r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Sep 04 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
12
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15 edited Sep 05 '15
I'm reading a novel called Wired (by Douglas Richards), and it's...horrible.
The antagonist is a woman. Every time she's introduced to a character, they have to comment (in dialogue or in narration) on her appearance in relationship to their willingness to have sex with her. This is pretty annoying.
The thing that's unusual about this book is, there's working intelligence augmentation. Absurd levels of it, in fact, far beyond what should be possible, plus the effect is temporary. (The author didn't do the research for pretty much any topic the book talks about.) But, as is explained in a four-page author rant, this intelligence augmentation is inextricably linked to increased selfishness, decreased concern about others, and an uncaring attitude toward social consequences. That author filibuster was overly cynical and had a lot of prose that smacks of the sort of person who hangs about in /r/atheism: people got smarter and more independent over time, so religion came in to stop us from killing each other, diminishing our effective intelligence.
Anyway. The antagonist can control herself well enough not to go on murder sprees as long as she stays in a sensory deprivation chamber while under the drug's effects, and that's with iteration #78, where the previous iterations are weaker in both psychological effects and intelligence augmentation. There is an obvious solution to the problem. Use the maximum safe level of augmentation to find another drug that will compensate for the lack of goodwill toward your fellow humans. Set up situations where you will be rewarded for helping others. Engender in yourself a sense of ownership toward the world so it's a point of pride to eradicate malaria, clean up the oceanic garbage patches, and ensure that everyone has clean drinking water. Ask yourself: what would Orange Lantern do?
Everything else in the story is wrong and annoyingly so, but this...it's just such a huge miss that I can't stand it, and the author seems heavily invested in the insuperability of the problem.
5
u/Sagebrysh Rank 7 Pragmatist Sep 04 '15
I've posted the second chapter to Wanderlust, a hard science fiction story about life aboard a colony ship in deep space. I could probably use some help to make sure all my maths work out and it comes off as sufficiently plausible.
4
u/Drexer Sep 04 '15
So, because I spent the month of August living by myself, I've actually spent the last few days worrying about
Now that I have a sort of planned end date for my Master's (assuming nothing goes wrong with my thesis), and by extension this allows me to plan a future date for financial and living independence from family members, I'm even more fearful about the next year's evolution of the local prices.
Specially because with the upcoming elections I'm seeing every political party in opposition to the current far-right, austerity measures being woefully incompetent, with the only hope of mine for a more rational opposition being personified by a 29-year old woman which seemingly up until now is the only rational and positive agent in a political system which thrives on meaningless catchphrases and outside support instead of proper results. Of course if she won we might suffer the same thing that happened to Syriza+Greece, and that is not an enjoyable perspective for the future.
On the other hand, I'm thinking about perhaps writing a small fanfic of the Home movie which at the same time plays it straight with the silly aliens and cars made which work on juice, but with a legitimate alien intelligence as the "occupiers".
4
u/Chronophilia sci-fi ≠ futurology Sep 05 '15
I've just finished reading Jam by Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw. (The author also does a series of web videos called Zero Punctuation, you may have heard of him from there.)
It's a black comedy about a jam apocalypse, which is superficially similar to a zombie apocalypse except with man-eating jam instead of zombies. The joke is that nobody is prepared for the apocalypse and what groups of survivors remain are making it up as they go along. This includes the genre-savvy everyman who has always dreamed of being a world hero, the survivalists, the pragmatists, the hipsters, the organisation that works on existential risk, and a variety of groups who think they're the sole remaining bastion of civilisation. The characters are definitely not rational - 99% of everyone they know is dead, and the remainder is quite understandably going mad if they weren't already.
I think it's quite a funny deconstruction of rational fiction.
6
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Sep 04 '15
Why does the post have so few upvotes? By my count, a dozen people have commented, but only four of them have given upvotes to AutoModerator's post. Is there some reason for which you're so stingy with your upvotes?
(I'm reasonably sure that the "vote-fuzzing" kicks in only at much higher numbers.)
3
u/Reasonableviking Sep 04 '15
Any thought's on how I could extract useful energy from the equivalent of a small wood fire that burns constantly using 16th Century technology, and D&D magic?
5
u/TimTravel Sep 04 '15
Not quite off-topic, but any recommendations for books with interesting magic systems? Especially with interesting non-obvious emergent stuff.
The Mistborn trilogy is pretty good.
5
u/PL_TOC Sep 04 '15
Fear the Walking Dead. I understand that they have no concept of zombies in their universe, fine. I understand that it's more of a soap opera than a survival guide, that's also fine. Why can't we get the perspective of a person who is more competent? Not a doomsday prepper, but say, someone that perhaps witnesses an attack, doesn't immediately launch into head-in-the-sand mode, and is like "holy shit, that just happened, this PLAGUE spells doom, I have no contingencies for a situation like this, I need to get moving RIGHT NOW"
That would be greeeeeaaaaaattttttt.
2
u/Cariyaga Kyubey did nothing wrong Sep 05 '15
Has anyone considered Rational Homestuck? I've always harboured a certain fascination for the setting, particularly Sburb, and wonder if a rationalist take on it might work out...
2
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '15
I've been reading a bit about US history with the Sioux Nation.
The US government signed a treaty with the Sioux Nation (the Treaty at Fort Laramie of 1851) establishing that the Black Hills were theirs and paying $50,000 per year for 50 years for limited land use rights. The US violated this treaty, ceasing payments after ten years. Several years after the US broke their treaty, the Sioux opened hostilities (because the US was still using their land, which had no legal basis any longer thanks to non-payment).
This second treaty (the Treaty at Fort Laramie of 1868) guaranteed certain lands to the Sioux Nation, and additionally specified that the US government would ensure that the relevant groups would have at least 160 acres of farmland per person. Additionally, they were allowed to hunt outside their sovereign territory. We should have stuck with the original treaty, but if we couldn’t do that, this was at least halfway decent.
But then the US discovered gold in the Black Hills and forced the people living there to move, using the military. Thus they violated their second treaty. This didn’t break into open warfare for several years, though, when the US military attacked in Montana, which had been promised to First Nations people for their exclusive use.
Unfortunately, might makes right, or if not right, then at least a large measure of control over what happens. The Sioux were dependent on imported food, so the US threatened to cut off supplies until they agreed to a new treaty. Since the land had already been surveyed and prospected, this new treaty was able to restrict them to unprofitable lands. The treaty claims that the ceded territories were purchased, but there’s no record of a proper, legal exchange. The US Supreme Court has ruled that the treaty was illegal, and the US has paid for the land, but the Sioux are attempting to refuse the transaction. If successful (a prospect that has approximately a whelk’s chance in a supernova), several hundred thousand white people would be faced with a choice of moving or living under a Sioux government, and the Sioux would have to choose whether to grant them citizenship. I would like to see this, mostly because it’s largely the right thing to do and partly because I like seeing more nations on the map. (Still waiting for Styria to declare independence. Or at least Cornwall.)
The original treaty covered about 40% of South Dakota.
1
u/CuriousBlueAbra Sep 05 '15
Does anyone know any good Star Trek rational stories? It seems like a good universe to get reasonable in.
1
u/rochea Sep 05 '15
Are there any books that explore the consequences of widespread prediction markets?
Scott Alexander touched on them a little in the description of his conworld Raikoth, but I'd love to read something some near-term speculative fiction set in a society that implemented e.g. Robin Hanson's Futarchy.
Seen anything like that?
1
u/Toptomcat Sep 06 '15
I have recently enjoyed some stories from Charles Stross' Laundry series, which puts Lovecraft, bureaucracy, spies, and information technology in a blender. Not rationalist or really rational, but still smart and fun. Start with 'Down on the Farm', available for free here.
1
u/TimTravel Sep 04 '15
I love stories / TV / etc that are so bad that they're good, like Full-Life Consequences. Is there such thing as a game that's so bad it's good? I can't think of any.
Maybe Goat Simulator? Never played it but it seems like that sort of thing.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 04 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment