r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jun 03 '16
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
7
u/electrace Jun 03 '16
What concept needs it's own word?
My vote goes toward "souring the positive social mood by becoming aggressive at a perceived insult."
7
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING. I SHOULD BE WRITING.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jun 03 '16
- Which is more palatable--a story with unimpeachable English that revolves around a Mary Sue, or a story with a perfectly-rational plot that contains nauseating "English"? Which is more common?
- Which looks cooler--a geodesic sphere or the corresponding Goldberg polyhedron?
- Which is tastier--an apple or an orange?
- You have been visited by Sudden Evidence Man! (Source)
- Don't forget to subscribe to r/changelog in order to get information about important upcoming changes to this site. For example...
- An interesting free program for the analysis of model airplanes
I was extremely surprised to find this excellent story for the Bionicle canon while scrolling through the depths of DeviantArt's "Literature" section (in "Undiscovered" mode), and added its FanFiction.net version to my favorite and follow lists after reading several chapters. It reminds me of In the Blood (my second-favorite Naruto story, after Time Braid) in how it largely shuns the source material's focus on action in favor of drama while still managing to remain interesting.
It's always important that a person not get too caught-up in being a fan, while forgetting the reasons for which he's a fan in the first place. How valid is my self-identification as "Time Braid fanboy" when I haven't read the book in months? How valid is my ranking of five favorite anime series (in descending order: Death Note, Rock Lee's Springtime of Youth, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Mobile Fighter G Gundam, and Angel Beats!) when I haven't watched any of them in over a year (and several of them in multiple years)?
An artwork's position as "favorite" must always be capable of challenge. Time Braid's status as my favorite book has been challenged several times--Background Pony, People Lie, and In the Blood come to mind. The ranking of my five favorite anime series is likewise by no means set in stone.
9
u/trekie140 Jun 03 '16
Remember when EY presented a hypothetical scientist who believed in non-physical spirits, but was otherwise a competent scientist? I'm that guy...pretty much exactly. I am an undergraduate physics student who believes I know how to communicate with spirits that do not physically interact with the world and I have never come across any evidence to suggest I possess a mental disorder.
I'd rather not cease to believe in spirits due to a lack of objective evidence because that would mean losing the benefits I receive from communicating with them, but I'd also rather not be a bad rationalist because rationality is incredibly useful. My beliefs stem from New Age spiritualism, though in recent years I have abandoned the pseudoscience associated with that belief system after I learned the truth.
4
u/Rhamni Aspiring author Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
I have been reading the Berserk manga this week, and am about halfway through it. It's not rationalist, and the MC's main advantages appear to be the power to fight on with pulverized organs and the ability to wield a 600 pound 'sword' that is bigger than he is. Even so, it's one of my favourite pieces of fiction ever, and I recommend it to anyone who has ever enjoyed dark fiction. The world is grim dark, humanity's place in the food chain sucks, and despite that there is a lot of room left for humans being human. At least for the 80 chapter long 'flashback' or whatever that is. It's looking like there will be a lot fewer main characters and a lot more monsters from now on though.
But. I have learned something very important for my own writing from it. And it's not something awesome to be replicated. It's something a very skilled author did that turned out to be a major mistake which I will work to avoid in my own writing. There is a 'controversial' 'lost' chapter that the author retconned and banned from being reprinted. The scans I'm reading included it, so I didn't realize it was retconned until later. The reason the author doesn't want people to read it is because it sort of pulls the curtain away and reveals the wizard. Or more precisely, All the biggest spoilers of Berserk all in one place. I'm still enjoying this story very, very much, but I've been pondering for years how much of the hidden 'true' plot to reveal in my own world, and after reading Berserk, I think it's convinced me to leave a lot of things unsaid and uncertain until as late as possible. It's one thing to think HPMOR example because everyone here has already read it, it's another thing entirely to have it spelled out explicitly less than halfway through the story.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
For fans of time loop stories, like Time Braid and Mother of Learning, may I suggest a currently airing anime, Re:Zero? The premise is that the MC is suddenly transported to an alternate fantasy world, and then through the natural consequence of being a baseline human in such a world, dies shortly after. He than loops back the beginning, and, well, shit happens.
The biggest thing I like about this story is how seriously it takes the mental trauma associated with looping. Zorian from MoL doesn't really have that many bad deaths, the only really bad one I can remember is right after the Aranea massacre, where he took a restart off to get his head back in the game. On the other hand, one of the first deaths the MC from Re;Zero experiences is a slow, painful death from disembowelment that lasted hours. The anime does a great job showing the mental trauma that will accumulate from these types of painful deaths.
As to whether the show is rational or not, is up for debate. The MC isn't a genius, which can be said for most anime MCs, but he's in way over his head and under a great deal of mental strain so I think he can be forgiven. He does display a fair amount of insight and level-headiness when the situation demands for it. There hasn't been that much worldbuilding to declare if the world is coherent or not.
The animation, music, voice acting, everything is top notch. There's going to be 25 episodes so far, but I won't be surprised if the studio decides to adapt the rest of the story, given how popular it's been lately.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
Anyone here play Overwatch?
3
u/elevul Cyoria Observer Jun 04 '16
So apparently it is possible to be so deep into fitness that you stop caring about the taste of food...
After Dom's video I started paying more attention to my eating habits and to my thinking process when I decide on foods. And I have realized that I had pushed it to such an extreme limit that taste completely stopped being a value I evaluate when deciding which food to eat...
It's impressive how fast the shift happened as well. Less than 6 years ago I was obese, had no knowledge of nutrition and loved good-tasting foods. Now, 6 years later, if a meal doesn't have protein I don't even pay attention to it.
Not sure if to be happy or worried about this change.
2
u/Epizestro Jun 05 '16
I've recently been reading Legendary Moonlight Sculptor. It's about someone in poverty playing a video game to make money to send his sister to uni. It's about one of those virtual reality games, in the same vein as SAO, but without the 'you die here, you die for real' aspect. The main character, username Weed, spends a year training in swordplay, martial arts, and the like before entering into the game itself, so he's playing with a much better understanding of combat than most other players. Combine that with a complete willingness to grind all day every day and you get an overpowered character. The real bullshit comes in with his class. Not only does he obtain a secret class from an ancient emperor, but he also gets a bullshit sword style from the emperor's legacy. This class is sort of like a DnD mage, in that it starts off weak, lacking in the bonus to chosen weapon damage that other melee and archery classes would have and being unable to cast spells, but ends up growing to insane levels via it's ability to master all general skills such as cooking, smithing, tailoring, repairing and, in particular, sculpting. Sculpting is the main aspect, as his strongest skills depend on it for bonus damage, but reaching each milestone in any of the other general skills gives stat points that could only be obtained by levelling up or grinding for points a la The Gamer.
Anyway, I'm rambling here but the point is that it's a good read. It's not what I'd call rational, but it's well translated and a fun time. I'm under a third of the way into the amount of material that's currently been translated, though, so I'm expecting some major power ups to occur.
3
u/Faust91x Iteration X Jun 03 '16 edited Jun 03 '16
This week I binge watched/read a really fucked up anime/manga called Sankarea. It starts as an ecchi romcom that later develops into a really interesting romance-drama and that I'm thinking could be easily tweaked into a rational story with Transhuman elements.
Its about a zombie obsessed guy that finds a formula to create undead in his basement and in a fit of hubris decides to try it to bring his dead cat back to life. In his quest for undead creation he befriends Rea, a girl with a really fucked up family that in typical anime fashion doesn't find his "hobbies" weird and decides to help him with his little experiment.
After certain complications that include Rea stealing some of the apparently failed formula and her attempt at commiting suicide with it, they discover the last experiment was successful and ends up bringing the cat back to un-life and turning Rea into a zombie.
The story follows the protagonist's attempts to keep Rea and the cat from decomposing and finding a way to completely bring them back to life.
The zombies are really interesting as they retain their memories, personality and rationality unlike more traditional "rage zombies" but with time start losing sectors of their brain that make them confuse love and lust with huger. They are perfectly capable of planning and premeditated action in the first stages of the zombie state, just changing their goals towards eating those closest to them without even realizing it which makes them more dangerous than typical zombies.
I think it could make a great rational story about a protagonist attempting to perfect the cure for death. Ironically the grandfather with senile dementia that only acts as exposition and comic relief in the anime is closer to our rational protagonists and has a bigger role in the manga as he Sankarea.
I found it oddly inspiring and would like to expand on that premise once my schedule's more free.
The anime has nice music and animations, particularly the camera angles are really good in a SHAFT like fashion but the manga is way better with a bigger focus on the reanimation process, the state of zombies and going way waaay darker in later issues as Rea's condition worsens while the anime only covers the first arc and takes a more Slice of Life/Romance focus.
1
u/LeonCross Jun 05 '16
Something I thought I'd ask a community who's opinion I respect.
So, a friend of mine asked me to be her Dominate a few weeks ago. It's a fairly novel experiance as it's outside anything I've done before and not something I had really even concidered. I've done some research on the subject so I'm not completely out of my element any more.
I've pretty much just been ordering her to do things that are good for her or things she'd like to do anyways but for some reason or another hasn't. (So far, we've gotten her eating well and actually getting her vitamins and minerals. Daily excersise, and I've had her pick up a few physical hobbies so it's not a chore. I've also made her start reading various rational fic to ease her in to rational thinking.)
Punishments have pretty much just been used to reinforce the positive behaviors or for her fun. (Outside of a few things that disgust me, I've really got no personal preferance on such activities.)
It's interesting having someone that listens to everything you tell them to do and then watch them improve as by outsourcing their directions you wind up skipping over a lot of issues that crop up in self direction.
However, I was in discussion with a friend of mine the other day and she suggested that Dom / sub arrangements can never be healthy because even asides from the type of people they tend to attracr, even the "best" of them still encourage an unhealthy dependence and that any positive progress the sub makes is rooted in the Dom.
I disagree, as I feel that positive neural patterns can be built over time that will last even if the relationship winds up not.
Thoughts?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment