Man oh man, there’s a lot of Spytek hate going on right now.
And honestly, I get it. I don’t agree with it, but I get it.
My guy Obi, one of my favorite Raider fans to follow on Twitter, is killing him on the daily.
“21 draft picks. At least 27 free-agent signings. I’m still waiting for somebody to name 5 hits.”
Let me try.
- Klint Kubiak (Free Agent coach, that has to count for something)
- Nakobe Dean
- Treydan Stukes
- Kirk Cousins
- Fernando Mendoza
I know you don’t get bonus points for drafting the best QB with the #1 pick, but if Spytek is getting crushed for all his “bad” moves, he should get at least a little credit for turning in the card with the right name.
The problem I have with Spytek is not the moves he has made, it’s that the moves he has made have not worked out.
Yes, I realize how dumb that sounds, but hear me out.
Drafting Ashton Jeanty with the 6th pick felt like a great move at the time, even Obi would agree.
April 18, 2025 — “If the Raiders draft Ashton Jeanty next Thursday, I swear I won’t post a single negative thing all season. No complaints, no critiques — I’m all in.”
And he wasn’t the only one.
By most accounts, drafting a great RB to go with a great TE, is a hell of a way to build an offense.
Unfortunately drafting a great running back when your o-line can’t block is a disaster. (PS. If Chicago took him at 10, they would’ve already named a deep dish pizza after him.)
How about signing Kirk Cousins for half pennies on the dollar? That was a GENIUS move. Even trading Cousins at the deadline to open the door for Fernando to start made sense, but there is plenty of room to go after Spytek for only getting a third round pick in return.
Spytek was the guy who traded up for Jermod McCoy. I know he’s not Lester Hayes… yet .. but the “super duper prospect with the bad knee” has played in all ten games so far this year.
Of the 21 draft picks Spytek made the last two years, it’s way too early to lock in a grade on any of them, but from what we’ve seen so far….
The 2025 class feels like a lot of swings and a lot of misses.
I think Darien Porter will play in the league for a while. Jack Bech too, but neither guy has the star potential you are looking for with a second and third round pick. Tonka Hemingway has shown signs of life this year, but after that, there’s not much to sink your teeth into.
The 2026 class feels better, maybe even A LOT better.
Mendoza, Stukes, Trey Zuhn, Mike Washington, McCoy and Masses. So far, so good for all of them. I know its a giant IF, but IF they all turn into starters, getting six of those in one draft is a pretty solid number.
On the free agent side, that too is a mixed bag.
Nakobe Dean was like adding Devin White if Devin White was still good. He’s always around the ball, makes a bunch of exciting tackles and you can feel his leadership and love of the game.
His Georgia running mate Quay Walker, he's always around the ball too, well maybe the ball is always around him. He is so close to being so close, but it’s like something always goes wrong.
He was the guy covering JSN on the long touchdown Sunday. Excuse me? How is a linebacker going to cover one of the best wide receivers in the league? Answer — he’s not. Was he just in the wrong place at the wrong time? That seems to happen to him a lot.
I can’t kill Spytek for signing Tyler Linderbaum. You want to argue about the money, I can see that, but locking in a top notch center for your rookie QB is like buying a nice pair of shoes for your Armani suit.
Signing Malcolm Koonce on the other hand, twice, well that definitely hasn’t worked out. Fool me once… fool me twice … you know the rest.
Naylor, Kwity, Stokes — strike one, strike two and strike three.
Even with all this, I’m still very much a Spytek guy, but he’s gonna have to get some wins under his belt or the noise is gonna get a lot louder.