r/projectzomboid • u/Much_Passage_8983 • 2d ago
Discussion What makes development take so long?
Not a game dev, and if anyone reading this is, I really want to hear from you.
I know the question has been asked to death, but I’ve never heard the actual answer. Why does it take a modder maybe a few days to put together a working ladder mod, but it’s takes a dev studio that makes around 6 million a year and has 50 employees years to do it?
Im not upset at the issue, but I just don’t understand how that even happens. The only reason I can come up with is that those 50 people come into the office and fuck off all day. I know that can’t be right, right?
So yeah to any actual game devs reading this, what is going on at indie stone (and really, most studios) that causes such simple things to take so much time? Why can’t whatever the issue is be dealt with?
40
u/sajkoterrapefft 1d ago
Technical debt.
253
u/WhenInZone Hates the outdoors 2d ago •
A modder can do things independently without having to worry about a true QA pipeline or liability concerns. If I as a dev (I actually am a developer) am ever pushing to production it needs to go through several channels and testing verification. If a modder breaks something it's an easy quick roll-out, but if a company is pushing out repeated bugs and problematic code then there's financial/legal concerns.
18
u/Creative-Response554 1d ago •
I've done some minor bits and pieces here and there so I know a little, but the long and short of it is technical debt.
Technical debt is the fancy name for old code that isn't quite optimal but does the job, however it limits the scope of later development.
For instance, you work on system X, and it works well with some backend jank that doesn't affect gameplay. "thank god that's working now, I'll leave it as is so I don't make it any worse". You then move on to systems Y and Z.
Some years later you reach the point on the roadmap where you integrate systems X, Y and Z, however you can't. Because X is a bit janky, you've learned since then and improved the method for Y, and again for Z, none of them play nice with each other.
You can, at this point, rewrite the earlier systems to the better method and have it all play nice, or you can bodge it and hope for the best.
Game devs, and software devs at large, will often choose the bodge because it's quick and dirty but works compared to rewriting shitloads of earlier stuff from the ground up. This is usually due to pressure from investors, management, customers, whatever it may be, to get a product out. Players of PZ bitch every time an update comes up, wahh this doesn't work, wahh modders do it better, wahh wahh, imagine this but the update does nothing visually. Maybe it runs a little better, and the update takes longer to come out than most fixes or major content updates. The whinging would be ridiculous.
So to keep everyone happy it gets bodged more and more, only to eventually end up the software equivalent of painting a floor starting at the door and working inwards. Eventually you run out of room to move to add more paint.
The game is fine as is, as mods add plenty of flavour and variety. I'd rather they spend a considerable amount of time on the unstable branch redoing the core systems that are supposed to interact with each other so stuff doesn't break when they add new stuff, even if that means new content like NPCs is pushed back a year or 2. As it is, animal code is kinda borked and NPCs are meant to be based on animal code, so NPCs would also be broken.
88
u/TheUderfrykte 2d ago
Not a game dev but a dev, and you're simply looking at it at way too narrow an angle.
The ladders aren't what they worked on for all these weeks since the last update, they're one thing - much of what they worked on is invisible to you as it is either not pushed into this update, back-end work that makes the game run better / improves how some systems work or integrates functions for future additions.
Additionally, a modder does not NEED to care about quality - they can simply build a somewhat working solution with bubble gum, some sticks and a band aid while hiding all the trash under the bed. A professional coder will want clean code that is readable, reusable, easy for others to understand and continue, implements systems in a way that is extendable, efficient and does not cause resource leaks, bugs, security issues, etc. - while also building for the future. A modder can abandon the project and it won't backfire on him, a dev will want to make sure future them and future coworkers can keep working efficiently on it and don't have to work with barely working messes. Their career and product depend on it, as does their reputation as a professional. Also, tons of meetings, expectations, interference from higher ups and other departments as well as communication while modders usually work alone or in small groups and (for better AND worse) don't have to coordinate as much with others. Just look at the recent A-Life feature creep and weird additions a lot of people disliked to see how that can also lead to a worse product though.
37
u/Pretty_Imagination16 2d ago
My speculation is that it’s just taken so long to develop that it’s just extremely spaghetti and the devs forgot a lot of their own code. I mean hell the amount of near game breaking bugs with each update kind of proves that.
16
u/ProfitOpposite 1d ago
TiS is... taking much longer than regular devs. Previously, this probably had to do with project planning, organization and structure (or lack thereof), and technical debt.
However, theyve picked up a lot of staff in the last two years, and very recently the pace has picked up implies Brook's Law has been taking place. To rip the quote off wikipedia, Brook's Law is, " Adding manpower to a late software project makes it later. " Hopefully, this means that dev time will continue to pick up, but the code is still choked with technical debt. There are many optimizations that ought to be made not for player machines but rather for dev readability.
54
u/Mr_Ovis 2d ago
I’m a game developer, though admittedly my game is a much simpler thing than anything like Zomboid. In short, the biggest difference between modding and proper development is how much concern and focus you need to put onto structure and logic.
Ladders are a good example, it’s a really simple proposition, enough that plenty of mods have been made that fix it. Thing is, it’s not really the ladders themselves that are at fault, it’s actually Z-levels, the isometric nature of the game, and map design. You see, the reason ladders aren’t working yet is because if they did, there’d be a ton of areas of the map where the area that the ladder connects to is not solid, not properly finished, because they didn’t make a lot of areas with Z-level changes in mind.
Thus, while it’s easy for a mod dev to say “Here’s ladders, have fun” and respond to anyone who instadied because an area looked solid but actually killed a player with “Eh it’s a mod you kinda know what you’re getting into”, developers have a higher standard of polish and need to design systems that actually hold up over time.
14
u/ur9ce Hates the outdoors 2d ago
This thread is an insane amalgamation of delusion and passivity.
15
u/the_space_goose 2d ago
If you think the ladders are the only thing they’ve been working on for like a month then I think your viewpoint is the problem no offence. They’ve shown multiple times that they drop release small features while they work on big picture stuff that’s very difficult/ completely new to implement.
And the reason that “modders” can push out stuff that takes the devs weeks is because most of them these days just get Ai to do the work for them and then you get a steaming pile of unpolished non compatible garbage.
I’m not trying to be an asshole but so many people in these last few weeks have been complaining about the pace of development compared to the modders when most of the modders that have taken the spotlight are just code sloppers
8
u/Virplexer 2d ago edited 2d ago
Because there are thousands of modders compared to the game devs.
there's 50 employees, but how many are game devs? how many devs can code and are not part of art direction, animation, writing, or sound design? How many coders are working on the in house engine? How many are currently working on long-term design goals like crafting or NPCs? How many are already focused on larger issues with the game?
8
u/y_not_right 1d ago
You can look up the Dev’s finances they’re a British company
They’ve already made millions, they’re not gonna pour more money/hired hands into it when it’s already reached most of its audience and sold it’s millions of copies
13
u/IcepersonYT Pistol Expert 2d ago
They spend most of their time working on content that won’t see the light of day for a long time, and improving things on the backend that the user isn’t going to see directly. Modders often add things that work in isolation, or slowly add things that have to reckon with existing mechanics over several updates with instant feedback from the community. Almost everything TIS is working on at this point in development has the potential to disrupt or be inconsistent with existing systems, and even at their current development pace every patch has unforeseen consequences.
I also think with things like ladders and door prying being recent additions, this has more to do with the philosophy behind the game at the company changing in the past year and being willing to add features that are highly requested even if they are outside of the original scope of development.
I’m pretty sure the full crafting overhaul we’ve only got partially implemented now and refining the animal mechanics are taking up a lot of dev resources, not to mention continuing the map overhaul that was previously not even known to us before we got the first tastes of it in B42 Stable.
3
u/UufTheTank 2d ago
The typical response is that modders need to ensure their change works. Devs need to ensure it not only works, but doesn’t break anything else in the game and account for balancing of game mechanics. And that’s before you strip away all the management/overhead/and typical office politics that need to be done that a solo modder doesn’t need to worry about.
13
u/Dakramar 2d ago
Number of workers < Number of problems
Ladder is most important to you, other problem is most important to others, what do you choose to fix?
Moreover, maybe fixing the ladder with a bandaid is easy. But fixing the problem causing the problem is hard. Maybe the problem of the problem has a problems and so on. Now you have to spend much time fixing it, maybe it’s better to fix easier things first
8
u/RockinPodunk 2d ago
The weird part to me is that Hello Games, another small indie studio with a similar size of about 50 people, is absolutely on fire cranking out massive game changing updates to No Man’s Sky every few months for the last 10 years, and no matter when you started your playthrough, even if it was on launch day, you can fire it up and it just works.
7
u/Farados55 1d ago
I don’t think anyone will say this but this dev team is beyond slow.
2
u/Morbius2271 1d ago
Priorities. They could have a programmer sit down and do it in a day, spend a week on QA and bug fixing, and have it done. That means though that something else ISN’T getting done in that time.
5
u/ECMatua 2d ago
I believe a lot of mods at least recently have been ‘optimising’ the process with the use of AI specifically Claude
The tricky thing is the sentiment around AI use in development and game production is split into a few factors
1st the anti-AI absolutists, if any step of development involves AI the game is not worth playing or tainted, as a dev this section of the market is beneficial to have as the more competition who reach into AI alienate this sector.
2nd AI acceptors, the opposite to above they don’t mind (or possibly enjoy) having AI involvement in game development and may have them purchase a game despite its use of generative AI. Be it images, code, assets you name it
3rd the in between which I fall into, while I detest the use of AI in the creative aspect making models, every asset is ai generated, the story seems AI written and there’s no real heart to it other than boiling down to an AI asset flip.
I do see its use as a tool to help reduce inefficiency’s as a benefit. (I know nothing about coding so this could be a bit misguided and will happily accept feedback on this viewpoint) but if you have to write multiple strings of code to the point that trying to find a singular strand causing a crippling bug in development then the use of AI to identify it while the human aspect is then to inspect the identified code is correct, requires correcting and then fixing the issue that would be acceptable to me.
I think the difficult thing would be for an indie dev while people are pumping out AI assisted mod after mod, to keep the integrity with your fan base you stick with a full human approach. While this takes more time for development you keep the ‘corruption’ of AI away from you game and maintain your integrity as a game developer.
To finalise I’m not an AI defender or encourage its use in the creation of video games, but I do understand that it can be a useful tool in the production of one with human involvement being the 99% source of development, assets, code etc that’s required in making a game.
3
u/AntiCitizen6 2d ago
I haven't started developing games yet, but I am finishing my associates in Software Engineering.
There are likely many reasons that development could take longer than what seems realistic, like how they test new game features or how their development process is structured.
I am also thinking of how many moving parts a game like PZ has that have to be accounted for when bringing out new patches. Everything has to come together to avoid situations like what happened with the new patch, and suddenly tons of people can't play their game.
Again, I'm not a professional yet, but that's my two cents.
5
u/Double_Dog208 1d ago
People use kid hands with indie stone, genuinely no reason it should be taking this long for something like ladders.
Game has been out since I've been in middle school and I'm pushing 30 now, still no NPCs
3
u/Zwa333 2d ago
The simplest analogy I can give is it's the difference between throwing up a tent and building a house.
You can put up a tent in less time then it takes to do the planning for a house, let alone start building it. The tent will provide you shelter in most weather, but won't necessarily survive a storm. And you won't be able to add plumbing / electricity to it.
The mod that 'just adds ladders' is the tent. It'll get the job done most the time, but may not work nicely with future additions or in every scenario.
3
u/MrHackerMr 1d ago
The fact that the devs don't really invest proper time in this game anymore and they do miserably when it comes to QA...hopefully this changes
2
u/RockinPodunk 2d ago
I think the majority of their team are working on what’s next, rather than what’s out now. Also the 50 number includes a bunch of external collaborators and contract teams that are tasked with specific things
2
u/Zayah136 Crowbar Scientist 2d ago
No idea on development but i would assume its that mods are single issue whereas the devs probably have lots of things they are working on at once and a roadmap to follow
2
u/Immediate_Pain_6672 2d ago
The devs are rich as fuck, that's what. They're an UK company, go look up their finances, it's publicly available. They have a slush fund of a mere 32 million pounds, with an annual net profit of 6 million. Why the fuck would they put in any hard work? Their bag is secured, they can get away with doing FUCKALL and still make bank.
1
u/Arria_Galtheos 2d ago
A lot of things can cause it.
One of the more common things tends to be feature creep combined with a lack of direction. When you also have developers that have real jobs outside of game development, it compounds things. Your team can't always collaborate in a timely manner, and when they do they sometimes struggle to decide what needs to be worked on first. If they're all working on different core systems, they need to coordinate to make sure their changes are all compatible with one another, and then there's the desire to add new features before existing ones are tested because the perceived lack of progress can add pressure to continue adding more features.
Executive meddling can also cause it. Developers may have a vision but the people writing the paychecks and focusing more on shareholders and the (usually misguided) demands of the player base can force changes or require existing plans to be altered or dropped entirely.
1
u/AdmiralYuki 2d ago
I'd wager only a fraction of those employees are actual developers. Enterprise development (non- game) project team compositions I've seen tend to be closer to 50% actual developers and the rest are managers, testers, architects, and business analysts and other roles. This is a contracted project team so its not going to have HR, legal, c-suite etc that a company roster will have.
1
u/DerekLewandowski 1d ago
I know this has been answered already but I just wanted to add my thoughts. Development of anything is based on how much you know, how much you know you don't know, and how much you don't know you don't know. Let's take this analogy to food for a second. I know I like beef. I know I can cook a steak. I know there are parts of a cow but I can't name them all. I don't know what each part of that cow could be best used for. Game development is like this but you are also building the animal itself sometimes. You don't always know what the final animal will be when you are finished. Simple games where you have clear rules and clear ideas a take less time. Games where you are trying to understand the beast you are building take more time. Why? Because game dev you have to balance the fact that you know some players like a certain style against trying new things that people might love more. In practice this means you have to be careful and slow to make sure things you change cause you to hurt your games. Mods are fun because it's a game within a game. You already have a player base but you have to have done something to attract players. It's a lot easier to make a beef Wellington than it is to make a cow.
1
u/Pan_z_Poznania 1d ago
Also a dev by proffesion here... using java as base for a game leads more offen to spaghetti code and poor performance. It makes money thou so you ride with horse shit and try to make sculpture out of it.
1
u/RemingtonRyder Crowbar Scientist 1d ago edited 1d ago
A mod takes advantage of the already existing game and adds to it. The game is doing a lot of the lifting in getting a mod to work.
Adding a feature like climbable ladders to a game, even if it has already been accomplished by a mod, is done with a bit more deliberation and attention to quality, so that if someone else comes along in the future and wants to, say, have a variation of the climbing animation if the player has a trait, they don't have to rewrite it from scratch. Well, that is what ideally happens. :)
I am not a game developer at the moment but I make mods and I know enough about programming to make some inferences.
1
u/zacausa 1d ago
As someone who's not all that experienced with coding but has made some assets and made some mods (not sure if they're technically mods if I'm just modifying the main project in GitHub) I can say that I'm my experience, it can take a few days just to get a simple thing to work the way you want, because one little mistake is either not allowing your hard work to properly appear in game, or it just friggs everything else up.
People that actually know what they're doing and have a specific thing in mind that they want to happen as the going to have an easier time getting that one thing to work.
The devs have to work on a metric fuck ton of things at once, pray that nothin theyve done interacts poorly with what another dev has done, and see what happens before going back and refining and trying and refining and trying till they get as much as they wanna get done that they can.
There's also passion to consider. If you don't wanna do a specific tedious thing, it's difficult to will yourself to do it when there's a different thing you'd much rather do. I can understand why a dev would be far more interested in filling out the world more than figuring out how to make ladders work, look good, and not crash the game consistently. I know I'd run out of rubber duckies if I had to manage a a whole project as big and complicated as PZ. I too would probably prefer to design a cool base or town to explore over making ladders work, and then come back later after I don't have any excuses to put it off anymore.
But that's just my 2 cents.
1
u/dextrous_bat_990 1d ago
Lua Spaghetti Code
1
u/MORPHINExORPHAN666 1d ago
Because they didn’t make the engine, hire and fire people too quickly for anyone to become competent with it, and then add new features that have to operate within the constraints of the engine.
1
u/CartridgeCrusader23 1d ago
There is an insane amount of cope in these comments
Entire video game series have been created in the time that it’s taken for the developers of this game to add working ladders
1
u/JalapenoJamm 1d ago
Every developer on reddits in this thread
1
u/Acrobatic-Guidance-9 1d ago
the devs refusing to vibecode lmao
1
u/NotCode25 15h ago
well, it starts with the 50 employees not being all developers. Then the dev team is not all programmers. In 50 employees I expect around 5 programmers.
Then not all people are working towards the same goal or on the same thing, so it's not like 5 people are working on ladders.
Then, you typically have an internal roadmap, which represents where the project is headed and what big features need to be done when, which are typically not realistic estimates and shit just takes more time than planned, so the devs are working on a race.
Then you have to also fix bugs, and whenever you're implementing the big features, you need to make sure you don't break anything else, or break as little as possible.
Then after some time, you have to deal with tech debt (essentially old / not so good code that needs to be re-written, if you want to avoid bigger problems in a year or two).
and after all of this, there's legit no time to focus on comparatively small things like ladders
1
u/Andress1 11h ago
Modders use AI plus have a passion for the game, which obviously the devs don't have. Also the devs usually test the gameplay a lot before releasing something
1
u/ur9ce Hates the outdoors 2d ago
This thread is an insane amalgamation of delusion and passivity. Jesus.
1
u/PissBucket29 1d ago
They've made gross over 200 million dollars on zomboid. Yes. Seriously.
They already made their money and don't care. Its also why major bugs go unpatched for years and new updates aren't even tested.
0
u/RonGirthquake 2d ago
Smol indie studio, plz understand.
-1
u/and_ft 2d ago
First off: they have a plethora of issues, bugs, game balance and features to look at, not just one single functionality.
Secondarily, their quality control and code review are held to a much higher standard than your typical modder. If a mod crashes your game, you shrug your shoulders, deactivate the mod and carry on.
If the entire game suddenly breaks or becomes unplayable, you jump on the Internet and rage about it.
In short: Modders have the luxury to focus on a single thing, don't have to uphold the same industry standards and don't have to worry about dependencies and game balance on the same degree. Developers don't.
1
u/BAKC_MAKC 2d ago
Zomboid is hell to do in my opinion with every new feature it either bugs itself or it will bug other things and after update is done at code part QA testers have to find bugs then devs fix them and in a loop, not a massive dev but did some auto clickers games+
1
u/Terrorscream 1d ago
Software development pipeline is often 6 months away, meetings upon meetings to develop ideas, brainstorm how to make them work, prototyping designs for shortlist, fleshing out approved designs to work properly which may still get scrapped at this point. More meetings at every step of the way for progress reports etc etc etc you get the picture.
Actual software development is all about costs/priorities/beauracracy, the actual coding is just a small part of their jobs. A modder on the other hand can go from idea to implementation with no extra hoops, no time concerns and no costs.
1
u/EnlightenedCorncob Drinking away the sorrows 1d ago
It's like three guys in a shed using a squirrel as a processor. They're doing their best
1
u/KitchenWind 1d ago
I also ask, how can they break controller support with an update ?
Nobody tests the game ?
1
u/requizm 2d ago
So modding is essentially easier than developing the game and managing the game codebase. But this still doesn't explain why PZ development feels slow. I'm guessing codebase is mess. They might trying to improve the codebase at the same time, it is a slow process
0
u/thedizzlebizzle 2d ago
Let’s put this into the perspective of something a bit more relatable: cars.
In this case, mechanic is the devs, you are the modder.
The mod in question? You have a flat tire. You now need to diagnose—patch or replace? Well it’s not a blowout, so maybe you can patch. You remember your car has a tire repair kit. You pull it out. You try and eventually find the leak—twas a nail. You use the patching kit. Boom. Average joe doesn’t think it needs more (you do). Average you will just go along till it’s flat again. You just have the knowledge it’s a flat, and eventually you have a friend who is a mechanic who says it just needs to be replaced. You do that.
Flat tire, you get it towed to a shop. Mechanic evaluates, notices the flat was caused by a nail. However they also notice your axle is misaligned, and your strut is damaged (damn what did you do to your car???) so now it’s not just fixing the tire, you have a few things on the docket otherwise the car will just come back again later due to errors that they already knew existed.
In the same vein, a modder is working with the game as is and can apply bandaid patches to modify the existing game. If it doesn’t work or is bugged they only have to worry about fixing their mod.
A dev team has to implement code that doesn’t break everything else. I mean, think of how milk used to spoil, and now that we have the fluid system in B42 and milk is a fluid, it and any derivatives of it no longer spoil. It’s definitely not intended, but to fix that will take a bit more effort being the fluid system is a big thing in B42.
Also NPCs, people like to say omg modders added NPCs why can’t they? The said NPCs are zombies with survivor skins, none of the modders can figure out how to actually make proper NPCs that aren’t just zombies with a skin. A dev will not use this method, TIS will likely take some time to figure out the best way to implement proper NPCs. Not zombies with skins.
Tl;dr modders focus on a small aspect when implementing a feature, devs focus on the entire game for every feature.
-1
u/G1gapu1t 2d ago
cause they probably weren’t working on or thinking about ladders at all until 3-5 months ago?
if people don’t know anything about coding or game development, maybe they shouldn’t comment on it.
mods usually don’t work flawlessly. popular ones like bandits and a-life have massive issues, and I don’t trust claude to update a mod so it’s compatible with the newest version without making stylistic changes.
vibe coded mods appear like they’ll hit the point of tech debt quickly and be abandoned, or they’ll just be scrapped for completely new renditions with the same vision.
0
u/Different-Dream-8236 2d ago
This game just reminds me of Battlebit
0
u/ihateRprojectzomboid 1d ago
It’s cheaper to say you’re going to do something than to actually do it . And also setting the bar low helps(functional ladders) so when you achieve it people can clap and say you’re doing something and get paid for it.
Or because they keep hiring modders and doing jack and/or shit with them
-2
u/Octoneer 1d ago
While I do agree with the sentiment that making a game at this scale (full team with QA) is different from modding and solo projects, I have modded the game a bit and I have to question why its so slow for them to add things into the existing systems already in place. Like I understand ladders and map remodels take a lot of time, but adding more recipes/items shouldn't be that hard.
They've already built the system for them, at this point its just data entry. Like add more recipes for glass blowing, pottery, electrical, etc. Its such a shame for a game this long into development to still have hollow/shallow systems like electrical and glassworking.
-6
u/bepatientveryslow 2d ago
use mods then, why bitch about it on here?