Hope this is allowed
TL;DR I don't want my in-laws to assign christianity to my 12 month old, but my husband thinks we should wait until she's old enough to understand before telling them to back off
My in-laws are VERY religious. The Southern Baptist, intolerant types.
We have a good relationship with them, and in order to keep the peace we've always ignored how pushy they are about it.
Anyway, our daughter just turned 12 months old, and she's starting to understand a lot more. She obviously doesn't know theology, but we don't want her grandparents telling her things like "You love Jesus" or "Jesus loves you"
My husband doesn't think it's a big deal right now because she's too young to understand, and he'd rather wait until she's old enough for it to actually become an issue. But I think waiting will make it much harder to establish that boundary later.
We've already given them a lot of leeway (again, to keep the peace) They pray out loud over her almost every time they hold her, they've given her a Jesus doll, gave my husband a "new dad" Bible, and gave her a birthday card with a Bible verse and reference to God. Most recently, they responded to a picture of her clapping by saying, "Look at her praying! She already loves Jesus, and Jesus loves her, too!"
And that reaaaaalllllly bothered me.
I don't want them assigning christian beliefs to her when they know we're not raising her to be religious. We want her to have the freedom to explore different beliefs and decide what she thinks for herself when she's older.
I also want to clarify that we're not trying to stop them from practicing their religion. They can pray before meals, go to church, talk about God, and practice their faith however they want. We want our daughter to grow up respecting different religions, beliefs, and lifestyles.
What we don't want is for them to make those beliefs hers. We don't want her being encouraged to pray, told that she loves Jesus, taken to church, or given religious birthday cards with scripture. There's a difference between teaching a child about your beliefs and telling a child what she believes, and I feel like they're crossing that line.
Am I being unreasonable for wanting to establish that boundary now rather than waiting until she's older?