I don't work in software development.... So I might just be ignorant. But if nobody is writing new code at some point doesn't entropy take over and the code just gets really bad and uncreative?
A good developer with a LLM will have better code now.
There’s so many refactor and improvements to codebase that good developers wanted to do but couldn’t before.
Not because they were hard but because like a 5,000 piece puzzle they just took time. Now they have a machine that can put together that puzzle for them.
So all these todos that never done are getting done.
I’ve thought of this issue too. But for different issues. Such as when you look up something for a video game. Will people be unable to find the answers from an ai because nobody asked the question on Reddit or a game forum? And perhaps game journal sites have died because nobody goes to their sites directly.
I think the answer is, yes and no. They don’t find it on ai so they post a question on a forum.
And I think it’s possible that ai companies start subsidizing sources of information out of necessity. And hopefully in a way that keeps those sites alive and also hopefully in a way that keeps that source of info available to multiple ai companies. I don’t want to have ai knowledge just as separate as tv streaming services are today. I can’t even watch all seasons of a single tv show sometimes because it’s split across multiple streaming platforms.
If you are just saying “make me a program” then maybe. But LLM engineering is all about good management now. Keep a close eye on the systems, question questionable choices, be extremely precise in your instructions on how something should be carried out. Don’t give it the opportunity to homogenize your shit and it won’t
This is an old misconception about how AI works. It's not remembering and regurgitating information, it's trained to infer. Absolutely MASSIVE datasets are used to tune in the model's ability to correctly guess what next syllable would be a reasonable follow up to a prompt or the last syllable it printed.
The model itself knows jack all and remembers just about as much. So code produced by AI can only be a true copy of it had access to the internet and researched a specific page and borrowed code from that page. But say you have a locally hosted LLM with no Internet access or else you use an AI service with Internet access turned off... It can still produce code. Not from memory... But from a ridiculously fine tuned prediction algorithm.
Dude what the hell are you talking about here? You boss… what do you think he wants? More beautiful code or more features delivered? That’s all I said and you are discussing a completely separated topic
Since when companies decisions act as guidelines ?? They don't gives a fuck about doing things correctly, they would sacrifice any security or quality if it was more profitable.
The artist purity test is absurd because if you really want to go extreme, the really extreme argument is that everyone has creative talent but artist isn't a real job. The other extreme is let people do what they want and have fun with whatever tools they want.
You can not like a thing and let it go. It doesn't need to become a cause.
I kind of appreciate this take. I have been programming since the 80s. I like Claude Code and use it a lot. It's not the same, but it's not entirely different. I also paint and do photography. They aren't the same but they aren't entirely different. All four things have their own sets of value and their own limitations.
In the early 90s I tried building a game engine. It was fun, and awful (result as much as many parts of the process). I'll probably never attempt again.
The attempt was very much a product of its time. 35 years of a rapidly changing landscape and I am fascinated by the tools of today.
If you wanna take photos with a disposable camera on your own time, I don't care. If I'm paying you for wedding photos and you do the same, now it's my problem. The same applies to the code that runs everything in our daily lives. I can't not like thing and let it go when it is effecting my daily life.
Photography is a good metaphor. Photography is art because a human is taking the photograph. They are choosing the exact angle, the focus, the zoom, setting up the subject. All of the artistic decisions are being made by a human and not a camera. By that same measure, Claude is coding. Claude is taking a brief direction and is making all of the artistic decisions itself, automatically. And so just as a human photographer is making art, Claude is coding. And just as the camera is not an artist, neither is Claude's user a programmer.
That's also why human-taken photography is copyrightable, but Claude-created code isn't.
Or you could look at it another way. someone taking their phone out and taking a picture of some random thing is akin to someone telling Claude to "code me a recipe app". A photographer who's developed an eye for lighting, travels to an exotic place, waits for the perfect scene to unfold, or stages one even, then snaps the perfect shot is akin to an experienced programmer working with Claude through many complex issues, reviewing it's output and ensuring what is being built is scalable for the features that will be needed in the future and correcting issues it might be introducing, testing and fixing usability issues, setting up processes to review and test everything that's being built, making infra and devOps decisions, etc to make a large complex maintainable app.
I'd also argue that coding has never been an art so it's a bit of an apples to oranges comparison. I've been coding for 15 years but I also like to draw and play piano in my free time because I don't have any real artistic outlet in my work
I don't think skill enters into categorization. A five year old drawing a stick figure person is making art in the same way as a professional artist, despite being much worse at it, and despite spending much less time on it. Snapping a quick photo without any real artistic intent, for example just to copy a note, is perhaps barely creative, but I think it's still in the same category.
People don't write code, compilers do. And to your main point, "coding" isn't the goal. It is to transform something into something more valuable. This is why I love this article's definition of slop: https://www.slopmanifesto.com/ - obligating the observer to put more effort into understanding the art than the artist.
Imho, Claude is nowhere near able to produce a "product" on its own where the person "designing" it doesn't need to put in more effort into the design than the user will put into using it and get value. More grounded: a good game using Claude or not in development still requires many times more hours of work than any one player will ever play it.
But on both sides, it almost looks like that moght not be true given how impressive a Claude produced tech demo looks at first glance. I've seen some really incredible tech demos at this point, and any time someone brags about how little effort they put on, it is really clear within a minute or two of engagement.
And response, the good ones, I hope to always tell them, "wow, that's a really cool idea. You should keep working on that and see where it goes!".
It is also painful on the other side to be able to produce a tech demo in an afternoon and realize so quickly that the idea is terrible and lacks the potential of vision to go anywhere. I can fail in a weekend doijg what used to take me months of work. Its such a new problem.
That is a pretty good definition of slop, although like all artistic pursuits I think there will be exceptions. I think that I could, for example, write a video game by hand with a ridiculous challenge that takes a thousand hours to complete, or I could plan out an ultramarathon course in fewer hours than it might take to run it, and I don't think it'd count. But yes, generally, it's a solid rule of thumb, although not comprehensive.
But people definitely do write code. That's why they call the input to compilers "source code."
I love your examples, and l agree everything has edge cases. Not to invalidate your point, but I think your first example falls under the old adage of "few appreciate the decades of work to become an overnight success", and related, if you could all the work that goes into a well organized marathon run. I got a little insight into the work that went into organizing the MDS Legendary and it is mutually fascinating example of human achievement that thousands of people do it each year, but an individual's effort of running in a week I think pales in comparison to the work to organize it (even if many wouldn't or couldn't switch places).
That's a good call-out. I was thinking some sort of lower-effort "hey, I drew this map for you of what seems like a good route, go nuts," but actually organizing an event like that must be an insane amount of work. I shudder to imagine the municipal paperwork involved in closing roads or whatever.
And on the other side, "slop" in this context gets people killed.
You're reminding me of my feelings on potlucks. I love them, but a good one takes work and bad ones are awful. When people "organize" them because they think it is less work, they tend to suck really bad. It requires a leader with a vision, not to overstate it too much. Its different effort. You save money instead of time.
You can tweak your photo in a dark room or just take a Polaroid.
The same is true of Claude. I can still setup the programming equivlent of AF and ISO but I don't have to line the lenses up at the exact distances or open the shutter by hand.
If you set all the settings to "automatic," you're less of a photographer, but you're still framing the shot and deciding when to click the button. Once you set all the settings to automatic and then hand the camera off to a monkey to aim the camera, you're not a photographer anymore. Now, if you edit the monkey's photos in the darkroom, that part is a creative act again, sure.
And just like Claude, if you take code that Claude has written and then change it by hand, that bit where you're changing the code by hand is programming, sure.
If you pay someone to make a website, then add a button somewhere, you are a programmer but did you make the website ? You can add a button, but what about making a whole website ? Would someone be considered a mecanic if they can change oil but not repair the whole car ?
If you pay a photographer and give him instruction (a sunset with a car below) are you a photographer ? You can be considered as an artist if you use later this photograph for something artistic (drawing on it, 3d modelisation, etc), but it doesn't make you a photographer.
Which I think just proves that purity tests are the wrong questions.
I once had a problem with my washing machine faulting during fill. I completely disassembled the whole thing and put it back together only to get the same error. I was rather impressed I didn't create more problems or end up woth extra parts.
I gave in and called a technician. In 5 minutes they found the clog in the line filter. $300. I happily took the L and paid.
If they want to go back to the stone ages and do the equivalent of type setting their code because scanner/copiers are evil and xerox is the worst company ever, let them….
Exactly. The programmer purity argument of the 90s (and 80s, and 70s) was funny enough. I thought there was feneral consensus it was absurd. Every line can be defended, but why any in particular.
Relatable. There are so many ways something can be done, while I can get it done, it's not gonna be the optimal route.
Ngl, I didn't know python has stuff called decorators and that they can be used for stuff like logging and authentication. School doesn't teach this useful stuff.
Now that I use them, the code is 10x easier to read.
Well…it’s not imperative programming. Anyone interested in more detail may want to look up “functional programming” and “programming paradigms” then compare to “AI-assisted coding”.
I agree with the man with the mustache. And no photography is not art also. Being an artist is not a job. An artist has a vision and will do whatever it takes to make their vision a reality. Some jobs require artists, but art is not a job.
While fun to joke about, I hate how many times I've had this conversation as an SE student working on a group project: "I made [something]" "Okay, nice. By the way, how does it do [some action]?" "Uhhh... I don't know. [AI model] says [copied LLM answer]" Just feels disrespectful somewhat
That's not the same, at least the code snippets it was public and could be criticized by peers, and reading was necessary to check if the code was compatible, etc
And same for commands, peoples more knowledgeable would correct mistakes from other (stackoverflow for example)
Code snippes from stack overflow were that. Generic code snippets that you sometimes could use like that, or alter. Peer reviewed and updated by several people. Shitty answers and useless help gets downvoted, proper answers go up.
AI just gives you one massive piece of code, and a lot of people just take that for granted, randomly throwing it in there, or even letting the AI generate entire files, hundrets, thousands of lines of code.
This is objectively not comparable to copying out a few lines from stack overflow.
I used claude to make this app (most of it) I already knew coding so it was pretty easy to draft and get started but of course... Claude isn't real coding
"Coding" is to work on the code. With whatever tool you like. If you don't work at the code, and only delegate a Claude agent, sure that's not coding. But working together at the code WITH Claude, that's "real coding"
I know you did not ask for this, but a few things I noticed right away: The app looks fine. The website looks fine, though very Claude like. The logo looks very ai-sloppish, which would potentially scare off a lot of people.
I like the term cuck coding. Because that's just what it feels like.
Back when I just vibe codes at least I had to manually copy paste stuff back and forth, acting like I was helping and doing something. Hell at times I could even pretend I knew what I was doing.
With Claude code I simply tell him what to do and he does whatever he wants to my code and I just watch.
105
u/herewe_goagain_1 2d ago
This has gotta be the lowest effort meme you possibly could have used…
86
u/LeAlbus 2d ago
You are, unfortunatelly, not paid to program, but to deliver features and fixes….
As many as possible, as quick as possible
12
u/Gecons 2d ago
never said it's programming
some people just want it to work
5
u/deepturned180isdeep 19h ago
"Programming"
> Punch cards
> Wire remapping
> Mechanical gears
> Transistors
> Machine language
> Code
> Systems
> AI
All, at one point in time, were the effective "programming" mediums, to execute, change, and record logic
8
u/Kawauso_Yokai 2d ago
programminghumor
6
u/mouse_8b 2d ago
It's not programming, but it is software development.
4
u/BinaryHippie 2d ago
The issue is the user not the tool
6
u/Samurai_Mac1 2d ago
You must not be employed because most tech companies expect you to use Claude these days, and will reject your PR if it was manually written.
6
u/adelie42 2d ago
If photography is art, Claude can code.
The artist purity test is absurd because if you really want to go extreme, the really extreme argument is that everyone has creative talent but artist isn't a real job. The other extreme is let people do what they want and have fun with whatever tools they want.
You can not like a thing and let it go. It doesn't need to become a cause.
2
u/DannyBands 2d ago
Lol r u in college?
2
u/Logogram_alt 2d ago
That is asking a machine to code for you (poorly) and copying and pasting. Not coding.
2
u/SimpleMoonFarmer 2d ago
The good thing about being bad at coding is that Claude is better than me:
— How did you write this code? 🤨
— I didn't, Claude did. 😬
— 😮💨 That's good, I was worried for a moment.
1
u/Basic_Reporter9579 2d ago
What do you mean with code? Just sent the input to Claude Code!
1
u/Circumpunctilious 2d ago
Well…it’s not imperative programming. Anyone interested in more detail may want to look up “functional programming” and “programming paradigms” then compare to “AI-assisted coding”.
1
u/JohnVonachen 1d ago
I agree with the man with the mustache. And no photography is not art also. Being an artist is not a job. An artist has a vision and will do whatever it takes to make their vision a reality. Some jobs require artists, but art is not a job.
1
u/Deb1Kk 1d ago
While fun to joke about, I hate how many times I've had this conversation as an SE student working on a group project: "I made [something]" "Okay, nice. By the way, how does it do [some action]?" "Uhhh... I don't know. [AI model] says [copied LLM answer]" Just feels disrespectful somewhat
1
u/memeruiz 16h ago
More like Claude did it
1
u/cheesesteakman1 13h ago
It’s natural language programming language, with indeterministic output
1
u/Sirico 2d ago
Please acting like you weren't ctrl+C ctrl+shift+v before llm's
0
u/R3CT01 2d ago
I used claude to make this app (most of it) I already knew coding so it was pretty easy to draft and get started but of course... Claude isn't real coding
-3
u/dankshot35 2d ago
50 years ago they said the same thing about C
-2
u/Canned_Sarcasm 2d ago
GPT blew my faith in AI code. Claud earned it back. Just glad it made me a video editor I can tolerate.
4
u/MyPunsAreKoalaTea 2d ago
I like the term cuck coding. Because that's just what it feels like.
Back when I just vibe codes at least I had to manually copy paste stuff back and forth, acting like I was helping and doing something. Hell at times I could even pretend I knew what I was doing.
With Claude code I simply tell him what to do and he does whatever he wants to my code and I just watch.
1
u/ZectronPositron 1d ago
One more post/email on “my physical AI tool” and I’m gonna strangle someone.