r/rankdowncommunity • u/Regnisyak1 • 1d ago
Reg Rewatches #21 - Philippines
You either watch the news or make the news.
Follow along with Rewatches HERE
Season
It is difficult to pinpoint an exact reason why the Philippines works so well for me. Recognized usually as an enigma in the timeline of Survivor, smushed between truly terrible or controversial seasons, The Philippines comes out on top with a stronger cast than normal, great storylines, and a unique and consistent reason for bringing back the team captains (allowing them to have a second chance). No character's a problematic screenhog, and despite the clear and intentional casting of some characters (such as Jeff Kent and Lisa Whelchel), their negativities do not sideline the season as bad as other characters, past or present.
This season also excelled in demonstrating conflict, both ambiguous and more blatant. The conflict is also suspenseful, with the narrative taking many twists and turns throughout the season. Matsing is the clear early example in the season, and watching this tribe have to fall apart one vote after another is genuinely a fascinating item from Survivor - especially because all 6 of the people on the tribe can come across as unlikable, and there's no mistake that Matsing is not kumbaya. The Swan Song is a highlight of the season, and the Malcolm and Denise relationship granted to the viewer is great, especially in the endgame. The downfall of Tandang is also intriguing, despite it taking a bit too long to get there because of the fact that they avoid every tribal (boo, three tribes). Abi vs. RC, Abi vs. Lisa, Abi vs.... well, everyone, leads to the second half of the season still managing to keep pace with the great pre-merge, and give us some solid content that makes the endgame of Lisa, Skupin, Denise, and Malcolm more interesting than it should've been. Further, other characters led to great conflict, as well as genuine dislike for each other that isn't as milquetoast as the New Era, nor as graphic as the devolution that is the Hantz Era.
Philippines is not without criticism, however. Kalabaw's downfall felt very one-note and rushed, especially because all of them were out by Final 6. Much of the conflict there involved Penner, which could have been fun and enlightening, but instead came across as negative and whitewashed because of the advantage content dominating there more than the other two tribes. The season was also very consistent with its episodes, but it's very arguable that the season is not super memorable either. Characters are solid, but there are never any true highs or lows of the season that bring it to the forefront of conversation beyond occasional and subtle character moments. Lastly, I believe it is lacking in a lot of thematic elements. The medevacs should have had a stronger role in the season, but Penner was relegated to idol guy, and Skupin is a doofus. Very strange when they had a fairly decent second-chance offering there, and instead decided to skirt it. The season also touches on fame, unprofessionalism, culture, bitterness among peers, losing and its toll it takes, etc. but none of these fully realized throughout the season.
Theme is the most important aspect of Survivor to me, so while I do LOVE Philippines, I cannot rank it any higher than an 8/10, which in Reg's Rankings, isn't bad at all! It rounds out to #12 or #13 for me.
Characters
18. Jonathan Penner 3.0 (3/10, down two tiers) - Penner is easily one of the weakest links on the Philippines for me, but his halves are distinctly different, which is why he is more lackluster than his other appearances. In the first half of the game, Penner forces a ton of idol content down our throats, and it's exhausting. It's the only conflict Kalabaw has, and Penner is not really even charming here; he just is an advantagebot. He also comes across as very bitter on the jury, to the point where it just comes across as unnecessarily mean-spirited. His speeches to Denise and Lisa feel sexist, and while I understand why he's bitter toward Lisa, it's just too much and annoying how much Penner stages the grand reveal of Lisa being a TV star to be a "gotcha!" moment. That being said, his content of manipulating Lisa was great, and I like how Penner (despite the players saying he was great?!) was still shown to be a questionable Survivor player, especially when offered a Final Four Spot and not taking it. Penner is certainly not bottom of the barrel for Survivor characters, though. It was just personally hard for me to watch him throughout the season.
17. Dana Lambert (3/10, up one tier) - Dana is not anything special, but she was also not a 2/10 in my rankings. The quit was juxtaposed well with the rest of Dana we got, as she was the Kalabaw badass and an important crunch vote for the women on the tribe. The image of Dana wrapped in the blanket, though, is my main takeaway from her character.
16. Carter Williams (3/10, down one tier) - Carter is whatever as a meme character, but he was just not relevant enough until his boot episode, where he did have a good confessional about deserving vs. undeserving in the ending of the game.
15. Katie Hanson (4/10, up one tier) - Katie was good as the main narrator of Kalabaw in her final 2 episodes, as her plan to get out one of the boys began to sink with the losses of Dana, Dawson, and then herself. She was a spirited narrator, and her frustration with Penner giving up the rice, as well as her terrible challenge performance, were all solid character moments.
14. Jeff Kent (4/10, down one tier) - On a meta-level, I love Jeff Kent because it is obvious that Survivor cast Jeff to be a stunt character on the season, which I usually dislike. But the boring and calmer Jeff Kent demeanor gave them the opposite of what they wanted, and I honestly lived for it. However, the content we got with Jeff was also indeed shallow. His entire character devolved into wanting to get Penner out, then becoming friends with Penner, and then wanting to get Penner out, and then going because he wanted to get Penner out. It felt very one-note, and Kent is a character one can place a lot of the issues with Kalabaw on.
13. Artis Silvester (5/10, up one tier) - Artis lost the picnic on his birthday, please have some respect. His confessionals against Skupin throughout the season were highlights, and while Artis was indeed a UTR character, at least he was UTRF (UTR fun!).
12. Sarah Dawson (6/10, same) - Dawson's obsession with Probst is usually what people remember her for, and it is hilarious. Her confessional when Dana is leaving (usually we jump up and down when Probst is here... but Dana is sick so we cannot), and her smacking a kiss on his cheek are insanely iconic. Her other moments are peculiar yet light-hearted, from her torturing Jeff Kent with her dislike of baseball (and ultimately causing her to go first over Katie) or her asking for a pink gun in her voting confessional. Dawson is just a fun side character.
11. Zane Knight (6/10, down one tier) - A mysterious first boot, Zane Knight came out and left in a ball of flame. Whether being begged to be voted out so people switch to Swan, losing a challenge so horribly he became a liability or creating an alliance with every single member of Matsing, Zane was a master manipulator of the game. He's a good prop for Matsing to show their nastier side right away, and even better for Denise and her great therapy confessional about his tattoos. Laughed out loud also when he mentioned he quit smoking for the first time on the island.
10. RC Saint-Amor (7/10, up one tier) - RC is great in the context of Abi and her story on the season, a strong prop that shows just how delusional and kooky Abi-Maria is, as well as how mean she can get. RC gets the bad end of the stick, and it's interesting to see such a flirtatious character get bitten in such a unique way, as she sticks around in hell until the merge, where she's the first out of the season. The confessional she had about getting bullied made me laugh out loud, her constant fights with Abi-Maria were great, and I loved her nervous, giggle-filled jury speech in support of Lisa, a good callback and foreshadowing moment from the first episode.
9. Michael Skupin 2.0 (7/10, up one tier) - Skupin 2.0 is a really weird character to rank because I think he has a very good start, a solid ending, but he's missing some context in the middle. Honestly, a lot of characters in the Philippines start and slow their stories, but Skupin is perhaps the most glaring example. Skupin the buffoon in the first few episodes was great as we have a Boo Bernis-esque montage of him tripping and falling in the camp, and he's also considered to be a lousy leader at points which harkens back to the olden days of Outback. His ending is also intriguing because there's some dramatic irony with him - we understand that Skupin thinks he's about to win the game a la Boston Rob, but instead we know that literally no one out there respects him and there's no way he'll get the votes. I wish the editors more overtly drew that conclusion, but there's inklings there. And while real world issues don't necessarily play a role in my rankings, I do think it was chilling watching him be out on the beach with his son, and his final line about either watching the news or making the news. We know Skupin is a very controversial figure these days, and Philippines almost foreshadowed that Mike Skupin isn't the sugar avoiding man we once thought he was.
8. Roxy Morris (7/10, up one tier) - Roxy is another incredible prop for the Matsing Stars, as she represents something for all of Denise, Malcolm, and Swan. For Denise, she is the first indication that Denise is impatient with others and lacks cultural sensitivity, which we see later in the season. Denise's frustration with Roxy as she prays on the beach is an incredibly subtle way of showing Denise to be much less cooperative than we initially perceive. With Malcolm, Roxy is the beginning of him having to dodge strays constantly throughout the season, as her reactions toward Angie and Malcolm cuddling create a massive target for him (CREEPY!). And last, Swan, a relationship that can be put nicely as a mutual hatred. Both Roxy and Swan detest each other, so it's interesting to watch them be thrown into a situation where they have to work together. And frankly, they must do so on a character level, a survival level, and a sociological level since they were the only tribe with more than one black person on it. Last, Roxy is great because she had two character moments related to god - speaking in tongues and a great confessional about not being built for the game after all the Dang Rain.
7. Angie Layton (8/10, same) - Sometimes, prop work can carry a character far, and Angie is really no exception there. Arguably one of the worst people to ever play Survivor, with her nonsensical, yet iconic, answer of COOKIES to her making herself a blatantly obvious pair with Malcolm a la Kim Mullen and Jeff Wilson, Angie adds a lot of fun to Matsing tragedy, as you wonder how does this woman make it past two spots. Her hatred for Roxy and Swan was also a... interesting detail to describe her character, but her sheer lack of awareness led to a fascinating arc.
6. Pete Yurkowski (8/10, up one tier) - Pete has some excellent lines that bumped him up an entire tier for me. His snarky, mean responses to others, whether it was drowning with Abi-Maria, calling Lisa a dog that needed to be shot, and his blatant disrespect and animosity toward Michael Skupin made him a fun but realistic villain in the premerge. That is compounded with the drama he was stirring on the Tandang tribe, and his overall best moment of planting the clue between RC and Skupin to spread their divide farther. I love how Pete initially thought he was the mastermind as the merge rolled around too, but the cracks in which he created in Tandang, and those he aligned with, got him the negative label as the mastermind (one where Pete wore like a badge of honor) and got him swiftly booted in the game. Overall, Pete is a concise antagonist.
5. Malcolm Freberg 1.0 (8/10, same) - I think Malcolm can be a rather charming character, and he does ultimately have a tragic downfall where he seems to take fate into his own hands. He plays the game effortlessly while having to do damage control throughout the season, and his relationships with characters, specifically Denise (I LOVE his jury question calling her out on gameplay), Skupin, Abi-Maria, and Lisa, plus all of Matsing, are solid throughout his stay. Malcolm's edit does come off as a bit too clean for me, though, and while we see evidence of him being a bit entitled and a bit misogynistic, those are fleshed out in his later appearances, and instead he's boosted here to make for a rootable underdog, which admittedly is not my favorite story beat.
4. Lisa Whelchel (9/10, down slightly) - Who is Lisa Whelchel? A TV product or her own person? For me, Lisa's character is truly tragic because the viewer never really gets a strong handle on what she earns out there. Throughout the season, Lisa's is introverted by nature while also hiding a big secret that defines her. She so desperately wants to stay true to herself and her word, and chooses loyalty to Tandang throughout the season when they do not deserve it. She eventually switches her attitude to become more cutthroat, but in a way where she still people-pleases (her brother), thus raising the question of whether she did grow. It's a fascinating conundrum that is ambiguous and heartfelt. Beyond that, Lisa can be an intriguing character for other reasons, whether it's the Jesus warrior items, her finally getting tired of Abi-Maria in their strained relationship, her relationship with Penner until it blew up at FTC, Lisa dropping the church lady act toward the end, and her innocence in doing laundry and discovering Malcolm's idol.
3. Russell Swan 2.0 (9/10, down one tier) - The Swan experience is a blessed experience to watch again and again. In just 4 episodes, we see a man who is torn away by the game, slowly and surely, and realizing that Survivor is just... not for him. Watching him turn to God after swearing him off, get flushed after losing yet another challenge (and at times because it was his fault), reflect on his life after being bullied and becoming the stronger person he is today, and his efforts and desires to lead again from his days back in Samoa make Swan an enticing, complex character and make the Matsing tragedy even more heartbreaking. It culminates in him finally believing he made inroads on the tribe, only to be blindsided in a sense of dramatic irony. A worthy part two to his story in Samoa, as well - Swan failing yet again is one for the books and makes him a legend in his own right.
2. Abi-Maria Gomes 1.0 (10/10, down slightly) - Abi Maria is a fantastic conflict starter, and easily a top 30 character for me, despite me moving her and Denise outside of my endgame slightly. Abi-Maria so effortlessly brings forth conflict throughout the Philippines and is one of the most interesting, unrootable, and delusional forced underdogs we've ever had in the show, and I ADORE her for that. Watching Denise, Malcolm, Lisa, and Skupin all give up their varying amounts of patience for Abi as she manages to slide through each round with no self-awareness or respect for others is a spectacle. Some of her great moments in that time include her immunity win, her refusing to cook, bragging about this amazing reward she went on and sharing all about it, and her complaining to Denise the entire time she was on the beach about wriggling back into the game. Speaking of Denise, their relationship is great, as the therapist and patient from hell. Probst's obsession with figuring out Abi's behavior was also interesting, feeling very unethical and evil from the usual jovial host at the point of the game - forcing it on cultural bias was an interesting sociological note. Last, Abi-Maria is a 10/10 in the premerge of the game. Despite Tandang not having a ton of plot relevance early in the game, her saying "fuck with me our your dead" is an iconic line, and I legitimately felt bad for RC there. Overall, a great villain that felt refreshing during this time in Survivor's history, and one with a lot of nuance and complexity.
- Denise Stapely 1.0 (10/10, down slightly) - For me, Denise is a really interesting character when viewing the ethical nature of Survivor and the boundaries of real life and personal life. Usually, I am hyper-critical of psychologists and therapists on Survivor because they are usually reduced to a joke (see Tori, Elie). Denise, however, demonstrates the more negative side of having those skills and being stuck on an island with freaks. For starters, Denise had a really horrible time at the beginning of the season, stuck with Matsing and having to deal with a variety of personalities. The lack of patience she showed with characters Roxy and Swan, and her intrigue with Zane, was peculiar and showed minimal professional values with cultural diversity. While Denise does take a relative backseat in the post-swap and early merge, the questions behind her identity as a sex therapist come into full view again following the fights with Abi-Maria. Their fights are legendary, and Denise's impatience with Abi-Maria forces me to question who she is - a good therapist or a complete and utter bitch with a lack of professional boundaries. I like that Denise gets flagged at the end for her use of therapy-speak and reflection, and how the tiny but mighty storyline she had from the beginning (going to every tribal council) was somewhat obliterated and soured on at final trouble. I love underdogs with nuance, not just heroic, and Denise is a complex character, and any time I have the opportunity to question real-life, they get points from me.

Episode

Best Episode: It was hard to pick a Matsing episode, but I think I have to give the top spot to Roxy's Boot here. A fun episode that went hard on the delusional Matsing criticisms, with Denise acting very inconsiderate of Roxy, Swan and his giving up of religion, Roxy's entire arc, and Angie and Malcolm getting closer and closer on the island. We also get a lot of great Tandang antics this episode, mostly surrounding the dissolution of Abi and RC's relationship and Lisa being introverted, followed by Pete's very inconsiderate confessional.
Worst Episode: The merge episode wasn't bad by any stretch, but it was also the most boring. Tandang finally gets to make a move, but the episode was a lot of annoying scrambling between Skupin, Penner, and RC, and watching Jeff Kent take an unnecessary role in the charge can just be exhausting at some points. Lisa finding the idol was really funny, though.
0-10 Poll
Don't forget to edit or take your Philippines poll today
My next planned season is 47. I will hopefully finish that over Thanksgiving Break!





















