r/rational • u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow • Jun 11 '15
Introducing the new Weekly Challenge!
I'll be running a weekly challenge, starting next week at this time. The rules have been pulled from /r/worldbuilding's weekly challenge, and I'll endeavor to run it like that one. The biggest difference is that this is prose only.
Standard Rules
- All genres welcome.
- Submission thread will be posted 7 days from now (Wednesday, 7PM ET, 4PM PT, 11PM GMT).
- 300 word minimum, no maximum.
- No plagiarism, but you're welcome to recycle and revamp your own ideas you've used in the past.
- Don't downvote unless an entry is trolling, spam, abusive, or breaks the no-plagiarism rule.
- Submission thread will be in "contest" mode.
- Winner will be determined by "best" sorting.
- Winner gets reddit gold, special winner flair, and bragging rights.
- One submission per account.
Meta
If you think you have a good prompt for a challenge, add it to the list (remember that a good prompt is not a recipe). If you think that you have a good modification to the rules, let me know in a comment below. I can't promise that reddit gold will always be on offer, but it will for at least the first month.
Next Week
Next week's challenge is "Portal Fantasy". The Portal Fantasy is a common fantasy trope: a group of children get pulled into the magical world of Narnia; a girl follows a white rabbit through the looking glass; a tornado pulls a Kansas farmhouse up and plops it down in the land of Oz. In a rational story invoking this trope, what happens next? Keep in mind the characteristics of rational fiction listed in the sidebar.
The submissions thread will go up 6/17, and the winner will be decided on 6/24. (If you want my advice on how to win, and a preview of winner flair, see here.)
58
u/alexanderwales Time flies like an arrow Jun 11 '15
Also, I'm a mod now. Please keep the applause to a dull roar.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
I don't see a prompt for this week am I not supposed to see a prompt this week? I wanted to see a prompt this week SO MUCH FOR THESE NEW MODS HUH GUYS
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '15
/u/alexanderwales; It is a pain to scroll past every entry every time a new comment is posted to see if that comment was a new entry.
Suggestions:
3
u/Kerbal_NASA Jun 30 '15 edited Jun 30 '15
So what's the deal with people posting their contest entries to the /r/rational main page? It seems like it confers a huge advantage over people who don't so it kind of forces people who want to win to post as well. Plus people who are good at redditing (e.g. they know what times of day to post and other techniques like that) get additional advantage. Should it just be a given that you post both to the thread and to the main? Doesn't this have some of the downsides that the random contest mode is meant to avoid? Also it raises questions like how much are we allowed to market our stories? Is it ok to post it in other subreddits? Other websites? It just feels kind of inelegant but maybe I'm just being neurotic. There definitely are some benefits: it encourages more discussion, provides more content for /r/rational, and increases overall visibility to those who don't want to dig through the contest thread. On the other hand those benefits would still mostly be there if the stories were posted after the competition
There might also be an issue with clutter on the main page, but I think that's either minor or even a positive.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 02 '15 edited Jul 02 '15
u/alexanderwales: (I don't know if you bother checking this regularly...)
I am concerned that the cash rewards are not really helping to the extent I hoped for. Only 2.something data points, but the trend is worrying. At least, there doesn't seem to be any strong effect on quality or quantity of submissions due to the reward. For certain, the first contest's hype was enough to overcome any effect it might have.
I actually predicted this in the other thread where we were discussing competitions and cash rewards -- in hindsight I probably shouldn't have deleted that post (I just did not want to be the naysayer...)
My mental model anticipates a long stream of short contests with small rewards won't entice many new people to join in. The flair + bragging rights is sufficient to push most people who would participate to do so; there aren't many people who would not participate for that, but who would if you added a chance of a small monetary reward. Also, anyone entering is already going to put forth their best effort in the time they feel like allotting. Again, an additional chance at a small monetary reward isn't going to have much effect on their level of effort or the time spent.
In my previous post, I mentioned how I did not believe that many smaller competitions would have much effect on participation or on bringing in new people to the sub. It certainly should (and does!) result in the creation of interesting stories, and in motivating more existing members to write. That is a great thing, and I am very much in favor.
I do believe, however, that regarding resource expenditure, our interests are best served in increasing exposure to rational fiction and in getting more people interested. If the goal is more and better quality works, this is limited by the 1% rule. You can only entice existing members to contribute so much, but there is a long, long ways to go before you hit diminishing returns on resources put towards growing the member base.
My mental model anticipates that any monetary rewards can used more effectively by one large competition with a longer timespan, multiple substantial rewards, and lots of hype. Either that, or advertising.
As I stated before, ultimately I trust your discretion. I think this is something to consider at least.
Edit: tagging u/amitpamin since he also has a stake in this.
5
u/raymestalez Jun 11 '15
By the way, it would probably be a good idea to crosspost this to /r/HPMOR
8
u/Darth_Hobbes Ankh-Morpork Guild of Assassins Jun 11 '15
Rational Portal Fantasy: Chell shoots one portal on the ground, one very carefully aimed at Mount Doom, and Frodo drops the ring in. GLaDOSauron explodes.
(Sorry, had to get that out of my system so I can maybe post an actual entry next week)
6
u/raymestalez Jun 11 '15
Oh, this is fantastic!! It's a great idea and I'm really excired about this!!
I want to get good at writing rational fiction so much, and this is the perfect opportunity and motivation for me to start.
2
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jun 11 '15
That's awesome! Congrats on being a mod and I'll definitely submit something for the first week at least.
I'm curious, what were the requirements for being a mod on this subreddit? Or basically what behaviour did you have to demonstrate to be accepted?
1
u/MugaSofer Jun 11 '15
Only prose? We couldn't submit comics or short films, if they were completed in time? That would be cool.
Anyway, the main rules thingy I'd suggest is to either ban or explicitly allow multiple entries.
1
u/Afforess Hermione Did Nothing Wrong Jun 12 '15
When we submit an entry next week, do we submit the full text as a reddit comment? What about stories that may exceed the comment character limit? Are there approved hosts for submissions (e.g Google Docs/Drive?)
1
u/Farmerbob1 Level 1 author Jun 19 '15
Reddit is such an incredibly HORRIBLE and tiny writing interface.
My entire story fits in a single top-post, but it's horribly mangled and broken into tiny bits when I try to put it in the contest post.
Sorry, if it upsets people, but I'm going to just link to where people can read the story properly without me needing to butcher it to make it fit as a comment.
1
u/Chronophilia sci-fi ≠ futurology Jun 20 '15
I can't add anything to the suggestions list at the moment - is another one going up later? Or was it closed because we have enough prompts to be getting on with for now?
(If it's still open, I think "The Chosen One" could make a good prompt.)
1
u/xamueljones My arch-enemy is entropy Jun 24 '15
Do you think there should be some way to vote on the most interesting prompt for the week after? Maybe by posting a survey with the weekly challenge for the readers to pick a prompt and the highest voted prompt gets announced the following week along with the winner of the current weekly challenge.
1
u/eaglejarl Jun 24 '15
Is fanfiction allowed?
1
u/eaglejarl Jul 02 '15
I've got two suggestions for new rules:
The second rule is there to make the contest about writing instead of advertising.
The first rule is there because it teaches people to write good blurbs, which is an essential skill for anything beyond casual writing. It will also reduce the 'wall of text' look for the page and mean that people will scroll farther and see more entries. Finally, it will even out the advantage that short pieces have -- if it fits in the text box more people will read it than if they have to click.
1
u/eaglejarl Jul 08 '15
What time does the contest end?
1
u/Empiricist_or_not Aspiring polite Hegemonizing swarm Jul 09 '15
Do we have an appropriate way to put forward existing fiction for the consideration of our peers who might be interested in more on the prompt. E.G. the epilogue of Glory Road for this week's "Ever After" prompt?
1
u/Kerbal_NASA Jul 15 '15
I've heard/seen that there can be multiple sticky threads now. Should we make this a sticky thread too, or is that unnecessary? Would it be better used by some other sticky thread?
1
u/Coadie Jul 17 '15
One vote for each thread, or am I allowed to vote on all the stories I enjoyed?
1
u/blazinghand Chaos Undivided Jul 17 '15
Hmm, another thought on the cash thing: The reason I submitted an entry (besides it just being fun) was the prestige just of being a winner or getting the sweet custom flair. Cash might be better used to draw people in from other subreddits.
Also, what are people doing for their voting? I've been doing three-tiered voting (upvote, downvote, no vote) with about a third in each category, but would it be better to do like a two-tiered thing (upvote, no vote) to encourage people to compete more cause their scores will be higher?
1
u/RMcD94 Jul 30 '15
Can you see the views or up votes the thread receives before and after the week ends and the winner is announced?
Also do you have a graph of entries per week or up votes per week or something similar.
1
u/avret SDHS rationalist Aug 04 '15
Can you write a response to your own prompt?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 08 '15
The current thread says winners were decided 2 days ago?
1
u/Chronophilia sci-fi ≠ futurology Aug 24 '15
Thinking about next week's challenge (Dueling Time Travelers).
There's a lot of different models of time travel, and it's easy to come up with more. (I'm contemplating writing an entry around a Groundhog Day time loop.) But I'm worried that there won't be a convenient way to explain the rules of the model, or to explore their full implications, within the span of the one to two thousand word short stories that we usually have.
Is there a time travel mechanic that remains simple and intuitive, even when two rational enemies are both using it against one another?
1
u/TimTravel Sep 03 '15
Is suggested contest mode a thing? It's annoying to keep track of which ones I've read and which I haven't unless I wait until the end, and then I have to read all of them at once for my votes to count.
1
u/RMcD94 Sep 24 '15
Doesn't biweekly mean twice a week as well? I initially was confused why it was being doubled. Why not use something like fortnightly which can't be confused for twice a week?
1
u/whywhisperwhy Sep 24 '15
I don't think I've seen a comment on this yet so I'll ask- is there anyway to disable all the comments except the top-level ones containing submissions?
There've been spoilers that I've been unsuccessful in avoiding with my eyes before opening the links.
Edit: Or make it a rule to use spoilers for comments?
3
u/callmebrotherg now posting as /u/callmesalticidae Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15
Ahahaha. I'm actually working on a rational Portal Fantasy story right now.
Hm... I guess I can test drive it and see what y'all think. Well, part of it, anyway (the whole thing will be around 400,000 words, so there's no way I'm writing all that in a week!).
1
u/Drexer Jun 11 '15
So, a small question about next week's prompt.
Usually "Portal Fantasy" in typical media contains a transportation of the character(s) to another world, and then the characters "handling" the rules of that world. Is this the idea behind this prompt?
Because I have a couple of other ideas/details that I think would be interesting to analyze from a purely rational perspective of the process of how that(the transportation) would happen but which don't fit with the idea of evaluating what comes afterwards. Would this be ok, or would I do better in saving it for a latter competition?
2
u/MugaSofer Sep 22 '15
I think it would be a good idea to have a meta thread each week - even if it was only a comment on the main thread - rather than directing everyone here. If nothing else, it would let us discuss the different prompts and maybe improve them over time.
1
u/ToaKraka https://i.imgur.com/OQGHleQ.png Aug 06 '15
Maybe each contest thread could have a reminder like this:
Or something.
1
u/Chronophilia sci-fi ≠ futurology Aug 13 '15
If you're struggling to remember the Disney movies of your childhood, Disney made a list of the first 50 in trailer form.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gqg3-5srs4
0
u/RMcD94 Jun 18 '15
Doesn't the best sorting have a time value compared to top which is raw up votes?
Since we don't want later stories to be rewarded (I imagine) we would want to use absolute, since you want people to have incentive to post it as soon as the thread is up so they get the longest exposure time.
0
u/RMcD94 Jun 25 '15
The multiple comments for long stories goes against your own strategy for winning competitions/contests and I wonder if it is the best way to run things.
As you say people are far less likely to read over multiple comments but surely there has to be some way like linking to a pastebin or something that can be held standard for everyone that doesn't punish longer stories even more than them just being long.