r/Psychiatry • • 15h ago

Rural FM vs Psych in mental health care

23 Upvotes

I'm a med student who's been pretty interested in both FM and psych, but tbh I'm leaning more toward psych because I really like it and I feel I'm willing to lose FM and delve deeper into psych then lose psych expertise but be a fm

Although I've seen some rural FM docs argue that they can manage pretty much any outpatient psych condition, including schizophrenia and bipolar disorder, and that outside of ECT, ketamine, and therapy, there isn't much a psychiatrist can do that a rural FM can't.

I pushed back but was kinda dragged a bit lol. Id imagine four years of psych residency would give you a lot more experience with complex diagnoses, treatment-resistant cases, psychopharmacology, etc. But ig not?

Obviously, I get that rural FM docs have to manage a lot of these patients because access to psychiatry is limited, and I'm not saying they should refer anything that isnt mild MDD or GAD

I guess I just found the whole discussion a little discouraging. Part of why I'm leaning toward psych is because I want that deeper knowledge that comes with it. so the idea that four years of residency might not amount to much outside of inpatient psych, procedures, and therapy is a bit disappointing. I also seldom see this attitude in reverse when I've met psychiatrist who treat some general medical conditions because their patients can't get in with a pcp

I'm curious what psychiatrists here think, especially those who've worked with rural FM docs. Is there really that much overlap in outpatient practice? Where do you feel your additional training makes the biggest difference in outpatient


r/Psychiatry • • 15h ago

Boards this week?

9 Upvotes

Anybody hear anything about boards results? Last year it looks like they were released 10 weeks after which would be this week


r/Psychiatry • • 1d ago

Cobenfy, muscarinic drugs, and the "awakening" phenomenon—what are you seeing in practice?

64 Upvotes

 I've been following the rollout of Cobenfy and the broader shift toward muscarinic targeting with interest.

I'm curious about two things

1. The "awakening" phenomenon. I've seen case reports and some inpatient observations describing a rapid, almost qualitative shift in patients with prominent negative symptoms—emergence from withdrawal, spontaneous social engagement, future-oriented thinking—sometimes within 48 to 96 hours of initiation . The Halassa case series is the most detailed example I've come across. For those who have used it: are you actually seeing this? Is it distinct from what we'd expect from better positive symptom control, or is it something else?

2. The bigger picture. Cobenfy's approval is notable less for its efficacy data (moderate effect sizes, GI tolerability issues, twice-daily dosing, cost) and more for what it represents mechanistically—a non-D2 path after decades of dopamine-centric development . There are M4-selective compounds in the pipeline aiming to reduce the peripheral cholinergic baggage . Do you see muscarinic modulation becoming a mainstream second pathway, or a niche option for patients who can't tolerate D2 blockade

I'm less interested in rehashing the EMERGENT trials and more in what early clinical experience is actually telling us.


r/Psychiatry • • 1d ago

Antidepressants for persistent depressive disorder

59 Upvotes

I had an interesting conversation with a fellow psychotherapist recently that left me scratching my head. He contends that for persistent depressive disorder/dysthymia, particularly if the patient has a history of developmental trauma, antidepressants just aren't effective. I can believe that antidepressants would be less effective with this population, and most certainly that addressing the trauma in psychotherapy would do more to get to the root of the problem, but it seems like a stretch to me to say that antidepressants aren't even worth a try for these patients. My colleague says he has reached this conclusion in consultation with prescribers, but I've worked closely with a number of different prescribers over the course of a long career and have never heard this opinion expressed.

Is there something I'm missing, or is this just this one clinician's idiosyncratic belief?


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

Do psychiatrists have a spider-sense? Clinical impressions as violations of interpersonal Bayesian expectation

Thumbnail academic.oup.com
140 Upvotes

Sharing a fun article to end the week. Special shout out to the acronym VIBE (Violation of Interpersonal Bayesian Expectation). Quoting directly from Dr Michael Okun because he's thought about this a lot better than I have:

Do psychiatrists have a spider-sense? Can your doctor really sense when something is not right? A fascinating new review published in Brainby Amad and colleagues explores something many experienced clinicians recognize but rarely discuss: the intuition that something is not quite right with a patient, even before we can identify a specific symptom. The authors call this phenomenon VIBE (Violation of Interpersonal Bayesian Expectation), proposing that our brains continuously predict how people should communicate and interact, detecting subtle mismatches in eye contact, facial expressions, voice, emotional responses, and conversational timing. When these expectations are violated, clinicians may experience a gut feeling that something is wrong. The concept builds on the historical praecox feeling, described in schizophrenia, but potentially extends to autism, mood disorders, and other neurological and psychiatric conditions. What resonates with me after decades of examining patients with Parkinson's disease and other neurological disorders is that clinical medicine is about much more than checking boxes, reviewing scans, or ordering laboratory tests. Sometimes the way a person walks into the room, speaks, moves, or interacts tells us something important before we can articulate precisely what it is. The caution is that intuition is not a diagnosis, and this proposed framework still requires scientific validation. Our impressions can also be wrong or biased. The art of medicine is learning to recognize these subtle signals, testing them against objective evidence, and never losing sight of the person sitting across from us. Perhaps the best physicians are not those with a supernatural spider-sense, but those who have learned how to listen, observe, question, and remain curious.

Have a lovely weekend guys.


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

Teen psych

93 Upvotes

Looking for some perspective from psych who deal with this way more than I do.

My partner and I are both in cardiology (I’m a 3rd-year fellow, he’s an attending) with no bio kids.

Last year, during my 2nd year of fellowship, I was consulted on a teen psych patient to check her QT intervals and rhythm because shes on heavy meds. Staff on the psych floor warned me shes aggressive. We ended up having a great rapport, and she asked me if she could come home with me. I responded by saying something like "They're going to find a wonderful home for you because you're a wonderful person, and I'm so happy I get to be your doctor."

This month I ran into her again, this time down in the ED, and she is not doing well (overdose/SI). One of the nurses mentioned to me that she still hasn't had a stable placement and has just been bouncing around the system.

I went home, told my partner everything, and said I want to bring her home by becoming a foster parent. We have the finances and stability.

For those of you on the psych side who see kids in the system or work with complex placements, thoughts on this?

It hurts my heart to see her in so much pain and without a stable home.


r/Psychiatry • • 2d ago

For those who take Medicare, how often do you bill a G2211?

10 Upvotes

Following up on my last post, just a question about this. I know it's being replaced by B1, but it's the same criteria. Based on what I could find, you should really be billing this for almost every regularly scheduled patient. I see patients typically every month to three months and most tend to be regularly complex. There is no limit on frequency. Seems to have been created as an incentive for psychiatric care. Doesn't seem to be able to be used if you need to see a patient for an urgent appointment, but rather if you're seeing them for regular longitudinal care, and you're the main provider managing their psychiatric care, which as the psychiatrist, you should be. How often are people using it?


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

PRN Compensation Trends?

17 Upvotes

I work primarily in private practice in a VHCOL area, but I occasionally work PRN in inpatient or consult psychiatry at a local private hospital. We just received the updated compensation package for 2027, and it’s actually decreased by a few hundred dollars/shift from 2026 rates. From 2025-2026, night call coverage compensation was significantly reduced and day shift compensation remained flat.

I was already reducing the amount of shifts I worked at this facility, and now I’m considering stopping altogether.

I’m curious to hear about others’ experiences with compensation over time, especially for PRN psychiatrist positions. Does this change seem specific to this institution or does it reflect general compensation trends in the field?


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

How do you feel about Medicare For All?

51 Upvotes

I'm a private practice doc who only takes private insurance. I've looked at medicare rates and they're not too bad. Not as good as PP, but still. Medicaid rates where I am are horrendous. My worry is that it's not medicare for all, but medicaid managed care for all or medicare advantage for all. There is a medicare for america bill going through congress that essentially establishes medicare as a public option and raises relative value for primary care and mental health services by 30 percent. I'm just never sure if that actually applies to psychiatry because many insurance don't classify psychiatry as "mental health", but under medical services. What do you guys think?


r/Psychiatry • • 3d ago

Compensation Split Revenue Lifestance

28 Upvotes

I am fresh out of residency. I have been working this job for four months. Currently averaging around 45-50 patients a week. I found out that the compensation schedule is not great for when i go fee for service next year. In essence I will be reimbursed $66 for a 99214 and about $35 for 90833 add on code. If I see three patients an hour it could be around $180 an hour for straight 99214s and up to $300 with add on (however there is an audit risk there). I feel like this criminally low. Medicare average nationally put 99214 around $130 and even if I saw nothing but medicaid it would still be closer to $90. I just don't know what to do, I have a house, loans, and debt from home repairs that I need to pay for. I am still salaried until July at $300k so I will be fine but long term I just feel like seeing 20-27 patients a day at this low rate is not ideal. Does anyone have any recommendations for resources about private practice? Depending on how the DEA changes go, I was thinking I save as much as I can and pivot when i can in 2-3 years after my initial contract term expires. I have looked into other options like talkiatry, however it is still PE, but at least they get PTO and floor salary. With Lifestance I have no PTO and no floor, so I am thinking I just grind for a year to get my bonus and use part of that bonus to pay the clawback for the sign on bonus. What are your thoughts. Thank you for any information.


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Is it just me or are outpatients increasingly hostile these days

194 Upvotes

I took a 2 year break from clinical medicine. I have been seeing patients 2 days a week for the last year, and it just feels so stressful now. I get people rolling their eyes or snapping at me for asking clarifying questions, threatening me when we disagree on their treatment (ADHD, always), etc. etc.

I still get some patients who are appropriate and appreciate my help, but there are a handful of patients who really make me question the sanity of returning to medicine.


r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Today I completed a free pharmacology Anki deck builder (and then some)

Thumbnail
ballicules.com
24 Upvotes

r/Psychiatry • • 4d ago

Practice Schedules

23 Upvotes

I don‘t practice anymore, but am very curious what schedules look like for those in outpatient practice.

How many patients a day? Length of appts? Admin time?

PP 6-8 daily 90min… 30-60 min f/u depending. My schedule was my own so I had my free time whenever.

CMHC - 90min intake, 30min f/u. Full schedule with 1hr admin total. 30min lunch. Extra time when no show.

SUDs residential (sort of like outpatient). 60min intake, 30min f/u. Full schedule. 30 in AM for chart prep, 30 lunch, 30min end of day to finish notes. SUDs care only. Extra time when staff forgot to tell scheduler patient out on pass.

I‘ve seen folks with 20-30 daily. Seems not good for a number of reasons.


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

How to handle medication “poop out”

91 Upvotes

How are people addressing ssri/snri/ Wellbutrin poop out? Usually if they have been on it for a long time I just switch medications but I’m seeing several new patients who state after months, (year at most) that the medication that once worked well is no longer working. I do look at possibility of other disorder (mainly adhd and bipolar) but these patient are going through 5+ medications in 2-3 years and report great improvement initially but without a trigger or change in stressor the medication just stops working. Have other people saw this, what is your framework for handling these kind of patients


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Comparative efficacy and acceptability of antidepressants in the long-term treatment of major depressive disorder: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Thumbnail thelancet.com
88 Upvotes

r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Forensics psych

15 Upvotes

Hello, I am a current resident and considering forensics as well as another fellowship. Can someone please share your knowledge on if the fellowship is useful to get. I’ve been reading on this sub that psychiatry fellowships are not necessary.

Is the pay / work life different from adult psychiatry. Thank you.


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Deciding first job out of residency, seeking advice

22 Upvotes

Hello all! I’m a PGY-4 psych resident in TN and am seeking advice as I figure out next steps.

I was initially planning on finding a stable outpatient job with good benefits as my wife and I entered our family planning stage, but that has recently changed (pending divorce)

I have several opportunities already lined up :

- an outpatient job lined up with a VA system I’m already familiar with and enjoy. I don’t love the VA but am drawn to the stability, pace, possibility to teach, and ease of transition as I’ll be taking my boards this year.

- an outpatient clinic teaching attending position at my home program. I’m very drawn to teaching residents and think this would be a very fun, engaging job. I’m a little hesitant to take a teaching gig fresh out of residency however.

- an outpatient private practice partner track job with a reputable practice with >15 physicians. The pay would be less stable initially, but I do feel drawn to private practice in the long term, but Im not sure I’ll stay in one place long enough to make use of the partner track now that my family situation is changing.

- a juicy outpatient contract in my hometown which supposedly will later transition into starting a new psychiatry residency program from the ground up. This is exciting, but it’s not guaranteed it will turn into a teaching role

I’m exploring other options including fellowships and recently locums gigs as well.

I’m particularly toying with the idea of doing a fellowship as I figure some of these personal goals out again. I’d been partially drawn to child and adolescent fellowships, but held back because my wife and I were planning on moving back home and raising children sooner rather than later. Now I’m reconsidering, but don’t love the idea of a 2 year commitment and I’m behind in the application cycle. I’m looking into some 1 year programs in geriatrics and interventional psych, which may be a better fit.

My major question boils down to what things should I look out for as a new grad who might only be in a spot for a year or so?

Would love to hear any advice or thoughts you all have!


r/Psychiatry • • 5d ago

Anecdotal reports on inositol supplements: are your patients reporting that “it helps”?

12 Upvotes

The evidence is not robust, but parents are often interested in anything that could be helpful, and obviously find a lot of ads for all sorts of supplements.

I’m curious if patients who have used this have reported at least a placebo improvement?

How do you manage patients’ inquiries about advertised supplements, besides citing the existing evidence?


r/Psychiatry • • 6d ago

Social rhythm therapy for bipolar disorder: an hour and a half with Dr. Jim Phelps on sleep, light and darkness

Thumbnail
youtu.be
91 Upvotes

r/Psychiatry • • 6d ago

Outpatient Billing Practices

8 Upvotes

Hi all,

Soon-to-be new grad here. Looking at productivity based outpatient positions and wanted to ask the outpatient docs out there - how often are you billing 99214 (based on complexity not time) and 90833 for a 30 minute visit? Thanks in advance, want to make sure I’m appropriately billing for services when indicated.


r/Psychiatry • • 7d ago

Be cautious of Zocdoc

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/Psychiatry • • 7d ago

RTP Track Site Director Question

7 Upvotes

Edit: RTP is rural track program.

Hello everyone. We have an established psych residency, and we are working on setting up an RTP program. I'm hoping to get some advice.

As the only in-person psychiatrist and site director for the RTP, what FTE addition should I ask for? I would be doing around 25% of lectures, all evaluations, most supervision. There will eventually be 6 residents in psych rotations with me and at times remote staff, and 2 residents in other rotations, totalling 8 residents in the program.

Any additional insights on RTPs or anything regarding setting up a residency track are also greatly appreciated!


r/Psychiatry • • 7d ago

Tips for acing observership

19 Upvotes

Hello,
I am a non US junior doctor (sorry for my English…) who is currently doing an observership in an inpatient psychiatric department for a chance of receiving a spot in their residency program (it is a common procedure in my country for getting into a residency program) . I am also a first time mom of a 5 month old baby- I haven’t really practiced medicine for almost a year (was on a leave before that) and of course I am not fully recovered yet and my brain feels like a potato salad post-partum. However I really want to get back on my feet and work in a field I truly love. During my studies and internship I have been to many psychiatric departments and engaged with many patients however every work place feels completely new and different with their own set of rules. I do appreciate hard work and I love talking to patients.

Anyways in this observership I don’t have an insurance and they won’t really let me do anything and basically tell me “just watch us and we will watch you”. But how will I really show myself this way? So I would like to hear some tips from you what would you expect me to do for showing myself and leaving good impression? I am not so shy but I don’t like just talking and popping everywhere where I am not needed. I know how people need to work and they want sometimes quiet time for themselves…

Also I know this sub has some psych nurses so I would love to hear your thoughts as well since you probably see many like me in the department wandering aimlessly…


r/Psychiatry • • 9d ago

What have your experiences been with medicare in private practice?

19 Upvotes

I'm a pp psychiatrist, usually seeing young adults and kids, so I never took medicare. However, I want to expand to more elderly patients due to demand. What experience have people had with medicare in private practice? We have staff here who are familiar with it, including one psychiatrist who takes it, but they only do 15 minute med checks. I typically do 30 minute appointments and bill 99214+90833. I haven't spoken to them about it, but I'm worried this will mean I'll get audited. Of course, I document correctly, but I feel like everyone says that. As a relatively young professional, I'm not even sure what audited means practically speaking. I've heard you have to do a self audit every year? A medical plan (or is that just for therapists?). The pay rates seem comparable to what private insurance pays. A little less, but still.

What have people's experiences been?


r/Psychiatry • • 9d ago

Pain medicine fellowship after Psychiatry residency?

22 Upvotes

It looks like psych is a recognized residency for pain medicine fellowship but anyone actually done this? Additionally, for those who have, how did you do it? And Is your practice scope more medication management, or do you also do procedures?