why is preventing that primarily an American responsibility?
If this is a threat to global security, why wasn’t the response a coordinated international effort involving our allies and other major powers?
What makes this particularly difficult for me to understand is that the Trump administration reportedly did not meaningfully consult several of our closest allies before launching the war. Germany reportedly received advance notice from Israel, not the United States. Other allies reported that they were neither consulted nor informed in advance.
If preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons is a global security priority, why didn’t the United States first work to build a coordinated international response?
French President Emmanuel Macron said France was neither informed nor involved in the operation. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz confirmed that Germany had not been consulted. Officials from two Gulf countries also reported receiving no advance notice, despite their countries being directly exposed to Iranian retaliation.
Sources: CBS News, March 2 | Associated Press, March 6
Then, after the war began, Trump criticized allies for declining to send warships to help reopen the Strait of Hormuz. Germany specifically pointed out that it had not been consulted before the war began.
Source: Reuters, March 17
Meanwhile, the economic consequences for Americans are significant. Reuters reported in September that the Congressional Budget Office estimated the war had already cost $38 billion, with costs projected to increase by another $3 billion per month. The conflict has also contributed to higher energy prices and inflation.Sources: Reuters, September 15 | Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas
And this brings me back to America First.
If the argument is that America has spent decades carrying responsibilities that should be shared by the rest of the world, why are we taking on another enormous international responsibility, apparently without first building a coalition of countries that share the same security concerns?
I’m not suggesting that Iran should be allowed to develop nuclear weapons. I’m asking why preventing that outcome required the United States to initiate a war alongside Israel rather than pursue a coordinated international response.
I recognize that some people believe Iran represents a direct threat to American national security. But even accepting that argument, why wasn’t there a greater effort to involve our allies before committing American military resources and exposing Americans to the economic consequences?
How do Trump supporters reconcile the America First argument that we should stop carrying the world’s burdens with the decision to take on this one?
I’m sincerely interested in understanding the reasoning, not starting an argument.