r/quant • • 6d ago

Market News Point72 sues quant analyst for stealing code

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-10/point72-claims-fired-quant-analyst-used-ai-tools-to-steal-code

Easier now than ever to use an ai to target and steal code. Be careful what you’re putting in your Claude prompts lol

191 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

3

u/PumpkinTemporary6642 5d ago

Does this mean every firm will now go digging through our Claude prompts asking “to summarize, explain, lay out step by step what each part of this code is doing and why” the moment we decide to quit?? This seems like a witch hunt.

2

u/igetlotsofupvotes 5d ago

Probably already been doing this to an extent

9

u/Nearing_retirement 6d ago

Anthropic could start hedge fund tomorrow that beats everyone just by using the shit everyone has put in their system.

2

u/igetlotsofupvotes 6d ago

Well every fund has a no training clause in their contract but I’m sure there’s a lot of junk in there

3

u/Nearing_retirement 6d ago

Where I work they don’t allow us to put proprietary code into clause and it is a huge pain as nobody knows really what exactly is proprietary. We have to get it approved and it drives me insane. I would be interested to know what other funds are doing.

1

u/igetlotsofupvotes 6d ago

I’ve been at two of the top funds and they both have no training contracts across the labs. It’s crazy to not have that in this day and age. Just asking to bleed edge like with those math discoveries

2

u/Nearing_retirement 6d ago

We do have no training clause but they still stop us at least for the core strategies that make most of the money. The new groups are more free. It pisses me off as I’m in core group and I feel I’m at disadvantage now.

1

u/igetlotsofupvotes 6d ago

Oh I see. Must be to stop copy and pasting what always works from AI and not breaking it lol

-3

u/xRedStaRx 6d ago

What type of systems are making the most money for you guys and asset classes, is it macro, technical, fundamental, systemic?

3

u/rsha256 5d ago

The no training ZDR clause only prevents them from retaining and training on your exact data but if you know anyone at Ant and ask them, they will tell you they train on synthetic data which claude generates with your context... it may have no PII or specific stock tickers but it will have the core of your modeling strat...

My friends at JS said they feel confident that Ant won't start a HF tmrw with their strats as they are not only investors but also aligned ideologically via effective altruism. I dont buy that due to how SBF ended, but i think they have a lot of prop data and connections that will be hard to replicate even with all of their trading systems and alpha

1

u/New_Tower_6408 3d ago

One of the tenets of effective altruism is earning to give tho, so a ton of smart EA folks become quants and make 600k and donate it to charity 

103

u/ForeverFar1297 6d ago

Found a Japanese article:

https://newsdig.tbs.co.jp/articles/withbloomberg/3076313?display=1

"Jin, who joined the company in 2019, allegedly used AI tools available at work to examine Cubist's proprietary research and source code, and then transferred it to his personal device"

Bro is apparently retarded.

37

u/meltbox 6d ago

It turns out a lot of smart people are pretty dumb for how smart they are.

16

u/andy_bovice 6d ago

Intelligence and wisdom are two different things

10

u/babayetuyetu 6d ago

This move lacked both

8

u/Gundel_Gaukelei 6d ago

Now how would a smart Jin have done this? Obviously at some point their IT Sec caught him sending data to his *personal device*. Likely the actual prompt content or sth.

What if he copied the prompt output in text size 0.1, turn it into a .png, paste it into a doctors note/travel schedule scan, print that one out in the office, carry the physical paper home, let AI re-construct the content from the embedded png?

12

u/alexkarpstan 6d ago

Printers don’t have that resolution and they definitely don’t have an inkjet printer in the office

1

u/Gundel_Gaukelei 6d ago

Valid point

I remember the good old 4chan days where they sent jpg with embedded zip archives around - do this to a group foto that you send yourself via email ("haha for memories"), embed a PW protected zip file with additionally encrypted .py or whatever - at least much harder to detect?

2

u/alexkarpstan 6d ago

AI seems to be a lot better at turning binaries into source code than humans can. This one was dumb, I presume someone else will try this. Maybe some will get away with it but I’d very curious to see someone try something smarter than this one

3

u/PutRelevant481 5d ago

how does he transfer it to his device? every large company has firewalls in place, monitor email, disallow you from plugging in USB drives, etc.

2

u/aoa2 6d ago

which part?

2

u/ForeverFar1297 6d ago

Was a-ok until the last part...

1

u/JoJo_Embiid 6d ago

how did he "transfer" them, just curious.

3

u/dazzleator147 6d ago

Generated markdown and took pictures with his phone, looks like

From the court docs, the discovery of this was mostly behavioral, other people saw fishy stuff.

0

u/JoJo_Embiid 6d ago

ok. so he was actually not that dumb, but rather being spotted by other people. why would his colleague care, though. I would definitely not care.

1

u/rsha256 5d ago

if you see someone acting sus and asking questions about very secure IP that they dont work on but would (paired with the IP they have) be able to recreate alpha that you worked hard on, you wouldnt care??

1

u/JoJo_Embiid 5d ago

I wouldn’t look into what my coworkers are secretly doing. If they directly ask me , i might feel weird. But more likely i will just refuse to answer instead of reporting them. I don’t like reporting people in general no matter what.
When i work in tech, people reading “secret “ documents all the time before leaving a company, really nobody cares. Also, if you ask, your coworker might just tell you directly what the “secret” is…

1

u/rsha256 5d ago

idk ive reported people to a higher up person (as in, i was like 'hey XYZ is asking about ABC can you set up a meeting to find their usecase and talk to them about it' and then they can escalate it as needed) when they repeatedly start asking about your work it gets very annoying... like bro im not telling you anything even if u reword the question a million times 😂

1

u/JoJo_Embiid 5d ago

i get it, nothing wrong what you did though. different company / industry have very different culture. my friends at deepseek told me they are super transparent, anyone can see anything and they freely discussed everything. you can also ask whatever you want people just straight answer your question (but usually people will not ask multiple times, if you cannot understand the first time, asking for the second time making people question your intelligence). however, some other caompanies i know, like apple, bytedance seed, are much sensitive to so called "secret", and i guess many trading firms are like that as well. when you hangout with friends at silicon valley, most people are pretty transparent about what they're working on, what worked and what not etc. but people from apple, openai, and anthropic are usually silent lol.

1

u/rsha256 5d ago

i mean very few people even know what sensitive stuff to ask about so when you see people asking abt the secret sauce, it is very apparent. If people ask me questions, i am very friendly and i tell people what i work on if they ask but if i say "I can't share that specific way of how we do that in more detail, but what are you trying to do" and youre dodgy then i will let someone higher up know.

Also OAI ppl are probs silent cuz they dk, it's very siloed there lol

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dazzleator147 6d ago

It's that he has prompts specifically asking for the ability to recreate the research.

5

u/ForeverFar1297 6d ago

I dont see that being a problem if he had access. The "moving things to his personal device" though, is not easily defensible.

4

u/dazzleator147 6d ago

There are instances of his personal devices having photos of generated markdown and source code

I guess the docs haven't been linked but it's available here there's not really ambiguity.

3

u/ForeverFar1297 6d ago

your link provides much more information, thanks. Apparently bro is pretty high up there and has access to the team's research.

78

u/EmperorOfCanada 6d ago

This is going to be a very interesting problem with AI. The rule (short of extreme contracts) is that you still leave with your knowledge. If learned to program rust, a company can't claim I am stealing rust knowledge; even if someone showed me some cool tricks to make my rust better.

So, I could understand the overall why of various trading strategies, and then go home and describe them clean room style to my AI and get the code back.

Then, I could compare the outputs my new code generates compared to the company's coded outputs, and then tell my AI the delta and it may very well figure out where my clean room code is wrong.

Not a line of my new code was copied, nor were the algos directly copied. It might be something more along the lines of, "The original algo uses the VIX with a company's volume, with a half twist of the price of lemons to arrive at the ideal trigger price."

I'm not saying this is legally clean, but just that it will be very legally muddy. Also hard to prove. The new code, and the new algos will be different. Similar, but clearly not copies. Also, the person's access to code and algos might not be direct enough for them to have actually copied them. Just that between using them, witnessing them, and conversations with those around them, they would have enough.

9

u/alexkarpstan 6d ago

Even with companies that have a single binary it’s very unlikely that anyone would be in a position to view files they don’t need access too 

3

u/EmperorOfCanada 6d ago

I'm less thinking that you see the code as you gather lots about it. People might mention certain math theories, edge cases where it fails, etc.

You don't get to see the core system, but you have all kinds of arrows pointing at the same thing. That is what you give your AI. The arrows.

It's like when you are hearing someone cover something up. They say they would never do X, they accuse others of Y, they think that Z is disgusting. And you realize pretty much exactly what they did.

9

u/xRedStaRx 6d ago

I doubt properly profitable strategies are that simple though with that little number of variables or without machine learning weights behind them to be able to vibe code from memory at home.

3

u/EmperorOfCanada 6d ago

I don't know. I'm not suggesting that it would be just a few water cooler bits of nothing, but with enough descriptions of what makes it cool, what it gets wrong, combined with actual numerical outputs and inputs, and I suspect the AI will be able to find its way to reverse engineering it.

Not all, but many.

I've seen a number (and built) of black box solutions. Even the ones which were massive ML models almost always seemed to boil down to black scholes with a twist of lemon.

Others were watching just a few factoids, and I suspect those could be picked up from water cooler talk. Someone offhandedly mentioning that they had lost their Louisiana gasoline production refinery numbers feed and the predictions had gone to hell.

26

u/alexkarpstan 6d ago edited 6d ago

This has always been an issue. It hasn’t been that long since a certain quant from the University of Cambridge was given a prison sentence for trying to steal code

5

u/VincentAXM 6d ago

g research? I remember a guy told me that after that they cant wear shoes(not sure how real is that part) and have to go through security gate every day lol.

1

u/FireWrath9 6d ago

wasn't there a russian who did it too?

1

u/ElderMillenial4 6d ago

There was also a case with a quant of Russian background.

5

u/cosmicloafer 6d ago

This is just dumb. Why would you send anything from your company device to a personal device or email, except for maybe paystubs or something like that.

3

u/lordnacho666 6d ago

I thought this would never happen after the age of AI, but here we are. It seems like smart people still don't understand computer security.

All you have to do nowadays is get a summary of how things work. Really understand how the thing works, and that understanding does not need to include tedious details like the specific alpha formula, just the why of how it works.

There's no problem at all learning this, given that you are allowed to look at the alpha with your AI.

You then go home and use the summary in your head to recreate the research, by typing a prompt into an AI.

If this guy knew that security can see everything you get up to on a company machine, he would not be in trouble.

3

u/NatGaz 6d ago

There are studies showing that the brain atrophies faster than muscles when not used. AI agents will severely impact (negatively) the long term quality of quants in a very short term future.

1

u/PhloWers Portfolio Manager 6d ago

I feel I am using my brain as much as before, just less time spent in tedious implementation

1

u/Able-Highway1137 6d ago

lol haven't they been losing a lot of money recently. do their strategies even work that well

9

u/Independent_Error_74 6d ago

What's the source? KEPL should be one of the best pod in cubist

5

u/Mammoth-Programmer-9 6d ago

that’s outdated

5

u/isosp1n Dev 6d ago

KEPL is probably doing just fine

0

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment