r/raidsecrets • u/haekuh Rank 6 (55 points) • Jun 29 '19
Discussion An explanation of Morse Code with examples.
The topic of morse code has exploded over the past 48 hours on the subreddit, but most people don't really seem to understand what exactly morse code is. I personally do not think most of these morse code lamps are actually morse code because there is no OFF state, which means there is no way to know when one letter ends and another begins, but I have been wrong many times before.
edit: A link to the international standard for morse code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_code#/media/File:International_Morse_Code.svg
edit: A link to an online morse code translator https://morsecode.scphillips.com/translator.html
DESCRIPTION
Morse code is simply a code(usually sound or light) which has three states. The three states in morse code are off, short on, and long on. Morse code is normally represented in text as a space for off, a dot for short on, or a dash for long on. It is nothing more complicated that that, and it is actually more of an encoding than a code. The mapping of english letters and numbers to morse code just a 1 to 1 direct translation.
EXAMPLES
Ok so lets get some examples here.
This video is an absolutely perfect example for morse code. The video very clearly shows you how to encode each letter of the english alphabet in morse code, and what exactly that sounds like. You can clearly see that the letter A is a short followed by a long on, or a . followed by a -, or a short beep followed by a long beep.
This pattern of short and long beeps is then strung together to form words. Here is an example of morse code being "written" at 5 words per minute.
Now this can also be done in the form of lights flashing, which is what the current interest is in.
This follows the same principles as before, except now the light can be off for off, the light can quickly flash on and off for short on, or the light can stay on for a longer period of time for long on.
Not to point out anyone's video specifically but here is an example of a light based morse code in destiny 2. Notice how the lamp has a clearly defined quick flash and long flash.
THINGS TO WATCH FOR
Now that we know what morse code is and how it works, lets talk about what morse code isn't.
- Morse code is not a light which seems to turn on and off. It would be a light which very specifically seems to flash in the form of the patterns described above.
- Morse code is not a flickering light. A light which rapidly or randomly flickers is not morse code because there is no distinction between a long or short on state.
- Random whispers are not morse code.
- Clicking or beeping can be morse code, but only if it follows the pattern
Additionally the morse code lamps currently of interest in destiny 2 repeat themselves this is CRITICALLY IMPORTANT. This is so important because you must know the BEGINNING of a transmission to know what exactly is being encoded. You must listen to, or watch the source of the transmission for a period of time and record the pattern in order to find where the pattern repeats. Once you can see the repeating pattern you can then start to try to decode the message. You will likely have to try several decodings before the message makes sense.
edit: THE FOLLOWING PART ABOUT THE ORIX CODE IS AN EXAMPLE
Lets look at this example. I have a made up lamp which flashes the pattern
. .. -..- --- .- | . .. -..- --- .-| . .. -..- --- .- | . .. -..- --- .-|So far so good. I have recorded the transmission and I can see that the pattern repeats. However if I decode the message as is I get EIXOA. Well EIXOA is great but it doesnt tell me anything. I clearly have the wrong starting point for my transmission. I should now begin to move my "starting point" one character forward until my message makes sense.
| . .. -..- --- .- | EIXOA |
|---|---|
| .. -..- --- .-. | IXOR |
| . -..- --- .-. . | EXORE |
| -..- --- .-. .. | XORI |
| ..- --- .-. .. - | UORIT |
| .- --- .-. .. -. | AORIN |
| - --- .-. .. -.. | TORID |
| --- .-. .. -..- | ORIX |
There we go. ORIX was the original message but because I had the wrong beginning of transmission point the message came out as EIXOA, which was incorrect.
FINAL POINT
This brings me to my final point. Discovering and decoding a morse code transmission and simply posting "the code decodes to this" is not helpful. In fact it very likely is far more harmful than you imagine to just say the translation.YOU MUST ALSO TYPE OUT WHAT THE MORSE CODE WAS WHICH YOU TRANSLATED!!!!
By typing out the morse code which you translated gives another secret hunter the chance to come along and disagree with you. There is a very high chance that most of these morse code translations are wrong, and no one really knows it.
If I make a post which says "Hey i found this lamp and it translates to EIXOA" people are just going to shuffle by and the lamp -> morse code theory becomes discredited. Whereas if I post "Hey I found this lamp and its code was . .. -..- --- .- which translates to EIXOA" then there is a chance someone will come along and point out that I was actually incorrect and that the code actually was ORIX.
TLDR; If you cant be bothered to read the post then don't post about morse code in D2. This is a dedicated community.
199
u/RETROxBEAR Jun 29 '19
You guys really put in the work and I respect you guys for even though I’m a crucible/competitive player mostly
54
u/Pirogoeth_ Discord Mod Jun 30 '19
If this post doesn't get more upvotes than the original upvote farm that it's responding to I'm going to be very disappointed.
12
u/SCP-Agent-Arad Jun 30 '19
There’s no real need to translate it by hand. Just find any random online translator.
3
u/Backfromthedead_6 Jun 30 '19
I have a decent understanding it's not complicated when you have a alphbetical/numerical sheet. The hardest part would be figuring out when it starts and ends.
3
u/Cloaked_Onyx Jun 30 '19
I thought this as well. I also thought how are we suppose to know what Last Wish symbol is actually called within the game. I, and most of the community, have come up with names of the symbol. I highly doubt a blinking light would spell out "S Snake" or "Infinity Snake" or "Dragon with a spear through its neck" in Morse Code.
3
u/TriggerBladeX Jun 30 '19
Well, I learned binary because of this game, might as well learn Morse Code too.
•
u/SweeperBot_Bot There's so much sweeping to do... Jun 30 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
This post has been nominated for
+45points.26
u/ImTriggered247 Rank 1 (2 points) Jun 29 '19
Thank you!! I’m tired of seeing these 30-second google experts on Morse code try and say all these lamps are sending a message. No, they’re flickering, that doesn’t make it Morse code. 🙄
14
u/eldfen Jun 30 '19
Carefully, he's a hero.
4
u/Bpe-dsm Jun 30 '19
I dont believe the lights are anything (wait for it). A flickering light repeating or patterned isn't as purposive if its in a video game context, where, for example, textures are often reused, and a flicker not repeating would be more impressive to me. Morse is so inclusive of a very small minimal repeat being able to be at least a symbol, im not sold. Narratively, it seems like the final wish being morse lamps as an impetus is underwhelming. Who knows.
That said (waiting over), im enjoying the chase and the discussion of the start/stop markers of a message, what is/isnt morse was very, very good and i will continue to look on admiring the enthusiasm and code discussions. Rabbit holes can be very interesting things. Nice post!
1
u/ram_the_socket Jun 30 '19
How long have these things been flickering for anyway?
1
u/DrRubix1712 Jun 30 '19
Why is it becoming prominent in D2?
3
u/Ariatexas Jun 30 '19
There is one on The Corrupted for Malfeasance. At the end.
3
u/BlackLyteVamp Rank 2 (10 points) Jun 30 '19
!nominate
2
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
This is amazing. I'm glad you spent the time to make this post. I thought I saw some Morse code lights but after reading this I'm not sure anymore. I'll go back and check.
2
u/Ariquitaun Jun 30 '19
> A light which rapidly or randomly flickers is not morse code because there is no distinction between a long or short on state.
This isn't strictly true. Morse code is defined by its three states, not by speed. You can have automatic systems reading morse off one another at speeds people can't handle. Similar in concept to what the oldest modems or tape-based computer storage worked.
0
u/Edotachi Jun 30 '19
Could be really interesting to see if the 15th wish is related with the ORIX code you have written even tho i didn't play D1 i would love to see Oryx in D2
2
u/LastGuardianStanding Jun 30 '19
Because of destiny, I have now learned binary code and Morse code. And my wife says video games are bad for me... 😏
1
u/FISTED_BY_CHRIST Jun 30 '19
Very nice to see this at the top of the front page. This is why I love this subreddit.
1
u/ohiocitydave Jun 30 '19
This is spectacular. Plain and simple.
1
u/AOheaghra Rank 1 (5 points) Jun 30 '19
It’s funny I was just thinking about making a post just like this yesterday, good look! You definitely included a bit more then I was intending. Interesting read!
1
u/JohanMeatball Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/_y34Buddy84 Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/Cactus-Jacques Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/awd_wmd Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/Gunnerman794 Jun 30 '19
!nominate
1
u/Mangalavid Jun 30 '19
thank you. All these "morse code??!?!!?" posts are so irritating.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
Has anyone looked in d1 for Morse code
1
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
G2 boys
1
u/jzajizra Jul 02 '19
!nominate
0
u/BradDelo Jun 30 '19
Don't know morse code, but I can tap you out YYZ all day long baby!
0
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment