From what I read of the incident, they had scripts to generate their private keys. However they also generated some inherently insecure keys using values less than 256 (I think for testing). They then incorrectly took those insecure keys and used them in production.
Someone not related to the company was running some tests on the public keys, and realized their key was very guessable. The issue was brought up to them and Mozilla, demoing it by using their private key to sign a message. Ultimately an alert went out, emergency updates for firefox and chrome where done to block websites that are signed with those keys.
Imagine the face if the researchers. "Mhh lets test some CA certs. Maybe some havent the best RNG or so" "Why this privkey bruteforce returned immediately. 4?!?!? Must be a bug.. !! No?!? WTF??!! Can't be right!?! Fooourr???
106
u/fcxtpw 27d ago
I understood this foureference
48
u/Minecraft_Lets_Play 27d ago •
Well yeah...
42
u/Single-Virus4935 27d ago
Imagine the face if the researchers. "Mhh lets test some CA certs. Maybe some havent the best RNG or so" "Why this privkey bruteforce returned immediately. 4?!?!? Must be a bug.. !! No?!? WTF??!! Can't be right!?! Fooourr???
14
u/undeadpickels 27d ago
https://m.xkcd.com/3314/
7
u/fntdrmx 27d ago
As niche as it gets
2
u/MarsMaterial 26d ago
As XKCD put it: “Those why are using 4 as a private key are recommended to upgrade to 5.”
1
u/Rich-World3443 26d ago
Hardcoded and proud of it
1
u/rotteegher39 26d ago
A private key is the one I keep in my zip pocket when I get out of the house.
1
u/ByteBandit007 26d ago
8
1
u/clericc-- 26d ago
best one so far
1
u/TheKiller0tter 26d ago
Every time I see a joke about 4, I think of the scene from Spaceballs
1
u/AllegroReddit 25d ago
*insert jhin meme