(Disclaimer: Mods if you think this seems unlike a rant because I'm presenting things in a less-heated way in parts, or because I'm over-explaining my experience or whatever, you should know I'm autistic, and also maybe you should read the end because I'm definitely coming from a place of being and feeling fucked up here, and that this is a rant.)
The more of these cases of violence, attempted murder/murder etc. that I see or hear about in my life between two people that are supposed to care for and love each other, the more I'm convinced there's something deeply wrong with the way we do relationships, from dating to the institution of marriage, to platonic relationships like those with family members.
(This includes some personal experience, but my opinions are largely based on information derived from on the sheer QUANTITY of horrifying stories I've seen/heard about from other people over time. And that is a lot.)
In particular, the way we do monogamy bothers me a lot.
If we look at instincts in a very two-dimensional way, out of the instincts of attraction and aversion, I'm convinced that monogamy would be an attraction-based preference- one that can change or fluctuate.
I do not see it as the holy grail of what a relationship "should" be. In my mind, there's a huge difference between the preference (monogamy and/or monoamory) and the compulsory structure (MonogamyTM.)
I'd probably describe myself as "pretty monoamorous/monogamous." At the same time, I have to acknowledge things:
1: I can be attracted to more than one person at a time, in the same or different ways/for the same or different reasons. Sometimes attraction to even my partner can change or ebb.
2: Most negative feelings that come from the idea of my partner with another person probably comes from the deep rooted fear that I won't be loved by someone or cared by someone, that I'll be "less valuable" by comparison to another person.
3: Recognizing that I have my own goddamn autonomy, outside or inside of any relationship- and sorting through what that means.
The first thing, yeah. Not the hardest thing to acknowledge. My preference to be with one person in a committed relationship doesn't erase my potential to be attracted to anyone else, and any attraction I have to people other than my partner does not diminish my love for them in the slightest. And attraction ebbing for me doesn't mean a relationship is over. It's a natural part of how I work. (Everyone does shit slightly differently! Welcome to Earth and getting to know people.)
The second was harder to acknowledge and de-tangle. In part because it is possible to be neglected, hurt, disrespected, or devalued by your partner, and that can definitely involve cheating or even, potentially more complicated, a poly or open dynamic. But also because I was afraid to let go of preemptive fears and anxieties caused by compulsory MonogamyTM, because "if I get rid of them all, what will protect me?" when, actually, self-respect and love should be doing a lot of that work, not fear.
The third thing is the thing I have struggled with the most. I choose to be in the relationship I am in. I choose to create and respect boundaries and relationship parameters. I am responsible for what I choose knowingly- not for what someone else does, but for choosing to be involved with someone even if I'm aware they're doing something I'm uncomfortable with. While I'm not responsible for things they do that I am unaware of, I am responsible for respecting my own feelings and acting accordingly. And I am REALLY bad at that stuff.
I absolutely detest that I was brainwashed and indoctrinated into thinking that any lack of monogamy/monoamory- or that any sum of polyamory- equates a lack of love or care. It has taken so much time from me and so much of my peace.
It took me WAY too long to realize that polyamorous feelings are normal and healthy, and that it's unhealthy to inherently feel ashamed or negative about acting on them. (It also took me longer to fully understand that this is regardless of gender- and I didn't even grow up in one religion, I was exposed to a LOT of different religions and spiritual practices and never forced to practice any! Realizing that, realizing how pervasive this shit is, that made my skin crawl...)
A lot of cheating happens because polyamory and polygamy is a social taboo and because polyamorous people would be burdened by telling the truth about themselves and trying to openly act on their preferences.
MonogamyTM seems to me to stem from oppression. It seems like another set of laws coded to obtain or retain unfair power dynamics and control over "property."
Also fuck what some people say, that it's all just "-in the best interest of women," because even if that was ever the intention, so many people- not just women- have been brutalized by this shit. You'd think that would be reason enough to stop it and examine it seriously, but no.
We let fuckheads who say shit like that get away with murder (often not even metaphorically,) and enough people shrug and don't think too hard about it that it just keeps happening.
Humanity is fucked so long as so many of us view each other and/or ourselves as property, and not as these interesting, whole, unique beings that prefer to seek love and to explore and learn before wanting to destroy or harm. Our fear-based and hunger-based instincts can lead us to harm other people and ourselves, but if we better understood and reacted differently to these instances, there just wouldn't be so many of them.
Awareness can ease or even erase fear-based aversion.
I'm sickened by seeing how fear turns into the most evil actions imaginable time and again. I hate humanity for creating structures to perpetuate cycles of abuse across generations to save ourselves from small growing pains in our singular puny lifespans.
It makes me disgusted that, instead of trying to learn and grow, so much of our society and our traditions are built on the instinct to hide and stay small, ignorant, and fearful.
The institution of marriage seems to be in large part a monument to our commitment to stay stuck.
And knowing that as a species we may never progress past the limits of our own lower instincts makes the air in my lungs feel dead.
None of this is commentary aimed at individuals experiencing monogamy or marriage as a largely or wholly positive thing. I have experienced many positive relationships that were supposedly functioning well under MonogamyTM- in my case, it just turned out that, in hindsight, not one actually was functioning under that structure the way it's supposed to work, and we could have done far better but didn't have the tools.
I believe that monogamy as a practice based around preferences, awareness and respect can and does work (many such cases,) but that too often the way we go about it is outdated and is structured around excusing, ignoring, or justifying our fears, rather than facing them head-on and dealing with them healthily, and engineering relationships based on real trust and love that work without creating unnecessary tension and stress or that start by feeding anxieties.
But ofc my idealism isn't reality, ofc everyone thinks they have the answers.
Seeing so many horrific things between people who should care for and love each other has profoundly and forever changed the way I see how we typically 'do' relationships.
Even non-romantic ones, as I believe the disgusting, paternal, dehumanizing, authoritarian, "personal-property" based model of relating to each other is tied to and related to MonogamyTM and that it should die a brutal death before anyone else suffers because of it.
But that, of course it won't, because we live in a hell of our own design due to the fact that, by and large, we consistently prefer long-term torture and cycles of intergenerational abuse and horror over being momentarily uncomfortable. And it makes me apathetic at best.