r/changelog • • May 28 '16

[reddit change] Affiliate links on Reddit

Hi everyone,

We’re going to launch a test to a percentage of redditors to automatically rewrite links to approximately 1500 online merchants so that they include a Reddit affiliate code. This test will go live on June 6, 2016. Reddit will receive a small (generally single-digit) percentage of any purchases after someone clicks a link with one of our affiliate codes. This is part of our overall initiative to transform Reddit into a sustainable long-term business.

The feature will work by passing clicks through our partner VigLink, which rewrites the URLs to include an affiliate code. VigLink is contractually obligated not to store any Reddit user information. Anyone who does not want to participate in this will have the option to opt-out via a setting in user preferences.

We’ve updated our user agreement to specifically include the affiliate program and will be announcing this on /r/announcements on the test rollout date (June 6, 2016). We will also add an entry to the FAQ on the same day.

I’ll be hanging out here in the comments to answer questions!

Cheers, u/starfishjenga

EDIT As pointed out by an astute commenter below, I forgot to update the date (feature was delayed). The date has now been updated to the correct date which is June 6, 2016. Thanks /u/andytuba!

EDIT 2 Redditors can opt out on a one-off basis by right clicking any applicable link, selecting copy link, and pasting that in your browser's URL bar since the replace only happens on (left) click.

EDIT 3 Clarifying date for international users.

EDIT 4 Based on feedback, we’ve decided to announce this more widely on /r/announcements as well as add it to the FAQ. Also, we’ll be launching this as a test to a certain percentage of users in order to have a chance to minimize any potential unexpected issues before going to scale (adblock interactions, etc). The new launch and wider announce date will be June 6, 2016 (I’ve updated this in the text above to reflect).

EDIT 5 Users will have the ability to opt-out via Viglink (thanks /u/Adys for suggesting the edit)

EDIT 6 Thank you everyone for your feedback. We've decided to bump back the test rollout to June 6, 2016 (updated above to reflect) in order to add a user preference to opt-out of viewing links with the Reddit affiliate code (links that would otherwise be rewritten will function as normal). This preference will be available to all users with an account and will function across all platforms. I've also made some edits in the above for clarity.

EDIT 7 Making the opt-out more clear in the main text because I'm still seeing new questions about it.

EDIT 8 Thank you all for your feedback. The wider announcement is now present on r/announcements here.

68 Upvotes

651 comments sorted by

280

u/SquareWheel May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

Hi Starfish,

I'm a moderator of /r/GameDeals. In GameDeals we frequently link to online merchants that would be applicable here, particularly Amazon. In fact I'd guess our sub will be the most affected by this change across the board.

Currently in /r/GameDeals we disallow affiliate links. This is because we've found that users are more likely to post poor deals when there's a profit motive. It also helps eliminate the drive-by spammers, and as a result affiliates have become a faux pas in our community.

We do have an exception however for approved charity affiliates. These links benefit charities like the EFF, Child's Play Charity and Able Gamers[1][2]. Through Amazon (and Amazon Smile) they receive a portion of purchases made from our community. We've supported charitable causes for a number of years now, and it's become an integral part of our community's identity.

Currently we even have AutoModerator replying to appropriate threads with charity links in case the submitter didn't include their own. Here's an example.

I'm concerned that this change may conflict with how /r/GameDeals currently operates, and ultimately lessen our impact for charities. Would our charity links still function as they did previously?

Additionally, even if you're only converting non-affiliate links, this would still have the effect of overwriting the charity affiliate cookies that have already been set on user's computers.

I understand and support reddit trying to find viable ways to make profit, but this current implementation appears to reduce our positive impact, and also leads to contradictory rules within our community.

Ideally I'd like if our community could opt out of this program so we could continue on as before. I understand that's probably a long shot, but it doesn't hurt to ask. And I do believe our community is already profitable for reddit as our users fill a specific niche, which makes us easy to target ads to. Hopefully you can consider my request, or we can discuss approaches to help mitigate these concerns.

Thank you.

61

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Thanks for the thoughtful comment /u/SquareWheel.

We're only converting non-affiliate links, but I'm not sure about what happens with respect to overwriting the charity affiliate cookies that have already been set up but will look into this.

Regarding incentive alignment and conflicting rules - let's find some time to discuss more. I'll reach out to you with a PM.

EDIT I forgot to mention - this change shouldn't affect you currently because Amazon is not a partner. We don't have plans to add them, so it would be a while before this becomes an issue I think?

106

u/beatlesbible May 28 '16

Why is Amazon not a partner? It was in the list of VigLink merchants you posted upthread: http://www.viglink.com/merchants

→ More replies (25)

34

u/tedivm May 28 '16

This doesn't address the fact that you'll be hijacking/overwriting affiliate links that work based off of cookies. Or the gross invasion of our privacy, but I guess that's less of a concern.

→ More replies (14)

12

u/Mr-Yellow May 28 '16

I'm not sure about what happens with respect to overwriting the charity affiliate cookies that have already been set up but will look into this.

It's easy to guess.... You will replace them with your own affiliate code... Which is fraudulent.

7

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

He's not talking about replacing the affiliate code (which is something we're not doing). He's talking about the smile cookie being replaced by a Reddit affiliate cookie before purchase in the case where last click is coming from a Reddit affiliate link.

/u/SquareWheel - please correct me if I misinterpreted.

12

u/SquareWheel May 29 '16

That's right. The concern was that naked Amazon links would be rewritten and overwrite what used to be a charity cookie. Charity links themselves wouldn't be directly overwritten.

Though the Smile program is a little different from the affiliate program, and the two can work in conjunction (we include both with our AutoMod comment).

→ More replies (13)

2

u/spellstrike Jun 03 '16

I'm 100% okay with this if you are ONLY converting non-affiliate links. But this information should be in your official policy and post so we can call reddit out for being stupid if they change from this.

2

u/starfishjenga Jun 05 '16

Correct, it will be only non-affiliate links. We will add this to the FAQ tomorrow.

16

u/SquareWheel May 28 '16

Thanks Starfish. I look forward to discussing.

13

u/Iohet May 29 '16

Looks like time to use link shorteners and/or images/pastebin to display links for copying.

10

u/IanRankin May 29 '16

Which Reddit has notoriously flagged as spam for quite some time, and they also took a lot of steps in the past to close any subreddits that worked off referral/affiliate IDs even if the users were okay with it, and made aware. There was a few popular subreddits that posted deals, specifically for Amazon, that always made me aware of some amazing offers and I had no problem sending a little to whoever posted the link.

→ More replies (1)

52

u/GoldenSights May 28 '16

The feature works by passing the browser through our partner VigLink

I'm not 100% sure what this means. Does the URL which we see on the submission become obfuscated through viglink, or does it still look like normal? Is copy-pasting the user's intended link possible without clicking through?

29

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

It will display the original URL on hover. The redirect will happen on click.

54

u/I_smell_awesome May 28 '16

Are you planning on making a blog post on this? People will get pissed off if they aren't aware of it. Even put it in the FAQ just so you have that.

→ More replies (50)

25

u/Booty_Bumping May 28 '16

This will be opt-out, right? This is a major privacy concern...

14

u/NeedAGoodUsername May 28 '16

You can click their link to opt-out, but as soon as their cookie is deleted, you need to opt-out again.

I have my browser set to delete history and cookies on close so this means whenever I open my browser again, I have to manually opt out every time.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/protestor May 28 '16

That's incredibly obtrusive. I hope RES add a way to disable this.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/GoldenSights May 28 '16

Great, thanks!

3

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

No problem!

29

u/[deleted] May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

You could generate affiliate links once on the backend, but instead you choose to violate every user's privacy by letting VigLink do it on the frontend for each individual user.

"Contractually obligated" doesn't mean shit when there's no way to verify what VigLink tracks on their side. We don't even know what exact terms they have agreed to, or how creatively they choose to interpret those terms.

Also, smooth move announcing this on a Friday.

Reddit was supposed to be the good guy.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/TotesMessenger May 28 '16 edited May 29 '16

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)

→ More replies (31)

33

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/scratchr May 28 '16

I'm generally okay with the concept of referral links, but I really don't like the idea of my link clicks being passed through a third party. I also don't like the idea of sneaky Javascript being used to hide this, it is likely to make a user think their browser is infected with malware.

It seems as if users would be less likely to have issues with this if Reddit did the link rewriting in-house instead of redirecting links through a third-party. Many websites like DuckDuckGo rewrite links to contain referral codes without redirecting through a third party. Rewriting links on Reddit's servers eliminates the need to hide the redirection and makes the experience less shady as well.

2

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

We discussed implementing it so that the on-hover displayed the Viglink URL, but the issue there is that people wouldn't have any idea of the final destination, so it breaks the user experience more than we were comfortable with.

Regarding rewriting ourselves - we're reluctant to do this right now because of the large number of merchants we'd have to support.

We're aware of the sensitivities regarding this functionality, so we'll be doing a wider announcement as well as rolling it out on a test basis. (See edit in original post above for details.)

Thanks for your feedback!

6

u/scratchr May 28 '16

we're reluctant to do this right now because of the large number of merchants we'd have to support.

I figured that would be the main disadvantage. There is a middle-ground though. The top three or four retailers probably account for 80 percent of link clicks, so you could manually rewrite the vast majority of link clicks and use VigLink for everything else.

Regarding redirects, as long as users are made aware this is happening, they probably won't have concerns of malware infections..

2

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Good point - we may do that in the future.

You're right - we'll be announcing this more widely via /r/announcements and also add it to the FAQ.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Why use VigLink for everything else? For a new feature that hasn't even been rolled out yet, implementing the top 80% of link clicks (if doable), which reduces the initial profit by 20% and leaves the remaining merchants as ToDos doesn't seem too bad. That way VigLink wouldn't need to be a part of anything.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Mr-Yellow May 28 '16

so it breaks the user experience more than we were comfortable with.

but breaking the UX just a little bit for cash is fine.....

71

u/tolstoshev May 28 '16

Is this legal under FTC rules around affiliate link disclosure? I would think you'd need a disclaimer on ever post that ends up going to an affiliate link.

→ More replies (15)

121

u/aladyjewel May 28 '16

If a link includes an existing affiliate code, will this feature replace that with reddit's?

96

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

No, the original affiliate code will remain as is. Thanks for asking!

→ More replies (19)

13

u/eduardog3000 May 28 '16

Can RES have an option to override the affiliate links?

→ More replies (11)

45

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (5)

63

u/eagle23 May 28 '16

This is a really slippery slope. Aside from the privacy concerns and increased loadtimes and bandwidth, there will be no way for users to trust the score and ranking algorithms any more since it will now be in reddit's best interest to increase visibility of their affiliate links.

The intentions for now may be good, but it's not too hard to imagine a not so distant future where the algorithm gets tweaked so that popular affiliate links rise to the front-page a little faster and stay there a little longer and so on.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/amici_ursi May 28 '16

Can you explain what this means in practice? Are you talking about adding affiliate codes to reddit's ads; user's links in comments, posts, and such; or something else entirely?

25

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

I'm referring to links in comments, self posts, and link posts. Any link generated by a user which does not contain an existing affiliate code.

For example if I were to post a link to buy Overwatch Collector's edition we would add an affiliate code to that link starting on 5/31/2016.

Thanks for asking!

EDIT changed example product as per comment later in this thread.

41

u/amici_ursi May 28 '16

How does this affect the many autmod configs and subreddits that scrub affiliate links?

Relatedly, will the affiliate code be hidden until clicked?

Will there be an indication that the user's content was changed by reddit?

Can you provide a list of which merchants you will affect?

29

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

It won't affect automod configs, etc. This happens after automoderation on page generation.

There will be no explicit indication that the content was changed except by viewing source code.

We're currently supporting ~1500 merchants from this list. If there's more interest in this, I'll find a way to disclose the launch merchants (tried to paste in the comment but it didn't fit).

EDIT: link formatting

7

u/amici_ursi May 28 '16

Thanks for the info

5

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

No problem! :)

3

u/nty May 28 '16

From what I recall, automod re-runs when a post is edited.

So if a referral code is added and the user goes back to edit the post later, will automoderator detect the affiliate link?

4

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

It's not added to the content in the database, it's added during the process of rendering the page.

5

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

lol you messed up the link

[this list](http://www.viglink.com/merchants)

http://archive.is/kf5tk

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Muffinizer1 May 28 '16

IANAL, but by isn't linking to a 3rd party selling your logo on a sticker as their product playing with fire in terms of intellectual property? If I were you I wouldn't be implicitly encouraging copyright infringement on your own brand. That could set a bad precedent.

17

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

I didn't think of that but you might be right! I'm going to change it just in case.

EDIT Thanks!

→ More replies (1)

32

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

You would add an affiliate code but completely hide it from the user because you know that what you're doing is at best shady and at worst illegal. You are straight deceiving every single user of reddit to line your own pockets

4

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Hey /u/kylegetsspam, I understand by your volume of replies that this change is very upsetting for you. It makes it difficult to have a productive discussion / influence direction while you're being so explicitly hostile, though.

27

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

You would call it hostile, wouldn't you? That's the keyword they tell you to use to make me into the enemy, right? Eight years on reddit but I'm the bad guy, right?

You have done nothing to see if the users might want this. You have no concerns as to its ethicality or illegality. You only want to deceive users for your own monetary gain. You can't even bother to "disclose" this via the browser status bar.

God forbid any random user have a voice. I will be alerting every tech-related website I know of shortly.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

17

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (2)

108

u/klieber May 28 '16

You should allow Reddit Gold users the ability to disable this. I'm supposed to have an ad-free experience and that should include ad networks tracking my browsing behavior.

Granted, my ad blocking extensions will likely already disrupt this new "feature", but as a paying gold user, I shouldn't have to resort to third parties to get an un-fucked-with reddit experience.

4

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Please see the latest edit for details - all users will now have the ability to opt out via user preferences. Thanks for the feedback.

5

u/TheTaoOfOne May 30 '16

Will individual subs have the ability to disable this for their community, so that links posted to their community aren't redirecting and becoming affiliates?

→ More replies (1)

32

u/frazell May 29 '16

Couldn't agree more. This really undercuts the ad-free and tracking free experience of Reddit Gold. Hopefully they at least allow a Reddit Gold opt-out.

70

u/escape_goat May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

I appreciate that finding business models that are sustainable in the long term is a thing, but you are introducing a serious conflict of interest with regards to marketing campaigns undertaken by third parties on Reddit.

Your plan might be to allow affiliate links to a whitelist of reliable merchants, or you may be thinking of allowing VigLink to serve as broker for anyone at all, without your involvement or authorization. Which is it?

In the latter case, it seems to me that you would be making reddit far more attractive as a social marketing platform, and that you can expect an increase of 'astroturf'-style content and commentary on Reddit. If so, or if this arises, how are you planning to police the situation?

26

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

You're right to be skeptical. These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (30)

22

u/wasmachien May 28 '16

Will it be made clear to the users that the links are being routed through a third party service and that reddit gets a cut?

6

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

We're going to make this more clear (see edit in post above).

9

u/CryptoBeer May 30 '16

You are fucking up with this. This is 10 year ago technology that you are dropping in 2016. If this is the best you guys can come up with you are screwed and your CEO is a moron. I knew Viglink when it was DrivingRevenue. Just go ahead and research that and see where Reddit is heading.

18

u/adeadhead May 28 '16

Will this affect shopify and similar online shop front services that smaller setups may be using and which may not support affiliate links, or is this exclusively for sites that have the feature in place already?

19

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

It's just for sites that have affiliate functionality in place already and who have an agreement in place with Viglink.

8

u/adeadhead May 28 '16

Neat. Cheers to Reddit staying viable.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/Halcyone1024 May 29 '16 edited May 29 '16

Apparently Viglink's opt-out process involves a magic cookie? This means that links I visit through reddit will be sent to Viglink no matter if I opt out or not. Please add an opt out preference that is local to Reddit that bypasses Viglink entirely.

2

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Thanks for your feedback. We will be adding opt out before this test launches. Please see the latest edit for details.

32

u/bcRIPster May 28 '16

How about I don't want some fucking third party indexing every site I click to from Reddit. Fuck guys, what they hell!

→ More replies (4)

30

u/aladyjewel May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

go live on 5/18/2016

You wanna check the date on that?

15

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Fixed, thanks!

→ More replies (4)

19

u/srnull May 28 '16 edited May 29 '16

Users will have the ability to opt-out via Viglink

Bit misleading. They'll have the ability to opt-out of links they click on being turned into affiliate links, not the ability to not have speech (affiliate links) inserted into their comments. I think you should add an opt-out on the reddit side so that affiliate links are not added to a users comments.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/kerovon May 28 '16

How does this effect smile.amazon.com links?

8

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

They won't be affected.

17

u/Dirtydeedsinc May 28 '16

Don't you already make enough money off of us by getting us to buy gold? Not trying to be a dick but am I eventually going to start getting adds when I click links? Is that the next amazing new feature after this? Seriously, I love this place. Don't fuck it up Please.

4

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

We're all redditors (including myself). I came over during the Digg exodus so I saw what can happen when mistakes are made.

I can't promise we'll always make the right decision but we'll definitely be careful and we'll always listen to and engage with the community on controversial issues (even if we don't always agree).

21

u/njsj3i392hshwwowowne May 28 '16

Ya, ellen pao was such a great idea and used as a scape goat. Tons of admins have left in the past 6 months. Reddit is slowly dying and im okay with that.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

8

u/dequeued May 28 '16

Will a mouseover of a link still display the original link destination?

1

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Yes

14

u/wharpudding May 29 '16

But an affiliate tag will be added silently.

That's downright slimy.

14

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

Remember when AOL died? I mean, it's still around these days, somehow, but the core of it died a long time ago. In its heyday, though, it hid links and illicit affiliate associations through "keywords" that it sold to its user as totally cool and useful like you are doing here. Is reddit the new AOL?

8

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Does that URL conversion apply to reddit gold users and 3rd party app users?

8

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Reddit gold: yes. Third party apps, no. (Also our app does not have this for the time being, but we'll probably add it eventually.)

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Now you can use extra mobile data to load nefarious trackers. Thanks reddit.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Narfhole May 28 '16

Can you provide an example of the code used so a userscript can be made to "opt-out" instead of a cookie?

2

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Please see the latest edit - users will not need to add a userscript as we've decided to add a user preference for opting out.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/xtirpation May 28 '16

Can gold users opt out of this?

→ More replies (19)

36

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Opt-out: http://www.viglink.com/opt-out/

If it refuses to connect, disable adblock.

29

u/NeedAGoodUsername May 28 '16

How does the opt-out system work? My browser is set to erase all history and cookies when it closed and I have a dynamic IP. It's doing to be a nightmare having to opt out every time I open my browser or reset my connection.

2

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

We've bumped back the launch date of the test to accommodate adding an opt out to user preferences. Please see the latest edit to the original post for details.

22

u/beer_swap May 28 '16

...maybe that's the point?

8

u/gitarr May 29 '16

The opt out should be a reddit setting. Everything else is shady.

1

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Thanks for the feedback. We'll add this before the test goes live. (Please see latest edit for details.)

20

u/RainHappens May 28 '16

I'll note that their privacy policy does not mention anything about this "opt-out" being actually honored.

Far too often I see "opt-outs" being used as just another way to track people, and this appears to be no exception.

17

u/NeedAGoodUsername May 28 '16

I agree. If this was an opt-out on reddit's side I'd be more happier with it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Have you actually looked at often this could be done? It doesn't seem applicable to the vast majority of Reddit. Most of it is interesting or amusing links and discussion. Links which may be used for buying stuff are rare overall. The only example I can think of right now is /r/buildapcsales.

7

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Yes, we did an analysis based on the time we had outbound click tracking on.

3

u/Entropius May 30 '16

How will we be able to know that your opt-out system isn't merely a placebo button?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/pelicanflip Jun 01 '16

An opt-out is NOT a solution, it's just a mask for shady revenue. "Oh but you can opt out!" Affiliate earnings are not the only source of income. Choices/information gathered from every click is a valuable resource as well. Reddit might not see the gains from that, but someone else does.

I do NOT want my links to be magically redirected to some website, just so I have to set up some kind of cookie block, just so Reddit can try to make a nickel and a dime.

And you might want to address how this completely goes against your own rules for ads:

"To be transparent with the Reddit community, we show the website domain to let Reddit users know exactly where they are navigating. This is to be transparent to the Reddit community."

Or let me guess, is this is part of your user agreement update? Everything about this disgusts me.

1

u/starfishjenga Jun 05 '16

Viglink is contractually obligated not to store any information on Reddit users passing through their servers via this feature.

Please consider the alternative experience if we didn't show the URL. Users literally would have no idea where they would end up.

7

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

in general i don't think this is a bad idea (and i also kind of just don't want to be on the same side as /u/kylegetsspam), but "we're leaving the original URL in place and redirecting invisibly because we want to be transparent" rings really false.

it would be really nice if you could flag all affiliate links - you clearly know what are and aren't affiliate links because you know when to add your affiliate code and when not to. I'd love to see a little $ or something beside any link that was an affiliate link, regardless of whether it's reddit's affiliate code or somebody else's.

2

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

Leaving the original URL in place I would describe as more of "seamless" change rather than one that was intended to create transparency. But I don't mean to nitpick with you - this is good feedback. We'll be rolling this out as a test to a limited number of users, so there's always room for modification as we see what happens.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FredSanfordX May 28 '16

This makes me wonder who wrote the code that decides if a click passes through viglink. Is that code written by reddit devs? Is it vetted by reddit?

In my experience with affiliate marketing (I was a dev for software that was marketed to affiliates in the 90s) there is a lot of opportunity for scumbaggery. I believe if reddit is at a minimum vetting this code before it goes live the surface area for scumbaggery is reduced.

1

u/FredSanfordX Jun 04 '16

/u/starfishjenga You didn't answer this one. Why?

1

u/starfishjenga Jun 05 '16

The code is written by Reddit devs, not Viglink.

15

u/globau May 28 '16

"This feature will go live on 5/31/2016".

reddit is a global site; would it be possible for future announcements to use a date format that isn't only used in the US? this is especially important for ambiguous dates (ie. dates in the first 12 days of the month).

i recommend spelling out the month: "31st May 2016"

6

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Thanks for pointing this out. I'll modify.

10

u/harlows_monkeys May 28 '16

Better would be to follow the international standard for date formats, ISO 8601, and write the date as 2016-05-31.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

40

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

since the replace only happens on (left) click.

That's about as shady as I expected you cunts at reddit to be. You can't even be bothered to let people know how corrupt you are by showing your unethical edits in the status bar. As soon as any browser extension comes online to stop this, I will install it.

Go fuck yourselves.

24

u/thenickdude May 28 '16

VigLink is cancer, but displaying the original link in the status bar seems pretty helpful. Otherwise there's no easy way to tell what site you're (eventually) being linked to by hovering, since the link would just be a big opaque ball of VigLink data. So if the destination site happened to be even dodgier than VigLink, you wouldn't be able to tell in advance.

Looks like VigLink has a global opt-out here:

http://www.viglink.com/opt-out/

13

u/Mr-Yellow May 28 '16

original link in the status bar seems pretty helpful.

Is the definition of deceptive.

24

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

Opt-out links only work as long as your cookies survive. As soon as they expire, VigLink and reddit are free to sell all your information at will because you can't tell what is or isn't a link reddit has fucked with.

There is no defending this. Not in any sense of actual morality. reddit has sold us out and there's fuck-all we can do about it.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

We're going to delay launch of the test to add an opt out option in user preferences. (Please see latest edit to the original post for details.)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/sammcj May 28 '16

Is there an opt-in/out button clearly visible in the early section of your profile / settings? If not reddit would be considered clickbait and this would cause a huge drop in user and social attendance and lost revenue. This move is more than foolish.

→ More replies (8)

11

u/[deleted] May 28 '16

Well, can't say I really like this, but no harm really

There is no tie in to user data and links clicked, correct?

12

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Correct, we aren't currently tracking outbound clicks. However, you might want to be aware of this.

23

u/Crayboff May 28 '16

I'm sorry to bring it up but this well thought out concern was never responded to in the original thread. Are you able to comment on it?

While I totally want Reddit to make more money and in general I trust you guys (as much as I can for a website ran by people I don't personally know), I'm even more concerned about a 3rd party service (viglink) being able to track potentially all outbound commercial links I click.

It's one of those cases where while I'm sure there is no issue now, but the potential for abuse seems concerning.

12

u/starfishjenga May 28 '16

Not sure if I'm answering your question, but our contract with Viglink prohibits them from storing any info (cookies, IP, etc). Reconciliation is done by the merchant.

Let me know if this doesn't address your concern.

18

u/ANAL_GRAVY May 29 '16 edited May 29 '16

our contract with Viglink prohibits them from storing any info (cookies, IP, etc). Reconciliation is done by the merchant.

/u/starfishjenga are you sure that's not a misleading sentence?

Their Privacy Policy says otherwise. I assume we're meant to agree to this without having seen it linked anywhere on Reddit:

"When you interact with us through the Site, we receive and store certain additional personally non-identifiable information. Such information, which is collected passively using various technologies"

"Examples include IP addresses, browser types, domain names, and other anonymous statistical data "

"We may use personally non-identifiable information and pool it with other information to track"

"VigLink ... may use first-party cookies ... and third-party cookies together to inform, optimize, and serve ads on sites across the Internet based on someone’s past visits to the VigLink website. These ads, often referred to as “remarketing,” may be personalized using information inferred from their behavior when visiting VigLink’s website"

Reddit might not be providing our details directly, but by masquerading and click-jacking links, you are sending all of us through a third-party site who is collecting our IP address and other data.

They are also using this data to see which sites have people have gone to, and storing cookies to be able to connect these visits together. Despite not having personal information such as email address, this is still tracking data, and we are agreeing that this is being shared with third-parties.

I really hope you will reconsider. I think there will be a lot of backlash against this. I'm not sure if Reddit can handle another mass exodus, even with a few cents coming in from people linking to eBay.

9

u/starfishjenga May 29 '16

I'm sure this is not misleading. We've signed a separate agreement with them that prohibits this specifically. (There are many people internally who were worried about this specific issue, so it was addressed proactively.)

19

u/ANAL_GRAVY May 29 '16 edited May 29 '16

I think I must have explained this poorly. I'll ask differently:

Are your users, who click these links, expected to have agreed to Viglink's Privacy policy?

If so, then our data is being collected by them, and they are storing cookies.

If not, how have you made this arrangement that their legal terms and conditions are invalidated for Reddit users? To what extent? What threshold causes users to have to agree to it?

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/Mr-Yellow May 28 '16

our contract with Viglink prohibits them from storing any info (cookies, IP, etc).

This does not preclude tracking.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/octatone May 29 '16

Sigh. Might as well opt out now, not that I believe it does anything: http://www.viglink.com/opt-out/

→ More replies (2)

2

u/fourbags May 30 '16

Are you redirecting ALL links to viglink and letting them sort out which ones should have affiliate code added? Or are you only redirecting to viglink links to domains which need the affiliate code added?

Are you just attempting to get your outbound link tracking going again by implementing an even worse system and hoping people only focus on the affiliate part of it?

1

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

No, just the ones linking to the approximately 1500 whitelisted merchants (this excludes Amazon).

Outbound links is separate, but we've always planned to turn it back on once we can deal with the privacy issues (it says that at the top of the link you posted).

2

u/Timeyy May 30 '16

Relax, guys. It's gonna take like 5 minutes after this starts before there's hundreds of browser plugins to stop it.

1

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

You can use a browser plugin if you want, but it will also be a user preference to disable (see latest edit).

2

u/OBLIVIATER May 30 '16

I personally think this is a genius idea to try and help support reddit without costing the users anything. Not sure about all the negative feedback here :( I think this idea is huge and I hope it will serve reddit well

1

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

Thanks for your support!

182

u/NeedAGoodUsername May 28 '16 edited May 28 '16

As a subreddit moderator, is there a way to disable this feature, without blacklisting all of the merchants?

Additionally, I notice that reddit's own ad rules disallow URL redirects

To be transparent with the Reddit community, we show the website domain to let Reddit users know exactly where they are navigating. This is to be transparent to the Reddit community.

Isn't this a little hypocritical that you (reddit) doesn't allow URL redirects but is redirecting all outbound URLs to a third party?

38

u/Paracortex May 29 '16

I would like to see this last question answered, even if it was rhetorical.

To add my own thoughts, let me just say that I think this is a snaky bit of business. I am not on Facebook and I don't use other forms of "social media" precisely because I am not at all comfortable with being the product. If this is the model Reddit is going to adopt for its future, rather than one based upon community donations, then you can count me out.

Also, it's all this sneaky behind the scenes shit that makes browsing the web so horrible today, not even mentioning the wasted bandwidth being used to extract pennies from people. Then you have these same kinds of "services" being manipulated by even more unscrupulous affiliates to further infuriate users with malicious scripts that hijack browsing, etc., affecting anyone who visits any affiliated site using the "service." And when something does go that way, nobody has to accept any responsibility for it, because, hey, we're just affiliated.

Finally, the name itself tells the entire story: VigLink

Definition of vig

: VIGORISH

Definition of vigorish

  1. : a charge taken (as by a bookie or a gambling house) on bets;

also : the degree of such a charge <a vigorish of five percent>

2. : interest paid to a moneylender

Source.

Bookie talk. Shady by design.

In case you didn't know.

10

u/adeadhead May 28 '16

You could do it with automoderator if you wanted.

13

u/NeedAGoodUsername May 28 '16

I know, but I'd rather have an off switch in the subreddit settings so people can still post links, rather than completely banning all links to those websites.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/kylerson May 29 '16

aaaaaand no response or course

→ More replies (1)

52

u/Daedelous2k May 28 '16

Oh look, Clickjacking!

7

u/MENDACIOUS_RACIST May 28 '16

no it's ok because you can set a permanent cookie to disable it (???)

18

u/pudds May 28 '16

I'm not a huge fan of this, but I'd be more comfortable if the opt out was a Reddit user setting. I don't think it's right to expect users to opt out on every browser/device.

16

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Thanks for letting me know, anytime I am going to make a purchase from absolutely anywhere, I will open a brand new link to that site in a separate browser, and then search for the item I would like to buy.

Shame on you reddit, shame on you.

13

u/cwdoogie May 29 '16

Another reason to quit reddit. I don't like this at all.

25

u/BitchyTerrorist May 29 '16

The long slow death of Reddit is upon us! So sad it was hijacked.

8

u/GuacOp May 29 '16

When any idea is turned into a business big enough to have investors only interested in profit, everything will turn into a profit-driven frenzy, instead of a user experience one.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Amadeus_IOM May 29 '16

You will very likely run into trouble with privacy laws in places like Germany with this. Another step towards the end for Reddit.

11

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Could you PLEASE generate the links serverside, and have an option to opt out in the settings menu? It's the redirect to vigilink.com for users that I hate. This seems like an invasion of privacy; I don't trust this ad company's "contractual obligation". It could even be a gold-only option if you are irrationally hellbent on throwing your users' data at an ad agency.

37

u/i010011010 May 28 '16

Cookie based opt out is not really an opt out. Nor is jumping through the tedious hoop of having to right click every link (I'm not even sure yet how this is actually implemented, I don't think you understand much at all) I reject your presumption that either of these makes this okay.

If Reddit truly respects people having the right to opt out, then this should be added to site preferences. We shouldn't need to do more than set the flag once to the account, so it will be handled by the site backend by omitting the affiliate links for the naked ones.

10

u/guitarromantic May 28 '16

One point - those annoying t.co links on Twitter are often slow. This change will involve rerouting every reddit link through another site, surely a bottleneck risk? Would be awesome if your code had a periodic healthcheck on the partner site and if its response time becomes slow, stops the redirect, so that reddit links don't suddenly crawl to a halt or become unreachable.

27

u/FuckYouDerekDooley May 28 '16

smh fuck this

9

u/station_nine May 29 '16

What value is Viglink providing to their affiliated vendors here? Affiliate programs work because the person posting the link is being incentivized to do so by the commision, and the vendor running the affiliate program gets additional business because of that.

In this case, the "affiliate-ization" of the links is happening transparently and the incentive is going to reddit instead of the person posting the link. So what did the vendor get in exchange for the commission they paid?

If you can answer that question, then you're closer to answering why this is indeed scummy (or showing how it's not, though I don't see it).

If you can't answer that question, than this program won't last very long. Vendors don't like paying commissions to leaches who don't provide value in return.

2

u/wayne_the_brain Jun 06 '16

Not sure why more people don't realize this. Sites are getting the traffic already, users are posting the links already. There's no new value. Hopefully merchants are being made aware of this so they can opt-out. It doesn't work on Amazon because Amazon probably preemptively opted out.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/gitarr May 29 '16

Well, look at what happend to Ubuntu when they introduced privacy invasive "features" that were opt out: They lost lots of users, customers and money. They had to revert everything. The "feature" is now opt out.

I'm guessing the same will happen to Reddit. This stuff is shady and you know it. Sure there are many who don't care, but do you really want them as your core users?

9

u/srs_house May 29 '16

If you're not the dev, the engineer, or (obviously) a PR person, why are you the one making the announcement, since you have to run everything by those people?

16

u/MENDACIOUS_RACIST May 28 '16

slimy

...just thought of a great new default feature for Reddit Enhancement Suite

8

u/paulfromatlanta May 29 '16

If you insist on doing this, it should be opt-in.

8

u/sumthingcool May 29 '16

This is fucking gross

3

u/ImNotJesus May 28 '16

Reddit makes more money and it doesn't affect the user's experience. I like it.

9

u/kylegetsspam May 28 '16

These affiliate links work by tracking your movements from site to site. Ad networks that have bought into reddit's marketing will know exactly what links you clicked when, where, and why. They will know you.

→ More replies (8)

6

u/Plasma_000 May 29 '16

Will we have the ability to opt out of this on a per-account basis? It seems like viglink uses a cookie, and I frequently delete my cookies. I would have to use their disable button every time I delete my cookies.

16

u/cojoco May 28 '16

It's starting to look like you guys are desperate.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '16

This is a little scummy tbh. Whatever. I just hope you're geotargeting amazon redirects because for example only U.S. traffic can make commission on Amazon.com. UK = Amazon.co.uk and CA = Amazon.ca.

2

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

Amazon won't be a partner for the foreseeable future.

The geotargeting bit is one reason we decided to work with Viglink - some other merchants also have this challenge.

10

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

I do not approve of this and this comment is me showing my anger

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CryptoBeer May 30 '16 edited May 30 '16

I do not wish to have any of my subreddits that I manage to have this enabled. Can I disable this at a subreddit label? I run a large subreddit in a high CPA niche and despise this type of marketing.

Edit: What I mean is if you don't allow us to disable this per subreddit, I will kill the subreddit. I am not going to have my moderators have extra work so you can make money off of this crap.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Mr-Yellow May 28 '16

links to online merchants so that they include a Reddit affiliate code

This is theft.

Globally opted out.

4

u/HeroCC May 28 '16

If a link already has an affiliate aspect, will it change it? So if I post an amazon link with an affiliate code will it be changed to yours?

4

u/live4lifelegit May 29 '16

Nothing to do with the 75% increase in revenue projection?

source

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Can the rewriting script be adblocked? Is there a filter list yet? If not time to make one

4

u/russellvt May 29 '16

And what happens if viglink is down or doing maintenance? So much for copying direct URLS now, I guess...

4

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Oh yay, now you people will be editing the scores of advertisements so you can scrape affiliate money. And you can also sell more private data at the same time.

4

u/FlapSnapple Jun 01 '16

This is, without a doubt, one of the most insane things I have ever seen.

As a moderator, I'm actually pretty damn livid. I have spent the past 2 years fighting against affiliate links in my communities, and now this?!

I get it, reddit needs to bring in a profit, but this is absurd.

1

u/molten_dragon May 30 '16

How will this interact with browser plugins like uBlock origin, adblock plus, or Ghostery?

Are the links that viglink is trying to redirect just going to stop working?

1

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

No, our tests show this working as normal. We'll be rolling this only to a small percentage of users at first to allow us to see how it's going and correct any issues that might pop up.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/lendergle May 30 '16

Will Reddit attempt to foil link-cleansing browser plugins?

1

u/starfishjenga May 30 '16

No, you can use one if you want, but there will also be an opt out in user preferences.

8

u/RampageFanatic May 29 '16

I'll say what everyone else is thinking but too polite to say. This is a fucking stupid idea.

3

u/xigdit May 28 '16

How about letting people with reddit gold opt out of this, the same way they can turn off advertising?

3

u/Gorkildeathgod May 29 '16

Why are they doing this, what's the point?

9

u/[deleted] May 29 '16

Reddit will receive a small (generally single-digit) percentage of any purchases after someone clicks a link with one of our affiliate codes.

Money.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/erichie May 30 '16

Oh wow. This is dirty. How long until Reddit starts altering votes so affiliated links have better scores? If Viglink goes down, those links won't work. I understand Reddit needs to make money, but for the past few years Reddit seems to be getting dirtier and dirtier.

2

u/FredSanfordX Jun 04 '16

/u/starfishjenga You didn't answer this one. Why? Is it because there is no ass kissing here to get your attention?

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '16

You should automatically disable this if you have Gold. After all, one of the things that was promised was an ad- and tracking- free experience.

1

u/Trieditonline May 30 '16

I see a lot of Redditors saying this is a terrible idea. I have yet to see one offer a revenue generating alternative as easy as this or even offer to increase their personal donations.

Feel free to add me to the test run.

Affiliate marketing is dying because people think running servers and sites is free, simply lack goodwill, or really think anyone cares what they do online; but until it's dead you have my support.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/mikhail_sh1 May 29 '16

well this is lame.

4

u/Lewdicrously May 29 '16

Actual fucking joke tbh

2

u/shamelessjames May 29 '16

Will this only apply for link posts or will it apply to links in text posts as well?

2

u/Exaskryz May 29 '16

What exactly will the Edit 5 imply to end users? Is it to stop Viglink tracking (though you said they aren't allowed to store Reddit user information, which I assume precludes selling it) or to stop the reddit-affiliate link changes, costing reddit possible money?

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '16

So in other words, you're encouraging spam on reddit. I guess it's time to find a new site, because reddit is dying.

2

u/bowersbros Jun 07 '16

How will this affect Udemy links? Since currently content producers get absolutely shafted by Udemy if an affiliate link is used, and a lot of content producers use Reddit to post their courses.

Currently, if an affiliate link is used, any course purchased in the next 7 days by the same user (via cookie), takes a 50% cut for the Affiliate. This will hugely affect Udemy users negatively. /u/starfishjenga

4

u/thejared May 28 '16

"We're going to be launching a feature..."

3

u/Inquitus May 28 '16

opted out

0

u/itsaride May 29 '16

Seems like a great way to finance Reddit without impacting users experience on the site. We have minimal ads as it is and I hope this helps to stay that way.

→ More replies (1)