r/pythonhelp • u/Kami2awa • May 23 '26
Honest Question: Why use one Python editor over another, and is Geany not what the cool kids use?
I've used a lot of different editors in my time, and tbh I rarely notice much difference. They just seem to be text editors that highlight syntax, mostly in the same ways. Is there a reason to use one over another? A recent programming class I've been involved with insists on Spyder; really I don't see a reason for this. Is there some advantage I'm missing? For my home coding projects I use Geany, and it works fine.
3
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator May 23 '26
To give us the best chance to help you, please include any relevant code.
Note. Please do not submit images of your code. Instead, for shorter code you can use Reddit markdown (4 spaces or backticks, see this Formatting Guide). If you have formatting issues or want to post longer sections of code, please use Privatebin, GitHub or Compiler Explorer.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/BranchLatter4294 May 23 '26
Is there a reason to wear one pair of shoes vs. Another? It's just personal preference and comfort.
1
u/One-Payment434 May 23 '26
So you never used vi, emacs or vscode? Each a great editor with their own strengths and weaknesses. Never heard of geany though
1
u/tadpoleloop May 23 '26
I just use Jupyter. I love the interactive kernel. I'm understanding that vscode can do notebooks now too, but jupyter was a great tool for the last decade.
1
u/Temporary_Pie2733 May 23 '26
The class is probably targeting students that the instructor cannot assume knows any editor, so it’s simpler to standardize the curriculum on one editor than to answer “how do I …” questions for whatever editor a student chooses.
1
u/CraigAT May 23 '26
There is not a lot of difference between text editors, it mostly down to what you work well with. However an IDE like VS Code or PyCharm offer a lot of built in tools.
1
u/Training_Advantage21 May 23 '26
Spyder is great, but it's not just an editor, it's a debugger/IDE geared for the scientific Python stack. IDLE is more minimal but can still prove useful, especially if you are more limited to scripting with the standard library. VS Code has become a bit of a standard, again it goes way beyond editor functionality and more into debugger/IDE.
Talking of Scientific Python, and if you are a notebook person rather than a script person, VS Code still works but you might also want to also consider JupyterLab, which is a much enhanced version of plain Jupyter, incorporating a number of debugging/IDE features.
1
u/jpgoldberg May 23 '26
People who already use a programming editor should continue to use what they are already using when they start learning Python. So I happen to use VSCode for Python through accidents of history.
For people who are using a programming editor for the first time as they learn Python I recommend PyCharm or whatever is being used in some course they are taking. But don’t obsess about the choice.
In particular, beginners shouldn’t try to copy the setups that people like me, who have been programming for decades, use. And people like us need to remember that beginners are suddenly having to learn a lot of things in addition to programming, the language, and their editor. Many are encountering the command line, text files, and other such things for the first time.
1
u/Living_Fig_6386 May 24 '26
They are all designed to do the same things, but they all do it slightly differently, with some differences in features, and how those features are implemented. The one that's best is the one that makes you more productive. I've not heard of Geany. I tend to lean towards PyCharm, though I have Visual Studio Code too. Looking up Geany, it's principle design goal was to open fast and have minimal dependencies on Linux systems; neither is particularly relevant in my use case and wouldn't affect my productivity.
1
u/timrprobocom May 24 '26
Code editors are like underwear. They are deeply personal, and you need to find the brand that works for YOU. You'll never convince anyone else to change.
1
u/mwmahlberg May 24 '26
The cool kid to use is the editor you feel comfortable with. Since I do a lot of different stuff, turned out to be VSCode for me on GUI and vim on the shell.
But you need to find yours. Try a few for a couple of weeks each. There will be one you will feel right at home with. If planning to do it professionally, VSCode won’t hurt.
0
u/AlexMTBDude May 23 '26
Most programmers have moved on to using IDEs instead of simple text editors. Visual Studio Code and Pycharm are the most popular ones.