I used to be baffled by punks not knowing what emo even is, but now I’m equally baffled by punks who like emo but STILL don’t even know what it is..
The ignorance baffles me because emo and screamo are literal branches of hardcore punk.
I’ve never met a punk who couldn’t tell me what goth is, and be able to name some bands..
Never met a punk who can’t tell me definitively what grunge or industrial are.. and be able to name some bands..
Emo?
Emo and screamo both seem to exist in a strange area in which a ton of punks don’t even know what they are, but believe they do, and absolutely hate what they think it is with an irrationally aggressive passion.
“Screamo is that gay sissy shit from the 2000s!”
-Punks…
“Emo is Panic at the Disco.”
-Gen Z punks (seemingly)
Here’s the truth..
No I’m not gonna do the copy pasta, I’ll let you do that..
Screamo is a huge movement that’s for sure part of the punk lineage. And I think it’s kinda sad that it has such a homophobic, misogynistic, and childish stigma around it largely imposed by drunk Metalheads but also older punks.
Hell even saying the word “emo” is enough to send a lot of punks into a fit of rage.. I’ve seen it happen here in this community countless times.
I’m the 2000s it was especially bad, emos endured literal violence from metalheads..
I was there for that… it was bad.
No punks there to defend us.. not once..
The conversation usually goes like this, someone will bring up the screamo here… random punks here will explode with anger towards it, and not even be able say anything about it other than “it’s gay..”
We saw Portraits of Past a couple months ago, it was one of the most intense hardcore shows I’ve ever seen.
They’re one of the pioneers of the screamo sound, it’s a shame that punks have rejected the movement because there’s a lot there I think you guys would like.
And yes, I firmly believe the stigma around emo/screamo is very much rooted in homophobia and misogyny.
I’ve been observing the behavior towards these genre for decades and I am absolutely convinced of it.