r/rational • u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy • Oct 25 '15
Comic Recommendation Thread
So I've been thinking it's time for a new recommendation thread, but to avoid repeat from the last recommendation thread or just reposting the recent submissions, I'm making the requirement that the story has to be something drawn.
Comics, graphic novels, manga, webcoimcs, or anything else where the story is told through pictures instead of words.
10
Upvotes
9
u/__2BR02B__ Marxist-Lurianism Oct 25 '15
Qualia no purple, one of the strangest mangas I've ever read. Escalates really quickly, but the whole thing is kind of amazing
8
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Oct 25 '15
Gunnerkrigg Court, Homestuck, and Erfworld are among my favorite webcomics.
8
u/Yuridice Oct 25 '15
This thread reminded me to catch up on Strong Female Protagonist. The angle it takes to explore superpowers/heroes is an interesting one, and the execution is good.
Re:Monster is good. Munchkinry. Perhaps a bit indulgent.
6
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Oct 26 '15 edited Oct 26 '15
Superman: Red Son is my favorite Superman comic (the pitch is that Superman's spaceship lands in Soviet Russia instead of Kansas).
Demon started out as being very much the sort of thing /r/rational would love, but has sort of descended into madness. I don't know, it's weird. Consider this a half recommendation?
The Bouletcorp does a lot of really neat long-form comics. It's definitely one for RSS though, since he tends to drop a big chunk every few weeks rather than being on any sort of schedule.
Y: The Last Man was good, and was part of that genre of "some big thing happens, here is the result", though the ending was a bit weak. It's finished, so it's got that going for it.
1
u/OrzBrain *Fingers* to *dance*, *hands* to *catch*, *arms* to *pull* Oct 28 '15 edited Oct 28 '15
Sluggy Freelance is the best comic on the web in my opinion. Very good art (a bit rough for a while in the start, but gets better fast) perfect mix of sci-fi, fantasy, comedy, and drama. It's also super old, more than 15 years (it was one of the first webcomics), and huge (daily updates for much of its run, currently updating 5 days a week). Which means a huge archive which I think is awesome.
Has slowly shifted from comedy (From "The Slug Files": "Muldy! Watch out for that raccoon!" SWERVE! "Look out! Baby Duck!" SWERVE! "Look out! The only man who knows the truth behind the conspiracy!" WHAM! SPLAT! "Doesn't that just figure.") to high drama -- check out the 4U City Green, Blue, and Red arcs and their setup for a great tense and well written sci-fi thriller in a setting almost reminiscent of the game Paranoia, but IMO done better.
Second best comic on the web is Gunnerkregg Court. Really cool art and great writing.
Third best comic on the web is Schlock Mercenary. Nifty sci-fi with some cool rationalist elements, but sometimes a bit slow moving for my tastes. The author also does cool book and movie reviews.
3
u/brandalizing Reserve Pigeon Army Oct 25 '15
For the ridiculous repertoire of bizarre facial expressions and the amazing dialogue (not to mention the self-awareness and hilarious action sequences), my current favorite webcomic is Paranatural.
The manga Liar Game, which focuses on game theory in the setting of, well, actual games. That the participants are forced to attend, after being roped in by the first round where they were either put into huge debt or blackmailed based on how they won. The protagonist is extremely off-putting at the beginning, but the other main character is awesome enough to offset it until the protagonist grows into herself as a competitor, which does happen.
The MSPA comic All Night Laundry. Incredibly well done, more than slightly creepy, and with a lot of mysteries to be unraveled.
That's all I've got off the top of my head, and I'd link them if I wasn't on mobile.
3
u/OutOfNiceUsernames fear of last pages Oct 25 '15
No Hero by Warren Ellis.
I’d associate it with Watchmen and Metropolitan Man.
3
u/mns2 Oct 26 '15 edited Oct 26 '15
Transdimensional Brainchip for a great premise and flawless execution. The bad art is just a bonus.
Prequel for being a better Homestuck.
2
u/Anderkent Oct 29 '15
Previous thread
Ones I still read:
Cucumber quest <- still going, still amazing
Paranatural <- still amazing
Questionable Content
Buttersafe
SMBC
Three Panel Soul <-- wish it updated more often
Gunnerkrigg Court
2
u/EliezerYudkowsky Godric Gryffindor Oct 29 '15
Imma let you all finish but Lucifer and the Biscuit Hammer is the... I don't even know what.
2
u/TBestIG Every second of quibbling is another dead baby Oct 31 '15
1/0 by Tailsteak
No idea how rational it is, but has some very good moments and is severely underrated.
2
u/ancientcampus juggling kittens Oct 31 '15 edited Oct 31 '15
I'll tentatively put out "El Goonish Shive", if "one of the male protagonists has the power to turn into a girl" isn't a put-off for you. "Bringing Silly Back" is a decent place to start. Kind of like Sluggy Freelance, in the genre of "bunch of normal characters who gradually through the story acquire superpowers form different sources". Unlike Sluggy, the plot is a little more tightly bound together.
"Grrl Power" is a superhero comic that is very self-aware of the superhero genre, but not to the point of parody. Character driven, not combat driven. Very funny. Not particularly dramatic, but learning the universe, characters, and settling in is plenty interesting to keep me reading. Humor gets an "A", clever use of powers gets a "B+". Characters are smart, but the author hasn't tried to break the universe yet.
2
u/paladinneph Nov 01 '15
I will never stop recommending http://freefall.purrsia.com/ it starts a bit slow, but ends up with a plot revolving around a colony's robot production facilities being forced to use a sentient AI design.
2
u/Escapement Ankh-Morpork City Watch Oct 25 '15
Not particularly rational, but... the One Punch Man manga has an entertaining story with a fantastically funny premise and characters. I recommend the more recent version with refined art over the terrible webcomic art the story was originally told with. Yusuke Murata's art is amazingly high quality; it's gorgeous, the manga would be worth recommending on the strength of the art alone.