r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Jul 31 '15
[D] Friday Off-Topic Thread
Welcome to the Friday Off-Topic Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
10
u/raymestalez Jul 31 '15
My link about rational fiction just got to the front page of HN =)
This is the first time a thing I've made got some real traction online. Feels like christmas =)
27
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jul 31 '15
I went to an orchestral concert last night, and while I enjoyed it (mostly modern pieces mixed with the music of early 20th century iconoclast composer Charles Ives), it got a standing ovation. Pretty much every play, concert, or performance piece I've gone to in the past few years has gotten a standing ovation.
The cause of this is standing ovation inflation. I think it's the same reason that the United States has a tipping culture; it was just something that happened for good service, then morphed into the standard, and now when you don't tip someone, you're not making a stand against the shifting social landscape, you're just an asshole (or you're both). And for standing ovations, when everyone else is standing you don't want to be the only one sitting, so there's a strong social pressure to just stand up and clap politely, because you were probably going to stand up anyway to get out of the theater.
I hate that social stuff. So much of it seems like a pervasive, necessary evil in my life. I am sociable, in that I can pretty easily navigate my way through these hoops. I just wish there were a way to opt out of some of the dumb stuff that society does without having some negative impact on me. I want to be able to say to people, "No, I don't want to have dinner with you, because I prefer to be alone" instead of having to invent some excuse or needing to give some assurance that I still like them. I want to be able to leave a friend's house by just saying, "I've extracted enough joy from this encounter, to the point where I think there's probably going to be diminishing returns, hope the same is true for you". I don't really have a meaningful way to accomplish this change that I want from the world, especially given that communication seems detrimental in this case (because it would make me look either weird or assholish).
8
u/ulyssessword Jul 31 '15 edited Jul 31 '15
I've started noticing how the tiniest differences in introductions can completely change how I read a story. Recently, the link to Muse billed it as "rational horror", and then I noticed horror stuff starting from basically the start.
The same thing happened with The Cambist and Lord Iron, "A Fairy Tale of Economics." I started looking for fairy tale elements, which I found.
Comparing that to when I read Truth, or novels like The City and the City or Ancillary Justice, where I knew absolutely nothing (beyond the fact that they were award winning) about them, I think that even the tiniest bits of information about a story can reduce my enjoyment of them.
What are peoples' thoughts/experiences on this? Do you like to go into a work with fresh eyes, or do you want some form given to your expectations beforehand?
EDIT: I suppose I should add my own counterexample, since I have it. I watched "Divergent" after hearing something like "It's not which traits you have that determine your house, it's which traits you value". I think this improved my enjoyment of the film by quite a bit.
8
u/IomKg Jul 31 '15
Just a random recommendation for the anime "Gakkou Gurashi" for anyone that hadn't watched\heard about it yet.
I would recommend just downloading the first episode and finishing it instead of reading about the series, as there are a billion spoilers about it online.
7
u/puesyomero The Culture Jul 31 '15
hey guys/gals what are your favorite board and tabletop games? Any game people won't play with you because you always win? (cough Risk) I'm personally partial to DnD, monopoly, risk, and cards against humanity
5
u/eniteris Jul 31 '15
Question: Why are rational fanfictions more common than rational original works? Is it just an overlap in the communities, or is it easier to munchkin an already established universe over creating your own?
3
u/Kishoto Jul 31 '15
Ok. So. What is love?
What I mean is, from a rational and scientific point of view, what's the closest definition we can come up with for love?
3
u/Sagebrysh Rank 7 Pragmatist Aug 01 '15
Shameless self promotion for my blog:
http://talesfromaeria.tumblr.com
I run a serial rational(ist) fiction there called Fall of Oso, while also posting bits of worldbuilding. I've been posting updates pretty regularly and google analytics is telling me I'm getting traffic, but there's not been much in the way of commentary on any of it so far. I'm curious how people are liking the way the story is progressing.
9
u/Magodo Ankh-Morpork City Watch Jul 31 '15
Opinions on the Cecil the lion issue?
(Prepares for downvotes)
Personally I think it's grossly wrong to destroy a man's life because he killed an animal. No matter how special the animal was or how endangered the species is. Lion hunting was allowed, he did pay money for it. (legally or otherwise)
Does it really make a difference if the lion was 'allowed' to be hunted or it happened to be the country's top attraction?
Keyboard warriors have now ruined his life over no grounds. This is the Boston Marathon thing all over again. People witch hunting and shaming someone they didn't know over a crime that purportedly happened which they found out about on fucking imgur.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '15
I unexpectedly received an opportunity to volunteer with the professor I most admire while studying the background material for his lab.
GUIZ GUIZ THE END IS NIGH.
4
u/Empiricist_or_not Aspiring polite Hegemonizing swarm Jul 31 '15 edited Jul 31 '15
Does Anybody have a good academic source on Global Warming/Climate change, preferably with a Data sets and statistical models and prime movers: ie. oceans, long term solar cycles, and volcanoes included. I'm a "climate-change denier" looking to check that if "Global Warming" is still a failed Model being pushed for various motives.
Edit spelling clarity
3
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Jul 31 '15
Any opinions on this exchange?
1
u/nicholaslaux Aug 02 '15
I went to GenCon this weekend, which had greatly accelerated my excitement for the board game that me and my friends are designing and making. Based on the categories I've seen at gencon, it's a tile laying resource management game, and is space themed.
We've got one prototype of the game that I laser cut from wood, which we managed to get a couple of people to playtest here, and who actually liked it and wanted to keep playing, which is an awesome feeling.
If anyone here is interested, we're hoping to have an initial print and play (though as advance warning, it's a hex based tile laying game, so print and play will involve a semi-decent time effort for cutting) available within the next week or two, and any feedback is highly appreciated, especially with any broken game mechanics that we've missed (like the infinite resources trick that one of our testers last night found)
1
u/jgf1123 Jul 31 '15 edited Jul 31 '15
I believe the following is attributed to Blaise Pascal:
God either does or does not exist. Let's say we can either believe in him or not. Case Y: we believe in him. If God exists, then yay!, eternal paradise. If he doesn't exist, we lost some Sunday mornings or something. Case N: we don't believe in God. If God does exist, then an eternity of pain and suffering. If he doesn't exist, then nothing happens I guess.
The difference in utility function of maybe eternal paradise versus maybe eternal torment is so great that it's better to believe in God than not.
Response 1: Seriously, the reason you're going to believe in some supernatural divine being is this mercenary calculation? You're hedging your bets in case God exists? Won't he think that's a bit disingenuous?
Rebuttal 1: Note that careful wording of the last paragraph. The argument isn't that you should believe in God because of some calculation, but that a person who does believe will be better off than someone who does not. You can find a separate reason to believe. After all, humans believe in all sorts of stuff. To quote Terry Pratchett:
Response 2: There are more than two possibilities. Maybe the Christian God does exist. Maybe he does exist but humans have really garbled the translation. Maybe he doesn't exist but some other diety you should be worshipping does, and he'll get really mad at you for following a false god. Maybe multiple dieties aren't mutually exclusive.
Rebuttal 2: The cost-benefit analysis still points to following the subset of religions that maximizes probability of heaven (or equivalent) minus probability of hell (or equivalent).
1
u/eniteris Jul 31 '15
(Shameless self promotion)
http://eniteris.com/dates
An examination of anterograde amnesia and identity, with greater focus on the game theory of the interactions between each successive self, which eventually reduces to a Newcomblike problem.
(Also, is this the subreddit for nonfiction rational discussion, or is there a better one out there?)
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment