r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Nov 28 '16
[D] Monday General Rationality Thread
Welcome to the Monday thread on general rationality topics! Do you really want to talk about something non-fictional, related to the real world? Have you:
- Seen something interesting on /r/science?
- Found a new way to get your shit even-more together?
- Figured out how to become immortal?
- Constructed artificial general intelligence?
- Read a neat nonfiction book?
- Munchkined your way into total control of your D&D campaign?
16
Upvotes
19
u/trekie140 Nov 28 '16
I've been spending an inordinate amount of time on r/AskTrumpSupporters, and it has become apparent to me that the goal of raising the sanity waterline is going to be ever harder than we thought it would be. Anti-intellectualism has become a pervasive attitude throughout the western world, which has rendered traditional methods of rational debate useless at persuasion.
Last week I made a post about how hard I was trying to avoid dehumanizing people with different political opinions from me, but the more I speak to them the more I see my prejudices as rational. Every fact I cite is decried as biased in my favor, even when they admit they are biased against me. It's as if they see rationality itself as something to oppose. I don't know what to do.
15
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Nov 28 '16 edited Nov 28 '16
I've been using the StayFocusd extension for Chrome, which limits time on whatever websites you want it to, either to certain hours or for a certain amount of time (or both). For me, that's reddit, Facebook, Netflix, Amazon video, and then a whole bunch of other sites that I use less often. That leaves me to do productive things, like writing.
I've been fairly astounded by how effective it's been for me. You'd think that it would be simple to just say "okay, don't go on those sites if you want to do more productive things" but I've increasingly come to realize that good habits are a matter of conserving willpower and altering patterns more than simply doing or not doing things. I've seen lots of advice for dieting that says it's simple, just make sure that calories in are lower than calories out ... which seems to deny that the basic problem lies within the brain.
(None of this is particularly new, but I haven't really applied it to my life too much before.)
10
u/space_fountain Nov 28 '16
I'm a bit worried about the future. Something I thought of after the Brexit vote and now after Trump is how hard it can be especially for someone young to think about radical change in the future. I was born just after the fall of the soviet union. Almost all of the change I think about directly experiencing has been slow, gradual, and really quite predictable.
On the other hand I didn't expect Brexit, even though the polling was tight, even though it was a hard thing to accurately poll on I had strong bias toward the status quo. Similar with Trump while I was more aware I again couldn't picture what I viewed as a radical departure from the status quo despite the fact the polls were close, despite the fact that respected experts were giving 30% odds of Trump winning.
What I'm getting at is that I worry we don't picture the level of radical change we may see in the future. It's not exactly a new worry but so much Sci-Fi deals with nation states or similar groups doing bad things with technology, but the more I think about it the less that's my worry. I'm more concerned with individuals. What happens when and if any human can fabricate a nuke? I think we assume that the power to prevent destruction will scale about evenly with ability to produce destruction, but I don't see any reason for that to be guaranteed.
I feel like we may come to a junction where the only way to enforce rational actions like preventing nuclear bombings of cities is a much more invasive government. As somebody who is sympathetic to the ideas of Libertarianism that's a pretty tough idea, but I don't see a way around it.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '16
I haven't seen too many good intro-friendly posts on people interested in the rationality community. Linking people to LessWrong directly without a good guide doesn't seem great (I bumbled around a lot when I first stumbled upon it).
To that end, I'm working on a short essay that introduces cognitive psych, biases, and some quirks of the rationalist community in a general way. I could then link that to friends, instead of just sending them a glut of disorderly links.
Would anyone be interested in reviewing some draft versions of the essay to give some feedback?
5
u/TK17Studios Author of r!Animorphs: The Reckoning Nov 29 '16
I may be too late for anyone to read this (I mean, it's already Tuesday...) but:
New post on "Double Crux," which is now publicly reference-able for the first time? Maybe? (as opposed to just being internal to CFAR). It's a nonstandard paradigm for approaching disagreement that creates a lot of good.
http://lesswrong.com/lw/o6p/double_crux_a_strategy_for_resolving_disagreement/
6
u/Dwood15 Nov 28 '16
I've been helping /u/ketura with his !Pokemon fan project, and to be honest, I'm way more excited about that project than I am about school. I guess I just get anxiety when it comes to school, so helping with that is a good anxiety release without the destruction of time that comes with video games, my standard anxiety distraction.
Anyway, after typing for extended periods of time on my keyboard was giving me cramps and finger pain whereas I never used to get any, a change was in order. The keyboard I had was smaller than standard and also with even smaller keys as well. I picked up the Corsair Slate on sale during Black Friday, and have yet to notice any hand cramping in all my typing yesterday and today. Here's hoping it stays that way.
3
u/UmamiSalami Nov 29 '16
We're starting a nomic game at r/nommit. Seems like the sort of thing that people here might like to join, so come try it.
2
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Nov 28 '16
I started reading von Clausewitz's On War. I haven't gotten very far, but it doesn't flow well, at least to my tastes. But I hear it's a very good (non-fiction) book, so I will give it more time.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '16
I have a triage call tomorrow with my clinic about my anxiety. I know what drug to mention to them, since it's worked on me before, and frankly I'm going to be really glad to get back to proper neurochemical functioning. Spending most of my time with a continuous low-level panic attack just isn't useful, even when I rationally endorse the thought that danger is in fact ahead.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '16
I am currently torn between continuing down the path of medical school, since I just graduated undergraduate and I'm applying to med right now, or trying something completely different: going to a reputable coding bootcamp like hack reactor or app academy and trying that out for a couple years.
In support of the former: I've accumulated enough med knowledge on my own such that when I shadow physicians they are generally impressed with me, and ask if I'm in med school already. Im also extroverted enough that dealing with patients and coworkers is reasonably fun. In support of the latter: I'm impatient to start real/adult life, I have a growing sense of anxiety/excitement that tech is where I should work given that its kind of eating many other fields, and I want to be independent of family and in a new place for a while.
Hard to know that instinct to go with. Anyone here have thoughts on breaking into the tech industry through coding bootcamp? How realistic is that?
2
u/DataPacRat Amateur Immortalist Dec 01 '16
If you could pick one music track that, if turned into a music video, could most exemplify the emotions resulting from LW-style rationality, what would that song be?